We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

carbs and losing weight

marie111
marie111 Posts: 91 Member
edited October 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi everyone just to see if anyone else has found this with there diet last week i lost weight and didnt eat a lot of carbs ie bread rice and so on not intentionally just worked out that way, this week gone back to work and have been having bread ie sandwiches and perhaps rice or potato and have not lost any weight infact looking at the scales this morning 1/2 lb on what does anyone think do i cut carbs out or does anyone no the bare minimum anyone needs in percent so i can change the settings. thanks marie

Replies

  • PBJunky
    PBJunky Posts: 737 Member
    Hi everyone just to see if anyone else has found this with there diet last week i lost weight and didnt eat a lot of carbs ie bread rice and so on not intentionally just worked out that way, this week gone back to work and have been having bread ie sandwiches and perhaps rice or potato and have not lost any weight infact looking at the scales this morning 1/2 lb on what does anyone think do i cut carbs out or does anyone no the bare minimum anyone needs in percent so i can change the settings. thanks marie

    Are you counting correctly? Doesn't seem like it cause carbs don't magically make you fat...anything in excess pushing you over your calories goals will result in weight gain
  • marie111
    marie111 Posts: 91 Member
    No been really good even give up the demon drink on my 2nd week drink free doing 8 weeks in total trying to dry out lol
  • PBJunky
    PBJunky Posts: 737 Member
    No been really good even give up the demon drink on my 2nd week drink free doing 8 weeks in total trying to dry out lol

    Going all cryptic on me with the demon drink and drying out...you referring to alcohol and going cold turkey?
  • Lyadeia
    Lyadeia Posts: 4,603 Member
    Carbs don't make you fat. Excess total calories do.

    That said, people see success at first on low carb diets because of water loss. When they start eating more carbs again, it appears that they gained weight when it's most likely just water.

    As long as you are under your maintenance amount of total calories, it doesn't matter if you eat nothing but carbs, you will still lose weight. Google the Twinkie Diet.
  • I imagine what has happened is that with a lack of carbs mean you have eaten in to your glycogen stores, when you use up the glycogen the body sheds water also (I think the ratio is 1 glycogen to 3 water) so you see a bit drop in weight mainly from the water loss.

    Once you build those glycogen reserves back up your body holds on to the water. Therefore you can see big shifts in weight in the short term.
  • marie111
    marie111 Posts: 91 Member
    definately sticking to my calories been a really good girl maybe just a blip will carry on and wait and see thanks guys
  • paulwgun
    paulwgun Posts: 439 Member
    if your going down the low carb route drink a minimum of 2litres of water a day and up your protein as you need to flush your system
  • I am exactly the same! since starting full time work I have gone from smoothies and omelettes to cereal and sarnies. I am bloated and appear to have gained a pound. I might start a thread for some low carb lunch ideas!
This discussion has been closed.