fat vs sugar

2»

Replies

  • Rocbola
    Rocbola Posts: 1,998 Member
    People can still consume oils and sugar, and still be healthy in spite of this. I would just prefer to be honest with myself about those items; they are not health promoting foods, they are health compromising foods.

    And people eat 500 calories of oil without realizing it all the time. A large order of fries is already about 300 calories just from the oil.
  • J72FIT
    J72FIT Posts: 6,008 Member
    People can still consume oils and sugar, and still be healthy in spite of this. I would just prefer to be honest with myself about those items; they are not health promoting foods, they are health compromising foods.

    And people eat 500 calories of oil without realizing it all the time. A large order of fries is already about 300 calories just from the oil.

    I am not convinced how health compromising oils and sugars are in the context of an otherwise healthy diet.
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    People can still consume oils and sugar, and still be healthy in spite of this. I would just prefer to be honest with myself about those items; they are not health promoting foods, they are health compromising foods.

    And people eat 500 calories of oil without realizing it all the time. A large order of fries is already about 300 calories just from the oil.

    I am not convinced how health compromising oils and sugars are in the context of an otherwise healthy diet.

    That was my question as well.

    I am not sure how these would be harmful in an otherwise balanced diet (assuming no medical conditions of course). If the diet is not balanced - then it's the diet's 'fault' and not the food source.
  • Derpes
    Derpes Posts: 2,033 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!
  • Rocbola
    Rocbola Posts: 1,998 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!
    Most of the people on this site would probably say "Ooooh that sounds great! As long as i log the calories, there will be no deleterious effects...."
  • DamePiglet
    DamePiglet Posts: 3,730 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!
    Most of the people on this site would probably say "Ooooh that sounds great! As long as i log the calories, there will be no deleterious effects...."

    more sugar, vanilla instead of water and maybe a dash of milk and what you have there is frosting.

    So, yeah.
    There really wouldn't be any deleterious effects.

    ETA:
    I like frosting. I don't like buttholes.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!

    Check out the ingredients for "Best White Icing Ever"...

    http://allrecipes.com/recipe/best-white-icing-ever/

    I'd recommend a mixer over a blender, but yeah, people (even healthy, fit people) eat exactly that all the time.
  • Holly_Roman_Empire
    Holly_Roman_Empire Posts: 4,440 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!
    Most of the people on this site would probably say "Ooooh that sounds great! As long as i log the calories, there will be no deleterious effects...."

    Google image results of "crisco sugar smoothie":

    RecipeImage.ashx?recipeid=6234&w=367&h=367

    If loving something like this is wrong, I don't wanna be right...
  • likitisplit
    likitisplit Posts: 9,420 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!

    Check out the ingredients for "Best White Icing Ever"...

    http://allrecipes.com/recipe/best-white-icing-ever/

    I'd recommend a mixer over a blender, but yeah, people (even healthy, fit people) eat exactly that all the time.

    Corn syrup will make it shinier.
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!
    Most of the people on this site would probably say "Ooooh that sounds great! As long as i log the calories, there will be no deleterious effects...."

    Considering 1 cup of crisco is about 2,000 calories of pure fat and 1/2 cup sugar is about 400 calories of pure carbs, I highly doubt that people would say that eating that every day would not have a negative impact.

    Again - context.
  • DamePiglet
    DamePiglet Posts: 3,730 Member
    Just drink a crisco and sugar smoothie.....here is the recipe:

    1 cup of crisco or lard

    1/2 cup of sugar

    8 ounces of water

    Throw it in a blender and boom!
    Most of the people on this site would probably say "Ooooh that sounds great! As long as i log the calories, there will be no deleterious effects...."

    Considering 1 cup of crisco is about 2,000 calories of pure fat and 1/2 cup sugar is about 400 calories of pure carbs, I highly doubt that people would say that eating that every day would not have a negative impact.

    Again - context.

    Spread it on a nice sized cake... share it with friends... I'd say that it would have a POSITIVE effect, actually. I like birthday parties.
  • taravernier
    taravernier Posts: 12 Member
    My response would be whichever satisfies the craving in the least amount of bites. A craving is the only reason I would be looking at fudge or fries... So to me it would be first about what exactly am I craving and secondly what will satisfy it with the least amount of damage.
  • psuLemon
    psuLemon Posts: 38,430 MFP Moderator
    You have to be realistic and look at your diet as a whole, as Sara mentioned. If you are hungry, foods higher in fats will improve satiety. Is this pre workout? Sugar will provide the energy to help, especially white or simple sugars. Personally, if I have hit most of my macro and micronutrient goals (especially protein), then I would eat something sweet. If I am starving, then I will go for the fat.
  • mccindy72
    mccindy72 Posts: 7,001 Member
    How about 250 calories of each? Why do you have to eat 500 calories of one or the other? CHOICES. There's no hard line. Or have some of one and then stop, and some of the other, and go eat some broccoli.