Rowing machine advice:
73CL350
Posts: 259 Member
Does anyone have advice on getting a rowing machine ? I often find my knee pain prevents me from doing the treadmill so then i just do nothing (bicycle is always worse than jogging for me).
Does anyone have a rowing machine ? Any special features to look for ?
Does anyone have a rowing machine ? Any special features to look for ?
0
Replies
-
I've owned a Concept2 rower for about 5 years and love it, I use it primarily for cross training (my main activities are running, biking & swimming) and I've found that it gives a great workout and helps recovery after a really hard run.
Concept2 machines are a little pricey but they are the gold standard (most competitive on-water rowers use them for off season training).
If you have knee problems I would strongly recommend that you try one out at the gym if you can, depending on the cause of the knee pain the repetitive motion of the rower may exacerbate things (have you had the issue diagnosed?)
7 -
Thank you Brian ... great advice.
No I've never had an MRI or anything on it. It just hurts sometimes and other times it feels totally fine. Not a constant pain situation so I try to press through it when i can.
I'll look into those machines. Going away from the brands/models ... what features did you find the most beneficial ?0 -
I'll look into those machines. Going away from the brands/models ... what features did you find the most beneficial ?
The most important thing is that they're built like tanks and require a minimal amount of maintenance (keeping the rail clean, lubing the chain etc) their displays are easy to read (the new monitor offers more feedback than my older one but I'm too cheap to upgrade) They have a great selection of workouts built into their monitor ( a variety of distances, interval work etc or you can create and save your own workouts)
Their website and on-line forums are full of great advice on becoming a more proficient rower.
They offer an on-line log system to track your workouts and for the more competitive rowers you can rank your best performances based on age group etc. They also run a number of both individual and team challenges during the year (we have a virtual team here at MFP) and they offer little rewards (t-shirts, pins etc) when you hit certain milestones (1 million metres, 5 million metre etc).
I've often thought that if more treadmill manufacturers supported their used the same way as C2 there would be a lot fewer expensive towel racks in people's basements.
https://concept2.com/indoor-rowers/model-d
https://concept2.com/indoor-rowers/model-e
2 -
I do suggest seeing an orthopedist so that you can have your knee pain diagnosed. Outside of that, I also suggest getting a Concept 2. I don't own one but rather I use the ones at my university's gym (which are impressively poorly maintained - which is to say, they aren't cleaned very well, there's a ton of dust that has collected in the flywheel, and the chains aren't lubed) and the ones at my rowing club (which are very well maintained). If I didn't have such easy access and wasn't hoping to move out of the country in a year, I'd buy one in a heartbeat.
They're built like tanks, from what I can tell they have very good customer service, they care about all levels of users (from olympic level rowers to people who use their rowing machines for fitness), and there's something to be said about the fact that they appear to be the gold standard in terms of rowing machines. I also like that it's really easy to see the drag factor and adjust the damper so that I can get the drag factor that I want. This is especially true given that the C2s at my university are so poorly maintained (at that gym I set the damper at around 7 as opposed to around 5 at my rowing club).2 -
Does anyone have advice on getting a rowing machine ? I often find my knee pain prevents me from doing the treadmill so then i just do nothing (bicycle is always worse than jogging for me).
Does anyone have a rowing machine ? Any special features to look for ?
I don't know anything about rowing machines, but on the cycling - make sure you have it adjusted properly (in particular that the seat is high enough). (I come across so many people that complain about their knees on the bicycle and it turns out that their seat was set WAY, WAY too low - new cyclists seem to default to putting the seat much too low for easier ground reach)5 -
I'd say C2 all the way (Concept 2). I rowed 3 years and then finally bought one two years ago. Love it. Use it nearly every day. There's so many reasons why it's the best but aside from what others have mentioned, the exact calibration and the bells and whistle apps are fun.
For instance, I have a cradle on my rower and an App called ErgData. I can see (in real time) stroke speed, stroke length, watts in real time, rowing speed, calories burned, etc. It also uploads automatically to my C2 workout training log. There are other apps, too, for the C2 that no others are close on. RowPro is a computer software that can be purchased that you can race others around the world in real time (up to 8 rowers I think in 3D). LiveRowing is a new one. You can race one friend on a stored race of nearly any distance. I think that's only on I-Phone for now.
Plus, there are literally dozens of online "clubs" if you want to get more serious. I do monthly competitions with my virtual rowing club. It's like a WOD, but for rowing and you compete with other teams around the world.
Plus, if you get hooked, there's indoor regattas too. Competitions where you pit yourself against others around the area or around the world in competition races. I compete every Winter in regional races and I'm gearing up for Nationals next year. Races are divided into age groups and two weight classes to be a little more fair. Many outdoor rowing clubs have integrated indoor/outdoor programs where you practice on the C2 and they also teach you after you're conditioned enough to row out on the water.
One of the very best things about rowing is the community. I used to run. I found (some) runners to be a bit elitist. You don't get that nearly as much, in my opinion, in the rowing community. I've been helped by rowers that are world class, that offer me free advice on form/training.0 -
I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.1
-
I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kindly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.1 -
Does anyone have advice on getting a rowing machine ? I often find my knee pain prevents me from doing the treadmill so then i just do nothing (bicycle is always worse than jogging for me).
Does anyone have a rowing machine ? Any special features to look for ?
I don't know anything about rowing machines, but on the cycling - make sure you have it adjusted properly (in particular that the seat is high enough). (I come across so many people that complain about their knees on the bicycle and it turns out that their seat was set WAY, WAY too low - new cyclists seem to default to putting the seat much too low for easier ground reach)
In the case of Concept 2 rowing machines, the only thing you can adjust, in terms of ergonomics, is the height of your feet on the foot stretcher. The main issue that the needs to be aware of is making sure that a. the drag factor isn't too high and b. their form is correct (or at least nearing correct). There are a number of videos on concept 2's website addressing the correct form.0 -
MikePfirrman wrote: »I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kindly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.
I so agree with this, all of this. I'm lucky that the gym I go to is pretty good about responding when I tell them something isn't functioning well, but they also just don't do basic maintenance on the C2s. I also suspect that they wouldn't want me to hook up things to their rowing machines and, sadly, none of them have PM5 monitors so I can't do it over bluetooth. That said, I might just buy the android kit and see what they do. I suspect there's an 80% chance that they just wouldn't notice.1 -
Not much else I can add other than to toss in another vote for the C2. I don't row as much as some but perhaps more than others (hitting 5 million meters soon).
Simple maintenance and the thing will last a LONG time. Built like a tank.1 -
MikePfirrman wrote: »I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kindly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.
Why would I be attending a gym that does not maintain its equipment? (Mine does a very competent job maintaining their equipment). Even at the lower price ($945) the pay back period for owning is over 3.5 years. And, I don't need to dedicate home space for the machine. But, to each his own. Far be it for me to begrudge another person his/her toys.4 -
I dont enjoy gyms ... historically I have found if I have to drive there... I just wont. (I went through 4 tanks of gas last YEAR so I'm kind of a shut-in)
A grand was more than i expected though so I'll re evaluate and see.
Thank you all for the great advice.1 -
Concept2 - buy once, cry once.
I bought a cheaper rower and it didn't take long before all the problems/weaknesses made themselves known, and the rower ended up standing against the wall in the corner gathering dust. I use the C2 rower at my gym and there's no question it's the best rower made. If I was going to buy one for home use, I wouldn't buy anything other than a C2.3 -
@AnnPT77 thought you would have some helpful thoughts on the subject!
Aww, thanks! :flowerforyou:
Others have given some pretty good advice, I think.
I, too, would recommend:
* Trying a machine, preferably a Concept 2, at a gym or something first for a while, if you can find one that's adequately maintained. Rowing isn't fun to everyone (though I don't understand why.
).
* Taking a look at the Concept 2 beginner videos, as you won't get even a remotely decent workout from a rowing machine if your technique is poor, and good technique is not obvious. (Most people in gyms do it wrong, and many trainers teach it wrong.) See https://www.concept2.com/indoor-rowers/training/technique-videos
* Buying a Concept 2 (expensive) if you choose to buy a rower, with a Waterrower as a potential (but to me far less preferable) alternative . . . and it's also expensive. I don't really see the point of the Concept 2 model E. I own a model D, but would consider a Dynamic (even more expensive) if I were buying now, because I find it a teensy, tiny, itsy-bitsy bit gentler on my pretty wrecked knees. (Rowing didn't wreck them, BTW.) It's almost never possible to buy an adequate used Concept 2 for enough of a discount to make it worthwhile - they hold their value exceedingly well, so plan to buy new.
* Getting the knee problem diagnosed, and if necessary treated, especially before you take on some new leg-intensive exercise (which is what rowing is; the idea that it's primarily upper body exercise is frankly idiocy). For certain kinds of knee problems, you are burning bridges to future treatments if you continue stressing them. With other kinds of knee problems, you aren't. Be smart; find out which kind you have.
The only real answer to "what kind of features should I look for in a rower?" is "buy a Concept 2", or, if you don't want to compete or interact with other rowers, maybe a Waterrower (which is maybe a little quieter, and looks more like furniture). But I'd get the C2, myself.
3 -
MikePfirrman wrote: »I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kindly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.
Why would I be attending a gym that does not maintain its equipment? (Mine does a very competent job maintaining their equipment). Even at the lower price ($945) the pay back period for owning is over 3.5 years. And, I don't need to dedicate home space for the machine. But, to each his own. Far be it for me to begrudge another person his/her toys.
In my situation, I'm paying for the gym it whether I want to or not because it gets taken out of my student fees. There are also other aspects of the gym that I do like, naimly their very well maintained pool (I actually care far more about the maintenance of a pool than I do a rowing machine). There are also some space issues in terms of storage and the whole hopefully moving to another continent in 9ish months.1 -
MikePfirrman wrote: »I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kind. ly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.
Why would I be attending a gym that does not maintain its equipment? (Mine does a very competent job maintaining their equipment). Even at the lower price ($945) the pay back period for owning is over 3.5 years. And, I don't need to dedicate home space for the machine. But, to each his own. Far be it for me to begrudge another person his/her toys.
At most gyms where I've seen/used one, they're one of the least-used and least-understood machines. People abuse them, because they don't know how to use them. The staff/trainers often don't understand them properly either, and don't do the necessary routine maintenance. I go to a YMCA. The equipment overall is very well maintained. The C2 rowers are OK for the first few years (they're high enough quality to take a lot of abuse), but degrade over time to a deplorable state, and few people seem to realize it because they simply don't understand the machine. If equivalent degradation happened to a more popular/well-understood machine (treadmill, elliptical, etc.) members would be complaining instantly. That's just my experience.
(I own my own, but notice theirs, and even hop on one at the Y now and then to warm up for some other activity.)1 -
I have a C2 rower. Unfortunately, it's just sitting in my living room collecting dust
I used a rower in the gym when I first started my weight loss journey, bought one so I didn't have to drive to the gym just to use it, then I became interested in competitive powerlifting and rarely use the rower now 0 -
I have had bad knees since I was a wee lass. In college, I discovered rowing machines in the gym and fell in love. In fact, I so loved rowing, the women’s crew coach saw me and invited me to join the team. Being someone who was always the first to be cut from a team in tryouts, I was ENORMOUSLY flattered. However, the thought of my *kitten* being inches from the Schuylkill River at 5am caused me to respectfully decline.
In other words, from my experience, you should be fine unless your knees are worse than mine. 😉🚣♀️2 -
Even at the lower price ($945) the pay back period for owning is over 3.5 years.
If you factor in the cost of traveling to and from the gym (unless you're lucky enough to have one in walking distance) the pay back is less and at the end of it you still own a machine that will give you decades of service. Granted that many people don't have the space and a gym will provide access to other equipment.
2 -
So much great information! Thank you all.
I'm talking about remodeling the basement so the gym area is a whole room not a corner. I just cant do gyms I'm too self conscious and I hate driving. So as I plan my remodel I'll look at saving aside a grand for the c2. Thanks all.3 -
I dont enjoy gyms ... historically I have found if I have to drive there... I just wont.
Probably true for a lot of people - if I don't choose a gym that's roughly on the way between work and home, then I typically won't go either. If you're not in an area with lots of gyms, I can imagine it might be difficult to find a convenient one that keeps a rowing machine in decently maintained order. I can attest that the 2 rowers in my gym (LA Fitness) seemed to be in pretty abysmal shape with 1 generally out of order (although they're upstairs in the hampster wheel area, so I've only seen them a few times).0 -
MikePfirrman wrote: »I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kindly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.
I so agree with this, all of this. I'm lucky that the gym I go to is pretty good about responding when I tell them something isn't functioning well, but they also just don't do basic maintenance on the C2s. I also suspect that they wouldn't want me to hook up things to their rowing machines and, sadly, none of them have PM5 monitors so I can't do it over bluetooth. That said, I might just buy the android kit and see what they do. I suspect there's an 80% chance that they just wouldn't notice.
Because I know you are into Watts training, I'd consider getting the cradle and a C2 plug attachment. The cradle is portable. It just sits atop the PM3 or PM4 or whatever they have and then one end plugs into your phone and the other in the rower. They might notice your phone is interactive with the rower but ErgData wouldn't change any setting or create any issues for the gym. The only issue you might run into is making sure that the firmware is updated on the rower at the gym. If it needs updated, I've known tons of people that update with a flash drive and the gym staff doesn't have a clue.2 -
So much great information! Thank you all.
I'm talking about remodeling the basement so the gym area is a whole room not a corner. I just cant do gyms I'm too self conscious and I hate driving. So as I plan my remodel I'll look at saving aside a grand for the c2. Thanks all.
By the way, there are quite a few climbers on the C2 Forums. Climbers tend to do really well on the rower. Just assuming from your profile pic that you climb often.1 -
I also fell in love using the rowing machine in college (rec had 3-4 c2 rowers tucked in a corner) so much so that I purchased one of my own a few years ago. I probably don't use it as much as I should, or envisioned when I purchased but I'm always happy I have it when I do use it. The research I did before purchasing agreed with what others have said in that the choice for purchase is a Concept2 (which is what I have, got it from amazon, positive experience all-around). If you feel like exercising some patience, it's probably worth checking whatever used platforms are available to you locally (craigslist, FB marketplace, LetItGo, etc.) and you may be able to save some cash on one that someone is looking to part with.0
-
MikePfirrman wrote: »
By the way, there are quite a few climbers on the C2 Forums. Climbers tend to do really well on the rower. Just assuming from your profile pic that you climb often.
I used to. Haven't in a number of years.
Once upon a time I was very athletic ... cross country and swim team ... boxed in a league ... and yes, climbing...
But that was a. ... LONG ... time ago.1 -
Here is my gym space .. it is due for a total remodel ... but I do believe there is room for the rowing machine as it is a very long narrow space:
0 -
MikePfirrman wrote: »MikePfirrman wrote: »I use, and like, the Concept 2 (C2) at my gym Since my gym cost is about $22 per month and the machine, on Amazon, is $945-1,160, I'll continue to use the gym equipment, it costs less.
The issue with that is you're dependent on your gym to maintain and even know how to maintain one. I recently was house hunting in AZ and looked at an LA Fitness where one C2 had a seat on backwards! I took the front desk back and showed them. This could really hurt someone's sit bones/tail bone.
The one gym I belonged to asked me how to maintain them. I was happy to assist to ensure that it was running well. It doesn't take much but I'd say 50% of them are broken in gyms. I will say my local LA Fitness fixed their one C2 after several of us complained when the inner workings broke, likely because they never lubed it.
The other issue is that the gym won't take kindly to me hooking up all my various fun apps/software to their rowers.
I so agree with this, all of this. I'm lucky that the gym I go to is pretty good about responding when I tell them something isn't functioning well, but they also just don't do basic maintenance on the C2s. I also suspect that they wouldn't want me to hook up things to their rowing machines and, sadly, none of them have PM5 monitors so I can't do it over bluetooth. That said, I might just buy the android kit and see what they do. I suspect there's an 80% chance that they just wouldn't notice.
Because I know you are into Watts training, I'd consider getting the cradle and a C2 plug attachment. The cradle is portable. It just sits atop the PM3 or PM4 or whatever they have and then one end plugs into your phone and the other in the rower. They might notice your phone is interactive with the rower but ErgData wouldn't change any setting or create any issues for the gym. The only issue you might run into is making sure that the firmware is updated on the rower at the gym. If it needs updated, I've known tons of people that update with a flash drive and the gym staff doesn't have a clue.
Thanks for the advice, especially about how easy it is to update the firmware. I'll have to remind myself to check what edition the firmware is tomorrow when I workout. I'll probably order the kit this afternoon. Worse comes to worse I'm out $10 plus shipping.0 -
Here is my gym space .. it is due for a total remodel ... but I do believe there is room for the rowing machine as it is a very long narrow space:
(photo snipped to reply)
Happily, a Concept 2 is a long, narrow machine. Model D is 96" x 24" overall, and you need enough width to comfortably let your elbows come out to your sides at the finish of the stroke without feeling like something is going to hit you, and (especially if you're taller) enough space at your back that you don't feel like you'll hit something in the layback of the finish. C2 recommends a 9'x4' operating space. (The Dynamic is a little smaller, 7.5'x4' recommended operating space.)
The machine can be set upright on one end if you have enough ceiling height, but Concept 2 recommends you not store it that way. I believe the issue is stability (in case of vibrations & such, you don't want that big ol' sucker falling on you!), so securing it upright could be an option. Also, they come apart into 2 pieces, and go back together, pretty quickly (probably under a minute, once the process is familiar), so you could take it apart between sessions if absolutely necessary.
3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions