GAH!!!!! James is off Idol? No way!!! so depressed

c2sky

Any idol fans out there? I never cared. I don't even have a t.v. but when I found out that Stefano went to my former neighborhood high school, I had to check it out on line. Then I discovered James. I was so instantly in love with everything about him. I'm so shocked he is gone. No way!

So sad, I can't eat.

And please don't tell me how great Haley is. She growled way too much, and she is sooooo arrogant.

taylor1098

I agree! James was so talented. Haley is awful and should have gone in week one in my opinion, In my opinion it should have been James, Scotty, and Lauren.

picturesing

Any idol fans out there? I never cared. I don't even have a t.v. but when I found out that Stefano went to my former neighborhood high school, I had to check it out on line. Then I discovered James. I was so instantly in love with everything about him. I'm so shocked he is gone. No way!

So sad, I can't eat.

And please don't tell me how great Haley is. She growled way too much, and she is sooooo arrogant.

REALLY!!!!! I'm on the West Coast!!!! Guess I won't have to bother watching NOW. Didn't have a clue I'd see that here...I was avoiding FB so I didn't "find out"......

lharr56

America got it wrong There is no way that James should have got sent home Haley needs to go next definitely Bummer

caterpillar2Butterfly

Im so sad to, but remember its usally the ones that dont win it that makes it big..

austepants

I agree! James was so talented. Haley is awful and should have gone in week one in my opinion, In my opinion it should have been James, Scotty, and Lauren.

I agree!!!

BirdsofaFeather

I agree with both of you!!! James!!! Though, I loved Casey, too

megansmom311

I really wanted to see James singing with Steven Tyler in the finale. What a letdown! :frown:

michelleisgettinfit

I know I can't believe it... I found out from a spoiler too... should have known better than to be on FB before I watched it. James should definetely NOT have gone home and Haley should have been gone a LONG time ago!

Aeriel

Any idol fans out there? I never cared. I don't even have a t.v. but when I found out that Stefano went to my former neighborhood high school, I had to check it out on line. Then I discovered James. I was so instantly in love with everything about him. I'm so shocked he is gone. No way!

So sad, I can't eat.

And please don't tell me how great Haley is. She growled way too much, and she is sooooo arrogant.

REALLY!!!!! I'm on the West Coast!!!! Guess I won't have to bother watching NOW. Didn't have a clue I'd see that here...I was avoiding FB so I didn't "find out"......

Unfortunately, people don't think about time zones. Too bad that it ruins it for those on the later time zones.

crjugrl

And please don't tell me how great Haley is. She growled way too much, and she is sooooo arrogant.

THANK YOU. Especially to the arrogant part. That girl can't take criticism at all.

Konpeito

Well I WAS going to watch the results...-_-;

PJilly

Crap! I was just killing time during Idol commercials, and now I know how it ends. :sad:

c2sky

Any idol fans out there? I never cared. I don't even have a t.v. but when I found out that Stefano went to my former neighborhood high school, I had to check it out on line. Then I discovered James. I was so instantly in love with everything about him. I'm so shocked he is gone. No way!

So sad, I can't eat.

And please don't tell me how great Haley is. She growled way too much, and she is sooooo arrogant.

REALLY!!!!! I'm on the West Coast!!!! Guess I won't have to bother watching NOW. Didn't have a clue I'd see that here...I was avoiding FB so I didn't "find out"......

oops sorry!!!!!!!!! i'm on the west coast too, but I don't have a t.v. so I looked it up on line.

paulasue75

oh shoot! i'm on the west coast and the show isn't over yet! What a shock! i was thinking it was gonna be haley for sure! I love james....but, Scotty is my man!

c2sky

so sorry guys. I vented here because I didn't want to spoil it on facebook. sorry....really.

I guess it's my shock that overcame my good sense to wait. But GAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! so shocked!!!!!!!!!!

jabbogurl

I really, really thought Haley was going home. I can't stand her and couldn't picture her on the radio, she'd be like another Ruben or that old gray haired guy that won, if she won. James always gets great feedback from the judges and the judges even said Haley sucked. So sad. But I think that James will still get a deal of some kind, both J-Low and Steven love him, so maybe they'll pull some connections.

paulasue75

It's ok! i'm just sad he's gone. i was really hoping it was haley this time! i really thought he was gonna win!

laydeeworeblak

I'm so mad James got voted off! I can't stand Haley. She growls way too much!

PJilly

I love James, but I had a funny feeling he'd be leaving tonight. I predict Lauren will win the whole thing.

paulasue75

I can't stand Haley either! and she had such a horrid ''don't you tell me i did bad'' look on her face last night! Dang! I never liked her singing! ever! ......James will still have a career! for sure!!!

cpanzeri

Loved James!!! However, I love Scotty and Lauren a tad more!! But Hayley... Really?? She should have been gone!!! I think James will get a deal regardless!!

Debbiebear04

I wanted James to win so bad!! I am very upset he was voting off before Hayley!! I was NOT impressed with her attitude and personality last night!!! I was hoping she would be voted off tonight! Now I hope Lauren wins it all!!!!

tat2tinkerbell

I'm in the central time zone and never watch results shows, I always wait for them to be over and know who is going to be voted off before I watch. I get too anxious lol. So tonight I turned in just to see the end of the show and saw it happen, broke my heart. I honestly was beginning to think he would win it. I like Scotty but I think he needs to go, Hailey does a lot of growling, and Lauren I love her, she can do no wrong in my eyes lol. If James is gone, I want Lauren to win.

Sorry some of you guys got your show ruined, but you can enjoy the performances without worrying during Ryan's suspense building bits (trying to find something positive lol).

sassiebritches

Poop....I was waitin all day for the AI show tonight.....Oh well, watched it with the hubby anyway ;/

LuckyLeprechaun

Ugh. So irritated over this. I love James. Pia and Casey should ha e lasted longer too. Now it's sort of obvious that Lauren will win. She's the next Carrie underwood.


Grrrrrr I'm so mad at idol right now. Haley should have been the one tonight or even Scotty. But not my baby pie James !!!!!!

almarsala

I seriously don't understand all the Haley hate. She's amazing and I haven't seen a single arrogant action from her. But I'm mostly pissed everyone spoiled that James went home. I love him!

nannyciriaco

I am an Idol fan, watch every season....I was totally shocked tonight I was convinced that he would win the whole tamale this year..Oh and I won't say how good Haley is, I don't like here...I actually expected it to be down to Scotty and James in the finale...But I truely believe that James will do very good in the music industry, I like him way better than Adam Lambert and he is doing really well...James' dream of making a better life for his family will come true...

c2sky

I seriously don't understand all the Haley hate. She's amazing and I haven't seen a single arrogant action from her. But I'm mostly pissed everyone spoiled that James went home. I love him!

for the third time. I am sorry. I didn't think people watching the show would be on here. FB maybe but not here. Well, I'm new. But I do feel Haley was arrogant. She certainly was last night. And when they announced who was staying, she never seemed happy, grateful or surprised, just kind of, "well of course."

Again, please understand, I have NEVER cared about this show. I only watched it because of the Stefano connection. But I was so impressed with James. And when I found out he had high functioning autism as well, that drew me even more to him. I have a 20 year old autistic son, who also performs. And he is a different person when he performs. He learned music in the 6th grade, when I introduced him to the drums. I never saw him be truly happy, until then. Then he learned to sing, play the piano, and act. So I admit, I had a motherly love for James, as well as a musical appreciation. I sing myself too. I will sincerely miss him. I hope he makes it at least as big as Jennifer Hudson did.

k2d4p

WHY WOULD YOU PUT THAT IN THE TITLE!! Some of us live in other countries and the results show has not aired yet. Thanks for ruining it for me. Jeez.... You could have put "spoiler" or something.

c2sky

WHY WOULD YOU PUT THAT IN THE TITLE!! Some of us live in other countries and the results show has not aired yet. Thanks for ruining it for me. Jeez.... You could have put "spoiler" or something.

o.k. apology #4......I'm sorry. Have you read my other apologies?
Anybody else want to holler at me?