Answer me this - same measurements, different weight???

dewsmom78

How is it I have almost the same measurements as I did 2 years ago, but there is over a 10 lb weight difference???

I am 5'3 - 36 years old.

5/16/12 - 3 months post baby #1 at 139 lbs:
Waist: 32
Hips: 38
Thighs: 21
Chest: 38.5
Calves: 14.5

7/24/14 - 4 months post baby #2 at 150 lbs
Waist: 32.5
Hips: 38
Thighs: 20
Chest: 38
Calves: 14

WBB55

If the measurements are accurate, it's because you have more muscle, probably.

psuLemon

If the measurements are accurate, it's because you have more muscle, probably.

This.. body composition determines stats, not weight. So if you have more muscle (which is more dense that fat), you will be slimmer.

Exhibit A. - 10 and 20 lb muscle gains.

http://www.nerdfitness.com/blog/2011/07/21/meet-staci-your-new-powerlifting-super-hero/

leggup

Are you using a tape measure that auto-tightens to the exact same tautness each time? If so, you've got muscle. If not, then you may need more data to be sure.

dewsmom78

Here is the comparison. I really hope it's muscle then!!

dewsmom78

Are you using a tape measure that auto-tightens to the exact same tautness each time? If so, you've got muscle. If not, then you may need more data to be sure.

No I just use a standard tape measure, been using the same one for years. So I know I might not get the "exact" spot every time....

DrJenO

Also, having babies can do crazy things to your body - weight, composition, extra skin, etc.

I've had 3 now, and I've gotten down to the weight I was 10 years ago, but clothes I KNOW fit me at the time (because I was still hanging on to some of them) fit me differently. My waist is smaller, but my hips and, um, lower front belly are bigger.

I_Will_End_You

Also, having babies can do crazy things to your body - weight, composition, extra skin, etc.

^ True.


And you could have just measured in a slightly different spot or tightened the tape differently.

leggup

Are you using a tape measure that auto-tightens to the exact same tautness each time? If so, you've got muscle. If not, then you may need more data to be sure.

No I just use a standard tape measure, been using the same one for years. So I know I might not get the "exact" spot every time....

So, it might be a little off. Chalk some of it up to measurements.

Also, losing weight- the same person doesn't always lose or gain from the same spots. I have a dress I wore 3 years ago that fit me like a glove. I think I was 10 lbs less than I weigh now. Now, when I wear it (at a higher weight), it's a little baggy in the waist and hip, but it's WAY too small in the chest. Like, a full cup size too small. No, I haven't had kids.

The good news is that when you do get down to the weight you were before, your measurements will be even smaller

dewsmom78

Are you using a tape measure that auto-tightens to the exact same tautness each time? If so, you've got muscle. If not, then you may need more data to be sure.

No I just use a standard tape measure, been using the same one for years. So I know I might not get the "exact" spot every time....

So, it might be a little off. Chalk some of it up to measurements.

Also, losing weight- the same person doesn't always lose or gain from the same spots. I have a dress I wore 3 years ago that fit me like a glove. I think I was 10 lbs less than I weigh now. Now, when I wear it (at a higher weight), it's a little baggy in the waist and hip, but it's WAY too small in the chest. Like, a full cup size too small. No, I haven't had kids.

The good news is that when you do get down to the weight you were before, your measurements will be even smaller

Thanks, that is what I am hoping for!

hbrittingham

Here is the comparison. I really hope it's muscle then!!

I think you look pretty dang awesome post baby #2!

dewsmom78

Here is the comparison. I really hope it's muscle then!!

I think you look pretty dang awesome post baby #2!

Aw, thank you! I still have a ways to go to fit in all my pre-baby clothes, but I'm working on it.