We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Body Fat Measurements - wasn't sure where to post

akadrea
akadrea Posts: 85 Member
edited February 15 in Fitness and Exercise
So,
I've had my body fat measured with calipers over the last 7 months by a trainer at my gym, and according to his measurements, I've lost 7% body fat since last summer. The only thing is - I don't FEEL like I should at the number I'm given - according to his measurements, I'm down to 10.5% body fat and I don't look RIPPED or anything (yes, I lift weights, probably not as consistently as I should or progressively heavy) but, Dang! Shouldn't I be seeing some serious definition????

Replies

  • MyRummyHens
    MyRummyHens Posts: 141 Member
    Is that profile picture representative of how you are now?

    I'm really interested in what answers you get. Arm wise you and I are very similar, I am not far behind you on the tummy muscle front, and I *may* just have slightly more leg muscle visible. I think I'm at about 18%, give or take.
  • 212019156
    212019156 Posts: 341 Member
    I would question that reading looking at your profile pic. 10.5% is pretty damn low for a female. If you really want to know what your body fat percent is get a DEXA scan done. You have to ask if they have a total body scan mode and a body composition option installed, because they don't come standard with that.

    If you get a total body scan done it will break down you body composition into different areas of your body and it will be way more accurate than a caliper especially when you are lean.

    By the way I used to work at GE medical and worked extensively with these devices. When I would scan someone and get a reading of 10% they were ususally extremely lean looking and vascular. I would also typically see that someone who had a caliper reading of 10% was in reality more like 13 or 14%. Hologic makes a DEXA scanner as well but I am not familiar with their body comp capabilities.
  • LeanButNotMean44
    LeanButNotMean44 Posts: 852 Member
    I would question that reading looking at your profile pic. 10.5% is pretty damn low for a female. If you really want to know what your body fat percent is get a DEXA scan done. You have to ask if they have a total body scan mode and a body composition option installed, because they don't come standard with that.

    If you get a total body scan done it will break down you body composition into different areas of your body and it will be way more accurate than a caliper especially when you are lean.

    By the way I used to work at GE medical and worked extensively with these devices. When I would scan someone and get a reading of 10% they were ususally extremely lean looking and vascular. I would also typically see that someone who had a caliper reading of 10% was in reality more like 13 or 14%. Hologic makes a DEXA scanner as well but I am not familiar with their body comp capabilities.

    Agree with the above. I also came out at 10-10.5% using calipers, but when I was Dexa'd it was 15.65% (my body type is way different than yours though - I am a pear shape).
  • akadrea
    akadrea Posts: 85 Member
    Is that profile picture representative of how you are now?

    I'm really interested in what answers you get. Arm wise you and I are very similar, I am not far behind you on the tummy muscle front, and I *may* just have slightly more leg muscle visible. I think I'm at about 18%, give or take.

    Yes - maybe a little leaner now - yeah - 10.5% just doesn't sound right to me!
This discussion has been closed.