Splenda....

want2BthinRN
want2BthinRN Posts: 22
edited September 22 in Food and Nutrition
I know everyone has different opinions about Splenda and other "sweeteners" but I have a different kind of question. I made some tea with "splenda" and it tastes JUST like the "real" stuff. My question is has anyone who has been at this a while noticed if the sweeteners effect your diet in any way. Good or bad? Thanx.

Replies

  • NoAdditives
    NoAdditives Posts: 4,251 Member
    Artificial sweeteners are perceived by the brain to be a real form of sugar and the hormone insulin is released. Insulin is the "fat storing" hormone. It tells the liver and kidneys to stop burning fat for energy and to instead take sugar from your blood. If there is not enough sugar in your blood you get hypoglycemic and need to eat or drink more to replenish your normal level of blood sugar. Plus, as I already said, it stops your body from burning fat. It is extremely counterproductive for those hoping to burn body fat.
  • WarmDontBurn
    WarmDontBurn Posts: 1,253 Member
    I use splenda daily and it has no impact on my weight loss. I am my biggest impact.
  • I like Splenda, but I've changed to Truvia (made from Stevia plant) and I definitely prefer its taste. I don't know what the effect is, but I do try and use it very sparingly. I haven't been working my plan for long, so I haven't noticed any type of a change. I'm not sure if I will or won't, but I do keep in mind that no artificial sweetener at all (along with no sugar) is better for me... but, Truvia is probably better for me than a teaspoon of sugar.
  • kelika71
    kelika71 Posts: 778 Member
    Interesting comments. I'm Diabetic, losing weight and use Splenda every day.
  • givprayz
    givprayz Posts: 328
    Artificial sweeteners are perceived by the brain to be a real form of sugar and the hormone insulin is released. Insulin is the "fat storing" hormone. It tells the liver and kidneys to stop burning fat for energy and to instead take sugar from your blood. If there is not enough sugar in your blood you get hypoglycemic and need to eat or drink more to replenish your normal level of blood sugar. Plus, as I already said, it stops your body from burning fat. It is extremely counterproductive for those hoping to burn body fat.

    I disagree with the above information from a scientific perspective. The brain has nothing directly to do with the way in which sugar and sweeteners are metabolized; that is a matter for receptors in the pancreas. Extensive study has found no change in blood sugar levels after ingestion of Splenda (sucralose) or Stevia, nor any support for the slowing of fat-burning with the use of either. There ARE studies that found people who used artificial sweeteners actually eat more calories, but the correlation is likely to be that people who use sweeteners are overweight because they eat too much, and they use sweeteners in the hope that it will help them lose weight painlessly, not that the sweeteners lead them to eat more.
    I dislike saccharin and Equal because they are completely artificial. Splenda is real sugar with an added inert chain that causes the body to be unable to recognize or metabolize it. Stevia is a plant extract that is not metabolized by the human body, much the way we cannot metabolize cellulose, so it passes unchanged through our bodies. It has been used for centuries and is perfectly safe. The only drawback is that it tastes different than sugar, so it takes a little getting used to.
    If you like Splenda, use it and enjoy! Don't be worried by the alarmists on these 2 sweeteners. (Go ahead and believe them about Equal though. It is a pretty scary chemical with neurotoxic properties.)
  • PNCTink
    PNCTink Posts: 232 Member
    I've been using Splenda (and now Truvia too) in my tea and on my oatmeal everyday and am losing weight still. I am not overloading myself with either, but i figure it's much better (calorie-wise) than white sugar or honey.
This discussion has been closed.