We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Losing weight/gaining muscle-which direction to go in?

easp
easp Posts: 5 Member
edited February 19 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi,


I started counting calories with the NOOM app around February of last year and following a good diet with balanced cardio and brought myself down from 82kg to 60kg. But I don't have the figure/form I'm aiming at. Flatter stomach, muscular shape, that kind of thing.


I'm 5'6'' and according to my BMI, 50kg is in my healthy range. So I'm wondering should I try to lose enough weight to get down there before trying build any muscle?


Also, I'm on the 2nd week of Stronglifts and I gained like half of pound but I'm not sure if it was muscle since I ate a lot of meat that week.


Which reminds me of how not knowing what/how much to eat makes this even more frustrating.
I read that when trying to build muscle you should create a calorie excess but when trying to lose you should create a deficit. Not sure which direction to go in.


Thanks for reading this. Sorry if it was kinda long. Any tips/help/advice would really help.

Replies

  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    If you are still eating in a deficet you are not gaining muscle esp not 1/2lb of it.

    2 weeks into stronglifts it is probably water retention and gylcogen stores in the muscle.

    A bulk is suggested when you have reached at least goal weight and BF% goal (18-20%) is what I have read a lot for a good place for a women to start bulking.

    To find out how much you should eat figure out your TDEE and substract a decent percentage off that. With 11kg to go I would suggest 10-15% deficet.

    Hit your goal weight, maintain for a bit while still lifting and getting your protien and try recomp for a while and if you are not happy try a small deficet again..5-10% and once you get to a good BF% do a bulk then.
This discussion has been closed.