Muscle vs Fat

dragonflydi
dragonflydi Posts: 665 Member
edited September 27 in Fitness and Exercise
Testing to see if I figured out how to post a photo by giving a visual of what 5 lbs of fat vs. 5 lbs of lean muscle look like.

I've seen a lot of people debate on here that 5 lbs is 5 lbs and that muscle doesn't weigh more than fat. This is very true. The 'gist' of what is being discussed however, is that muscle is much more dense than fat so while they weigh the same, the amount of space they take up is considerably different.

I ran across this image that helps demonstrate what people are talking about for those who are visual learners like myself. This is a replica of 5 lbs of lean muscle vs. 5 lbs of fat. While they weigh the same, the amount of space they take up (and the overall shape) is drastically different, which helps to show why two people who are the same height and weigh the same can look totally different, wear different size clothes, etc.. The one whose body composition is primarily muscle will be smaller and more fit while the one with a body composition that is higher in fat will larger and more lumpy, regardless that they weigh the same … just like these photos.

The pic is on here on another board, but I hope I figured out how to add it here ...

5lbs.jpg?t=1305056790

Replies

  • dragonflydi
    dragonflydi Posts: 665 Member
    Testing to see if I figured out how to post a photo by giving a visual of what 5 lbs of fat vs. 5 lbs of lean muscle look like.

    I've seen a lot of people debate on here that 5 lbs is 5 lbs and that muscle doesn't weigh more than fat. This is very true. The 'gist' of what is being discussed however, is that muscle is much more dense than fat so while they weigh the same, the amount of space they take up is considerably different.

    I ran across this image that helps demonstrate what people are talking about for those who are visual learners like myself. This is a replica of 5 lbs of lean muscle vs. 5 lbs of fat. While they weigh the same, the amount of space they take up (and the overall shape) is drastically different, which helps to show why two people who are the same height and weigh the same can look totally different, wear different size clothes, etc.. The one whose body composition is primarily muscle will be smaller and more fit while the one with a body composition that is higher in fat will larger and more lumpy, regardless that they weigh the same … just like these photos.

    The pic is on here on another board, but I hope I figured out how to add it here ...

    5lbs.jpg

    Seems I still have work to do since the photo is still there and it's not being recognized :(
  • TrainingWithTonya
    TrainingWithTonya Posts: 1,741 Member
    Is this the pic you're trying to post?

    fat-v-muscle3.jpg

    From Photobucket, you have to copy the IMG code, but then change the IMG to img at both ends of the code. I don't know why MFP doesn't recognize the same letters just capitalized.
  • dragonflydi
    dragonflydi Posts: 665 Member
    Is this the pic you're trying to post?

    fat-v-muscle3.jpg

    From Photobucket, you have to copy the IMG code, but then change the IMG to img at both ends of the code. I don't know why MFP doesn't recognize the same letters just capitalized.
    It is ... moreso just to figure out how to post a pic and while I've copied the instructions everyone has given me and my photo is in my album on photobucket, it won't work :(

    6044994_7006_thumb.jpg ... that link is from my profile, maybe that one will work?
  • dragonflydi
    dragonflydi Posts: 665 Member
    Is this the pic you're trying to post?

    fat-v-muscle3.jpg

    From Photobucket, you have to copy the IMG code, but then change the IMG to img at both ends of the code. I don't know why MFP doesn't recognize the same letters just capitalized.
    It is ... moreso just to figure out how to post a pic and while I've copied the instructions everyone has given me and my photo is in my album on photobucket, it won't work :(

    6044994_7006_thumb.jpg ... that link is from my profile, maybe that one will work?

    Hmmm can't do it from photo bucket, but I can from my profile doing the same stupid thing? Go figure ...
This discussion has been closed.