Nut Butter differences in nutrition satisfaction?

moxette

I have been eating 1.5 TBS of skippy natural peanut butter with a slice of 45 calorie bread for breakfast nearly every morning for close to 8 months. Still not sick of it! It holds me over until my mid morning snack and tastes great with my morning coffee. Last week I decided to try the Maranantha Almond butter for a change of flavors. I liked it so I went through the same ritual. Exact same amount of butter and same brand of bread with same coffee. For 3 days in a row I was STARVING within 45 minutes and had wierdo cravings every day. Switched back to regular old skippy and I was back to normal immediately. Any insight on this? The nutrition seems nearly identical on the label but my body says it isn't.