Am I really unfit??
bex1086
Posts: 85 Member
I am by far from a couch potato, I weight lift 3 days a week and I was doing body pump/other bits of cardio 2-3 days a week. My job is fairly active and I usually do a 4 mile walk once a week although it's not fast paced since I'm taking small kids to school.
I've been trying to complete couch to 5k on and off since 2012 but never succeeded. I've recently taken it up again and I'm on run 3 of week 5. Absolute flop, I can't even run for a minute without feeling like I can't breathe. I wanted to do 2x 10 minute runs since I did 2x8 the other day and the raccommended 20 minute run would just be too big a jump.
I do have breathing issues but I don't know if they are caused by being seriously unfit but I don't see how I can be that bad. The doctors said there was nothing wrong with me so I don't know what the issue is.
I'm not overweight so it's not that but I probably am skinny fat. Why do I suck at this? I also suck at weightlifting, only just lifting a bit over my body weight for squats, not deadlifts, my row, bench and overhead is a bit less than half my body weight. Can't do a single body weight pull up either.
I've been trying to complete couch to 5k on and off since 2012 but never succeeded. I've recently taken it up again and I'm on run 3 of week 5. Absolute flop, I can't even run for a minute without feeling like I can't breathe. I wanted to do 2x 10 minute runs since I did 2x8 the other day and the raccommended 20 minute run would just be too big a jump.
I do have breathing issues but I don't know if they are caused by being seriously unfit but I don't see how I can be that bad. The doctors said there was nothing wrong with me so I don't know what the issue is.
I'm not overweight so it's not that but I probably am skinny fat. Why do I suck at this? I also suck at weightlifting, only just lifting a bit over my body weight for squats, not deadlifts, my row, bench and overhead is a bit less than half my body weight. Can't do a single body weight pull up either.
0
Replies
-
It's very possible that you're too fast. Running asks a lot from your body. Added to that we have a habit of wanting to be fast. Thus slow down. Slow down so much that you can still talk. If that means that walkers overtake you then don't take notice. Running burns more than twice as many calories as walking, thus even if they overtake you, you're doing more than twice as much as they. Plus in time you will get faster. Thus don't worry about it. Slow down.8
-
A classic mistake, one I made several times while attempting c25k, is trying to run too fast.
Have you tried slowing down?
I started my latest c25k attempt 3 years ago at a speed barely above fast walking, felt 'ridiculously' slow but it did work, I'm now running around 30km a week and at a decent speed.
1 -
It may just take you more time. You'll get there, just be patient. When running you can try "Powerwalking"--first 5 min normal walk, second 5 min medium speed, and 3rd 5 min a slow run. Repeat until your time is up. I do 40 min cycling these speeds. You can up your game as you get stronger and better--faster for longer.
Another suggestion is to work on your breathing. There are breathing exercises. I swim and used to sing in a choir. All that gave me great lungs.
Good luck. You can do this.0 -
I think I'm going fairly slow, I'm making a conscious effort to keep it slow and not go too fast and burn out.
I'm going to try again Tuesday and see how I get on, hope today was an off day. I scrapped the proper running and just did a minute of running and some walking on and off and for longer than intended to make up for the lack of actual running.0 -
I think I'm going fairly slow, I'm making a conscious effort to keep it slow and not go too fast and burn out.
I'm going to try again Tuesday and see how I get on, hope today was an off day. I scrapped the proper running and just did a minute of running and some walking on and off and for longer than intended to make up for the lack of actual running.
You know, being fast or not compared to others doesn't matter. You say you can't catch your breath while running. This means you are too fast. So slow down. Go really, really slow if you have to. There's no shame in that.2 -
+1 for slowing down.1
-
I think I'm going fairly slow, I'm making a conscious effort to keep it slow and not go too fast and burn out.
I'm going to try again Tuesday and see how I get on, hope today was an off day. I scrapped the proper running and just did a minute of running and some walking on and off and for longer than intended to make up for the lack of actual running.
As others have mentioned, you may just want to slow down your pace and be patient as your body becomes used to running. As far as the bolded portion: You have identified a very effective tool for building run fitness - The Run/Walk approach. This is a great way to build run fitness while minimizing chance of injury. By using a planned run/walk workout, for example 4 minutes running/1 minute walking, you are building your aerobic and muscular endurance while allowing time for your heartrate to recover during the walk breaks.
This method works for all levels of runners, not just newbies. I'm using this method currently as I return from an injury and don't yet have the run fitness to keep up with my running friends. Many in our larger training group do a run/walk long effort on Sundays following a hard run or long bike ride on Saturdays. The run walk is very sustainable and helps us build mileage without undue pounding as we train for marathons, ultra events or long course triathlons.
Again, the ratio is up to you. Just be consistent in your easy paced runs (you should be able to speak your name and address while running or you're probably going too fast) and you will see improvements fairly quickly. Good luck with your intro to running. Let us know how you progress.
2 -
I have tried to be a runner several times in my life. Even when I was in top shape—and I mean strong, not just thin—I could not run without hating every second. I was huffing and puffing and it felt like my whole skeleton was taking a pounding. So I slowed down. Way, way down… to a walk. 🙂
While I like to claim that I’m not built for running, I often wonder if I could have done better with someone coaching me on how to be a proper runner (form, breathing, etc.) If you REALLY want to run, maybe get someone to coach you?
4 -
Some time ago I seem to have come down with some type of post viral syndrome, and it seems to have affected my heart. I was not “fit” but I took walks and stuff regularly. But after the virus, suddenly the hills I walked up no problem left me huffing and puffing.
People said, oh, you’re out of shape, but it didn’t make sense that I would suddenlybe unable to do something I was doing regularly. Furthermore, no matter how much I pushed to “get in shape” I kept huffing and puffing, week after week, with no progress.
Doctors found nothing.
Not saying this happened to you, and I have no advice, but I did want to say I could relate to that frustration. Maybe you’re just dealing with something perfectly normal, or maybe you do have a heart or lung issue that doctors aren’t seeing and may not be able to help.
In my case, after many years I am not what I was before the illness but I have improved! I think some of the damage healed and while my ability to recover from exertion is still abnormally low, I can now make progress on physical goals.
Good luck to you!1 -
I kind of have the feeling you might not believe us, even though we all say run slower. Let me go a bit more into detail.
In order to get better with running you need to run, not walk.
Why?
When you walk there are always 1 or 2 feet on the ground
When you run there is always zero or 1 foot on the ground
The difference is that running is more similar to jumping than to walking. You propel yourself into the air and both feet are off the ground. Go on, walk 100m and evaluate how difficult it was. Now jump 100m with both feet. How much more difficult was that?
It's a lot more difficult, and it's a completely different way of moving. Hence you won't get better with running by walking. You need to run. And in order to get better at running you need to run longer. You won't get better by running 300m and getting all out of breath. Hence, in order to run longer you need to run slower. Once you're getting better at running you'll also get faster automatically.
A good measure at running slow is still being able to talk. This might be a bit too difficult in the beginning, thus you might also adjust your breathing to the steps. Depending on the size of your lungs you might try inhale during 3 steps, exhale during 3 steps. Or do this over 4. If you can't keep this up then you're too fast. For my slow runs I usually do 4/4 to 3/3 for the really fast ones or fast intervals 2/2.2 -
Has your doctor ever tested you for exercise induced asthma? It may be that you are absolutely fine in normal circumstances but that cardio causes asthma. It could also be that you’re going too fast or (unpopular opinion) you might just not be a runner. I flogged myself a few years ago to do a 10k, just to prove I could. I could out-swim many of the men in my swimming club but I cannot run to save my life. I sound like a wounded hippo.
I do have asthma which is a tiny part of the issue, but I’m just pants at running. And cycling actually. But I can swim, could train martial arts for hours and now weightlift for hours.
You mention that you aren’t happy with the weights you are lifting either: are you following a good progressive programme?2 -
I agree with all of the above votes for doing a run /walk program. That is how I started when I trained for a marathon. I was an accomplished mountain hiker (at altitudes - so no breathing issues) but totally terrible at running. Most couch to 5K to marathon programs start you that way anyway.
The other part that was crucial both for climbing and running is maintaining core strength and spine flexibility. I am devoted to pilates for both but also did weight training when running to make sure I was properly keeping my core strong. If your posture sucks you get more tired and are more likely to injure yourself as well. At least I am ….1 -
One persons slow is another person fast. One persons fast is another persons slow.
+++ for the you are going to fast. It really doesn't matter if you think you are going slow already. If you are going too fast, you will not be able to go the distance. Go even slower than you think you are already going.
C25K is not a race for speed/time. Endurance is what the goal is. Improved speed will come later.
It is ok to repeat days of the program as needed.
Best of Luck
1 -
I just did a mini practice run before I hit the weights. In 4 minutes my pace was 8"2km, don't know if that's about right. I am short with short legs so my stride isn't very long at all.1
-
You're running at 8.2kph, am I understanding that correctly? If so, you definitely need to/have plenty of margin to slow down.
I started running 3 years ago at 6.2kph, 8.2kph was my precise speed yesterday for a long run.
Not saying you need to start as slow as me, but slower than 8 kph definitely.1 -
You're running at 8.2kph, am I understanding that correctly? If so, you definitely need to/have plenty of margin to slow down.
I started running 3 years ago at 6.2kph, 8.2kph was my precise speed yesterday for a long run.
Not saying you need to start as slow as me, but slower than 8 kph definitely.
No according to my watch my speed per hour was 7.17kph.0 -
OK, so a pace of 8min20sec per km is what I didn't understand properly. You ran at that pace for 4 minutes. Could you carry a conversation at that pace?
If not, I'd try a 9min/km pace (6.67kph) and see if that helps, or even slower
As I said above, I started running at 6.2kph and I'm not even particularly short (5ft5/166cm). I know I have zero innate athletic/cardiovascular ability. I was the first one to drop out at school when we did the shuttle run/beep test.
And while I'm sure I'm still a slow runner now comparatively, I actually enjoy it now (my main type of exercise), my speed has increased vastly over the last few years (slow run pace 8.2kph, 5km personal best is under 28min) and I'm very proud to be able to run well over 10km (20km is my personal best).1 -
I find it really hard to go slower, I'm already making a conscious effort to slow down! I'll give it a go tomorrow and see how I get on.1
-
I hope it helps
I know it contradicts what Yirara said above, but if slowing down doesn't help, I would suggest speedwalking/incline walks: I found it very helpful as a way to build up my fitness level.1 -
I hope it helps
I know it contradicts what Yirara said above, but if slowing down doesn't help, I would suggest speedwalking/incline walks: I found it very helpful as a way to build up my fitness level.
Please, do contradict me Lietchi! It's mostly based on personal experience I guess. A few years ago I was playing Pokemon Go every day, speed-walking around 6-15km each day. Then started running again after a break. And while I was fit enough I noticed my body just wasn't used to the movement anymore and I basically started from scratch. I also notice the same right now, starting to run again after an injury break. And I do have to force myself to go really, really slow.0 -
I agree that running is different with regards to the leg muscles (despite my weak fitness level, my calves were what was holding me back in my running at the start) but if fitness level is the issue, the walking may help 0
-
"Fit" is relative. Distance running is a practiced thing...one can be quite physically fit and unable or have great difficulty with distance running because it hasn't been specifically practiced. Often it isn't a matter of cardiovascular capacity if you're already fit, but rather a matter of the body not used to the mechanics of moving in an unpracticed way or using the muscles in an unpracticed way which can lead to a load of discomfort.
As an example, once upon a time my wife and I were very into endurance events and training. She was a 1/2 and full marathon runner and I was an endurance cyclist, regularly participating in 1/2 and full century rides. For fun I did a 5K with my wife which was a cake walk for her but I struggled mightily even though I could easily ride my bike at a good race clip for 100 miles. Conversely, "for fun" my wife decided to join me on a 25 mile ride in Santa Fe...for me that was a joy ride and something I was just doing just to do it...basically *kitten* and giggles for me. She had a pretty rough go of it, and while she completed it, she was surprised that her time was so bad and that I had finished a full 12 minutes earlier than she did. It wasn't so much the distance for her, but rather the rolling hills, lots of climbing, and just generally being uncomfortable in a saddle that long. She slept the whole drive home that afternoon.5 -
So today I went out and I did the C25K week 5 run 2 again so I ran twice for 8 minutes (second time was a bit more, maybe 9) and it was much easier than a minute the other day. I've slowed right down and can pick up the pace later on.
I woke up this morning and thought in 3 years I'll be 40 and want to achieve something so what can I do in that year...I'll run a marathon, ideally the London one buy I didn't realise it was so hard to get into so if I can't do that I'll find another. I may have bitten off more than I can chew but I've got 3 years to train, plenty of time!4 -
So today I went out and I did the C25K week 5 run 2 again so I ran twice for 8 minutes (second time was a bit more, maybe 9) and it was much easier than a minute the other day. I've slowed right down and can pick up the pace later on.
I woke up this morning and thought in 3 years I'll be 40 and want to achieve something so what can I do in that year...I'll run a marathon, ideally the London one buy I didn't realise it was so hard to get into so if I can't do that I'll find another. I may have bitten off more than I can chew but I've got 3 years to train, plenty of time!
You know, you can do this! Maybe not the London marathon due to ticket sparcity, but any marathon. I started running at around your age and I'm still running. One thing I noticed, and I think you noticed here as well is that if I start really slow I can go faster later on no problem. If I start faster then my run usually fails. What also helps is to walk a bit before running. I always make sure I have a walk of about 500-700m to my 'start spot', and then I start slowly, and then pick up later.4 -
So today I went out and I did the C25K week 5 run 2 again so I ran twice for 8 minutes (second time was a bit more, maybe 9) and it was much easier than a minute the other day. I've slowed right down and can pick up the pace later on.
I woke up this morning and thought in 3 years I'll be 40 and want to achieve something so what can I do in that year...I'll run a marathon, ideally the London one buy I didn't realise it was so hard to get into so if I can't do that I'll find another. I may have bitten off more than I can chew but I've got 3 years to train, plenty of time!
You know, you can do this! Maybe not the London marathon due to ticket sparcity, but any marathon. I started running at around your age and I'm still running. One thing I noticed, and I think you noticed here as well is that if I start really slow I can go faster later on no problem. If I start faster then my run usually fails. What also helps is to walk a bit before running. I always make sure I have a walk of about 500-700m to my 'start spot', and then I start slowly, and then pick up later.
I can and I will do this!
I also walk for 5 minutes prior to my run and do a 5+ minute after depending how far I am from home.
Fitting everything in is going to be challenging, I don't want to give up my weight training any time soon although that will have to get dropped with a few month's to go. I work and I have 2 small kids who can't be left alone and a husband who also needs a life and me who occasionally goes out to do something other than exercise.1 -
Since you have three years, I wouldn't jump into a marathon training program right away. Get to doing a 5K and then work on proficiency, then a 10K and work on your 10K proficiency...1/2 marathon, etc, etc. That strategy worked well for my wife and her woman runners group as she built up over the course of a couple of years. She's since "retired" from the 1/2 marathon and marathon game and now only does 10Ks at the most and honestly has the most fun with those...but she hit the long distance endurance stuff pretty hard for a couple of years. Her last race was in Lisbon and she ended up collapsing and blacking out on the course and woke up in the hospital, so that was her retirement party.3
-
A lot have said slow down. Definitely! But it could also be running economy. A shorter stride might help slow the pace down, or you might be able to shorten stride and pick up cadence. Perhaps even maintain pace. If you are striding out where your landing foot catches you out in front of your center, that’s effectively creating a braking effect and you are actually working against yourself. Maybe something to try.0
-
You're running at 8.2kph, am I understanding that correctly? If so, you definitely need to/have plenty of margin to slow down.
I started running 3 years ago at 6.2kph, 8.2kph was my precise speed yesterday for a long run.
Not saying you need to start as slow as me, but slower than 8 kph definitely.
No according to my watch my speed per hour was 7.17kph.
I haven't run since I left the military and no one could force me to run anymore. But when I was running regularly, my pace for an hour was 5 MPH / 8 KMH.
To graduate from USAF basic training these days, women have to cover 1.5 miles in 14 minutes 26 sec, which is 6.43 MPH / 10.3 KPH.
So I agree with the others that you have a lot of room to slow down.0 -
I did a 20 minute run yesterday which I was very proud of myself for. A friend wants me to do a 10K race in October so it would be nice to be able to do that. Maybe a half marathon next year too.
I am going to struggle to fit everything in though, it's proving tough doing 3 running days and 3 weight training days as well as having small kids and a job.
The kids are too young to be left alone and I'm at work 4/5 days they are at school so I'm relying on my husband to be at home but he also needs time to get his stuff done. Don't really know what the solution is other than dropping something/doing one run after a weight session so I can drop one evening.
Maybe I have too many goals, run far, lift heavy, lose weight, build muscle 🤔1 -
I did a 20 minute run yesterday which I was very proud of myself for. A friend wants me to do a 10K race in October so it would be nice to be able to do that. Maybe a half marathon next year too.
I am going to struggle to fit everything in though, it's proving tough doing 3 running days and 3 weight training days as well as having small kids and a job.
The kids are too young to be left alone and I'm at work 4/5 days they are at school so I'm relying on my husband to be at home but he also needs time to get his stuff done. Don't really know what the solution is other than dropping something/doing one run after a weight session so I can drop one evening.
Maybe I have too many goals, run far, lift heavy, lose weight, build muscle 🤔
Pretty much this...at minimum, they're conflicting. Being a 5K runner and lifting, etc isn't too big of a deal, but once you really get into more distance, particularly 1/2 and marathon distances, running pretty much has to be the priority. Even now, my wife mostly does 10Ks and she lifts 2x per week because otherwise she wouldn't get proper recovery (she's also 48). She doesn't lift "heavy" and her gym sessions are namely for cross training purposes and injury prevention and to maintain physical competency. She uses a runners lifting program that she started using several years ago with a coach and it's completely different from a more traditional (lift heavy/build muscle) kind of program. It's definitely not bodybuilding or powerlifting.
When she was really putting in the miles, she only was in the gym once per week. She does a lot of plyometrics, core exercises, and bodyweight work and band/TRX work, much more so than barbell stuff. I was similar when I was heavy into endurance cycling...lifting heavy multiple times per week lead to recovery issues and I worked with a coach to program work that enhanced my cycling skills more so than traditional barbell stuff (though there was some of that). Also, dieting and endurance training is a pretty tough road to ho as it is difficult to find the balance of calories to lose weight efficiently, but not so low as to impede performance. Neither one of us got into long distance endurance stuff until we were in maintenance and could comfortably eat what we needed to to perform and recover.
Mind you, we're both "oldish" and don't recover like we did in our 20s or even 30s.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions