How do you feel about intermittent fasting? +friends
SBMarie93
Posts: 16
So there are people out there that do the 5:2 diet (something like intermittent fasting 2 days out of every week but instead it deprives calories)
I was curious about how some of you feel about this. Have any of you tried it? Does anyone recommend trying it? Who's against it? etc.
I was thinking about doing a 5:3 but modified
For me:
This would include no weight lifting.
Just my usual 15-20 min cardio (jog froward and walk backward)
15 abdominals (2x)
15 tranversus abd. (2x)
25 butt/leg lifts (2x)
And then some stretching to cool down
I would eat between 7am-3pm every everyday (nothing over 200 calories for each meal I eat) and then fast for 16 hours
The work out would take place between 2:30pm-4 pm
Oh and I love to have some friends! Add me if your interested
I was curious about how some of you feel about this. Have any of you tried it? Does anyone recommend trying it? Who's against it? etc.
I was thinking about doing a 5:3 but modified
For me:
This would include no weight lifting.
Just my usual 15-20 min cardio (jog froward and walk backward)
15 abdominals (2x)
15 tranversus abd. (2x)
25 butt/leg lifts (2x)
And then some stretching to cool down
I would eat between 7am-3pm every everyday (nothing over 200 calories for each meal I eat) and then fast for 16 hours
The work out would take place between 2:30pm-4 pm
Oh and I love to have some friends! Add me if your interested
0
Replies
-
Wait, I'm confused -- is the nothing over 200 calories per meal for the low days or the up days?0
-
The low days-- but I can have more than one meal within that 8 hour time frame0
-
The up days I'd have my regular 1200 calorie dietThe low days-- but I can have more than one meal within that 6 hour time frame0 -
I just do the standard 5:2 which works well for me. Hit goal weight last week so am supposed to be dropping to 6:1 to maintain but to still get the IF health benefits. Although will weigh tomorrow as I think after Easter over indulgences I have probably gained a fair amount. If so I'll be back on 5:2 until I'm back at goal. Urs seems a bit complicated, from what I understand it is best to just stick to the standard 5:2 lifestyle otherwise it can go wrong.0
-
None of this makes sense. There is no 5:3. There are 8 hours in 7-3, not 6. What you are talking about is called 16/8 - a version of IF. You should be focused on eating the proper amount of calories during your 8 hour eating period - not limiting the calories for each meal. it's hard to eat multiple meals within an 8 hour period.0
-
The up days I'd have my regular 1200 calorie dietThe low days-- but I can have more than one meal within that 6 hour time frame
That is not how 5:2 works -- if you're going to do 5:2 you're supposed to eat maintenance on the other days.
Don't try and mix and match like this -- either pick 1200 or do 5:2.0 -
I'd between 3-4 meals in an 8 hour time frame (that gives 30mins-1hour of digestion between each meal) that's between 600 and 800 calories in that time frame, and its just a round 200 not a perfect 200 calories. then I'd be off for another 16 hours.0
-
The up days I'd have my regular 1200 calorie dietThe low days-- but I can have more than one meal within that 6 hour time frame
That is not how 5:2 works -- if you're going to do 5:2 you're supposed to eat maintenance on the other days.
Don't try and mix and match like this -- either pick 1200 or do 5:2.
This ^^^
You eat at maintenance 5 days a week and then have 2 "fast" days a week where you only eat 500-600 calories. If you want to do this then set your MFP calories at maintenance and then simply aim to only hit 500-600 calories of that for two non-consecutive days of the week.0 -
The more exotic/unnatural something is, the less likely it is to work on the long run.0
-
The up days I'd have my regular 1200 calorie dietThe low days-- but I can have more than one meal within that 6 hour time frame
That is not how 5:2 works -- if you're going to do 5:2 you're supposed to eat maintenance on the other days.
Don't try and mix and match like this -- either pick 1200 or do 5:2.
This! IF is fine if you are consuming the proper amount of calories.
Pick something and try it, don't try to combine all of them into one, making it over complicated and overly restrictive.
Also why no weight lifting?0 -
I'd between 3-4 meals in an 8 hour time frame (that gives 30mins-1hour of digestion between each meal) that's between 600 and 800 calories in that time frame, and its just a round 200 not a perfect 200 calories. then I'd be off for another 16 hours.
Right, but this puts your average for the week (assuming 700 on those days and 1200 on the others) at a bit over a thousand calories a day, not including exercise calories). This is not really enough for proper nutrition or for care of the body between workouts, unless you are very short, very slender, and older.
Again -- you asked for thoughts. This diet is too low-cal.0 -
I strongly recommend reading the Fast Diet book and watching the documentary Eat Fast Live Longer, I've read the book three times and watched the documentary twice, you need to have a full understanding of the system. Both will spell out how to do the 5:2 properly. I am not convinced you'll get the other health benefits otherwise.0
-
If you are serious in your profile, in losing 65 lbs in 4 months to join the military, if you really try this, more likely you will in the hospital in the end of these 4 month period. You need realistic goals and to start valuing your health more than anything else.0
-
The up days I'd have my regular 1200 calorie dietThe low days-- but I can have more than one meal within that 6 hour time frame
Um.....no
1200 calories is a diet day not an "up" day.
5:2 is 2 days at fast .....500 calories for women & 5 days at maintenance. Your entire deficit comes from 2 days.
Here's a group that can explain it better than I can
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/8005-5-2-fasting0 -
A friend of mine said if I wanted to weight life then up on carbs the day before. It's not to say that I can't just more of an I won't (personally).0
-
If you are serious in your profile, in losing 65 lbs in 4 months to join the military, if you really try this, more likely you will in the hospital in the end of these 4 month period. You need realistic goals and to start valuing your health more than anything else.
Man, I didn't even notice the join the military part. OP, you can crash it off, but you're never going to survive boot camp if you lose as much muscle mass as your plan will have you losing. For *your* goals, you need to be incorporating weight training as well.
http://www.military.com/military-fitness/army-basic-training/getting-prepared-for-bootcamp0 -
I'd between 3-4 meals in an 8 hour time frame (that gives 30mins-1hour of digestion between each meal) that's between 600 and 800 calories in that time frame, and its just a round 200 not a perfect 200 calories. then I'd be off for another 16 hours.
800 calories x 3 days
+1200 calories x 4 days
= 7,200 a week...........1,028 daily average. Not nearly enough to maintain lean muscle. Only the scale looks good.0 -
I agree with the others. I lost almost all my weight with the alternate day diet (JUDDD), and you need to eat maintenance calories on the days you're not fasting, NOT 1200 calories. Please do some more research. IF is a fantastic tool, and one that got me to and past my goal, but it's not for everyone, especially those prone to ED or those who don't follow the plan as written.0
-
Sounds far too complex for no obvious benefit.
If you want to do 5:2 then follow that plan (properly), if you want to do Leangains then do Leangains (properly).
If you are serious about trying to lose a huge amount of weight in a short time then 5:2 is definitely not for you - if you follow the plan then you would only be losing about a pound a week.0 -
The ad to the right says, "lose up to 15 lbs in 21 days!!!!" Yeah, water weight! Starving yourself is bad. Fasting as a diet is bad. This crazy crap they have on the internet is....bad! Just cut back sensibly until you lose weight normally!0
-
I have been doing it on and off for 4 months and have lost 18 kgs of mainly fat.
The good part is to maintain the losses / benefits you only need to do it once weekly.
Just keep trying and it will become easier. I mainly do resistance training and some cardio.
Read the book watch the clip, eat fast and live longer.
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xvdbtt_eat-fast-live-longer-hd_shortfilms0 -
Perhaps I should modify this:
It's not a 5:2 I kind of understand 5:2 ( I'm not really looking for a 5:2 diet plan)
I'd eat regularly 1200-1500 calories 4 days a week and about 700 (not including exercise) 3 days a week
For me:
This would include no weight lifting.
Just my usual 15-20 min cardio (jog froward and walk backward)
15 abdominals (2x)
15 tranversus abd. (2x)
25 butt/leg lifts (2x)
And then some stretching to cool down
I would eat between 7am-3pm every everyday (about 200 calories for each meal I eat, that's between 3-4) and then fast for 16 hours
The work out would take place between 2:30pm-4 pm
And I'm not saying that I'd do this until I reach my goal. Just whenever I feel comfortable with it. For example a week out of every month. I'd never push myself to far to the point of exhaustion.( If I needed to make it 2 days vs. 3 I would) I have to be able to function for work and college classes. I'm sorry if some of you got the wrong picture.
I do appreciate your guys' feed back.
If you could modify this ^ to fit your diet how would you? Would you up your calories on low days? Do a shorter fasting period?0 -
I give up! Don't ask a question, get perfectly decent (and consistent answers) and ignore the advice. Good luck, ur gonna need it!0
-
If I could help u modify ur plan it would go like this...
Read the book
Watch the documentary
Eat 500 cals on non consecutive days for 2 x days per week
Eat maintenance on the other 5 x days per week
Workout as u wish
It's pretty simple, don't over complicate the fasting as u won't get the other health benefits, IF is way more than about weight loss.0 -
Will keep it simple for you....
Your weight loss aim is far too ambitious in such a short amount of time.
Your suggested calories are far too low.
Your workout routine is really poor.
So however you dress it up you are planning to crash diet and lose a stack of muscle mass.0 -
If I could help u modify ur plan it would go like this...
Read the book
Watch the documentary
Eat 500 cals on non consecutive days for 2 x days per week
Eat maintenance on the other 5 x days per week
Workout as u wish
It's pretty simple, don't over complicate the fasting as u won't get the other health benefits, IF is way more than about weight loss.
I'm not looking to be bashed on.
I appreciate your advice. And Susan's and Andy's and Primrose for sticking up for what she believes in. If you say 500 calories on nonconsecutive days I'll take it into consideration and perhaps lengthen my time frame. I'm brainstorming and reaching out to try something new.
--And for the person who commented about lean muscle. I like to do strength training and weight lifting 1-2 weeks out of every month alternatively on week days (mon-wed-fri)
Like I said it's not a definite set in stone plan. It's an Idea.0 -
If I could help u modify ur plan it would go like this...
Read the book
Watch the documentary
Eat 500 cals on non consecutive days for 2 x days per week
Eat maintenance on the other 5 x days per week
Workout as u wish
It's pretty simple, don't over complicate the fasting as u won't get the other health benefits, IF is way more than about weight loss.
I'm not looking to be bashed on.
I appreciate your advice. And Susan's and Andy's and Primrose for sticking up for what she believes in. If you say 500 calories on nonconsecutive days I'll take it into consideration and perhaps lengthen my time frame. I'm brainstorming and reaching out to try something new.
--And for the person who commented about lean muscle. I like to do strength training and weight lifting 1-2 weeks out of every month alternatively on week days (mon-wed-fri)
Like I said it's not a definite set in stone plan. It's an Idea.
You asked for advice, you were given advice, you decided to ignore good advice. Your plan is bad. Go back do some research, keep it simple and good luck in boot camp with limited exercise and months of depriving yourself.0 -
I have my plan figured out with someone else who does intermittent fasting
4:3
4 days eat 2000-2400 cal
3 days 500 calories in the 8 hour time frame I set.
My short little exercise throughout the week.
I'd do this 1 week out of every month.
Then go back to my regular 1200-1500 cal diet and regular work out with weight lifting and more strength training.
And I'm not looking to lose 74 lbs in 4 months does anyone know how to change the ticker thing?0 -
The more exotic/unnatural something is, the less likely it is to work on the long run.
I agree with this. Do it closer to how you plan to live after you reach your goal.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions