Way over on sugar but under on calories?

Is the MFP sugar limit just a suggestion? I didn't use to track it in my diary, but recently added sugar and sodium. I will be at or under my calories for the day, but have blown way past sugar. And it's just from fruit. Do I need to address this to move forward with weight loss? I don't really want to give up fruit because of the health benefits and I'm not overeating on calories in general.
Thanks for letting me know what you think!

Replies

liveyourlifex

MFP's limit is too low, i think
i went on another website to see my daily recommendations for calorie intake and sugar intake, and the sugar was realllllly low on MFP. that website suggested me to eat around 60 g of sugar but on MFP, it suggests around 35?
plus, fruit has good kind of sugar, so dont worry about it!

jasmin1310

I'm in a similar boat and would like to know... so bump.

toez79

Yeah my MFP limit is 24, and I easily exceed that with just a couple pieces of fruit. Thanks for the response!

sharidiane

I have the same issue, and I have been wondering the same thing. I go waaaaay over on sugar, but if I just stop and just subtract out the sugar from fruit, I am way under.

o_O

angechilada

It's a suggestion, but it's based on research. Even though fruit does have vitamins, consuming lots of fruit isn't beneficial for losing weight because SUGAR is still SUGAR. If you want the "health benefits", just eat green vegetables, and keep fruit to a minimum. Berries (for the most part) have the least amount of sugar per serving. Also, eating sugar/simple carbs makes your blood sugar spike and then drop, which gives you the sensation of feeling hungry. That's probably why they recommend a certain level of sugar.

mlb929

I quit tracking my sugars on MFP because it doesn't break down fruit vs a marshmallow. The way they hit on the glycemic index is still high - but I know I'm making a better choice with an apple or orange vs a cookie or marshmallow. So without being able to tell the difference between natural and processed, I opted out of trackng sugar as it just frustrated me. I'm careful about my food choices but shouldn't feel guilty about having an apple daily that pushes me over.

angechilada

lol at "fruit has the good kind of sugar". That is complete bull****. Just saying. Your body might use the sugar beneficially if you have a moderate amount before/after a workout, but having tons of fruit on a day where you're doing no physical activity is almost as bad as eating candy. Vitamin and fiber-infused candy.

MamaByGrace8

Thanks for bringing this topic up. I need to address this in my own diet. :-/

sunshine__angel

Fruits are high in natural sugars, which often makes the sugar content in our diets look off the charts. However, you don't really have to worry about them, it's only additive sugars that you should be steering clear from. If you can try and spread your fruits out throughout the day, you should be fine. Right now I am eating 2 fruits a day, but I don't think the sugars from any amount will really make or break your diet/lifestyle change.

DebbieHarryxxx

I took that out of my daily intakes...the -80 or so was annoying!! haha - i love fruit, and since taking it off it has done me no harm what so ever, if i had a banana and an apple in one day it would go wayyy over, it really frustrated me! i took it off and have no regrets (she types munching a pear lol!)

toez79

Haha I was thinking about just taking it back out.

Another side to the question - is it bad to be getting way more fiber than your MFP suggestion? It's the same thing, I get a ton of fiber in my allowed calories, and I assume it can't be a bad thing.

JLervold86

Well put Angechilada! I always though that fruit sugar and processed sugar were different and didn't really pay attention...then realized I wasn't losing weight. I started cutting down my sugar to the recommended 32g a day (plus if I earn any back) and shed 4 pounds in 4 weeks (I'm looking to shed that last 10 pounds, well 5 now LOL). Sugar makes a HUGE difference and turns straight to fat, even if there are some vitamins that come along with it. I still go over about once a week (I need dessert with my cheat meal) but overall I keep that number LOW! If you can it'll make a huge difference

)

Missylydia

nah your body handles natural sugars in fruit (combined with fibre) waaaay differently to unnatural added fructose in a chocolate bar (for example)

eating4balance

It's okay to be over on natural sugars like in fruits and vegetables, but added sugars like in yogurt, instant oatmeal, protein bars and cereals are where you have to watch.

allisoncook87

I quit tracking my sugars on MFP because it doesn't break down fruit vs a marshmallow. The way they hit on the glycemic index is still high - but I know I'm making a better choice with an apple or orange vs a cookie or marshmallow. So without being able to tell the difference between natural and processed, I opted out of trackng sugar as it just frustrated me. I'm careful about my food choices but shouldn't feel guilty about having an apple daily that pushes me over.

I'm with you, As long as it's fruit and not junk. Just don't get completely outta control and only eat fruit all day. Natural sugar is a good thing

wg2011

You are correct. Your facts are right on target. Cut carbs aand sugars to see weight go down then work on what needs to be done to maintain, by adding small amounts of each. unfortunate most people suffer at weight control because they either dont understand the effect of sugar or are being misinformed.

angechilada

The actual recommended amount of fiber for women is something like 25g…I think MFP has it much lower. Fiber is good because it can make you feel full and also helps with regular…movements. Hahaha. So yes, but getting too much fiber can have the opposite effect. Most people don't consume that much fiber on a daily basis so it probably shouldn't be an issue.

poustotah

lol at "fruit has the good kind of sugar". That is complete bull****. Just saying. Your body might use the sugar beneficially if you have a moderate amount before/after a workout, but having tons of fruit on a day where you're doing no physical activity is almost as bad as eating candy. Vitamin and fiber-infused candy.

YAY!!!

misslissa555

I have this problem too. MFP says I can have 24g of sugar a day. That is nothing! I just went from being vegeterian for 15 years to being a vegan (was sick of not losing weight from eating dairy--I loveeeeeeeeeed cheese). I was vegan before for 30 days for a contest at work and lost 16 lbs. Anywho, I need fruits and veggies in my life. Doesn't the food pyramid say to eat like 5 fruits/day? I'm confused now.

toez79

Yeah MFP has my fiber at 14 grams, which I think is too low. Depending on my food that day, I end up closer to 30-40. But anytime I have lowered fiber or tried to cut carbs, I always gain weight. Fiber helps keep me moving and losing, I've noticed. And I try to get most of my fiber from fruits and veggies anyway.
Did you know a pint of raspberries has 20 grams of fiber!?!?

ylenija

I think that if you are willing to lose body fat, you should definitely limit the amount of carbohydrate in general. The sugars (inside the carbs) increase your insulin production and makes the muscle burn them instead of burning the fat. Insulin also inhibits the activity of your HDL that breaks down the triglycerides into fatty acids that would go in your bloodstream to be burned. Furthermore the LDL activity of storing fat in the fat cells is increased when insulin is present.
That said, I think that to burn your fat, you should definitely limit the amount of sugars...and that probably keeping it as low as suggested might not even be enough for some insulin resistant people...of course do not forget that fruit contains a lot of fiber that can be subtracted from the total amount of carbs and that the sugar contained in fruit is partially fructose whose release is slower and doesn't cause the insulin spike.

This might sound kind of controversial, but I am personally trying this approach and a lot of people I know are as well, with very good results. I try to eat as low carbs as possible, eating everything else without limits (I get full very easily with this approach and never starve), I am losing fat, my blood is completely healthy, I exercise and I have a lot of energies and I sleep like I never did. Of course my suggestion is a lifetime change in the eating habit and it seems to work...

I hope I did not bored you. Have a good day!

MayhemModels

high-fibrous fruit/ Apples, Berries, Pears, Any kind of fresh or frozen berries, Grapefruit, Strawberries, Kiwis, Oranges, Cherries, Apricots, papaya, prunes,

irridia

I think that if you are willing to lose body fat, you should definitely limit the amount of carbohydrate in general. The sugars (inside the carbs) increase your insulin production and makes the muscle burn them instead of burning the fat. Insulin also inhibits the activity of your HDL that breaks down the triglycerides into fatty acids that would go in your bloodstream to be burned. Furthermore the LDL activity of storing fat in the fat cells is increased when insulin is present.
That said, I think that to burn your fat, you should definitely limit the amount of sugars...and that probably keeping it as low as suggested might not even be enough for some insulin resistant people...of course do not forget that fruit contains a lot of fiber that can be subtracted from the total amount of carbs and that the sugar contained in fruit is partially fructose whose release is slower and doesn't cause the insulin spike.

This might sound kind of controversial, but I am personally trying this approach and a lot of people I know are as well, with very good results. I try to eat as low carbs as possible, eating everything else without limits (I get full very easily with this approach and never starve), I am losing fat, my blood is completely healthy, I exercise and I have a lot of energies and I sleep like I never did. Of course my suggestion is a lifetime change in the eating habit and it seems to work...

I hope I did not bored you. Have a good day!

I'm going to start this keeping my carbs to around 100g/day tomorrow. My hope is that I end up with better HDL numbers and better fasting glucose numbers. giving up my bread & fruit will be hard...*sigh*

ylenija

I know...it has been kind of hard for me at the beginning (consider that I am Italian and for us flour is everywhere!), but after a few days without carbs (and insulin), the cells in your body actually learn that they won't be able to be fed by sugars any more, so they will start burning fat instead and you won't have the usual cravings for sweets and breads. Furthermore by eating fibers, protein and fats mostly, you won't feel hungry that much...you can only get benefits by shifting to this eating approach.