Numerical models for determining Max TDEE deficits
I've been trying to formalize the relationships between all the various energy stores in the body (glycogen, adipose fat, intramuscular triglycerides), energy sources (ingested food), and calorie burns (BMR, non-exercise, exercise). So I have this spreadsheet laid out where I map the rates of all these processes on an hour by hour basis. IE, at 0300h, the body is sleeping and burning at the BMR rate. At 0900h, it is burning BMR + non-exercise + resistance training, and digesting a pre-workout meal of 20% of the daily intake of carbs/protein/fat.
From the literature, I pulled a number of rates that are used in all this:
- Fat stores metabolize at 30 calories/day/pound of fat
- Intramuscular triglycerides metabolize at 80% of fat store metabolism
- Glycogen stores are tapped when instantaneous burn is greater than fat stores and ingestion can provide
- Glycogen stores are replenished when the opposite is true
- Carbs/Protein/Fat are metabolized at 60g/8g/5g per hour
- Resistance training co-opts 75% of protein for rebuilding if there is enough energy from other sources
So now I get to play with the numbers. I can create a body that weighs X pounds with Y% body fat, with whatever exercise burn pattern I like over a 24 hour period, and find the lower limit on sustainable TDEE deficit by seeing when glycogen stores are no longer able to replenish. Obviously the numbers are totally dependent on the quality of assumptions around metabolic rates.
This is a sampling of what I see - with a *daily* routine of one hour resistance training (300 calories) in the morning and one hour of intense cardio (1000 calories) in the afternoon...
A person with 30% body fat can support a TDEE deficit of 50%
A person with 20% body fat can support a TDEE deficit of 25%
A person with 15% body fat can support a TDEE deficit of 10%
A person with 10% body fat can't support a TDEE deficit at all
By "support" I mean the body starts with glycogen stores that do not deplete over the 24H cycle, allowing the exact same activity to be performed the next day. Taking days off will obviously increase the size of the supportable deficit. This does not take into account nutrients at all - that's just too complex for me to model at this point.
There is a crapload of interesting relationships that pop up - IE, resistance training reduces size of the max possible deficit at any given body fat %age (that's a Good Thing!) and if you don't fuel with carbs while lifting, there won't be any protein available for muscle building because fat stores can't provide energy fast enough.
Anyway, it's entirely possible I've completely screwed this up. The results look kinda reasonable, so far, but I'd be very curious is anybody else has gone through an exercise like this, or knows of a paper/article that ties all these rates and factors together into a numerical model.