Hi,
I'm new on this site and I have a question about what calorie intake I really should be consuming. I'm getting very confused the more I research and use different calculators... MFP tells me I should be eating 1560 calories/day to lose 1.5 lbs/ week. Prior to a few days ago I was eating around 1800 calories but now I've lowered it to the MFP number.
I began exercising (cardio - elliptical machine) about 20-30 minutes 3-5 days/ week May 13th, 2014. So almost a month ago. I am a 30 year old male with a height of 5' 8.5" ish. I tend to carry fat more like a woman in the hips before it goes to my stomach.
My starting weight was ~205 lbs. My goal is to be down in the 150's ASAP.
I only yesterday created a profile on MFP, so there really isn't much to look at in regards to my food logs and stuff, but I have been eating a deficit and exercising for almost a month.
Today on 6/6/14 - I weighed in at 199.8 and although my hips and waist have gone down slightly they also go up a bit and have not done much in the past 2 weeks. Today I gained some weight, and otherwise it hasn't gone down in a week really.
TLDR; How many calories should I be eating?? It's causing me anxiety because I can't just be sure how much to eat. (Before starting my diet I had very sporadic eating times where sometimes there was very little food and sometimes I would binge out but i'm not sure what my average daily calorie consumption was)
FitnessFrog calculator says my TDEE is ~2710 and my BMR ~1971
So, am I making no progress because my 30 minute cardio/ day is way too much for only 1560 calories? I feel like I shouldn't trust the MFP #'s but what do I know.. I am very careful and measure out every macro (carb, protein, fat) throughout the day between 3-5 meals. I don't feel starving on 1560 or anything. But my tape measurements and scale measurements are definitely not budging very much at all.
Someone please assist! My recent blood work had all normal numbers for thyroid function and all that so I would hope it's not something wrong with my metabolism being destroyed or something.

Thanks for any help on nailing down what my calorie intake should be, it's ruining my motivation!