Saturated Fats
esmeylull
Posts: 68
Yeah, I know. This is the most common question ever but... saturated fats aren't bad for you. I always knew coconut oil or butter as good fats. Or am I wrong? Please enlighten me
0
Replies
-
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)0 -
Well, google is actually your friend here. There is a lot of evolving thoughts around fats, which are good and bad for your and why. Also new and more compelling research about what chloresterol really is and does. I, personally, think we are badly infomed and BIG PHARMA has lead us down the primose path. But that debate is for another day. And one I had with my own Doctor when she suggested statins to me (I have "high" chloresterol, but excellent LDL: Triglycerides ratio -which many believe is the best indicator of risk. Had to fire that one on two counts: statins for women and not understaning or even bothering to look at my ratios.
Good Luck!0 -
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)0 -
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)
that's a good question. that comes from the chocolate, so I'm guessing corn starch as a filler with more flavoring and artificial stuff in the chocolate?0 -
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)
that's a good question. that comes from the chocolate, so I'm guessing corn starch as a filler with more flavoring and artificial stuff in the chocolate?0 -
OMG, not another one of these threads. :yawn:
Saturated fats does not contribute to risk of heart disease. Some literature backing this up shown below:
Siri-Tarino PW, et al. Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2010.
Mente A, et al. A systematic review of the evidence supporting a causal link between dietary factors and coronary heart disease. Archives of Internal Medicine, 2009.
Dreon DM, et al. Change in dietary saturated fat intake is correlated with change in mass of large low-density-lipoprotein particles in men. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1998.0 -
Yeah, I know. This is the most common question ever but... saturated fats aren't bad for you. I always knew coconut oil or butter as good fats. Or am I wrong? Please enlighten me
Quick question for the OP - are you bored at the moment? I'm just curious because you seem to like posting "controversial" topics - Eg natural sugar last night now saturated fat. What next? Maybe low carb or have you already done that and I missed it.0 -
Yeah, I know. This is the most common question ever but... saturated fats aren't bad for you. I always knew coconut oil or butter as good fats. Or am I wrong? Please enlighten me
Quick question for the OP - are you bored at the moment? I'm just curious because you seem to like posting "controversial" topics - Eg natural sugar last night now saturated fat. What next? Maybe low carb or have you already done that and I missed it.
Are you always this rude ? Don't like my question? Don't answer it.0 -
Yeah, I know. This is the most common question ever but... saturated fats aren't bad for you. I always knew coconut oil or butter as good fats. Or am I wrong? Please enlighten me
Quick question for the OP - are you bored at the moment? I'm just curious because you seem to like posting "controversial" topics - Eg natural sugar last night now saturated fat. What next? Maybe low carb or have you already done that and I missed it.
Are you always this rude ? Don't like my question? Don't answer it.
Me rude? LOL if you think that's rude then you have a lot to learn........0 -
Yeah, I know. This is the most common question ever but... saturated fats aren't bad for you. I always knew coconut oil or butter as good fats. Or am I wrong? Please enlighten me
Quick question for the OP - are you bored at the moment? I'm just curious because you seem to like posting "controversial" topics - Eg natural sugar last night now saturated fat. What next? Maybe low carb or have you already done that and I missed it.
Are you always this rude ? Don't like my question? Don't answer it.
Actually, I was wondering the same thing as mungowungo. It's pretty disheartening to see these threads reduced to high school level verbal mud slinging. So, when someone brings up a series of controversial topics that end up in mud slinging, it raises a few eyebrows. No need to get upset over it, I don't think mungowungo meant harm.0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
Also, in as much as I've read, there are substantial differences in the saturated fat from animals vs plants...so not all saturated fats are created equal. Medium vs long chain...blah, blah, blah, blah....0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.0
-
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
I've done a fair amount of research and ultimately just end up going in circles. I guess at this point I'm convinced that I don't have to go out of my way to cut it out completely or even make great efforts to reduce my consumption...it's not particularly a lot anyway...but I'm not convinced that I can just eat all the saturated fats I want with zero health consequences either.
I suppose I'm in an "it's just fine in moderation" mode like I am with pretty much everything else.
I would also add that I think part of the issue with the approach that has been taken in the U.S. has been an overall reduction in fat in general, not just the saturated variety. Low fat/no fat is a recipe for disaster in my estimation.0 -
Yeah, I know. This is the most common question ever but... saturated fats aren't bad for you. I always knew coconut oil or butter as good fats. Or am I wrong? Please enlighten me
Quick question for the OP - are you bored at the moment? I'm just curious because you seem to like posting "controversial" topics - Eg natural sugar last night now saturated fat. What next? Maybe low carb or have you already done that and I missed it.
Are you always this rude ? Don't like my question? Don't answer it.
Actually, I was wondering the same thing as mungowungo. It's pretty disheartening to see these threads reduced to high school level verbal mud slinging. So, when someone brings up a series of controversial topics that end up in mud slinging, it raises a few eyebrows. No need to get upset over it, I don't think mungowungo meant harm.
Thank you.
And since this is a public forum I will post in any thread I choose to. There is no need to send me PMs not to.
And if you want to you can look at my blog. There are quite a few sources articles in there about saturated fats. If you are truly interested you could start by looking for "The Oiling of America". It is on YouTube - it is a very informative talk.0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
I've done a fair amount of research and ultimately just end up going in circles. I guess at this point I'm convinced that I don't have to go out of my way to cut it out completely or even make great efforts to reduce my consumption...it's not particularly a lot anyway...but I'm not convinced that I can just eat all the saturated fats I want with zero health consequences either.
I suppose I'm in an "it's just fine in moderation" mode like I am with pretty much everything else.
I would also add that I think part of the issue with the approach that has been taken in the U.S. has been an overall reduction in fat in general, not just the saturated variety. Low fat/no fat is a recipe for disaster in my estimation.0 -
I personally had a marked improvement in my cholesterol levels by going out of my way to eat more plant sources of saturated fat. Don't know if it needed to be plant sourced, but I don't like butter, fatty meat or a lot of cheeses anyway. My cholesterol (total and HDL) was clinically low 2 yrs ago, and I've raised my cholesterol 30 points (31 of which by my HDL) with a cleanish IIFYM diet with focus on eating 15 or so g of saturated fat more than I was before.
And fwiw I eat like 32 oz of meat everyday, so just animal products don't raise MY cholesterol...I do eat a lot of fruit, vegetables and soluble fiber though.0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
Also, in as much as I've read, there are substantial differences in the saturated fat from animals vs plants...so not all saturated fats are created equal. Medium vs long chain...blah, blah, blah, blah....
This^^ Research is still evolving, Long chain saturated fats are more unhealthy than medium chain. The medium chain is what is in Coconut oil. Some people can handle saturated fats better than others.0 -
I personally had a marked improvement in my cholesterol levels by going out of my way to eat more plant sources of saturated fat. Don't know if it needed to be plant sourced, but I don't like butter, fatty meat or a lot of cheeses anyway. My cholesterol (total and HDL) was clinically low 2 yrs ago, and I've raised my cholesterol 30 points (31 of which by my HDL) with a cleanish IIFYM diet with focus on eating 15 or so g of saturated fat more than I was before.
And fwiw I eat like 32 oz of meat everyday, so just animal products don't raise MY cholesterol...I do eat a lot of fruit, vegetables and soluble fiber though.
Honest question...do you believe it was the increase in plant sources of saturated fats or the mono-unsaturated fats in things like nuts, avocado, etc. I have seen similar results...a year ago my HDL was around 22 and now I'm at 50. Unfortunately, I can't really point to any one thing...I started eating more nuts and avocados and using more olive oil and avocado oil in my cooking...but I also quit smoking (was a 2-3 PAD smoker) and started a regular exercise regimen.
By the same token, my LDL levels have dropped significantly...about 35 points over 12 months time and I am now in the "healthy" range without meds. I also eat quite a lot of fruit, vegetables, and soluble fiber and I supplement with plant sterols. I eat beef or pork probably 3x weekly but otherwise eat a lot of chicken, salmon, mahi mahi, and lots of eggs...
I never know exactly what to make of all of this stuff other than I'm rockin' it thus far and will just continue on I suppose...0 -
For me, it's been dark chocolate/coconut. The rest of my macros were pretty consistent.
My total was 109, and it was 138 at my last bloodwork and 140 the time before. Most of my immediate family (including 34 yo sister) are on meds for high cholesterol, so mine isn't just "good genetics".
I've raised my HDL from 29 to 60.0 -
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)
that's a good question. that comes from the chocolate, so I'm guessing corn starch as a filler with more flavoring and artificial stuff in the chocolate?
What does this even mean? 7% of what..?0 -
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)
that's a good question. that comes from the chocolate, so I'm guessing corn starch as a filler with more flavoring and artificial stuff in the chocolate?
What does this even mean? 7% of what..?
Caloric daily total I think0 -
You can eat fat but just don't get fat.0
-
I personally had a marked improvement in my cholesterol levels by going out of my way to eat more plant sources of saturated fat. Don't know if it needed to be plant sourced, but I don't like butter, fatty meat or a lot of cheeses anyway. My cholesterol (total and HDL) was clinically low 2 yrs ago, and I've raised my cholesterol 30 points (31 of which by my HDL) with a cleanish IIFYM diet with focus on eating 15 or so g of saturated fat more than I was before.
And fwiw I eat like 32 oz of meat everyday, so just animal products don't raise MY cholesterol...I do eat a lot of fruit, vegetables and soluble fiber though.0 -
saturated fats lead to high cholesterol which leads to heart disease...
(I just wanted to toe the company line in case they were watching)
that's a good question. that comes from the chocolate, so I'm guessing corn starch as a filler with more flavoring and artificial stuff in the chocolate?
What does this even mean? 7% of what..?0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
Also, in as much as I've read, there are substantial differences in the saturated fat from animals vs plants...so not all saturated fats are created equal. Medium vs long chain...blah, blah, blah, blah....
This^^ Research is still evolving, Long chain saturated fats are more unhealthy than medium chain. The medium chain is what is in Coconut oil. Some people can handle saturated fats better than others.0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
Also, in as much as I've read, there are substantial differences in the saturated fat from animals vs plants...so not all saturated fats are created equal. Medium vs long chain...blah, blah, blah, blah....
This^^ Research is still evolving, Long chain saturated fats are more unhealthy than medium chain. The medium chain is what is in Coconut oil. Some people can handle saturated fats better than others.
Exactly...which isomers of saturated fat? Careful with the assumptions that are not in agreement with organic chemistry.0 -
I personally had a marked improvement in my cholesterol levels by going out of my way to eat more plant sources of saturated fat. Don't know if it needed to be plant sourced, but I don't like butter, fatty meat or a lot of cheeses anyway. My cholesterol (total and HDL) was clinically low 2 yrs ago, and I've raised my cholesterol 30 points (31 of which by my HDL) with a cleanish IIFYM diet with focus on eating 15 or so g of saturated fat more than I was before.
And fwiw I eat like 32 oz of meat everyday, so just animal products don't raise MY cholesterol...I do eat a lot of fruit, vegetables and soluble fiber though.
Honest question...do you believe it was the increase in plant sources of saturated fats or the mono-unsaturated fats in things like nuts, avocado, etc. I have seen similar results...a year ago my HDL was around 22 and now I'm at 50. Unfortunately, I can't really point to any one thing...I started eating more nuts and avocados and using more olive oil and avocado oil in my cooking...but I also quit smoking (was a 2-3 PAD smoker) and started a regular exercise regimen.
By the same token, my LDL levels have dropped significantly...about 35 points over 12 months time and I am now in the "healthy" range without meds. I also eat quite a lot of fruit, vegetables, and soluble fiber and I supplement with plant sterols. I eat beef or pork probably 3x weekly but otherwise eat a lot of chicken, salmon, mahi mahi, and lots of eggs...
I never know exactly what to make of all of this stuff other than I'm rockin' it thus far and will just continue on I suppose...
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2014286/0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
Also, in as much as I've read, there are substantial differences in the saturated fat from animals vs plants...so not all saturated fats are created equal. Medium vs long chain...blah, blah, blah, blah....
This^^ Research is still evolving, Long chain saturated fats are more unhealthy than medium chain. The medium chain is what is in Coconut oil. Some people can handle saturated fats better than others.
Exactly...which isomers of saturated fat? Careful with the assumptions that are not in agreement with organic chemistry.
I could not tell you the exact breakdown anymore. Ive been out of college to long to remember. I'm a registered Dietitian so I have gone through organic Chem and all that fun stuff. However the saturated fats that are long chain have been shown to be "stickier" and are the ones that tend to stick to the walls of your veins/arteries....however like I said, research on this is still evolving and new information is coming out everyday. I have seen some people with perfect cholesterol levels, then they started using coconut oil/taking a coconut oil supplement and their cholesterol levels started to climb. That was the only change they made in their daily routine. So again everyone handles fats differently, saturated, long chain, medium chain or short chain. Depending on genetics and the persons body can contribute to cholesterol and in some it does not.0 -
I have yet to be convinced either way. I don't go out of my way to avoid saturated fats, but I generally stick to around 20g per day as a general rule. I have a family history of high LDL cholesterol and heart disease and dropping dead at relatively young ages from heart attacks...so I don't take any of this too lightly and just try to be as healthy as I can be.
Also, in as much as I've read, there are substantial differences in the saturated fat from animals vs plants...so not all saturated fats are created equal. Medium vs long chain...blah, blah, blah, blah....
This^^ Research is still evolving, Long chain saturated fats are more unhealthy than medium chain. The medium chain is what is in Coconut oil. Some people can handle saturated fats better than others.
Exactly...which isomers of saturated fat? Careful with the assumptions that are not in agreement with organic chemistry.
I could not tell you the exact breakdown anymore. Ive been out of college to long to remember. I'm a registered Dietitian so I have gone through organic Chem and all that fun stuff. However the saturated fats that are long chain have been shown to be "stickier" and are the ones that tend to stick to the walls of your veins/arteries....however like I said, research on this is still evolving and new information is coming out everyday. I have seen some people with perfect cholesterol levels, then they started using coconut oil/taking a coconut oil supplement and their cholesterol levels started to climb. That was the only change they made in their daily routine. So again everyone handles fats differently, saturated, long chain, medium chain or short chain. Depending on genetics and the persons body can contribute to cholesterol and in some it does not.
I agree with you when you said that the science is evolving. It is not uncommon to hear about people improving their LDL and HDL with a change in their diet by INCREASING natural fats, including the natural saturated fats. I am one of those people. And I refuse to be considered a rare snowflake. And there is more evidence in the scientific literature that certain fats, including saturated fats, which were once demonized, are now regarded as healthy and not a contributor to risk of heart disease.0 -
Frankly our level of knowledge about nutrition is so lacking that trying to say specific types of fats are simply better than others, or whatever, is unsupportable.
Don't get caught up in the details, especially when we're so clueless. Just eat food you enjoy, eat lots of veggies, exercise, and get appropriate macro and calorie intake. Spend the rest of your time doing things worthwhile.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions