3 months, ZERO PROGRESS
Replies
-
It is not true that if you have a deficit you wil lose "end of story" or "period" if your deficit is too large, you will put your body in starvation mode. your metabolism will slow down and your body will try to keep and store all it can. Your deficit should never be more than 1k calories a day, and your net cals shouldnt be below 1200.0
-
It is not true that if you have a deficit you wil lose "end of story" or "period" if your deficit is too large, you will put your body in starvation mode. your metabolism will slow down and your body will try to keep and store all it can. Your deficit should never be more than 1k calories a day, and your net cals shouldnt be below 1200.
"Starvation mode" isn't a thing that really exists. I agree that (except in extremely rare instances) one should not push their deficit above 1000 calories, but you won't suddenly stop losing weight if you eat too little.0 -
oh to be 29 again and be able to eat 3000 on your cheat day and still lose...Try having your cheat day be the day you go up to 1500, and the rest of the week stick to 1300. You have to create that deficit.
a cheat day is a cheat day.... sometimes my "cheat" days hit close to 3000 calories lol and ive still been losing every week.
You could eat 3000 on a cheat day and still lose. It has very little to do with your age, and everything to do with your discipline the rest of the time.
I dont cheat when I eat 3000. i eat all my calories individually. with vengeance. and then I lick the plate. full tongue out.
The main reason I love MFP is that it gives me an excuse to lick the plate. "I logged these calories already, I need to make sure I get them all!"0 -
i mean this is the nicest way, this article changed my life.
http://www.acaloriecounter.com/blog/why-am-i-not-losing-weight/
i know it doesn't sound that simple, but it really truly is.0 -
I am burning at least 300 calories in a half hour.
This in lies your problem. It is very difficult to burn 300 calories in am half hour in your average everyday workout.0 -
i mean this is the nicest way, this article changed my life.
http://www.acaloriecounter.com/blog/why-am-i-not-losing-weight/
i know it doesn't sound that simple, but it really truly is.
That is a great, great, great article. Bookmarked.0 -
[/quote]
"Starvation mode" isn't a thing that really exists. I agree that (except in extremely rare instances) one should not push their deficit above 1000 calories, but you won't suddenly stop losing weight if you eat too little.
[/quote]
This Doctor says otherwise. Its happened to me. <http://blogs.webmd.com/pamela-peeke-md/2009/07/stop-starving-yourselves.html>0 -
i mean this is the nicest way, this article changed my life.
http://www.acaloriecounter.com/blog/why-am-i-not-losing-weight/
i know it doesn't sound that simple, but it really truly is.
I second this in the nicest way.0 -
"Starvation mode" isn't a thing that really exists. I agree that (except in extremely rare instances) one should not push their deficit above 1000 calories, but you won't suddenly stop losing weight if you eat too little.
This Doctor says otherwise. Its happened to me. <http://blogs.webmd.com/pamela-peeke-md/2009/07/stop-starving-yourselves.html>
She's wrong. Well, technically she's right, but you'll notice she does not mention the magnitude of the effect.
The degree to which your body will adapt metabolically to a low-calorie diet is not nearly enough to stop weight loss on a VLCD.0 -
Check your SODIUM intake... if it's too high (I keep mine lower than what MFP recommends) you could be retaining water, which in turn effects your weight loss progress...0
-
"Starvation mode" isn't a thing that really exists. I agree that (except in extremely rare instances) one should not push their deficit above 1000 calories, but you won't suddenly stop losing weight if you eat too little.
This Doctor says otherwise. Its happened to me. <http://blogs.webmd.com/pamela-peeke-md/2009/07/stop-starving-yourselves.html>
She's wrong. Well, technically she's right, but you'll notice she does not mention the magnitude of the effect.
The degree to which your body will adapt metabolically to a low-calorie diet is not nearly enough to stop weight loss on a VLCD.
http://www.aworkoutroutine.com/starvation-mode/
different article, same sarcastic *kitten*. love it.0 -
I disagree with you. That is not the reality of human beings. There are many more variables.I said and/or.
if your HRM does not have a chest strap and you are using it for weight training you are over estimating burns.
It doesn't matter the deficet in reality if you are at a deficet you will lose. People on VLCD (very low calories diet) lose weight not in a good way but they still lose.
End of story.
Actually this is the reality unless you have thryoid problems or PCOS which in most cases it is known and these questions are not asked.
I've been reading this thread and thinking PCOS the whole time.0 -
I disagree with you. That is not the reality of human beings. There are many more variables.I said and/or.
if your HRM does not have a chest strap and you are using it for weight training you are over estimating burns.
It doesn't matter the deficet in reality if you are at a deficet you will lose. People on VLCD (very low calories diet) lose weight not in a good way but they still lose.
End of story.
Actually this is the reality unless you have thryoid problems or PCOS which in most cases it is known and these questions are not asked.
I've been reading this thread and thinking PCOS the whole time.
yeah, maybe if she was measuring her food and doing everything right, then yeah, maybe consider things like that... but thats like me looking in the mirror one morning and thinking i have lupus since my cheeks are a bit red... maybe it was because i was in the sun yesterday? rule out the small things, before suspecting the big things...0 -
Hi Aimee. I am wondering how many grams of carbs you are eating per day? What kind of calories you eat matters.
I started my weight loss about a year ago because I noticed that though I was working just as hard at my summer job, which is physical labor in a greenhouse, I wasn't losing the weight I usually did every summer. I wasn't eating any different. I asked my doctor. She said It's possible that you could be carb sensitive. This was new to me and actually there is new research into this that can be found on the internet.
If I'm remembering what I read, our body's ability to process carbs correctly can change over time especially if we tend to be big carb consumers. Carbs are supposed to be metabolized into fuel for our muscles and any excess that we don't use gets stored as fat. There are changes that can happen (which have to do with your liver I believe) that make your body send less carb energy to your muscles and more directly to fat storage. Bummer huh? I am definitely in this category and have to keep my carb intake at absolutely no more than 100 grams a day while keeping my protein up and total calories between 1200 - 1400 per day to lose weight which creates a 300 - 500 calorie deficit for me.
Also, if you're calorie intake is too low it can actually trigger this fat storage process. I friend who is a nurse and pretty informed about weight loss said that when you reduce your caloric intake gently by just a few hundred calories a day vs. drastically your body doesn't turn on the "Slow down the metabolism! Store fat! We're starving! alarm" and you will lose weight more easily over time.
I would suggest reading up on this. Hope it helps. Also, Fitday has a more detailed process of finding out the appropriate number of calories for you each day. I like this site better for everything else. Good luck.
Melanie0 -
epic facepalm0
-
Hi,
I've definitely been here, but the times of the day really mean alot as well. Are you eating Breakfast, 2-3 hrs later Snack, 2 hrs later Lunch, 2-3 hrs later Snack, 2 hrs later Dinner. Also, when are you working out? You should try incorporating green tea, grapefruit (if not on medication) cayenne pepper into your diet as well. It will increase fat burning. Also, make sure you are breaking a sweat when working out. I know it gets costly to eat clean, but there are alot of foods out there that are inexpensive, like a bag of grapefruits are around $5.00, quick oats (plain), cottage cheese, eggs, spinach, broccoli, lettuce, and family pack of chicken. Nice easy marinade for chicken-extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic or garlic powder, and fresh basil. Keep them in a ziploc bag on hand and grill one up put it over steamed spinach or a salad......it's a very filling meal. Also, keep carrots, celery, and cucumbers cut up at all times in the fridge in ziploc bags, Portion control is so important. You want to keep your body eating and burning all day. If you crave sugar.....peel and cut up some apples with a little sprinkle of cinnamon and put in the microwave for about 10 seconds and you have a nice treat. Don't give up!! You can do this!!!0 -
Hi Aimee. I am wondering how many grams of carbs you are eating per day? What kind of calories you eat matters.
I started my weight loss about a year ago because I noticed that though I was working just as hard at my summer job, which is physical labor in a greenhouse, I wasn't losing the weight I usually did every summer. I wasn't eating any different. I asked my doctor. She said It's possible that you could be carb sensitive. This was new to me and actually there is new research into this that can be found on the internet.
If I'm remembering what I read, our body's ability to process carbs correctly can change over time especially if we tend to be big carb consumers. Carbs are supposed to be metabolized into fuel for our muscles and any excess that we don't use gets stored as fat. There are changes that can happen (which have to do with your liver I believe) that make your body send less carb energy to your muscles and more directly to fat storage. Bummer huh? I am definitely in this category and have to keep my carb intake at absolutely no more than 100 grams a day while keeping my protein up and total calories between 1200 - 1400 per day to lose weight which creates a 300 - 500 calorie deficit for me.
Also, if you're calorie intake is too low it can actually trigger this fat storage process. I friend who is a nurse and pretty informed about weight loss said that when you reduce your caloric intake gently by just a few hundred calories a day vs. drastically your body doesn't turn on the "Slow down the metabolism! Store fat! We're starving! alarm" and you will lose weight more easily over time.
I would suggest reading up on this. Hope it helps. Also, Fitday has a more detailed process of finding out the appropriate number of calories for you each day. I like this site better for everything else. Good luck.
Melanie
This was your first post, Melanie.
It should also be the last [until you read enough to understand why this post is so wrong].0 -
Hi,
I've definitely been here, but the times of the day really mean alot as well. Are you eating Breakfast, 2-3 hrs later Snack, 2 hrs later Lunch, 2-3 hrs later Snack, 2 hrs later Dinner. Also, when are you working out? You should try incorporating green tea, grapefruit (if not on medication) cayenne pepper into your diet as well. It will increase fat burning. Also, make sure you are breaking a sweat when working out. I know it gets costly to eat clean, but there are alot of foods out there that are inexpensive, like a bag of grapefruits are around $5.00, quick oats (plain), cottage cheese, eggs, spinach, broccoli, lettuce, and family pack of chicken. Nice easy marinade for chicken-extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic or garlic powder, and fresh basil. Keep them in a ziploc bag on hand and grill one up put it over steamed spinach or a salad......it's a very filling meal. Also, keep carrots, celery, and cucumbers cut up at all times in the fridge in ziploc bags, Portion control is so important. You want to keep your body eating and burning all day. If you crave sugar.....peel and cut up some apples with a little sprinkle of cinnamon and put in the microwave for about 10 seconds and you have a nice treat. Don't give up!! You can do this!!!
so thats what ive been doing wromg... i forgot to sync my body to the clock on the wall...0 -
Hi,
I've definitely been here, but the times of the day really mean alot as well. Are you eating Breakfast, 2-3 hrs later Snack, 2 hrs later Lunch, 2-3 hrs later Snack, 2 hrs later Dinner. Also, when are you working out? You should try incorporating green tea, grapefruit (if not on medication) cayenne pepper into your diet as well. It will increase fat burning. Also, make sure you are breaking a sweat when working out. I know it gets costly to eat clean, but there are alot of foods out there that are inexpensive, like a bag of grapefruits are around $5.00, quick oats (plain), cottage cheese, eggs, spinach, broccoli, lettuce, and family pack of chicken. Nice easy marinade for chicken-extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic or garlic powder, and fresh basil. Keep them in a ziploc bag on hand and grill one up put it over steamed spinach or a salad......it's a very filling meal. Also, keep carrots, celery, and cucumbers cut up at all times in the fridge in ziploc bags, Portion control is so important. You want to keep your body eating and burning all day. If you crave sugar.....peel and cut up some apples with a little sprinkle of cinnamon and put in the microwave for about 10 seconds and you have a nice treat. Don't give up!! You can do this!!!
Big ol pile of "NOPE"0 -
This Doctor says otherwise.
The evidence is overwhelming that the doctor is just plain wrong.0 -
Why is this thread still going? I thought OP determined her body could bend the rules of physics days ago and peaced out.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
i spitlaughed0
-
i'd like to the the lads' and lasses' of mfp for keeping me entertained at work.0
-
10 pages of discussion on someone complaining of lack of progress but has a closed diary and doesn't weigh her food.
This should have been closed on the first page.
Yup.
Then you get all the "Oh my poor dear, hang in there, please don't give up" Followed by same old advice. Lol.
OP already knows what she needs to do.
Did people skip the middle of this post???
OP has acknowledged quite a lot of good advice and she'll be checking her TDEE. She's also booked an appointment with the doctor and is looking into a registered dietician.
People starting the conversation all over again after she posted said responses it seems.
I know we're used to people complaining and not doing anything with the very valuable info they receive, but this OP is not one of those people.0 -
i mean this is the nicest way, this article changed my life.
http://www.acaloriecounter.com/blog/why-am-i-not-losing-weight/
i know it doesn't sound that simple, but it really truly is.
That is a great, great, great article.
QFT0 -
From what I understand about how MFP works, is the calorie budget your given is calculated with the, lets say, 500 calorie deficit. So I've read in other forums that you should be eating your exercise calories back so you don't have too much of a calorie deficit. Maybe you're not eating enough, and your body needs more nutrients.0
-
In my first 4-months I lost nothing. Then in the 5th month: -7 lbs. Just keep at it, you'll figure out what works for you.0
-
10 pages of discussion on someone complaining of lack of progress but has a closed diary and doesn't weigh her food.
This should have been closed on the first page.
Yup.
Then you get all the "Oh my poor dear, hang in there, please don't give up" Followed by same old advice. Lol.
OP already knows what she needs to do.
Did people skip the middle of this post???
OP has acknowledged quite a lot of good advice and she'll be checking her TDEE. She's also booked an appointment with the doctor and is looking into a registered dietician.
People starting the conversation all over again after she posted said responses it seems.
I know we're used to people complaining and not doing anything with the very valuable info they receive, but this OP is not one of those people.
Chances are that she's not calculating calorie intake correctly or consistently over time. Her closed diary makes it impossible to examine this.0 -
This exact same thing happened to me. I was weighing EVERYTING and tracking EVERY DAY! Working out 5 days a week and was sooooo good and totally could not lose weight. At all.
But really? I WASN'T tracking weekends, because I don't eat and drink THAT much and I have created a HUGE deficit and I walked to the laundro-Mat and I deserve a 'cheat day'. Oops.
Turns out I was drinking my weight in wine and eating blocks of cheese and crackers thus completely negating any deficit I may have created during the week.
Well go figure.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions