Which of these bridesmaid dresses should I choose?

_lyndseybrooke_

I was asked to be a bridesmaid in a friend’s wedding in May. She picked out the color champagne for the dresses, but is allowing us to choose our own style. I haven’t been able to find a single thing in a store, so it appears I’ll have to order something from online.

I’ve chosen to order from a company through Amazon called CocoMelody even though the $30 shipping cost is outrageous, simply because you can’t beat the fantastic reviews. I’m trying to choose between these two dresses:

One: http://www.amazon.com/Landybridal-A-line-Length-Bridesmaid-Champagne/dp/B00B1OSW8Q/ref=sr_1_1?s=apparel&ie=UTF8&qid=1394206002&sr=1-1&keywords=corset+champagne+dress
Two: http://www.amazon.com/Landybridal-Corset-Length-E22659-Champagne/dp/B00B1OSLLY/ref=sr_1_2?s=apparel&ie=UTF8&qid=1394206002&sr=1-2&keywords=corset+champagne+dress

Yeah, yeah, I know they’re very similar, both being knee-length strapless corset dresses. Both have great reviews as well. It’s a rustic-theme wedding, so we’ll be wearing cowgirl boots (that I have yet to purchase). So, I’m wondering which of these dresses would probably look best with the boots. They both have the corset tie-up back with a side zipper that many have had issues with, but is easily fixed/replaceable. The obnoxious flower is detachable on both.

For reference, I’m about 5’5” and 135 lbs. I’m ordering a medium and will take it in if I need to.

So, let’s take a vote: one or two?

SweetTrouble_

I vote #2

momof3and3

#2

drangonfly2323

I prefer #2, but they are both really cute.

knittnponder

#2

Keliandra

#2 will make your waist look smaller

BusyRaeNOTBusty

I like the retro look of number one. Kind of pin-up-y.

cindyj7

Definitely #2. I'm sure you'd look beautiful in either.

BekaBooluvsu

#2. has more detail in the dress

RunsOnEspresso

2.

Something about 1 just doesn't sit right. I think it's the pleating on the skirt make it look heavy or matronly?

seltzermint555

Champagne dresses with cowgirl boots. I'd end the friendship.

fruitsalad15

I think 1 looks more classy! Both are very cute and I think perhaps 2 would go better with the boots having the different layers on the hem line!

KateRepine

#2

rhoule76

#2, top is more flattering and I agree that it will make your waist look smaller.

HedgeHugs

Oooooo #2

disneygirl626

Apparently I'm in the minorite but #1 is simple and classy. I like that one better.

82jeh

#2

ruffnstuff

I think given the context that you can't control, #2 would look "better" with the boots.

treineck

#2, but it would be really cute if the top of #1 had the bottom of #2...then it would be perfect lol

TomTomato

#1. But I am a 48-year-old dude. So take that with a grain of salt...

SummerRain43

I like them both but I think I like #1 better.....it will come in nicely at the waist and show off your waist well and I like that fact that it's not quite as floofy as the second one....in my opinion, less is more.....and especially if your boots might be a little elaborate....to have two items that might be a little busy, would take away from both....but they are both lovely....:)

fitgirlandfoodie

#1 I think the pleat thingy in the second one will date badly in photos etc..

Blessed9jaBeauty

#2, but it would be really cute if the top of #1 had the bottom of #2...then it would be perfect lol

OMG! My sentiments EXACTLY! LOL!:flowerforyou: Whatever you choose, I'm sure you'll look lovely. I pray that the day and the marriage is a success.

climbing_trees

#1 but take the flower off.

da1128

I like the simplicity of #1. #2 might be a bit busy with boots. You will look great in either dress!

Ask yourself, can I wear this dress again for another occasion? Would I want to? If so, go for the more classic #1.

Apparently, you are required to wear the cowgirl boots in the wedding to go with the 'theme'?

Just my opinion, but classic pumps would look better with both.

I am also in the minority, but I'd go with #1.

_lyndseybrooke_

I like the simplicity of #1. #2 might be a bit busy with boots. You will look great in either dress!

Ask yourself, can I wear this dress again for another occasion? Would I want to? If so, go for the more classic #1.

Apparently, you are required to wear the cowgirl boots in the wedding to go with the 'theme'?

Just my opinion, but classic pumps would look better with both.

I am also in the minority, but I'd go with #1.

Yes, it's a rustic/country themed wedding. Cowgirl boots are required from all the bridesmaids. The bride will be wearing them as well, but her wedding dress is long. Think this type of thing: http://rusticweddingchic.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/bridesmaids-in-cowboy-boots.jpeg

I'm actually really excited about it. They'll definitely be more comfortable than the heels I wore to the only other wedding I've been in. I wore flats at my own wedding.

AlsDonkBoxSquat

2

Kalee34

If I were buying it myself I would choose #2.

Legs_McGee

I vote for #2

brewji

#2

Naina145

I love #1 but if your wearing boots #2 would look better with it.