10-Day Sugar Challenge: Fed Up

SnicciFit
SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
Thoughts?

http://gma.yahoo.com/why-katie-couric-wants-you-to-get--fed-up---take-a-sugar-challenge-171811341.html

I think the challenge could be beneficial for many just for awareness purposes. It is pretty alarming just how many foods have added sugar in them.
«1

Replies

  • SugaryLynx
    SugaryLynx Posts: 2,640 Member
    I think Katie Couric is an idiot. Personal opinion.

    Excess food intake and lack of movement is more likely a cause in obesity than sugar. It's just the new target, just like fat used to be. I'll make my own 10 day challenge. "Eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge. I think if you're getting a balanced diet and don't have an underlying medical condition, it's a trivial micro.
  • Holly_Roman_Empire
    Holly_Roman_Empire Posts: 4,440 Member
    I think Katie Couric is an idiot. Personal opinion.

    Excess food intake and lack of movement is more likely a cause in obesity than sugar. It's just the new target, just like fat used to be. I'll make my own 10 day challenge. "Eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge. I think if you're getting a balanced diet and don't have an underlying medical condition, it's a trivial micro.

    Pretty much sums up my thoughts on it too.
  • jonnythan
    jonnythan Posts: 10,161 Member
    Katie Couric? Has she turned into some nutrition expert or something now?

    I think the whole thing is stupid. Sugar is yummy.

    And I'll expand on Lynx's 10 day "eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge by extending it to the rest of my life. Any kind of "10 day challenge" is stupid to begin with, and doubly stupid when it's arbitrary. Yay you can control your food intake in some arbitrary way for 10 days! Now what about the other 20,000 days you have left in your life?

    Sugar is delicious. That's why it's in fruit: to make them taste good.
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    I think Katie Couric is an idiot. Personal opinion.

    I agree, she is!
    Excess food intake and lack of movement is more likely a cause in obesity than sugar. It's just the new target, just like fat used to be. I'll make my own 10 day challenge. "Eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge. I think if you're getting a balanced diet and don't have an underlying medical condition, it's a trivial micro.

    While I don't think sugar is the ONLY culprit, it definitely can't hurt for people to be enlightened to just how much of it they are consuming. The extra calories come from a lot of places, and sugar is definitely one of them. I think it would be hard to find someone who is obese and overeats constantly, but never ingests added sugar. It's just so easy to over-indulge in, especially when it's in a beverage or added to foods you don't expect it to be in.
  • kgeyser
    kgeyser Posts: 22,505 Member
    The reason foods have added sugar in them is because years ago, fat and saturated fat in particular were demonized as being the cause of heart disease and recommendations were given by the American Heart Association to reduce intake. This led to manufacturers turning to added sugar to make foods palatable. And now, the American Heart Association is once again leading the charge of food demonization, only they aren't going to admit that they're a big reason added sugar is a problem.

    Katie Couric needs to go back to being a real journalist and not a TV host.
  • wheird
    wheird Posts: 7,963 Member
    She's pretty much an idiot.
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    Sugar is delicious. That's why it's in fruit: to make them taste good.

    I agree, sugar IS delicious and it is in fruit so that we know to eat it! I think the point of this whole thing is to look at all the places sugar is ADDED into our diets.
  • SugaryLynx
    SugaryLynx Posts: 2,640 Member
    I think Katie Couric is an idiot. Personal opinion.

    I agree, she is!
    Excess food intake and lack of movement is more likely a cause in obesity than sugar. It's just the new target, just like fat used to be. I'll make my own 10 day challenge. "Eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge. I think if you're getting a balanced diet and don't have an underlying medical condition, it's a trivial micro.

    While I don't think sugar is the ONLY culprit, it definitely can't hurt for people to be enlightened to just how much of it they are consuming. The extra calories come from a lot of places, and sugar is definitely one of them. I think it would be hard to find someone who is obese and overeats constantly, but never ingests added sugar. It's just so easy to over-indulge in, especially when it's in a beverage or added to foods you don't expect it to be in.

    I'm glad we can agree on something haha <3

    The calorie count, which is what is the factor in weight gain, is already accounted for in food labeling (though I know labeling can be off in caloric content by a small margin, it still remains). So, I wouldn't say I advocate eating super excess amounts of sugar, it isn't what should be the focal point but rather ensuring you're aware of calorie density in foods. Avacados, nuts, quinoa, bananas, etc are a few examples of calorie dense "whole" foods that, if not accounted for properly and eaten regularly, could easily lead someone into a calorie surplus
  • SugaryLynx
    SugaryLynx Posts: 2,640 Member
    Sugar is delicious. That's why it's in fruit: to make them taste good.

    I agree, sugar IS delicious and it is in fruit so that we know to eat it! I think the point of this whole thing is to look at all the places sugar is ADDED into our diets.

    Sugar is processed the same in the body, whether it be added or not. The benefit of eating fruit is the vitamins and fiber that you cannot get from straight sugar but the fact remains.
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    Katie Couric? Has she turned into some nutrition expert or something now?

    I think the whole thing is stupid. Sugar is yummy.

    And I'll expand on Lynx's 10 day "eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge by extending it to the rest of my life. Any kind of "10 day challenge" is stupid to begin with, and doubly stupid when it's arbitrary. Yay you can control your food intake in some arbitrary way for 10 days! Now what about the other 20,000 days you have left in your life?

    Sugar is delicious. That's why it's in fruit: to make them taste good.

    I also agree that a 10-day challenge is not going to do any good, if you don't make any changes because of it. Like I said in my OP, might be good for awareness (there are a lot of people out there who have no idea what is in the food they are eating), but it's up to the individual to actually make changes based on that awareness.
  • Jestinia
    Jestinia Posts: 1,153 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).
  • jonnythan
    jonnythan Posts: 10,161 Member
    Sugar is delicious. That's why it's in fruit: to make them taste good.

    I agree, sugar IS delicious and it is in fruit so that we know to eat it! I think the point of this whole thing is to look at all the places sugar is ADDED into our diets.

    Yup, look at them.

    So.... what about them?
  • jonnythan
    jonnythan Posts: 10,161 Member
    Oh Dr Hyman. He of the complete line of "sugar is evil" diet books lining the shelves of your local Barnes & Noble.

    He's found his angle and he's hitting it hard. Gotta sell those books.
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.
  • Holly_Roman_Empire
    Holly_Roman_Empire Posts: 4,440 Member
    I think Katie Couric is an idiot. Personal opinion.

    I agree, she is!
    Excess food intake and lack of movement is more likely a cause in obesity than sugar. It's just the new target, just like fat used to be. I'll make my own 10 day challenge. "Eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge. I think if you're getting a balanced diet and don't have an underlying medical condition, it's a trivial micro.

    While I don't think sugar is the ONLY culprit, it definitely can't hurt for people to be enlightened to just how much of it they are consuming. The extra calories come from a lot of places, and sugar is definitely one of them. I think it would be hard to find someone who is obese and overeats constantly, but never ingests added sugar. It's just so easy to over-indulge in, especially when it's in a beverage or added to foods you don't expect it to be in.

    If only I could introduce you to my dad. My mom cooks for him on the regular, and he only eats fruits to satisfy his sweet tooth.

    Non-processed foods, zero sugar, or any other fad does not guarantee weight loss or fitness.
  • SugaryLynx
    SugaryLynx Posts: 2,640 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance
  • eric_sg61
    eric_sg61 Posts: 2,925 Member
    Oh Dr Hyman. He of the complete line of "sugar is evil" diet books lining the shelves of your local Barnes & Noble.

    He's found his angle and he's hitting it hard. Gotta sell those books.
    Yep, a doctor salary is great and all...........but not near the monetary magnitude of selling fear-mongering books to the masses.
  • Jestinia
    Jestinia Posts: 1,153 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance

    1. Both parents usually work far too many hours to constantly keep an eye on the kids.

    2. They go off to school and many public schools give a choice between rancid and disgusting slop, or the vending machine. I chose vending machine and I don't blame any other child for doing so.

    3. We have a massive number of fat sick kids in America, why are we marketing crap to them? What purpose does it serve except to make money for people who have more than enough already? Why allow it? Also, why do manufacturers even put sugar in everything? Who thought it was a good idea to put sugar in bread?

    4. Since these morons do put all kinds of crap in our food, I want more accurate calorie counts, non-deceptive serving sizes, and I don't ever want to see 'natural and artificial ingredients' on a label again. I want to know what the ingredients are, patents be damned.
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance

    Uhhh.. yeah. I know that now it is up to me. I was referring to when I was a kid and I wasn't exposed to veggies. And I definitely don't survive on plain chicken, veggies & fruit. I eat a very wide variety of foods (which sometimes includes things like Talenti), such as ribeyes with homemade mayo, sweet potatoes & steamed veggies smothered in butter. No dry chicken here.

    There's a misconception that if you don't eat pizza, ice cream & cookies regularly, then you only eat the boring food or the same foods all the time. So. Not. True. Your diet can be incredibly interesting without those things. Although, if that's how you choose to get your nutrients and make your diet interesting to you, that's cool with me.
  • jkwolly
    jkwolly Posts: 3,049 Member
    Eat all the sugar!!!!!!! :drinker: :drinker: :drinker:
  • SugaryLynx
    SugaryLynx Posts: 2,640 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance

    Uhhh.. yeah. I know that now it is up to me. I was referring to when I was a kid and I wasn't exposed to veggies. And I definitely don't survive on plain chicken, veggies & fruit. I eat a very wide variety of foods (which sometimes includes things like Talenti), such as ribeyes with homemade mayo, sweet potatoes & steamed veggies smothered in butter. No dry chicken here.

    There's a misconception that if you don't eat pizza, ice cream & cookies regularly, then you only eat the boring food or the same foods all the time. So. Not. True. Your diet can be incredibly interesting without those things. Although, if that's how you choose to get your nutrients and make your diet interesting to you, that's cool with me.

    I was one of those kids who grew up eating "junk" and I didn't become overweight until after high school when I became sedentary.

    My example was purely to say you don't HAVE to eat a certain way or eliminate things not only so lose weight but to maintain your health. Everything in moderation. If you enjoy your lifestyle, that's great but back to the main point. ..

    Sugar is tasty and not the culprit for obesity and shouldn't be used as such

    21de5wj.jpg

    Back I go behind my fortress of evil
  • Holly_Roman_Empire
    Holly_Roman_Empire Posts: 4,440 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance

    1. Both parents usually work far too many hours to constantly keep an eye on the kids.

    2. They go off to school and many public schools give a choice between rancid and disgusting slop, or the vending machine. I chose vending machine and I don't blame any other child for doing so.

    3. We have a massive number of fat sick kids in America, why are we marketing crap to them? What purpose does it serve except to make money for people who have more than enough already? Why allow it? Also, why do manufacturers even put sugar in everything? Who thought it was a good idea to put sugar in bread?

    4. Since these morons do put all kinds of crap in our food, I want more accurate calorie counts, non-deceptive serving sizes, and I don't ever want to see 'natural and artificial ingredients' on a label again. I want to know what the ingredients are, patents be damned.

    My husband and I both work, and I know exactly what goes into my kid's mouth while I'm not there. Pick up a school menu. If you don't like what's served for lunch, pack them a lunch. The other two meals of the day, I control at home. If I can make 2 of the 3 meals reasonable, then I don't really worry about that third one if it's less than stellar.

    Companies market to kids so that when they all go to the store together, little Johnny says, "Mommy mommy, I saw this cool cereal on Nickelodeon and it looks awesome! Buy it for me!" But you know what? Mom doesn't have to put it in the basket.

    As for upbringing, yeah, a lot of parents do their kids a disservice by not introducing vegetables into diet. I was one of them, but now I eat my veggies on the regular because I'm an adult.
  • Jestinia
    Jestinia Posts: 1,153 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance

    1. Both parents usually work far too many hours to constantly keep an eye on the kids.

    2. They go off to school and many public schools give a choice between rancid and disgusting slop, or the vending machine. I chose vending machine and I don't blame any other child for doing so.

    3. We have a massive number of fat sick kids in America, why are we marketing crap to them? What purpose does it serve except to make money for people who have more than enough already? Why allow it? Also, why do manufacturers even put sugar in everything? Who thought it was a good idea to put sugar in bread?

    4. Since these morons do put all kinds of crap in our food, I want more accurate calorie counts, non-deceptive serving sizes, and I don't ever want to see 'natural and artificial ingredients' on a label again. I want to know what the ingredients are, patents be damned.

    My husband and I both work, and I know exactly what goes into my kid's mouth while I'm not there. Pick up a school menu. If you don't like what's served for lunch, pack them a lunch. The other two meals of the day, I control at home. If I can make 2 of the 3 meals reasonable, then I don't really worry about that third one if it's less than stellar.

    Companies market to kids so that when they all go to the store together, little Johnny says, "Mommy mommy, I saw this cool cereal on Nickelodeon and it looks awesome! Buy it for me!" But you know what? Mom doesn't have to put it in the basket.

    As for upbringing, yeah, a lot of parents do their kids a disservice by not introducing vegetables into diet. I was one of them, but now I eat my veggies on the regular because I'm an adult.

    So it was fine to market cigarettes to kids, because parents could control that, too. Why not market alcohol to them, as well? I wouldn't make the comparison, by the way, if it weren't so obvious there is a problem.

    Both my parents worked when I was in high school. They had no time or money to pack a lunch. In fact, we qualified for a dollar breakfast or something like that at the school due to low income. Know what they fed us? A giant pastry with fake blueberries or cherries on it.

    School lunches need to change. Then the junk needs to go. And advertising junkfood to kids is unnecessary. It doesn't make our society better, there is evidence it might make it worse, so why allow it?
  • mb19339
    mb19339 Posts: 1
    I'm interested in taking the challenge! I'm shocked at how vicious the response is below "Katie Couric's an idot" over and over again. Seriously? She's not a researcher, but that doesn't make her an idiot for weighing in on important issues, that's what good journalism/reporting/media is about, engaging the most compelling research with the public. The documentary she is talking about on her show is based on serious and wide-ranging research by experts in the field, but all anyone is hearing is "ohmygosh they're attacking sugar must be a fad!!!" Obviously, anything can be taken to an extreme, but I know from personal experience excessive sugar affects me very negatively and our culture is way too dependent on it. It isn't about sugar being "evil" it's about a culture of dependency on it.
  • snikkins
    snikkins Posts: 1,282 Member
    Things the film advocates:

    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.


    Things I agree with:

    Eliminate junkfood marketing to kids.
    Make food labels more transparent.
    Get rid of junk food in schools (but also put in healthy meal programs, don't just keep feeding them downer cow reject meat).

    Junk food marketing to kids is really out of control. And I was just remembering when I was in (high)school and basically survived on pizza, cheetos & pepsi. I'm sure those healthy eating habits are (at least in part) what led me to become overweight shortly after graduation. It wasn't until my 30's that I actually started eating vegetables. Pretty sad, really. Of course, my parents can take some of the blame too.

    Here's the thing. Parents have control over how much and how often kids are being fed non nutrient dense foods. But you're an adult now, you can't blame anyone but yourself for whatever state you may be in. This all comes down to personal responsibility.

    No one forces you to overeat. No one forces you to eat anything. YOU and you alone are in control. There is far too much lack of responsibility for our actions in today's world.

    I still eat fast food quite a few times a week, actually. I eat ice cream, pizza, cookies... but I do so with moderation and while still getting the nutrients my body needs. You know what your body does with excess nutrients it can't use? So, why would I want to eat nothing but plain chicken, veggies and fruit and ignore that beautiful pint of Talenti? Sometimes, that pint helps me meet my nutrients for the day. It's all about balance

    Uhhh.. yeah. I know that now it is up to me. I was referring to when I was a kid and I wasn't exposed to veggies. And I definitely don't survive on plain chicken, veggies & fruit. I eat a very wide variety of foods (which sometimes includes things like Talenti), such as ribeyes with homemade mayo, sweet potatoes & steamed veggies smothered in butter. No dry chicken here.

    There's a misconception that if you don't eat pizza, ice cream & cookies regularly, then you only eat the boring food or the same foods all the time. So. Not. True. Your diet can be incredibly interesting without those things. Although, if that's how you choose to get your nutrients and make your diet interesting to you, that's cool with me.

    I was one of those kids who grew up eating "junk" and I didn't become overweight until after high school when I became sedentary.

    My example was purely to say you don't HAVE to eat a certain way or eliminate things not only so lose weight but to maintain your health. Everything in moderation. If you enjoy your lifestyle, that's great but back to the main point. ..

    Sugar is tasty and not the culprit for obesity and shouldn't be used as such

    21de5wj.jpg

    Back I go behind my fortress of evil

    It's the picture again! :love: (I'm not stalking you... I swear... :laugh:)
    <snip>
    The film challenges its audience to take a 10-day sugar-detox, but that's just part of what needs to be done, says Dr. Hyman. Among his suggestions: a soda tax; eliminating food marketing to kids; making food labels more transparent; and getting rid of all junk food in schools.

    I really disagree with the notion of a soda tax. Typically, Pigovian taxes seem to not work as well as intended and often come with unintended consequences.
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    It isn't about sugar being "evil" it's about a culture of dependency on it.

    :flowerforyou:

    thank you thank you thank you
  • Confuzzled4ever
    Confuzzled4ever Posts: 2,860 Member
    I benefit greatly when I cut added sugars out of my diet.

    I was onto the "reduce/remove added sugar" band wagon long before I ever read anything or watched anything on it. I just know what i feel. Is it that way for everyone?? We wouldn't know unless everyone cuts it out.

    today was not a good day.. Added sugar all over the place in my diary.. And I am suffering for it. :sick:
  • SnicciFit
    SnicciFit Posts: 967 Member
    I benefit greatly when I cut added sugars out of my diet.

    I was onto the "reduce/remove added sugar" band wagon long before I ever read anything or watched anything on it. I just know what i feel. Is it that way for everyone?? We wouldn't know unless everyone cuts it out.

    today was not a good day.. Added sugar all over the place in my diary.. And I am suffering for it. :sick:

    It's hard to become aware of how different foods make you feel/affect you without actually removing them for a while and then paying attention when you add them back in. Too much added sugar makes me cranky & fatigued. After cutting out added sugar for 30 days, I also find that a lot of foods that have sugar added are way too sweet for my palette now. It also allowed me to enjoy other tastes differently. For example, plain almonds are actually quite sweet. I had no idea.
  • tigersword
    tigersword Posts: 8,059 Member
    I think Katie Couric is an idiot. Personal opinion.

    I agree, she is!
    Excess food intake and lack of movement is more likely a cause in obesity than sugar. It's just the new target, just like fat used to be. I'll make my own 10 day challenge. "Eat all the sugar and get fit" challenge. I think if you're getting a balanced diet and don't have an underlying medical condition, it's a trivial micro.

    While I don't think sugar is the ONLY culprit, it definitely can't hurt for people to be enlightened to just how much of it they are consuming. The extra calories come from a lot of places, and sugar is definitely one of them. I think it would be hard to find someone who is obese and overeats constantly, but never ingests added sugar. It's just so easy to over-indulge in, especially when it's in a beverage or added to foods you don't expect it to be in.
    I think it would also be hard to find someone who is obese and overeats constantly that never ingests fat or protein, also. See? It's not the individual nutrient that's important. It's the "overeating constantly" part that's important.
  • RaspberryKeytoneBoondoggle
    RaspberryKeytoneBoondoggle Posts: 1,349 Member
    I remember when my kids were little and they had friends who had free access to a fridge filled with pop, so whenever they were thirsty or hungry they could help themselves. I'm talking two and three year olds included in this. Bulk pop is very inexpensive and it was an easy way for parents to not have to listen to "I'm hungry " complaints from their children.
    This sort of thing is more common than I would have thought.

    I was a parent who didn't control how my children ate, as in, they ate as much or as little as they wanted, but I did control the foods that were in my house and always made sure that there were easy healthy snacks around. There are many ways we can help our children to not have issues with food. My way is just how I chose to do things. I do think, however, that a 10 day period of micromanaging every ingredient my child ate would only create problems.

    Today my children are young adults who are fit and slim and healthy and enjoy treats and "unhealthy" snacks but also cook healthy meals and bake cookies. I usually eat all the cookies, because I don't seem to be able to stop at just one like the rest of my family. I didn't learn to eat in moderation or follow my own cues for when I was full, but I am learning this now.