Weight gain

I’m unsure if this will make sense to some but is the amount of weight you gain dependent on the amount of calories you eat - for example, if you eat a lot will you gain a bigger amount than in if you eat less or is the amount of weight you gain always the same each time?

Replies

  • kimny72
    kimny72 Posts: 16,013 Member
    Over the long term, the calorie amount of your surplus will determine how much weight you gain on average. It won't always work out exactly week to week, as your scale weight includes water weight and digestion fluctuations, not just fat.

    I too have always eaten on the higher carb side and have gained and lost weight based on calories as expected, have never had blood sugar or hormonal issues, and have also gotten pretty good at vetting sources FWTW :wink:
  • angiew12345
    angiew12345 Posts: 1 Member
    The amount of weight you gain is dependent on Insulin. We see this with Type 1 diabetic patients. They inject insulin into a specific sight every day, their body will store fat in that site. Everyone has a different metabolism, different caloric needs. There is an ex olympic athlete in a wheel chair that says she consumes about 3,500 calories just to maintain. Just like how that Michael Phelps has a genetic change that reduces lactic acid and some double jointing in his ankles. Everyone's built a bit differently.

    https://mayooshin.com/biggest-loser-study-maintain-weight-loss/

    If you eat a low carb high fat diet, and you use a ketone breath analyzer. Do you know what it's showing? Calories that you are breathing out. When you pee on a stick do you know what it's showing? Calories you are peeing out. High fat low carb diets promote the creation of brown fat, especially with Tumeric, cold exposure, and change the way your body runs. The Keto community finds that sometimes increasing your caloric intake bumps up your weight loss. Even in wheelchair bound people, where as people who go to the gym too hard, for too long, too often, and calorie restrict lose their hair and don't have near as much weight loss.

    Calories in, calories out, is outdated. It has to be Calories in, hormones effected, calories out if you really want to min/max health.
    MikePTY wrote: »
    The amount of weight you gain is dependent on Insulin. We see this with Type 1 diabetic patients. They inject insulin into a specific sight every day, their body will store fat in that site. Everyone has a different metabolism, different caloric needs. There is an ex olympic athlete in a wheel chair that says she consumes about 3,500 calories just to maintain. Just like how that Michael Phelps has a genetic change that reduces lactic acid and some double jointing in his ankles. Everyone's built a bit differently.

    https://mayooshin.com/biggest-loser-study-maintain-weight-loss/

    If you eat a low carb high fat diet, and you use a ketone breath analyzer. Do you know what it's showing? Calories that you are breathing out. When you pee on a stick do you know what it's showing? Calories you are peeing out. High fat low carb diets promote the creation of brown fat, especially with Tumeric, cold exposure, and change the way your body runs. The Keto community finds that sometimes increasing your caloric intake bumps up your weight loss. Even in wheelchair bound people, where as people who go to the gym too hard, for too long, too often, and calorie restrict lose their hair and don't have near as much weight loss.

    Calories in, calories out, is outdated. It has to be Calories in, hormones effected, calories out if you really want to min/max health.

    This is absolute balderdash.

    Weight loss is calories in vs calories out. There are no special powers with Keto. If you eat at a deficit in Keto, you will lose weight, if you don't, you won't.

    My dietician says weight gain is not as simple as 500 extra calories per day equals 1 pound per week. Your body handles it differently. If you're very underweight, you can gain the weight back faster than if you're at normal weight or overweight, while eating the same.
  • kimny72
    kimny72 Posts: 16,013 Member
    The amount of weight you gain is dependent on Insulin. We see this with Type 1 diabetic patients. They inject insulin into a specific sight every day, their body will store fat in that site. Everyone has a different metabolism, different caloric needs. There is an ex olympic athlete in a wheel chair that says she consumes about 3,500 calories just to maintain. Just like how that Michael Phelps has a genetic change that reduces lactic acid and some double jointing in his ankles. Everyone's built a bit differently.

    https://mayooshin.com/biggest-loser-study-maintain-weight-loss/

    If you eat a low carb high fat diet, and you use a ketone breath analyzer. Do you know what it's showing? Calories that you are breathing out. When you pee on a stick do you know what it's showing? Calories you are peeing out. High fat low carb diets promote the creation of brown fat, especially with Tumeric, cold exposure, and change the way your body runs. The Keto community finds that sometimes increasing your caloric intake bumps up your weight loss. Even in wheelchair bound people, where as people who go to the gym too hard, for too long, too often, and calorie restrict lose their hair and don't have near as much weight loss.

    Calories in, calories out, is outdated. It has to be Calories in, hormones effected, calories out if you really want to min/max health.
    MikePTY wrote: »
    The amount of weight you gain is dependent on Insulin. We see this with Type 1 diabetic patients. They inject insulin into a specific sight every day, their body will store fat in that site. Everyone has a different metabolism, different caloric needs. There is an ex olympic athlete in a wheel chair that says she consumes about 3,500 calories just to maintain. Just like how that Michael Phelps has a genetic change that reduces lactic acid and some double jointing in his ankles. Everyone's built a bit differently.

    https://mayooshin.com/biggest-loser-study-maintain-weight-loss/

    If you eat a low carb high fat diet, and you use a ketone breath analyzer. Do you know what it's showing? Calories that you are breathing out. When you pee on a stick do you know what it's showing? Calories you are peeing out. High fat low carb diets promote the creation of brown fat, especially with Tumeric, cold exposure, and change the way your body runs. The Keto community finds that sometimes increasing your caloric intake bumps up your weight loss. Even in wheelchair bound people, where as people who go to the gym too hard, for too long, too often, and calorie restrict lose their hair and don't have near as much weight loss.

    Calories in, calories out, is outdated. It has to be Calories in, hormones effected, calories out if you really want to min/max health.

    This is absolute balderdash.

    Weight loss is calories in vs calories out. There are no special powers with Keto. If you eat at a deficit in Keto, you will lose weight, if you don't, you won't.

    My dietician says weight gain is not as simple as 500 extra calories per day equals 1 pound per week. Your body handles it differently. If you're very underweight, you can gain the weight back faster than if you're at normal weight or overweight, while eating the same.

    Unfortunately, we see a lot of posters here who are struggling to gain weight even though they feel like they are eating a lot, so it seems like this might not always be true.

    Regardless, having a calorie goal, logging accurately and consistently, and monitoring your results is a great way to get the data you need to have a strategy going forward.
  • simonwood1981
    simonwood1981 Posts: 4 Member
    It all comes down to calories in vs Calories out, the aim is to gain lean muscle mass while keeping bodyfat low. Track your calories, find your maintanence level and go slightly above, don't over do it as you will gain more bodyfat then lean mass.

    It takes time to gain weight properly, if you are strugling to gain and think that you're eating alot already, add a shake in the morning which will bump up your calories.

    1 banana
    1tbsp peanut butter
    1 scoop of protien powder
    1 scoop of porridge oats.

    blend this up and you'll have an extra 700 - 900 calories