Counting calories CAN be pointless
AusteenaHayes
Posts: 91
Okay so this is my honest belief here. Counting calories should be used to guide people into a healthier lifestyle but it shouldn't be the ONLY way.
Like I run and workouts six, seven times a week. I typically run a good six or seven miles and do plenty of strength training. Anyone feel at time that counting calories is pointless, especially when you're as or almost as active as me?
Like I run and workouts six, seven times a week. I typically run a good six or seven miles and do plenty of strength training. Anyone feel at time that counting calories is pointless, especially when you're as or almost as active as me?
0
Replies
-
No... it's not pointless if you want to lose weight, and that is my honest belief.0
-
thats like saying balancing your checkbook is pointless. I guess it is if you have unlimted money.0
-
No.
Weight loss isn't the only goal.
If I was as active as you but my goal was to maintain or gain weight, I would still track my calories to make sure I'm not undereating.0 -
This won't end well0
-
No, it's not the ONLY way. But it does seem strange to start a thread about it on a calorie-counting website. :ohwell:0
-
You can't out lift or outrun a bad diet. I stopped counting calories and gained a lot of my weight back.0
-
You should stick with it. If you hit your goals, cool. If not, cool.
Good luck though, having a mission but no analyzable data isn't a good idea for long term success.0 -
If you can get the results that you want without calorie counting then I think that's great. But it doesn't make calorie counting "pointless" for those of us who choose to/need to do it.0
-
I ended up on MFP because I thought like you. I worked out A LOT. Spin classes several times a week, lifting several times a week, other classes. People would say to me "you should be SO skinny (GRRR) as much as you work out!". Yeah, unfortunately, I LOVE to eat. And I would eat a lot of food. And guess what?! I gained weight! Started counting calories and discovered just how much I was eating and started making changes. Then I thought I knew what I was doing and when life got in the way I stopped really logging and BAM hello 15 lbs. that I thought were gone forever. So for me, counting calories IS the point.0
-
IMO, at a high level of activity, calorie counting can be even MORE important. For me, I want to make sure my body is fueled properly for my running and strength training, but also maintain a modest calorie deficit. If I didn't count calories, I run the risk of too few calories, leading to malnutrition and fatigue. Or, I could be eating too many, and I'm stalling my weight loss.
So, I track my calories burned and make sure I eat those back. I can't ensure I'm doing this properly without counting.0 -
You can't out lift or outrun a bad diet. I stopped counting calories and gained a lot of my weight back.
I *hate* this saying. "A bad diet" is so subjective - you can absolutely out-lift/out-run what SOME people would call a bad diet, but you probably can't out-lift/out-run a 6000 calorie/day diet. Even if it was entirely food that people would consider good.
I know that's what you were trying to say - I just hate that phrasing.0 -
Not every tool is right for every person at all times. Use the tools that are right for you where you are right now. If you don't need to count calories to reach your goals, then don't.
However, this doesn't change the fact that any increase or decrease in your weight is the result of either a calorie surplus or deficit, respectively. This is true whether or not you track.0 -
Well, I managed to gain even more weight while CrossFitting 2x per day, 6 days per week. I don't do CrossFit anymore, regular weightlifting and some cardio instead, started counting calories, and have lost almost 20 lbs. So, for me anyways, counting calories is pretty darn important0
-
Okay so this is my honest belief here. Counting calories should be used to guide people into a healthier lifestyle but it shouldn't be the ONLY way.
Like I run and workouts six, seven times a week. I typically run a good six or seven miles and do plenty of strength training. Anyone feel at time that counting calories is pointless, especially when you're as or almost as active as me?
Counting calories isnt the only way to lose weight otherwise nobody would ever have lost weight using any other method, however being very active isn't a reason not to count calories in my view because you can still gain weight
Even more important if you are very active is counting the calories and watching macro's to ensure that you aren't creating to large a deficit and are getting sufficient protein to give you the best chance of preserving as much muscle as possible otherwise it could possible lead to problems in the future0 -
If you can reach your goals without counting calories then more power to you, but for most people simply leading an active life won't give you a free pass on calorie counting. Accurate calorie tracking is the most efficient way IMO0
-
Calorie counting is a valuable tool, is not pointless, and you don't need to do it to get results.0
-
Not every tool is right for every person at all times. Use the tools that are right for you where you are right now. If you don't need to count calories to reach your goals, then don't.
However, this doesn't change the fact that any increase or decrease in your weight is the result of either a calorie surplus or deficit, respectively. This is true whether or not you track.0 -
Counting calories was pointless until I got into my mid-twenties.
At 19, your personal experience and anecdotal observations may not supply you a fair representative sample.
But counting calories is not the only way. There are a thousand others.0 -
Anyone feel at time that counting calories is pointless, especially when you're as or almost as active as me?
nope.
im interested in my macros as well, and counting calories and all the nutritional value of everything i consume helps me reach them.
hope you're getting enough to fuel your level of activity and not wither away to nothing.
eta: ah....just saw that you're 19. give it another 10 years and see how you feel.0 -
Ok. Of course, it's not always the right tool. It's a handy one though.0
-
IMO, at a high level of activity, calorie counting can be even MORE important. For me, I want to make sure my body is fueled properly for my running and strength training, but also maintain a modest calorie deficit. If I didn't count calories, I run the risk of too few calories, leading to malnutrition and fatigue. Or, I could be eating too many, and I'm stalling my weight loss.
So, I track my calories burned and make sure I eat those back. I can't ensure I'm doing this properly without counting.
^ This ^0 -
Okay so this is my honest belief here. Counting calories should be used to guide people into a healthier lifestyle but it shouldn't be the ONLY way.
Like I run and workouts six, seven times a week. I typically run a good six or seven miles and do plenty of strength training. Anyone feel at time that counting calories is pointless, especially when you're as or almost as active as me?
No. But then, you are The Most Active Woman In The World, so your experience may be different than most.
0 -
OP, I agree with you. I don't think that it is pointless for everyone, but I definitely feel it's mostly pointless for me at this point. I'm so active that it really doesn't matter what I eat (using the knowledge of what I learned while losing weight).0
-
You can't out lift or outrun a bad diet. I stopped counting calories and gained a lot of my weight back.
I *hate* this saying. "A bad diet" is so subjective - you can absolutely out-lift/out-run what SOME people would call a bad diet, but you probably can't out-lift/out-run a 6000 calorie/day diet. Even if it was entirely food that people would consider good.
I know that's what you were trying to say - I just hate that phrasing.
Agreed. I have a pretty 'bad' diet. but it's oh, so good.0 -
It's pointless if you consistently eat at a deficit or maintenance without thinking a lot about what you're eating, which is the case for many persons (pointless meaning unnecessary because you're already doing what you need to do in order to reach or maintain your goal size). If you have trouble eating at a deficit or at maintenance, then it's not pointless at all and is quite helpful, regardless of how active you are.0
-
Exercise makes me hungry and makes me think it's okay to eat ALL the food and drink ALL the beer. I could totally be "very active" and still gain if I didn't count.0
-
"You can't compete with what you eat"0
-
Exercise makes me hungry and makes me think it's okay to eat ALL the food and drink ALL the beer. I could totally be "very active" and still gain if I didn't count.
Definitely this. My appetite knows no bounds.0 -
Definitely not pointless. I've lost over 50 pounds counting calories and I also work out 6-7 days a week and am pretty active.
Like others have said, you can't outrun a bad diet no matter how active you are.
What's easier to do, to cut out 300 calories from a meal or to burn 300 calories at the gym?
And that's the answer to your question basically although I understand what you're trying to say.0 -
Nope, not pointless if you're not getting the results you want "unmonitored".
I am a fairly healthy individual -no chronic health issues. One or two colds/year. No GI diseases. No depression, etc. Only ongoing limiter in diet is lactose intolerance (blame bad genes ).
And I am still struggling to lose about 5 lb to reach what I think is my "optimal" body composition for competing. I ride and race a bicycle 15-20 h / week. I clearly need to be more diligent with my dietary efforts - not just tracking, but eliminating the mindless eating. I am guilty of that too often, eating lots of suboptimal foods after a hard ride.
At least tracking honestly provides a log of what I am doing and where I can improve. Simply tracking doesn't solve anything. Conversely, if you're happy with where you are, why go over the hassle of logging anything? It's just a tool. You don't buy a hammer if you don't need to push some nails in.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions