Carbs

JoT2013

Hi,

Is it just me or is anyone else finding it difficult to find food that doesn't have a huge amount of carbs?

I am allowed 1200 calories per day and although am always under my calorie target,I am always over my carb allowance.

I didn't notice until today when reading back through my diary that (homemade) slimming world chips have been tracking at carbs!

I have them approx. 4 evenings a week, so I have clearly been over my carb allowance rather a lot

Help! Please

Thanks,

Jo

Unknown

This content has been removed.

amylg05

Well I know how yummy these chips but I wouldnt advise eating them 4 times a week o_o thats potato 4 times a week and theyre really carb heavy and high GI. You could try sweet potato instead? I cut them in to wedges and put a little pepper and chilli flakes over them - theyre much lower in cals and personally I think tastier. Or you could try brown rice or even things like cauliflower mash as an alternative low carb side ^-^

JoT2013

I'm 42,174cm, have just under 3 and a half stones to lose and am allowed 150 carbs per day.

I'm not active...desk job and couch potato according to the stats (true I admit!) and arthritis etc etc etc, limits exercise.

The daily allowance allows for 1.6lbs loss per week..so not a huge loss.

JoT2013

Thanks Amylg05. I do eat brown rice but unfortunately my tastebuds have a definite aversion to most vegetables...especially green ones!lol

I am going to try the sweet potato wedges tho...thanks again

Unknown

This content has been removed.

SonicDeathMonkey80

Yeah, lazy American here too early for math

Carbs = not bad

1200 calories = not enough

SezxyStef

Yeah, lazy American here too early for math

Carbs = not bad

1200 calories = not enough

1 stone = 14lb so that is about 50lbs
1cm = appx 2.5 inches so 174cm is about 5 ft 8 or 9

1.6lbs a week is to fast try for 1lb a week...

1200 calories is not enough and it's not about the types of food you eat it's about the quantity.

Eat at a reasonable deficet...

ETA: Canadian and it's mid morning so my brain is functioning.

JoT2013

To be truthful, I'm not struggling on the calorie allowance, just the carbs allowance.

I love cooking and eating, so don't mind putting the extra effort in.

I thought 1.6 lbs was a healthy amount to lose a week? It doesn't seem a lot when I calculate how long it's going to take to get back to my old weight!

Marathon not a sprint...must remember that more often!

GlitterrMagpie

I don't worry about carbs, some days I'm over but as long as I have a calorie defecit I lose weight.

MapleFlavouredMaiden

Yeah, lazy American here too early for math

Carbs = not bad

1200 calories = not enough

^^ This.

zyxst

Is there a reason, such as a medical condition, that you have to limit carbs?

LeahFerri

To be truthful, I'm not struggling on the calorie allowance, just the carbs allowance.

I love cooking and eating, so don't mind putting the extra effort in.

I thought 1.6 lbs was a healthy amount to lose a week? It doesn't seem a lot when I calculate how long it's going to take to get back to my old weight!

Marathon not a sprint...must remember that more often!

If you lose weight too fast, you can lose too much muscle mass, which nobody wants to have happen. How long did it take to put the weight on? Keep that in perspective when you think about how long it'll take it to come off. 1.6 pounds/week is pretty fast when you have only 50 to lose, and a lot of people (myself included) wind up feeling like garbage after a few weeks at 1200 and giving up.

I personally focus on hitting the protein macro more than anything else (feel free to look at my diary, although there have been a few wonky days recently. Including today.) If I hit that, I'm usually a little over on fats and under on carbs(mostly because I can't set my macros the way I really want them!).

lilRicki

eat more

mantium999

To be truthful, I'm not struggling on the calorie allowance, just the carbs allowance.

I love cooking and eating, so don't mind putting the extra effort in.

I thought 1.6 lbs was a healthy amount to lose a week? It doesn't seem a lot when I calculate how long it's going to take to get back to my old weight!

Marathon not a sprint...must remember that more often!

If you are not struggling with the calorie allowance, and really are hung up on the carb target, you should evaluate what you are eating. Calorie target first (whatever that may be, everyone's is different), eat enough protein and fat, and let carbs fall where they may. Really is as simple as that.

TR0berts

Yeah, lazy American here too early for math

Carbs = not bad

1200 calories = not enough

1 stone = 14lb so that is about 50lbs
1cm = appx 2.5 inches so 174cm is about 5 ft 8 or 9

1.6lbs a week is to fast try for 1lb a week...

1200 calories is not enough and it's not about the types of food you eat it's about the quantity.

Eat at a reasonable deficet...

ETA: Canadian and it's mid morning so my brain is functioning.

You sure about that? :laugh:

TeaBea

Thanks Amylg05. I do eat brown rice but unfortunately my tastebuds have a definite aversion to most vegetables...especially green ones!lol

I am going to try the sweet potato wedges tho...thanks again

Keep trying new veggies.....cook them differently. Tastes change. Veggies will help you lower carbs if you need to.

One example.....there is a world of difference from canned green beans and fresh (steamed) ones. Try roasting veggies in the oven, add a little olive oil & garlic. Cauliflower is really good roasted. Grill asparagus. Grate carrots into sauces (chili, spaghetti) ....you'll hardly notice. Different methods will change flavors and textures.

MapleFlavouredMaiden

To be truthful, I'm not struggling on the calorie allowance, just the carbs allowance.

I love cooking and eating, so don't mind putting the extra effort in.

I thought 1.6 lbs was a healthy amount to lose a week? It doesn't seem a lot when I calculate how long it's going to take to get back to my old weight!

Marathon not a sprint...must remember that more often!

You say you're not struggling, are you weighing and measuring everything? Are you actually eating 1200 and feeling fine and dandy? You said you are very sedentary.... if you eat more, you'll move more. Even subconsciously. If you are eating this low and feel fine it could mean your metabolism is low. Also losing 1.6 is too fast for most people. You'll lose muscle mass and plateau soon enough. Not good.

Rocbola

Why restrict carbs? Carbs just so happen to be the main calorie source found in human food.

People who restrict those foods have higher risk of all cause mortality. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1240623-fruit-n-veg-more-reduced-risk-or-all-cause-mortality

Carbs are delicious!!!

yarwell

The study of all cause mortality does not talk about "carbs" but vegetables, and fruit - with the exception of "canned and frozen fruit" and fruit juice.

It would be misleading to give the impression that http://jech.bmj.com/content/early/2014/03/03/jech-2013-203500.full.pdf+html even considers the effects of pasta, bread, potato etc let alone identifies them as beneficial.

Vegetables may have a stronger
association with mortality than fruit (HR for 2 to 3
portions 0.81 (0.73 to 0.89) and 0.90 (0.82 to 0.98),
respectively). Consumption of vegetables (0.85 (0.81 to
0.89) per portion) or salad (0.87 (0.82 to 0.92) per
portion) were most protective, while frozen/canned fruit
consumption was apparently associated with increased
mortality (1.17 (1.07 to 1.28) per portion).

I can eat 5 portions of vegetables on Atkins induction, possibly even a portion of raspberries on a good day.

yarwell

Is it just me or is anyone else finding it difficult to find food that doesn't have a huge amount of carbs?

It isn't hard, if you avoid bread, pizza, pasta, potato in all forms, starchy root vegetables, sugar, cookies, candy, sweets, biscuits and the sweeter fruits (banana, grapes) you can put a big hole in it, should you wish to.

Your diary is closed so we can't see what's giving you the grief.

erickirb

Yeah, lazy American here too early for math

Carbs = not bad

1200 calories = not enough

1 stone = 14lb so that is about 50lbs
1cm = appx 2.5 inches so 174cm is about 5 ft 8 or 9

1.6lbs a week is to fast try for 1lb a week...

1200 calories is not enough and it's not about the types of food you eat it's about the quantity.

Eat at a reasonable deficet...

ETA: Canadian and it's mid morning so my brain is functioning.

You sure about that? :laugh:

1 inch = 2.54 cm, so pretty close 174/2.54 = 68.5 inches, so 5'8.5"

Unknown

This content has been removed.

_Zardoz_

Nothing wrong with carbs. Carbs give you energy. Energy is a good thing

yarwell

Nothing wrong with carbs. Carbs give you energy. Energy is a good thing

yep, and fat has more than twice as much per gram.

Gmtribble90

Why restrict carbs? Carbs just so happen to be the main calorie source found in human food.

People who restrict those foods have higher risk of all cause mortality. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1240623-fruit-n-veg-more-reduced-risk-or-all-cause-mortality

Carbs are delicious!!!

Ok does anyone else just want to eat this whole thing?

R_Woodruff

Why restrict carbs? Carbs just so happen to be the main calorie source found in human food.

People who restrict those foods have higher risk of all cause mortality. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1240623-fruit-n-veg-more-reduced-risk-or-all-cause-mortality

Carbs are delicious!!!

Ok does anyone else just want to eat this whole thing?

Glad I'm not the only one!

babyj0

It's easy, just eat meat. Make meat the main thing. Eat carbs to fill in. We are taught to fill the plate with carbs and have a 4oz portion of meat. I fill the plate with meat, and have a small portion of rice or something. It's really simple once you get inot it. Just eat more meat.

This. Because I want more meat!

babyj0

Why restrict carbs? Carbs just so happen to be the main calorie source found in human food.

People who restrict those foods have higher risk of all cause mortality. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1240623-fruit-n-veg-more-reduced-risk-or-all-cause-mortality

Carbs are delicious!!!

Ok does anyone else just want to eat this whole thing?

I was more like "Who the hell cuts fruit that perfect??" Lol

JoT2013

The reason for limiting carbs is only because I am trying to stay within the limits that the MFP calculated that I should eat.

I'm not averse to carbs...on reading my diary it's clear that I like them rather a lot!lol

Everyday my carbs and protein are maxed out...so can't add anymore meat either!

I like home made oven chips with steak, mushrooms and onions, I love wholewheat pasta with a homemade tomato based sauce.

I take salad wraps (love salad!) in whole wheat tortilla wraps to work...so I don't think my diet is unhealthy?

Its just that they add up and take me over my limit of carbs. Healthy eating, fruit...natures Skittles would be about my all time favourite desert/snack but yet the sugar is massively high!

However, reading this makes me think that ppl are just using the MFP calculated amounts as a guideline rather than a limit to not go above...I may adopt that approach and see how it goes.

1200 calories is what MFP stated and this is my first time of counting calories so am attempting to follow what it states. I actually thought that 1.6 lbs was a small amount??

I will look at the calorie amount again and read up a little more...don't want to be slim and unhealthy...my lack of fitness is down to illnesses, meds and a sedentary lifestyle. I'm on here to help myself be healthier, not to make myself worse.

Thanks everyone btw...interesting reading on here

suziecue66

MFP always calculates a too low protein allowance. How many grams of protein have you been having. I would have at least 100g of protein daily.