Has anyone heard of the corset diet?
Replies
-
Really? People will try anything but, hard work. What a lazy world we live in.0
-
i couldnt eat much on my wedding day because my dress was very tight... i ate 2 cupcakes and a chicken and bacon sandwich for breakfast the next day because i woke up starving!!!!!
that's so sad - I ate everything on my wedding day while wearing the corset - and i really enjoyed it - i had selected hte food i wanted after all, I even had space for a few pints of local real ale ... YUM0 -
That has taken it too far.
doing enythin excessively is likely to be unhealthy though
>> everything in moderation IIFIYM
0 -
"Sinclair said after a year of wearing corsets daily, along with a year of maintenance, people can get a reduction in waist size of up to three inches."
I lost 3 inches off my waist (and 10lbs) in 6 months by eating 1500-1700kcals net and exercising (started at 148lbs and with being 5'4 tall, didn't have too much to lose to start with).
That is faster, safer, healthier and less painful than wearing a tight corset for up to 10 hours a day!
Sigh!
Such a silly, silly idea!0 -
Yuh but we're all born with a corset, it's called your core and it can change your shape miraculously. And you can eat! And you can breathe! You never have to take it to the dry cleaners. It can get out of shape but it will always fit you, besides with a little work you can resore it to its former glory. It won't warp your skeleton or stunt your growth, if you do it right it will help your bones. You don't have to pay anybody for it. You don't have to get cut to pieces and stitched up again. It goes with every outfit.
Only thing is, it's free and so Dr Oz is not going to be the shill man on the next infomercial/ advertorial he calls a TV show. Nobody can sell it to you. That's kind of why I love it. In your FACE to the people on TV and billboards who try to tell me I can't do it myself and I need their help whether it's something to wear or a magic pill. Playing on our insecurities to make yourselves rich, you won't get a penny out of me.
I'm so glad the people on these boards are smart and confident enough to laugh at this total nonsense instead of falling over themselves to try it or buy into the lies told to us in order to make us feel bad.
This is why I've stuck with mfp for so long haha! :laugh:
Best post ever
0 -
i couldnt eat much on my wedding day because my dress was very tight... i ate 2 cupcakes and a chicken and bacon sandwich for breakfast the next day because i woke up starving!!!!!
that's so sad - I ate everything on my wedding day while wearing the corset - and i really enjoyed it - i had selected hte food i wanted after all, I even had space for a few pints of local real ale ... YUM
I wasn't sad at all on my wedding day!0 -
I just like corsets because if I'm wearing one under my clothes it's hard for the casual observer to notice that I'm a middle aged woman who hasn't been eating and exercising as well as I could have been. And unlike girdles, they don't do that whole all-day wedgie thing.
0 -
According to an article I read awhile back a corset is supposed to help support posture. In a way wearing one is good but I agree with the majority of this thread. I cannot see myself wearing a corset 24/7. :sick:0
-
Is this like the thing where you wear a cup size too big and really make yourself believe your breasts are large, and then they allegedly grow to fit the bra?0
-
Yuh but we're all born with a corset, it's called your core and it can change your shape miraculously. And you can eat! And you can breathe! You never have to take it to the dry cleaners. It can get out of shape but it will always fit you, besides with a little work you can resore it to its former glory. It won't warp your skeleton or stunt your growth, if you do it right it will help your bones. You don't have to pay anybody for it. You don't have to get cut to pieces and stitched up again. It goes with every outfit.
Only thing is, it's free and so Dr Oz is not going to be the shill man on the next infomercial/ advertorial he calls a TV show. Nobody can sell it to you. That's kind of why I love it. In your FACE to the people on TV and billboards who try to tell me I can't do it myself and I need their help whether it's something to wear or a magic pill. Playing on our insecurities to make yourselves rich, you won't get a penny out of me.
I'm so glad the people on these boards are smart and confident enough to laugh at this total nonsense instead of falling over themselves to try it or buy into the lies told to us in order to make us feel bad.
This is why I've stuck with mfp for so long haha! :laugh:
+10 -
"Under the supervision of Dr. Alexander Sinclair..."
Just goes to show that a doctor's advice can also be terrible. Second and third opinions are necessary for reason's like this quack for anything that's potentially dangerous.0 -
sad, very sad, as this gives a bad name to healthy weight loss and to corsets
me i'm a big fan of corsets, but you don't need to wear them that tight or that long, they should compliments and enhance not distort your figure
I wore a corset and skirt for my wedding, becasue i knew that I wouldn't get a strapless bra to fit my 30JJs, or a dress bodice that was sufficiently supportive, i like my cream and blue wedding corset so much i've worn it since to other parties
but I also knew that I could happily wear a properly fitted corset for an extended period without any problem
I wore this corset (with blue halter neck and bow):
http://www.fairygothmother.co.uk/70-m1_36sl2_trg3.htm
with this skirt: http://www.fairygothmother.co.uk/70-m28trg3_r50.htm
and most people couldn't even tell it was a corset and skirt rather than a dress (though i thought the baby blue corset lacing gave it away somewhat)
LOVE IT!!0 -
Do some actual research on tightlacing. When done properly, it is not harmful, and most people who do it aren't doing it to "lose weight." Waist-training is a centuries old concept and has been practised by men and women throughout history. Waist-training from corsets and gurdles is why women appeared "curvier" in the years prior to 1960's, when lighter under garments started becoming the new norm.
A majority of those in the communities do wear them for aesthetics. Some people wear them for back support. Corsets are changed every few month as body shape adjusts. Corsets are custom tailored to individual's measurements and most professional corseteries do not make the type that crush ribs. The realignment of internal organs isn't even as severe as the pressure that would be placed on them by a baby at a pregnancy's 3rd trimester.
Constricting devices can be adjusted throughout the day and can be worn for 24 hours and sometimes are medically (scoliosis brace, anyone?).
Stop being so judgemental of what other people do with their bodies. Tightlacing culture isn't even a diet culture so much as a fashion culture.0 -
I just read the article. Desperate people taking desperate measures all for a quick fix.I am NOT looking to try this diet. I just came across it and it was flabbergasted at the idea.
http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2014/04/29/women-lacing-up-corsets-to-lose-weight/
Ridiculous.
Oh, and what happens when you don't wear the corset anymore? Does your body give a sigh of relieve and bring your weight back?0 -
Don't get me wrong, I love all my corsets. And I have quite a few, all tailor-made to my exact shape. And I love em. But no.
No, no, no, no, no.
No.
^This. Oh-so-very this!
I love my corsets, but I think it's a bad idea to use them to lose weight. All that does is restrict how much you can eat in one sitting. However, if one decides that they want to tightlace daily for the rest of their life, power to them (I know one such burlesque performer). It's not for me.0 -
I am NOT looking to try this diet. I just came across it and it was flabbergasted at the idea.
http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2014/04/29/women-lacing-up-corsets-to-lose-weight/
I saw a segment discussing it on a show. It's nothing new, something that was popular in Victorian times. There are negative side effects to it though and I can't imagine the corset being all that comfortable to wear. I can remember my Mom and her girdle escapades! Spanx is great for a bit of instant slimming without the side effects.0 -
Yes
No
Agreed. Ugh =(0 -
Do some actual research on tightlacing. When done properly, it is not harmful, and most people who do it aren't doing it to "lose weight." Waist-training is a centuries old concept and has been practised by men and women throughout history. Waist-training from corsets and gurdles is why women appeared "curvier" in the years prior to 1960's, when lighter under garments started becoming the new norm.
A majority of those in the communities do wear them for aesthetics. Some people wear them for back support. Corsets are changed every few month as body shape adjusts. Corsets are custom tailored to individual's measurements and most professional corseteries do not make the type that crush ribs. The realignment of internal organs isn't even as severe as the pressure that would be placed on them by a baby at a pregnancy's 3rd trimester.
Constricting devices can be adjusted throughout the day and can be worn for 24 hours and sometimes are medically (scoliosis brace, anyone?).
Stop being so judgemental of what other people do with their bodies. Tightlacing culture isn't even a diet culture so much as a fashion culture.
People are commenting negatively on it being a dieting device, not on the concept of corsets.
For me personally, I'll wear the one or two that are a part of my 'sexy collection' for the hour or two before it comes off but I won't be attempting to change the shape of my bones with it. I might like to have kids someday, so I'm going to keep my ribs nice and wide like they are now and continue to give my organs they space they were genetically given.Stop being so judgemental
Stop being so sensitive.0 -
Do some actual research on tightlacing. When done properly, it is not harmful, and most people who do it aren't doing it to "lose weight." Waist-training is a centuries old concept and has been practised by men and women throughout history. Waist-training from corsets and gurdles is why women appeared "curvier" in the years prior to 1960's, when lighter under garments started becoming the new norm.
A majority of those in the communities do wear them for aesthetics. Some people wear them for back support. Corsets are changed every few month as body shape adjusts. Corsets are custom tailored to individual's measurements and most professional corseteries do not make the type that crush ribs. The realignment of internal organs isn't even as severe as the pressure that would be placed on them by a baby at a pregnancy's 3rd trimester.
Constricting devices can be adjusted throughout the day and can be worn for 24 hours and sometimes are medically (scoliosis brace, anyone?).
Stop being so judgemental of what other people do with their bodies. Tightlacing culture isn't even a diet culture so much as a fashion culture.
Well said! :drinker:0 -
Do some actual research on tightlacing. When done properly, it is not harmful, and most people who do it aren't doing it to "lose weight." Waist-training is a centuries old concept and has been practised by men and women throughout history. Waist-training from corsets and gurdles is why women appeared "curvier" in the years prior to 1960's, when lighter under garments started becoming the new norm.
A majority of those in the communities do wear them for aesthetics. Some people wear them for back support. Corsets are changed every few month as body shape adjusts. Corsets are custom tailored to individual's measurements and most professional corseteries do not make the type that crush ribs. The realignment of internal organs isn't even as severe as the pressure that would be placed on them by a baby at a pregnancy's 3rd trimester.
Constricting devices can be adjusted throughout the day and can be worn for 24 hours and sometimes are medically (scoliosis brace, anyone?).
Stop being so judgemental of what other people do with their bodies. Tightlacing culture isn't even a diet culture so much as a fashion culture.
People are commenting negatively on it being a dieting device, not on the concept of corsets.
For me personally, I'll wear the one or two that are a part of my 'sexy collection' for the hour or two before it comes off but I won't be attempting to change the shape of my bones with it. I might like to have kids someday, so I'm going to keep my ribs nice and wide like they are now and continue to give my organs they space they were genetically given.Stop being so judgemental
Stop being so sensitive.
This is a misrepresentation of an entire subculture. It has a rich and interesting history. It is not a diet culture.0 -
There is nobody more creative than someone wanting to lose weight without the work. =p
I've definitely been there. I've taken water pills to "lose weight" (losing water weight, that's all), I've all but starved myself, I've eaten every kind of "super cool weight loss food!" known to man and a few known to cats (kidding). THEY DON'T WORK! None of it works! It's a waste of money and it's ridiculous to think that you can get anything worth while without working for it.
Water pills have some rather dangerous side effects as does some of the other quick fix weight loss gimmicks. We can't even buy water pills OTC here but I know you can buy them in the US.0 -
Nobody is being judgmental, they are simply commenting on the conversation.Do some actual research on tightlacing. When done properly, it is not harmful, and most people who do it aren't doing it to "lose weight." Waist-training is a centuries old concept and has been practised by men and women throughout history. Waist-training from corsets and gurdles is why women appeared "curvier" in the years prior to 1960's, when lighter under garments started becoming the new norm.
A majority of those in the communities do wear them for aesthetics. Some people wear them for back support. Corsets are changed every few month as body shape adjusts. Corsets are custom tailored to individual's measurements and most professional corseteries do not make the type that crush ribs. The realignment of internal organs isn't even as severe as the pressure that would be placed on them by a baby at a pregnancy's 3rd trimester.
Constricting devices can be adjusted throughout the day and can be worn for 24 hours and sometimes are medically (scoliosis brace, anyone?).
Stop being so judgemental of what other people do with their bodies. Tightlacing culture isn't even a diet culture so much as a fashion culture.
Nobody is disputing the beauty of wearing corsets for fashion or just because you feel like it, or even disputing that sometimes corsets/braces are medically necessary or used for back support purposes, but many of us are disputing the audacity of wearing a corset tight enough to stop you from getting hungry.
In other words, the "corset diet".0 -
She has
:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:0 -
There is nobody more creative than someone wanting to lose weight without the work. =p
I've always found this ironic! If people were to put the same amount of effort into learning about nutrition/exercise that they did looking into 'quick diet fixes', they'd actually become healthier.
I can't say anything though....because I do the same with my schoolwork. -_-0 -
Do some actual research on tightlacing. When done properly, it is not harmful, and most people who do it aren't doing it to "lose weight." Waist-training is a centuries old concept and has been practised by men and women throughout history. Waist-training from corsets and gurdles is why women appeared "curvier" in the years prior to 1960's, when lighter under garments started becoming the new norm.
A majority of those in the communities do wear them for aesthetics. Some people wear them for back support. Corsets are changed every few month as body shape adjusts. Corsets are custom tailored to individual's measurements and most professional corseteries do not make the type that crush ribs. The realignment of internal organs isn't even as severe as the pressure that would be placed on them by a baby at a pregnancy's 3rd trimester.
Constricting devices can be adjusted throughout the day and can be worn for 24 hours and sometimes are medically (scoliosis brace, anyone?).
Stop being so judgemental of what other people do with their bodies. Tightlacing culture isn't even a diet culture so much as a fashion culture.
People are commenting negatively on it being a dieting device, not on the concept of corsets.
For me personally, I'll wear the one or two that are a part of my 'sexy collection' for the hour or two before it comes off but I won't be attempting to change the shape of my bones with it. I might like to have kids someday, so I'm going to keep my ribs nice and wide like they are now and continue to give my organs they space they were genetically given.Stop being so judgemental
Stop being so sensitive.
This is a misrepresentation of an entire subculture. It has a rich and interesting history. It is not a diet culture.
Of course it is and people understand that. They aren't commenting negatively about the "subculture". They don't like corsets being used as a dieting device either.0 -
This made me laugh! Needed that! Thanks. 0
-
There is nobody more creative than someone wanting to lose weight without the work. =p
I've definitely been there. I've taken water pills to "lose weight" (losing water weight, that's all), I've all but starved myself, I've eaten every kind of "super cool weight loss food!" known to man and a few known to cats (kidding). THEY DON'T WORK! None of it works! It's a waste of money and it's ridiculous to think that you can get anything worth while without working for it.
Water pills have some rather dangerous side effects as does some of the other quick fix weight loss gimmicks. We can't even buy water pills OTC here but I know you can buy them in the US.
The ones here in the US are typically very weak. That being said, I have known people (high school wrestlers) who have taken laxatives to get down to wrestling weight just before a match.
Like I said, none of it is a long-term solution to losing weight. The only thing that is would be a moderate calorie deficit and some exercise.0 -
Agreed!
[/quote]
People are commenting negatively on it being a dieting device, not on the concept of corsets.
For me personally, I'll wear the one or two that are a part of my 'sexy collection' for the hour or two before it comes off but I won't be attempting to change the shape of my bones with it. I might like to have kids someday, so I'm going to keep my ribs nice and wide like they are now and continue to give my organs they space they were genetically given.Stop being so judgemental
Stop being so sensitive.
[/quote]0 -
I love my corsets. I couldn't imagine using them as a dieting tool, however, I don't see how it's so difficult to wear a properly fitted one for hours. My corsets are laced to fit me and I can wear them for hours and not be uncomfortable.
Tightlacing is a very interesting culture and I find it amazing the things some women have done to their bodies in order to change their shape. The history behind it and its cultural impact is truly worth a read.0 -
I suppose there might be a psychological component to a corset helping with diet. Those "Thundershirt" wraps for dogs act like a hug to make them feel more secure, a corset might have the same effect for an emotional eater.
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions