Myfitnesspal

Message Boards General Health, Fitness and Diet
You are currently viewing the message boards in:

Do you weigh in and Measure each time or Just Weigh only

mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
On the check in screen it gives you the option of entering your weight. It also has a place to put your body measurement. Do you weigh and measure or just weigh? Please explain your logic behind doing 1 or both. Does the scale tell the whole story each week of how much you followed the plan? What insights can you get from measuring ?
«1

Replies

  • heybalesheybales Member, Premium Posts: 18,543 Member Member, Premium Posts: 18,543 Member
    Scale does not tell the whole story - especially if exercise is involved, and the several known water weight fluctuations.

    I use measurements monthly since they don't move as fast as scale weight anyway.
    Those measurements also happen to be used in 3 different body fat calc's to see an average trend there.

    I have it in a spreadsheet though since I find it easier than MFP.
    For that month I'll also get the figures for amount eaten, changes in weight, and what that means for my apparent TDEE. With variable exercise that isn't really useful going forward for me though, but still...

    But yes to measurements, especially the spots you know you gain fat first.
    Nothing like a 2 lb gain without a measurement increase to calm you that nothing bad is happening.
    Conversely nothing like an increase in waist size and weight stays the same coming out of heavy cardio season to say - watch it!
  • LietchiLietchi Member Posts: 1,794 Member Member Posts: 1,794 Member
    I weigh daily. It doesn't tell the full story, but I look at the long term trend and that's enough for me. And I do mean long-term, a week is not enough at my slow rate of loss, out even a longer: I can clearly see the trend over 2 months.

    I measure occasionally, but I'm very irregular about it. That reminds me, I'm way overdue now, it's been 6 months I think 😁
  • lgfrielgfrie Member, Premium Posts: 1,368 Member Member, Premium Posts: 1,368 Member
    I weigh daily, and take measurements whenever I can find my tape measure, which is like once every few months. I feel the scale tells as much of the story as I need to know on an ongoing basis.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    lgfrie wrote: »
    I weigh daily, and take measurements whenever I can find my tape measure, which is like once every few months. I feel the scale tells as much of the story as I need to know on an ongoing basis.

    Thank you for your insight. Have a great day.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    Lietchi wrote: »
    I weigh daily. It doesn't tell the full story, but I look at the long term trend and that's enough for me. And I do mean long-term, a week is not enough at my slow rate of loss, out even a longer: I can clearly see the trend over 2 months.

    I measure occasionally, but I'm very irregular about it. That reminds me, I'm way overdue now, it's been 6 months I think 😁

    glad I could serve as a reminder. And the only reason I measure weekly is I hit plateaus and I want to feel like I have accomplished some loss even if it's just a few inches. But your right about long term trends.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    heybales wrote: »
    Scale does not tell the whole story - especially if exercise is involved, and the several known water weight fluctuations.

    I use measurements monthly since they don't move as fast as scale weight anyway.
    Those measurements also happen to be used in 3 different body fat calc's to see an average trend there.

    I have it in a spreadsheet though since I find it easier than MFP.
    For that month I'll also get the figures for amount eaten, changes in weight, and what that means for my apparent TDEE. With variable exercise that isn't really useful going forward for me though, but still...

    But yes to measurements, especially the spots you know you gain fat first.
    Nothing like a 2 lb gain without a measurement increase to calm you that nothing bad is happening.
    Conversely nothing like an increase in waist size and weight stays the same coming out of heavy cardio season to say - watch it!

    I hear ya - I like your spreadsheet idea , I may have to start doing that hadn't thought of putting it in that format. Thanks .
  • noobootsnooboots Member Posts: 479 Member Member Posts: 479 Member
    I personally dont find measurements that accurate. I know I swell up from time to time, I can tell because my shoes are tight or my socks dig in but more accurately I wear a small thin bracelet and sometimes its all loose and falling up and down my wrist and other times I can barely budge it. Its just water but because I know I swell up, measurements for me are highly inaccurate. I weigh most days and just see the dial going up and down and accept the ups because thats just water as well and its mostly downward trend wise.
  • ninerbuffninerbuff Member, Greeter, Premium Posts: 44,374 Member Member, Greeter, Premium Posts: 44,374 Member
    I do 90% of the time. Weighed sunflower seeds this morning.6519mikmtzwl.jpg

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png
    edited February 21
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    I do 90% of the time. Weighed sunflower seeds this morning.6519mikmtzwl.jpg

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png

    Nice scale - wow that's great. thanks for your response 90% of the time that's impressive.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    nooboots wrote: »
    I personally dont find measurements that accurate. I know I swell up from time to time, I can tell because my shoes are tight or my socks dig in but more accurately I wear a small thin bracelet and sometimes its all loose and falling up and down my wrist and other times I can barely budge it. Its just water but because I know I swell up, measurements for me are highly inaccurate. I weigh most days and just see the dial going up and down and accept the ups because thats just water as well and its mostly downward trend wise.

    Thank you for sharing, water weigh is a pain, that's why I only weigh once a week. Have a great day.
  • cwolfman13cwolfman13 Member Posts: 38,703 Member Member Posts: 38,703 Member
    I only took measurements monthly. Measurements are going to significantly lag behind the number on the scale, especially in places people normally take measurements. When I first lost weight, most of my initial 20 Lbs came from my extremities, my neck, and a bit in my face...so things like my wedding ring started getting loser, collars on my shirts weren't as tight, feet shrunk, etc...not things (well maybe neck) that most people would normally measure.
  • gcmintongcminton Member, Premium Posts: 167 Member Member, Premium Posts: 167 Member
    I weigh daily for trend data, and very very rarely measure (we're talking once a year, if that). For now I'm happy enough with the scale and watching how my clothes fit, plus it's helped me get used to the normal fluctuations so I don't panic over them.

    There are two reasons I don't measure more often: I'm lazy, and I don't trust myself to accurately measure in the same spots everytime so the accuracy is going to be iffy anyway. If I'm honest it's mostly the first reason. ;)
  • Poobah1972Poobah1972 Member, Premium Posts: 129 Member Member, Premium Posts: 129 Member
    When making a recipe that is portioned I weigh everything. I also like to weigh from time to time, just to make sure my bearings are straight. Like I usually know what 1 oz of cheddar cheese looks like... My fiance recently cut 6 slices of cheddar cheese, i guessed it was 1.5 oz and turns out I was right. I'm pretty good with liquids and butter too... However it's always good to measure once in a while.

    I also like to measure my meat portions by scale, as that's a bit harder to judge and the scale doesn't lie.

    Then stuff like kraft calorie wise dressing at only 20 cals per TBSP... I just eye ball it cause it's not to much either way. On the other hand if your using full fat dressing, that a different story and can easily be 200+ cals if your not careful.

    I should add at my size, and how quickly the weight is coming off I really don't need to worry about it to much right now. But my fiance is pretty new to dieting and tracking macro's. So i do it for her more then anything. As we get closer to goal, this stuff becomes more important as the window grows much smaller.
    edited February 22
  • Speakeasy76Speakeasy76 Member Posts: 320 Member Member Posts: 320 Member
    gcminton wrote: »
    I weigh daily for trend data, and very very rarely measure (we're talking once a year, if that). For now I'm happy enough with the scale and watching how my clothes fit, plus it's helped me get used to the normal fluctuations so I don't panic over them.

    There are two reasons I don't measure more often: I'm lazy, and I don't trust myself to accurately measure in the same spots everytime so the accuracy is going to be iffy anyway. If I'm honest it's mostly the first reason. ;)

    Same here! I can never seem to get the measuring tape to go in the right spot, and I'm not even always sure where the right spot is. I tried to measure myself yesterday because I had the measuring tape out for something else, and I gave up after 2 body parts :D .
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    cwolfman13 wrote: »
    I only took measurements monthly. Measurements are going to significantly lag behind the number on the scale, especially in places people normally take measurements. When I first lost weight, most of my initial 20 Lbs came from my extremities, my neck, and a bit in my face...so things like my wedding ring started getting loser, collars on my shirts weren't as tight, feet shrunk, etc...not things (well maybe neck) that most people would normally measure.
    cwolfman13 wrote: »
    I only took measurements monthly. Measurements are going to significantly lag behind the number on the scale, especially in places people normally take measurements. When I first lost weight, most of my initial 20 Lbs came from my extremities, my neck, and a bit in my face...so things like my wedding ring started getting loser, collars on my shirts weren't as tight, feet shrunk, etc...not things (well maybe neck) that most people would normally measure.

    Thanks for sharing. Have a good evening.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    gcminton wrote: »
    I weigh daily for trend data, and very very rarely measure (we're talking once a year, if that). For now I'm happy enough with the scale and watching how my clothes fit, plus it's helped me get used to the normal fluctuations so I don't panic over them.

    There are two reasons I don't measure more often: I'm lazy, and I don't trust myself to accurately measure in the same spots everytime so the accuracy is going to be iffy anyway. If I'm honest it's mostly the first reason. ;)

    It is hard to hit the same spot every time. especially when I am doing my arms.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    Poobah1972 wrote: »
    When making a recipe that is portioned I weigh everything. I also like to weigh from time to time, just to make sure my bearings are straight. Like I usually know what 1 oz of cheddar cheese looks like... My fiance recently cut 6 slices of cheddar cheese, i guessed it was 1.5 oz and turns out I was right. I'm pretty good with liquids and butter too... However it's always good to measure once in a while.

    I also like to measure my meat portions by scale, as that's a bit harder to judge and the scale doesn't lie.

    Then stuff like kraft calorie wise dressing at only 20 cals per TBSP... I just eye ball it cause it's not to much either way. On the other hand if your using full fat dressing, that a different story and can easily be 200+ cals if your not careful.

    I should add at my size, and how quickly the weight is coming off I really don't need to worry about it to much right now. But my fiance is pretty new to dieting and tracking macro's. So i do it for her more then anything. As we get closer to goal, this stuff becomes more important as the window grows much smaller.

    Thank you very much for sharing it is hard to eye ball meat. I totally agree.
  • Duck_PuddleDuck_Puddle Member Posts: 3,162 Member Member Posts: 3,162 Member
    I track as many things as is reasonable and relatively easy. Also things that can me measured with reasonable level of repeatability (the same way/level of accuracy every time). That gives me the best likelihood of seeing progress...somewhere. Perhaps my weight is going down, perhaps my clothing size is a little smaller, perhaps my heart rate is a little lower during an activity I do frequently, perhaps my waist is a bit smaller, perhaps I had fewer headaches this week or whatever makes sense for you.

    There will be times when progress isn’t happening the way you’d like, or hormones or weather caused you to retain water (scale) and bloat (measurements/clothes) even though you’re doing everything right. Having other metrics to look at can show progress (over the long term).
  • callsitlikeiseeitcallsitlikeiseeit Member Posts: 7,206 Member Member Posts: 7,206 Member
    weigh daily for trend data. log it weekly on Fridays on MFP. Take measurements on the 1st of the month.
  • mpkpbk2015mpkpbk2015 Member Posts: 390 Member Member Posts: 390 Member
    weigh daily for trend data. log it weekly on Fridays on MFP. Take measurements on the 1st of the month.

    Love your avatar - thank you for input. Appreciate it. Have a great day.
Sign In or Register to comment.