We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

vegetable juice?

strapple
strapple Posts: 353 Member
edited September 2024 in Food and Nutrition
back in the past when i was thin i used to replace breakfast with a very tall glass of low sodium tomato juice and maybe a piece of fruit

and for lunch i would have a tall glass of carrot juice and celery with nonfat ranch

this seemed to work but i was also quite young (in my early teens)

is this something that could work for me now as an adult? or would i be depriving my body of many essential needs?

Replies

  • makena78
    makena78 Posts: 162 Member
    I know a V8 is full of sodium but, it is very healthy otherwise. I drink that sometimes as brunch. If you can make a vegetable drink from scratch it would be even better. It's just packed with nutrients and vitamins. I can't say about just plain tomato juice though.
  • DKBelle
    DKBelle Posts: 585
    Could work, but you still need to eat "normal food" meat. What I do is that when I finish my workout I drink one glass of blended fruit juice. I put in 1 banana because it has sugar and in this way I don't need to put extra sugar or honey in my shake :)
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    I know a V8 is full of sodium but, it is very healthy otherwise. I drink that sometimes as brunch. If you can make a vegetable drink from scratch it would be even better. It's just packed with nutrients and vitamins. I can't say about just plain tomato juice though.
    i always use low sodium v8 juice but i would totally make my own homemade if i knew it could replace a meal

    because i know a glass of vegetable juice fills me up

    but im afraid of stripping my body of other nutrients by replacing a meal with a liquid
  • I don't see why this wouldn't work! You may want to invest in a juicer... then you know what's going into it and you can make sure it isn't high in sodium and can control what nutrients you are getting! Just a thought!
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    Could work, but you still need to eat "normal food" meat. What I do is that when I finish my workout I drink one glass of blended fruit juice. I put in 1 banana because it has sugar and in this way I don't need to put extra sugar or honey in my shake :)
    eating meat is difficult for me because i have a medical intolerance to red meat and also have to keep kosher

    basically the only guilt free meats i can enjoy are white chicken and any form of fish

    so are you saying instead of replacing meals with juice, to drink it post work out instead of a snack?

    hmmm this seems like a good idea!
  • DKBelle
    DKBelle Posts: 585
    Exactly instead of eating snack you can drink juice. By the way I don't eat red meat neither, if I do it is only happening once in a very long while :) So you can find kosher chicken, turkey for sure, but you need protein! If you are not a big meat eater try to get your protein at least from milk, cheese!
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    Exactly instead of eating snack you can drink juice. By the way I don't eat red meat neither, if I do it is only happening once in a very long while :) So you can find kosher chicken, turkey for sure, but you need protein! If you are not a big meat eater try to get your protein at least from milk, cheese!
    LOL im lactose intolerant!! xD

    i literally think god just hates me and didnt want me to eat anything ever hahahha

    i try to get protein from spinach and beans, and of course white meat like chicken and fish

    the only red meat ill touch is beef and thats like once in a blue moon
  • DKBelle
    DKBelle Posts: 585
    :) I don't think anyone hates you! Yes beans has the most I think although I am not into these :P Main thing try to keep balance. There are ham made out of turkey and chicken so just make a sandwich at least out of it with veggies and bit of butter :)
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    ooooh yes i love turkey ham and veggies :}
  • lodro
    lodro Posts: 982 Member
    You may want to invest in a juicer for vegetables, that way you can blend your own and use the pulp to add to ommelettes for instance, that way you get some of the fiber too. You can also make little vegetable pancakes with them, with some egg and a little flour to bind them.

    A good juicer expresses all nutrients that are in the plant. Drinking fruit juice is a waste of a good fruit in my opinion, better eat them whole.

    Spinach doesn't contain protein.
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    You may want to invest in a juicer for vegetables, that way you can blend your own and use the pulp to add to ommelettes for instance, that way you get some of the fiber too. You can also make little vegetable pancakes with them, with some egg and a little flour to bind them.

    A good juicer expresses all nutrients that are in the plant. Drinking fruit juice is a waste of a good fruit in my opinion, better eat them whole.

    Spinach doesn't contain protein.
    omg i never thought of adding pulp to egg white omelets! i usually just throw it out! ty this is such solid advice :}
  • lodro
    lodro Posts: 982 Member
    I even juice parsley, and some sauerkraut to add to half a cucumber and a couple of tomatoes

    I use this one:

    http://www.nutritionlifestyles.com/zstarjuicer.htm

    Seems expensive, but it is very well made, so should last you a lifetime and is very, very easy to clean and that, for me, was the most important thing. Plus I wanted to be able to take it with me.

    With a slow turning juicer you are sure to get all the nutrients from vegetables. You can juice fruits too (although i wouldn't juice a banana with it)
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    i dont like fruit so id feel no need to put a banana into my juices

    but i really will look into a personal juicer based on this thread!

    ty for all the wonderful advice! :}
  • GypsyWagon
    GypsyWagon Posts: 82 Member
    Do you eat tofu? You could blend some silken tofu in with the juice for protein.
  • strapple
    strapple Posts: 353 Member
    Do you eat tofu? You could blend some silken tofu in with the juice for protein.
    oh great idea!
This discussion has been closed.