why is soup filling but smoothies aren’t?

trulyhealy

not a serious question but i love soup is much it’s so filling but in the past whenever i had a smoothie it wasn’t filling at all

MsCzar

That's why I don't do smoothies. They don't fill me.

chuckle_bunny

What is the macro breakdown of each?

Does the soup have oil and a protein source?

Is the smoothie mostly fruit?

Your body breaks down simple sugars quickly. Downing a fruit smoothie in a few minutes wouldn't satiate you longer than taking your time with a chicken noodle soup, if the calories are equal.

I drink smoothies but not with the intention of satiating hunger. I want the energy and nutrients. But there are many different ways people make smoothies.

Redordeadhead

For me, neither is filling.

sardelsa

It depends on the soup or smoothie.
If either have a lot of protein per cup I find it quite filling, if there is a lot of fat or carbs (like a creamy soup or smoothie with high fat yogurt, peanut butter, juice) it's more hidden and I don't feel the calories as much.
If I make a smoothie with too many high fibre fruits and vegetables, it's thick and filling.

Oh and temperature can make a difference. Hot soup, takes longer to eat and you tend to feel fuller sooner. Cold smoothies, you tend to drink faster and don't register.

janejellyroll

Satiety is highly individual, but if I was filled by soup and not by smoothies at about the same amount of calories, my first guess would be that there was a macro difference that was driving that. I don't find fruit particularly filling at all, especially if it is blended. Most smoothies have a pretty good amount of sugar and they can really vary when it comes to fat and protein (some have a lot, some don't).

I still drink them sometimes, especially in the summer. But I don't count on them filling me up, I'll have them either as part of a larger meal or when I'm in the mood for something light.

lemurcat2

I find smoothies and soup both filling (at least, made the way I do), but a couple of reasons soup might be more so for the cals (other than macros, which are discussed above) is that some people find drinking something less filling than eating, and similarly eating the same volume of soup is likely to take longer, since spooning it up can be slow.

My smoothies tend to have some protein and fat, more veg than fruit, and plenty of fiber, and also to be a pretty high volume that means they take a while to consume. For me, that's likely why they are filling. I've tried even reasonable cal/reasonably healthy smoothies (no added sugar or fruit juice, at least some protein, fat, and greens) from local restaurants that sell them, and for basically the same cals would get a much smaller volume with more cals from fruit, and for me, while those were tasty, they were not filling for long. And I'm someone who finds EATING (rather than drinking) fruit reasonably filling.

cwolfman13

I eat a lot of soup...well, mostly "stoups" that are pretty full of chunky veg, meat, potatoes, etc...there's usually a whole lot packed in there the way I do soup, so they're usually pretty filling.

Smoothie depends...pre COVID, the gym I was going to had a smoothie bar. I would often get one on Saturday mornings after my spin class as my breakfast. The one I usually ate had a good bit of peanut butter in it and was pretty thick and pretty filling...another one was fruitier, but had quite a bit of coconut and coconut cream, so pretty filling as well.

When I was doing endurance cycling events I used to make a recovery smoothie after my long rides of 30 miles +. It was a lot of fruit and some ice and full fat greek yogurt...it wasn't particularly filling, but that's what I wanted because I wasn't particularly hungry after a ride like that, but I needed the quick calories and sugar so I wasn't crashed out on my butt the rest of the day...as I recall, it was somewhere in the neighborhood of a 1000 calorie smoothie.

kshama2001

My smoothies are MORE filling than my soups - for smoothies I work to get the macros plus fiber into the sweet spot that I know satiates me, while with soups I just follow the recipe.

rheddmobile

I feel like none of y’all have been dirt poor!

Hot water will ease hunger pains. Cold water doesn’t. Soup is hot and smoothies are cold.

yirara

Liquid-y soups don't really fill me up that much. Smoothies not at all, btw. But soups fill me up if I eat them with a big chunk of bread. I love bread.

Goober1142

Soup takes longer to eat. I eat my smoothie with a spoon and it's very filling.

kshama2001

yirara wrote: »

Liquid-y soups don't really fill me up that much. Smoothies not at all, btw. But soups fill me up if I eat them with a big chunk of bread. I love bread.

This time of year, I normally send cookies to out-of-state friends, but am into making bread this year instead. Not sure how well it will ship, but am going to give it a shot. Made a test pumpernickel boule tonight, and ate it with Spanish Chorizo, Ham and White Bean Stew. Yum!

Diatonic12

trulyhealy wrote: »

not a serious question but i love soup is much it’s so filling but in the past whenever i had a smoothie it wasn’t filling at all

@trulyhealy Most soups start with a base of homemade broth or canned broth. That broth has fat, fat, fat and fat has far more satiety value than a smoothie without any fats. A fruit smoothie with no fats won't hold your hunger at bay. If you add a protein powder that can help but almost all protein powders are made out of denatured proteins that are created in a lab and manufactured in a plant. You can't duplicate mother nature in a lab or plant.

I make my own homemade bone broth. That process takes 3 days and the end result is rocket fuel. It tides you over, it holds you over and it makes you feel sooo good. Soups have lasting satiety due to the fat, fat, fat content.
Add your favorite condiments and add-ins and you are cookin' and runnin' on all cyclinders.

springlering62

I put four pounds of chicken in my last batch of dried bean soup. That might have something to do with it.

Seriously, I spent the first 18 months having the same smoothie every morning, and it kept me full til lunch time. I padded it out with a ton of ice, and ate it with a teaspoon to make it last and feel like I was a “volume eater”. Then, one day, it no longer held me.

I started having shaved ham sandwiches, or chopped chicken wraps, the occasional egg something, pancakes, even a big ole supersize gourmet donut.


This is making me crave a smoothie, though. Might soak some almonds and make some almond milk in the morning and see what I can make of the bag of frozen mango hidden in the bottom of the freezer....