My rant about the MFP community.
summalovaable
Posts: 287 Member
Let me begin by giving you a little back round information about myself:
I'm 18 years old
I have low thyroid(aka the ultimate weight loss inhibitor)
My mothers a dietitian so I've been hearing about healthy choice my entire life
I'm currently attending university to also become a dietitian.
I've lost over 25 lbs within the last year( keeping in mind the whole thyroid issue... not an easy task).
Before i continue remember this is a rant, so you'll probably notice a slight hypocrisy with what I'm saying but I feel like i've kept this comment in too long. Also, before i begin this does not apply to ALL my fitness pal members, i've noticed many very nice helpful and encouraging people and i think that for anyone beginning a weight loss journey this website is great for assistance.
But that right there is the kicker: ITS FOR ASSISTANCE. It is one thing to post your opinion, but an entirely different thing to argue it. I've watched many times people argue a fact that is entirely WRONG, but people continue to insist they're right. I think the issue is this: many people can lose weight, weigh loss is not hard or complicated but not many people can keep it off. Everyone here seems to believe they've got the answer, well guess what? Most of you don't. Do you really think cutting carbs is a life long plan? My mother made me sandwiches every day for lunch for two reasons:
1. Carbs are not as awful as every believes, THEY didn't make me gain weight.
2. They fill you up, so I wasn't hungry 10 minutes later.
Don't get me wrong, i wasn't eating ten slices of bread a day, we were able to PORTION control our meals. We ate all our fruits and veggies, and had a sufficient amount of meat. But we also did this thing called excercise. When i was old enough i joined a gym so my parents, brother and I did work out as a family, but we also went OUTSIDE. Enjoyed long walks, and bike rides. We gardened like it was our day job (because my parents need that award winning land scape). We cleaned the house daily and kept BUSY. And when the day was out, we enjoyed a delicious home cooked meal made by my mother. She knew we were hungry so she FED us.. didn't starve us with small amounts of veggies, but gave us VARIETY in each meal. No, we didn't eat dessert every day but I was not deprived a little ice cream when i really wanted it, or even some cookies and milk if I behaved all day.
You're probably wondering how if we were living such a healthy lifestyle i managed to put on so much weight right? Well at about 15 or so i was diagnosed with my thyroid condition, I was putting on a lot of weight and it seemed like it would never stop. For those of you who don't really understand a thyroid condition: It essentially means I have the world's worst metabolism, everything converts to fat if im not careful, it doesnt break down all those extra calories. This also means that there is a long list of foods i'm especially supposed to avoid because my body doesn't break them down as well. Refined sugars and even some typed of vegetables is on that list, but i've learned to ignore it and it has worked just fine so far.
I'm not sure many people have made it to the bottom of this post, but please remember weight loss is not complicated, neither is maintaining. Eat right, excercise regularly but also live a little. Also remember this: every piece of advice you get on here is just an opinion. There is very little fact as to whether or not it will work for YOU. if you want to lose weight listen to your body. Eat when your hungry and stop when your not. Give into your sweet tooth once in awhile, and don't go over board on the foods you've always known were bad for you.
I know nothing i've said is new information... but it sure feeels good to get it all out.
I'm 18 years old
I have low thyroid(aka the ultimate weight loss inhibitor)
My mothers a dietitian so I've been hearing about healthy choice my entire life
I'm currently attending university to also become a dietitian.
I've lost over 25 lbs within the last year( keeping in mind the whole thyroid issue... not an easy task).
Before i continue remember this is a rant, so you'll probably notice a slight hypocrisy with what I'm saying but I feel like i've kept this comment in too long. Also, before i begin this does not apply to ALL my fitness pal members, i've noticed many very nice helpful and encouraging people and i think that for anyone beginning a weight loss journey this website is great for assistance.
But that right there is the kicker: ITS FOR ASSISTANCE. It is one thing to post your opinion, but an entirely different thing to argue it. I've watched many times people argue a fact that is entirely WRONG, but people continue to insist they're right. I think the issue is this: many people can lose weight, weigh loss is not hard or complicated but not many people can keep it off. Everyone here seems to believe they've got the answer, well guess what? Most of you don't. Do you really think cutting carbs is a life long plan? My mother made me sandwiches every day for lunch for two reasons:
1. Carbs are not as awful as every believes, THEY didn't make me gain weight.
2. They fill you up, so I wasn't hungry 10 minutes later.
Don't get me wrong, i wasn't eating ten slices of bread a day, we were able to PORTION control our meals. We ate all our fruits and veggies, and had a sufficient amount of meat. But we also did this thing called excercise. When i was old enough i joined a gym so my parents, brother and I did work out as a family, but we also went OUTSIDE. Enjoyed long walks, and bike rides. We gardened like it was our day job (because my parents need that award winning land scape). We cleaned the house daily and kept BUSY. And when the day was out, we enjoyed a delicious home cooked meal made by my mother. She knew we were hungry so she FED us.. didn't starve us with small amounts of veggies, but gave us VARIETY in each meal. No, we didn't eat dessert every day but I was not deprived a little ice cream when i really wanted it, or even some cookies and milk if I behaved all day.
You're probably wondering how if we were living such a healthy lifestyle i managed to put on so much weight right? Well at about 15 or so i was diagnosed with my thyroid condition, I was putting on a lot of weight and it seemed like it would never stop. For those of you who don't really understand a thyroid condition: It essentially means I have the world's worst metabolism, everything converts to fat if im not careful, it doesnt break down all those extra calories. This also means that there is a long list of foods i'm especially supposed to avoid because my body doesn't break them down as well. Refined sugars and even some typed of vegetables is on that list, but i've learned to ignore it and it has worked just fine so far.
I'm not sure many people have made it to the bottom of this post, but please remember weight loss is not complicated, neither is maintaining. Eat right, excercise regularly but also live a little. Also remember this: every piece of advice you get on here is just an opinion. There is very little fact as to whether or not it will work for YOU. if you want to lose weight listen to your body. Eat when your hungry and stop when your not. Give into your sweet tooth once in awhile, and don't go over board on the foods you've always known were bad for you.
I know nothing i've said is new information... but it sure feeels good to get it all out.
0
Replies
-
Carbs = whole grains = delicious, tasty, filling nutrition.0
-
Well said! I don't read many long posts, but for some reason I couldn't stop reading this one.0
-
I dont really get the no carb thing, when did they become the enemy? Surely everything in moderation. I have noticed people seem to do the no carb as a quick fix and it rarely stays off. Although I am sure if its done right it works.0
-
I love this post. Well stated!0
-
My mother is an RN and I grew up with the exact same diet. We also spent everyday outside if it was nice, doing our chores first and then playing. I enjoyed your rant--and I made it to the bottom! LOL :laugh:0
-
Let me begin by giving you a little back round information about myself:
I'm 18 years old
I have low thyroid(aka the ultimate weight loss inhibitor)
My mothers a dietitian so I've been hearing about healthy choice my entire life
I'm currently attending university to also become a dietitian.
I've lost over 25 lbs within the last year( keeping in mind the whole thyroid issue... not an easy task).
Before i continue remember this is a rant, so you'll probably notice a slight hypocrisy with what I'm saying but I feel like i've kept this comment in too long. Also, before i begin this does not apply to ALL my fitness pal members, i've noticed many very nice helpful and encouraging people and i think that for anyone beginning a weight loss journey this website is great for assistance.
But that right there is the kicker: ITS FOR ASSISTANCE. It is one thing to post your opinion, but an entirely different thing to argue it. I've watched many times people argue a fact that is entirely WRONG, but people continue to insist they're right. I think the issue is this: many people can lose weight, weigh loss is not hard or complicated but not many people can keep it off. Everyone here seems to believe they've got the answer, well guess what? Most of you don't. Do you really think cutting carbs is a life long plan? My mother made me sandwiches every day for lunch for two reasons:
1. Carbs are not as awful as every believes, THEY didn't make me gain weight.
2. They fill you up, so I wasn't hungry 10 minutes later.
Don't get me wrong, i wasn't eating ten slices of bread a day, we were able to PORTION control our meals. We ate all our fruits and veggies, and had a sufficient amount of meat. But we also did this thing called excercise. When i was old enough i joined a gym so my parents, brother and I did work out as a family, but we also went OUTSIDE. Enjoyed long walks, and bike rides. We gardened like it was our day job (because my parents need that award winning land scape). We cleaned the house daily and kept BUSY. And when the day was out, we enjoyed a delicious home cooked meal made by my mother. She knew we were hungry so she FED us.. didn't starve us with small amounts of veggies, but gave us VARIETY in each meal. No, we didn't eat dessert every day but I was not deprived a little ice cream when i really wanted it, or even some cookies and milk if I behaved all day.
You're probably wondering how if we were living such a healthy lifestyle i managed to put on so much weight right? Well at about 15 or so i was diagnosed with my thyroid condition, I was putting on a lot of weight and it seemed like it would never stop. For those of you who don't really understand a thyroid condition: It essentially means I have the world's worst metabolism, everything converts to fat if im not careful, it doesnt break down all those extra calories. This also means that there is a long list of foods i'm especially supposed to avoid because my body doesn't break them down as well. Refined sugars and even some typed of vegetables is on that list, but i've learned to ignore it and it has worked just fine so far.
I'm not sure many people have made it to the bottom of this post, but please remember weight loss is not complicated, neither is maintaining. Eat right, excercise regularly but also live a little. Also remember this: every piece of advice you get on here is just an opinion. There is very little fact as to whether or not it will work for YOU. if you want to lose weight listen to your body. Eat when your hungry and stop when your not. Give into your sweet tooth once in awhile, and don't go over board on the foods you've always known were bad for you.
I know nothing i've said is new information... but it sure feeels good to get it all out.
Great post..Thank you for sharing....double bump0 -
Agreed there are people here who think they have their MDs or Degree in nutrition or somthing.0
-
i love carbs, and could never give them up or sugars. Supposedly it is more addictive then cocaine I also agree that losing weight is actually easy, but keeping it off is the hard part. I know I've done it, lost lots and gained back over time.
But I disagree with your sandwich theory, i'm starving to death after a sandwich. I know not the point of your post:flowerforyou: I've never been able to explain it. :huh:0 -
I loved this post and I love your positive approach despite the fact that you are in a less fortunate position than most. Good luck with your own weight loss and maintaining a healthy lifestyle.
Opinions are like arseholes, everybody has one. It's always good to remember that.
0 -
Awesome post!0
-
Didn't sound like a rant to me sounded like good advice and TRUTH. I read a post the other day I think you would have loved. It was along the same lines. Good nutrition and exercise is the ONLY way to lose weight and keep it off. It is a lifestyle not some 4, 8, 10 week program that you join, lose some weight, go off of and then put the weight back on. People spend too much time looking for an easy way when the easy way is right in front of them. Eat right and exercise, it's that simple.0
-
My mother is an RN and I grew up with the exact same diet. We also spent everyday outside if it was nice, doing our chores first and then playing. I enjoyed your rant--and I made it to the bottom! LOL :laugh:
agree entirely! right down to the mother is an RN thing.
0 -
I made it to the bottom!!
Right on!!!!0 -
I love carbs, I seem to have lost some weight...lol! I also know about the thyroid, my daughter was diagnose when she was 7 and she is now 15. She has a weight problem, and Im trying to help her as much as I can. I dont come on here thinking I know everything, cause I dont. I know what works and dont and I find myself stump from time to time but I know it takes committment and motivation is number one.0
-
Yes. Everyone needs to read this post. 0 -
Yes, exercise and nutrition are important and your post was dead on, but if that was it, there would be no obesity epidemic. There is something called compulsive eating that is usually the reason for most people carrying around an extra 100 or so pounds. Telling them to eat right and exercise doesn't help, there is definitely a mental component to it as well, so although I like your common sense approach, I think it should be said.0
-
That's good common sense. On this site some people believe that "you aren't hungry because you're brain isn't getting the proper signals so you have to eat more."
I believe the same thing you do, if you're hungry eat, if you're not don't, not hard. Just so everyone knows... a low calorie diet over a long time impairs the thyroid, so does a low carb diet over time.0 -
My mother is an RN and I grew up with the exact same diet. We also spent everyday outside if it was nice, doing our chores first and then playing. I enjoyed your rant--and I made it to the bottom! LOL :laugh:
agree entirely! right down to the mother is an RN thing.
Ditto!
I have had hypothyroidism since 18 months old so I know how hard it is to lose weight with it. I also have PCOS and for 2 years my body wouldn't let me lose any weight no matter what I did. Now that I am doing things differently though things are easier and it is from eating BALANCED meals like I had when I was a kid. Carbs are not the enemy. They give you energy and make you feel fuller longer. I just watch the ones I eat because my doctor has me on a low glycemic Index plan so I eat the ones lower on the scale, like whole grains and pasta that is low on the glycemic index. most of mine come from fruits and veggies.0 -
Yay! Love this.0
-
Well i didn't post this on the mcdonalds website. I posted it on a website for people looking to lose weight. I just want to see healthier weight loss advice, not such extreme measures. Although my mother may be a dietitian MANY of her siblings are severely obese, and regardless of what she's tried to do to help they don't want it. I'm fully aware that not every one will lose weight quite so simply for one reason: not every one has the motivation or wants to LISTEN. I've been a tutor since i was in the ninth grade (though this doesn't have to do with weightloss) i've noticed that many people have the ability to do math, but not many people have the motivation to excel at it. I believe this is true for weight loss as well. Its just as simple as "its all in your head." believe me i know the struggles of wanting to eat a little more then you should, and the mental struggle you have when you eat what you shouldn't then feel disgusted with yourself after. Maybe i should have stated that a little more clearly, and you're absolutely right. But i am just sharing my own personal story/opinion, and while it has worked for me it won't work for everyone.. every rule has an exception.0
-
love your post! wise for only 18 years... keep up the great work you are doing.0
-
I am glad you did post! like many things in life, humanity can make it very very complicated. Thank you for posting this.0
-
Hmmm.. I have hypothyroidism too and I didn't know there was foods I should avoid. Learn something new everyday.0
-
I love this! I have hypothyroidism as well, and It's soo hard to lose weight! Great post! Thank you for sharing!0
-
Well said! And guess what? I LOVE carbs. I eat carbs everyday. I even snack. And I've still lost weight. People need to stop depriving themselves and learn to live!0
-
great post!!! very well said!0
-
"Do you really think cutting carbs is a life long plan? "
Yes, I do.
I honestly don't know why you felt the need to single out low carb dieting in your rant. If you and your mom don't think its right for you, I could care less, that is your decision. However, there are plenty of people on these forums following all manner of diet plans who feel strongly about what they are doing and post their strong opinions here. They can't all be right but I didn't see you focusing any attention on them in your rant. Why not?
Finally, did you ever consider that maybe you and your mom are wrong? I'm not saying everyone should do a low carb diet, but on the other hand I can see no reason to sit idly by and let your post go unchallenged.0 -
It wasn't a rant it was just an advise. Great post.0
-
Great post. For the most part, I've gotten the same advice from MFP.0
-
"Do you really think cutting carbs is a life long plan? "
Yes, I do.
I honestly don't know why you felt the need to single out low carb dieting in your rant. If you and your mom don't think its right for you, I could care less, that is your decision. However, there are plenty of people on these forums following all manner of diet plans who feel strongly about what they are doing and post their strong opinions here. They can't all be right but I didn't see you focusing any attention on them in your rant. Why not?
Finally, did you ever consider that maybe you and your mom are wrong? I'm not saying everyone should do a low carb diet, but on the other hand I can see no reason to sit idly by and let your post go unchallenged.
Smiling because I have to agree with you. Yes there are plenty of aternate carbohydrates out there for people with celiacs and gluten intolerances but for the most part its a low carb form of living (right up there next to the point of having none if youre dilligent and can break your processed food addiction) While I agree that nutritionists have more training then most to give nutritional advice, they are not perfect. And dietary regulations and recommendations change almost weekly, and must be customized for EVERY patient because there is no "one size fits all" form of eating0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions