"...was under his/her calorie goal"

Mmmary212

i love everyone saying no to eating back calories has lost around 3lbs, and the people eating some of 'em back are in the -20lb range. jusssst an observation.

And that may be the case for some, however.... You don't know when that 3lb loser (lol) started...or how long that 20lb loser started....or if that 3lb loser has lost weight prior and just had a baby and restarted or if that 20lb loser has been trying for 3 years.

I don't eat my exercise calores ::::looks at loss:::

Yeah, I feel like no one read my post at all... I addressed this. I lost 19 pounds doing it my way (which I'm NOT saying is the only way, it's just the way that worked better for me) Then when I was on maintenance I developed bulimia and gained it back. The three pounds I've lost is within a week of trying to recover from bulimia, so I didn't appreciate that rude comment at all.

Wait, what rude comment? Something I said?

My reply was my thoughts, I didn't say anything in regards to your posts....therefore that doesn't mean no one read it. Maybe it wasn't anything anyone want to reply to? <<shrug>>

Lunachic77

@ Misspenny..You are barely eating even on the days where you don't exercise. You eat the same foods over and over..cereal, lunch meat and a small fruit and still don't touch your daily calorie goal. I realize you are a recovering bulemic and it's fine if you don't want to eat your exercise calories back, but at some point you have got to eat more nutritious and plentiful meals...one day you had a surplus of 800+ calories w/o exercise.

Kat120285

When I first started a little over a month ago of course MFP set me at 1200, I then moved it up to 1250 and finally 1300. Well weight stalled. I did some reading around and finally upped my activity level to very active. My base is now 1690 and once I exercise that goes up to around 2400. I know how MFP works and I eat those exercise calories back because I still have the built in deficit from MFP.

I've worked hard for my muscle and I don't want my body turning to it for fuel. Sure sometimes eating that much can be tough but I do it to maintain my muscle and feed my body as well as my work outs.

misspenny762

i love everyone saying no to eating back calories has lost around 3lbs, and the people eating some of 'em back are in the -20lb range. jusssst an observation.

And that may be the case for some, however.... You don't know when that 3lb loser (lol) started...or how long that 20lb loser started....or if that 3lb loser has lost weight prior and just had a baby and restarted or if that 20lb loser has been trying for 3 years.

I don't eat my exercise calores ::::looks at loss:::

Yeah, I feel like no one read my post at all... I addressed this. I lost 19 pounds doing it my way (which I'm NOT saying is the only way, it's just the way that worked better for me) Then when I was on maintenance I developed bulimia and gained it back. The three pounds I've lost is within a week of trying to recover from bulimia, so I didn't appreciate that rude comment at all.

Wait, what rude comment? Something I said?

My reply was my thoughts, I didn't say anything in regards to your posts....therefore that doesn't mean no one read it. Maybe it wasn't anything anyone want to reply to? <<shrug>>

No, nothing you said.

misspenny762

@ Misspenny..You are barely eating even on the days where you don't exercise. You eat the same foods over and over..cereal, lunch meat and a small fruit and still don't touch your daily calorie goal. I realize you are a recovering bulemic and it's fine if you don't want to eat your exercise calories back, but at some point you have got to eat more nutritious and plentiful meals...one day you had a surplus of 800+ calories w/o exercise.

I very often don't track food because it's a binge or other reasons. Huge deficits are often misleading.

I know that my diet is incredibly screwed up.

If I want advice, I'll ask for it.

This is why I had my food diary private... Going back to that I guess.

TheBraveryLover

This thread is getting out of hand with people making negative comments about other people's open diary.

This is the reason I'm picky with who I friend and only have my diary open to my friends. It's really no one's business what someone eats or doesn't eat. If anyone wants your negativity, they'd ask. If you don't like the diet of someone who's diary you're reading, simply don't comment. It's really that simple.

The self importance in this thread is astonishing.

Misspenny762, feel free to add me as a friend. I'm no where near as judgmental as some on this site.

crythreetears

I guess its whatever works best for everyone. I eat 3 meals a day and 2 snacks, and still don't reach my goal. I'm just not the type of person to snack on things all day, and I don't find myself to be hungry. As for how much i burned working out, it may or may not even be the correct amount..

naku

This thread is getting out of hand with people making negative comments about other people's open diary.

This is the reason I'm picky with who I friend and only have my diary open to my friends. It's really no one's business what someone eats or doesn't eat. If anyone wants your negativity, they'd ask. If you don't like the diet of someone who's diary you're reading, simply don't comment. It's really that simple.

The self importance in this thread is astonishing.

Misspenny762, feel free to add me as a friend. I'm no where near as judgmental as some on this site.

most sane comment in the whole thread so far.

liyahxoxo

kay I have a question. I'm not trying to be rude or anything, I actually am asking an innocent question:
I honestly DON'T understand how can some people never eat ANY of their exercise cals back and lose weight? this does not make sense to me. If I think about myself, personally, trying to do that:
a.the math behind it makes no sense (starvation mode, gradual slowing down of metabolism etc.) b. I would get so starved I would go absolutely maniac. Maybe I just have an abnormally large appetite and it's something wrong with me? I don't know..

liyahxoxo

kay I have a question. I'm not trying to be rude or anything, I actually am asking an innocent question:
I honestly DON'T understand how can some people never eat ANY of their exercise cals back and lose weight? this does not make sense to me. If I think about myself, personally, trying to do that:
a.the math behind it makes no sense (starvation mode, gradual slowing down of metabolism etc.) b. I would get so starved I would go absolutely maniac. Maybe I just have an abnormally large appetite and it's something wrong with me? I don't know..

Oh and I wasn't talking about anyone specifically, just jumped into the thread ! I don't mean to offend anyone I promise!

WarmDontBurn

This thread is getting out of hand with people making negative comments about other people's open diary.

This is the reason I'm picky with who I friend and only have my diary open to my friends. It's really no one's business what someone eats or doesn't eat. If anyone wants your negativity, they'd ask. If you don't like the diet of someone who's diary you're reading, simply don't comment. It's really that simple.

The self importance in this thread is astonishing.

Misspenny762, feel free to add me as a friend. I'm no where near as judgmental as some on this site.

most sane comment in the whole thread so far.

If it is no one's business then the option to make your diary private is there. If you open it up then you are asking for it to be looked at and while I agree that for most if I don't "like" their diary I don't read it but what about those people starting out that are barely eating because they think that is the way should we not say something? Or being their "friend" doesn't mean you look out for them. Not to judge but to help?

naku

kay I have a question. I'm not trying to be rude or anything, I actually am asking an innocent question:
I honestly DON'T understand how can some people never eat ANY of their exercise cals back and lose weight? this does not make sense to me. If I think about myself, personally, trying to do that:
a.the math behind it makes no sense (starvation mode, gradual slowing down of metabolism etc.) b. I would get so starved I would go absolutely maniac. Maybe I just have an abnormally large appetite and it's something wrong with me? I don't know..

to answer your question, they lose weight because they eat less calories than what they burn.

simples!

liyahxoxo

to answer your question, they lose weight because they eat less calories than what they burn.

simples!

But I thought that if you exercise a lot and don't eat any of the cals back and you end up with a low caloric intake total for the day and keep on doing this your body starts holding to every little thing you do eat and then it's hard to lose weight?

naku

to answer your question, they lose weight because they eat less calories than what they burn.

simples!

But I thought that if you exercise a lot and don't eat any of the cals back and you end up with a low caloric intake total for the day and keep on doing this your body starts holding to every little thing you do eat and then it's hard to lose weight?

maybe for some, but not for all. everyone is different.
if you want to eat your exercise calories back and lose weight that way, great! if you don't want to eat your exercise calories back and lose weight that way, great too!

like said earlier, I myself haven't eaten my exercise calories back during my time on MFP. to be honest, I haven't ever even logged my exercise even though I go to the gym 3 times a week.
during those 3 months, my calories have been around 800-1300 per day, probably averaging around 1000. according to my trainer I have increased my muscle mass, my blood works are pretty much perfect, I'm full of energy like never before and consider myself (quoting my doctor from 2 weeks ago) very healthy.
my weight loss has once "stalled" for 2 weeks when I only lost 200g, but continued after that as I noticed I hadn't had much fibre during that time and adjusted.
to be honest the closer I come to my goal weight, the easier this seems to be....

this is MY experience on weight loss, calories and exercise. yours might be different. the point is that there are no set rules that work for every single person. even the 1200 ultimate limit of calories doesn't work for everyone.

as long as you are healthy, get closer to your goal and feel happy about your progress, I wouldn't worry about what other people think or the rules they try to impose on others.

vraesgame

OMG! Could you people whine any more? Celo didn't single anyone out, didn't tell anyone specifically that they are wrong, and didn't say anything in his post that should make you feel guilty about your eating. It is a free country. Do (or eat) whatever the hell you want. No one is forcing you to eat anything. Celo stated his OPINION about friend food diary comments. Geez people, if the OP offended you, you need to get some thicker skin....

I complete agree!!

Rinny_D

I found this post and all the responses interesting. Yes, I still have more than 100 pounds to lose, but I've belonged to various weight loss groups for more than a decade and have taken nutrition courses.

I think the most important thing, whether or not you are going to show support for someone, is to realize we're all different. And for those of us trying to lose, we need to understand where we came from and what it will take for our own bodies.

At my heaviest, I was maintaining 280 by taking in 3500-4000 calories a day. I've always been muscular and have always worked out. The fact that I could eat that much and maintain (whether or not I worked out) shocks some people, but that's my body. So when I found MFP, thanks to my new trainer, I realized why all those other programs didn't work for me. Going from 4000 calories a day to 1500 is unrealistic for me. But when I add my exercise (600-900 calories) to my base of 1550 (aiming for a 2 lb/week loss), it seems so much more doable. Even taking in 2500 calories a day now results in a loss for me because I was maintaining at 3500-4000 before.

So, I think that we all need to realize the differences in our bodies, and we all need to be supportive only when we know what the other person is going through. I have a friend on thyroid medication who finds it very hard to lose weight eating 1500 calories a day. I'm supportive of her regardless of her eating 1300 or 1700 because I know her struggles. So I guess what I'm saying is that maybe instead of throwing out a blanket of support for people you don't really know, you focus, instead, on supporting those you DO know.

Food for thought, that's all. :-)

Although you raise some great points I have been on Thyroid replacement for my ENTIRE life. I know how much it screws with your body!

But at the end of the day of you eat well, exercise regularly, live well and have regular blood tests to get your levels right you will be fine!!!!

The more you use the Thyroid issues as an excuse, the less you are taking accountability for your own actions and the harder it is to get the required or desired outcomes.

I have tampered with my medication levels to make it so I loose weight quicker or been lazy/depressed and not taken it because I didn't want to care and slowed my body up. But you know what...... When I stopped doing that crap and started doing it the proper way and took accountability for my own actions... That is when the results started actually making their appearance!

And to repeat this post was more so aimed at those (in my opinion) who are eating under calorie goal by a LOT, day after day after day- (eg 500 cal per day total with OR without exercise) and then eating **** like 1 KFC meal and that's it..... seriously!

Rinny_D

I was actually thinking about this topic earlier this morning. I think that a lot of people don't do research on the best ways to approach weight loss. The general thought process is less calories = weight loss. Many people don't think about the minimum their body needs to operate, and applaud themselves for barely eating anything, because that seems like the fastest way to get to their goals.

I understand that people's bodies function differently, and there are many different goals, but I agree that applauding someone who could be unintentionally sabotaging their goals or their health because of a lack of information, is not helpful.

VERY well said

Azuleelan

to answer your question, they lose weight because they eat less calories than what they burn.

simples!

But I thought that if you exercise a lot and don't eat any of the cals back and you end up with a low caloric intake total for the day and keep on doing this your body starts holding to every little thing you do eat and then it's hard to lose weight?

The point of having a deficit is to make you go into your fat reserves. Slowly but surely, your body does (faster the fatter you are). If you don't eat back your exercise calories, BUT make sure to eat a minimum of 1200 AND take enough protein (40%) then you are NOT going into starvation but are forcing your body to go into its fats reserves for all that exercise you did.
Most ppl seem to not understand that, I think because all their info comes only from this site.
BTW, this site is awesome, it's a great place to start, but for those who have a bit more knowledge, it has a couple of issues, like adding up those calories by default, and requiring you to eat too little protein.

Happy weigh loss

liyahxoxo

@ Azuleelan and naku:

ooh I see.
Thanks, it cleared this huge conflict for me.
I think that it's fair to say that each and every body is so different that what works wonders for one, does not work for the other. you just have to find what your body works best with- that right balance.

Mmmary212

kay I have a question. I'm not trying to be rude or anything, I actually am asking an innocent question:
I honestly DON'T understand how can some people never eat ANY of their exercise cals back and lose weight? this does not make sense to me. If I think about myself, personally, trying to do that:
a.the math behind it makes no sense (starvation mode, gradual slowing down of metabolism etc.) b. I would get so starved I would go absolutely maniac. Maybe I just have an abnormally large appetite and it's something wrong with me? I don't know..

I will answer for myself, and only myself.

It's not how much I eat....it's WHAT I eat....