Your non-mainstream crush?

Alex_is_Hawks

Solidly out of the mainstream.

Sia Furler

NOT surprised.

Gettinfit242

I have crushed on Henry Cavill since the tudors!!! hes just...beautiful!!! and Joe manginello aint too bad either!!

da_bears10089

Charlie Hunnam... damn, just damn..

K_Serz

John Krasinski from The Office.

Hes non-mainstream?

Allie_71

Boba Fett.

BrainyBurro

join the line. it's a long line.

K_Serz

Rosplosion

I'd break space and time just to do this guy.

That_car_is_full_of_balloons

judge judy

PhearlessPhreaks

Wayne Coyne and Steven Drozd from The Flaming Lips.

mou_254

Matt Lanter...yum yum

definitely him!! *drool*

SpeSHul_SnoflEHk

People on my FL.

SoDamnHungry

I liked all of these people before it was cool.

sweetlyybroken

Benedict Cumberbatch (he DIDN'T used to be mainstream)..

Nate Ruess

kelseymaccombs

Jason Segal.

I know he's really popular right now, but not usually as the heartthrob.
To quote him on How I Met Your Mother, "I'm cuddly, *****!"

TheGirlsATimeBomb

JACK MOTHER FREAKING BLACK

marry me ):

Timshel_

Alexandra Daddario

kelseymaccombs

Benedict Cumberbatch (he DIDN'T used to be mainstream)..

Nate Ruess

NATE RUESS!! I actually met him once (and I also love him).

zombiesalad

Chris Thile.

just_me_mindy

Matthew Gray Gubler