We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Good idea or not?!?

Kasey_Ford
Kasey_Ford Posts: 38 Member
edited September 2024 in Food and Nutrition
I was thinking about beginning to supplement one of my meals with a protein shake, but I'm not sure if this will help me or hinder me. Any tips with what kind I should try and which to stay away from? I already know that slim-fast is not all it's cracked up to be. Keep in mind I'm only going to supplement lunch with it. I eat a light breakfast and easy dinner, but my lunches at work are always fatty fast food!!! I know I can count on you guys to deliver!

Replies

  • AJMWriter
    AJMWriter Posts: 1 Member
    I'd give CLIF Bars a try--great protein and fiber to keep you going cuz that's what they're made for. Highly recommended!!
  • WorkingMomGetsFit
    WorkingMomGetsFit Posts: 70 Member
    You can eat grilled chicken breast with a side of steamed vegies and a side salad for the same amount of calories as some shakes. I have tried the shakes before and they taste great and are loaded with vitamins/minerals, but they just don't have the staying power as a healthy meal. Just my opinion :-)
  • Ral263
    Ral263 Posts: 318 Member
    You can eat grilled chicken breast with a side of steamed vegies and a side salad for the same amount of calories as some shakes. I have tried the shakes before and they taste great and are loaded with vitamins/minerals, but they just don't have the staying power as a healthy meal. Just my opinion :-)

    ITA. There are just many calories (if not more) in a shake than in a real meal that will keep you fuller longer, and provide more nutrition since you can eat a ton of veggies for few calories. Pack a lunch and bring it to work instead!
  • missy204
    missy204 Posts: 30
    its an ok idea. I personally don't like the taste. Hubby drinks Whey protein shakes and gets good results.
  • Mayor_West
    Mayor_West Posts: 246 Member

    ITA. There are just many calories (if not more) in a shake than in a real meal that will keep you fuller longer, and provide more nutrition since you can eat a ton of veggies for few calories. Pack a lunch and bring it to work instead!

    That depends greatly on the shake- not all are created equal. Some are MRP (meal replacement packets), which are meant to be eaten without any other foods, as they provide a balance of protein, carbs, fats and nutrients. As a result, these have a higher calorie content.

    However, a shake consisting of primarily whey protein, can contain anywhere from 100-130 calories per serving, with 20-30 grams of protein.


    Also, I'd avoid Clif Bars- they have a decent amount of protein, but a higher calorie count- 230 calories, 25g sugars and only 9g protein.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories