We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Advice column - losing weight
Shannon023
Posts: 14,529 Member
Amy Alkon is my favorite no-nonsense advice columnist. (Taken from Westword magazine)
When I married my wife seven years ago, she was 20 pounds lighter. She's unwilling to sacrifice a constant flow of sugary stuff, and lazy about working out. During our last conversation about her weight, she said I should be attracted to her no matter what, then said, "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it." This sent me into a panic. I'm somewhat and sometimes attracted to her at her current weight, but I would be (SET ITAL) greatly (END ITAL) and (SET ITAL) frequently (END ITAL) attracted if she lost the extra pounds. I want her to understand that being attracted to her is a basic need, and almost all of my crankiness stems from it not being met. I've been willing to sacrifice a lot — like working long hours to support our kids while she pursues a career she loves that generates almost no income. I have a strong preference for a certain body type — the one she used to have — and I'm willing to do virtually anything, and pay any amount of money, to see it again. The only thing I'm not willing to do is make her miserable.
In the dating phase, women do what it takes to attract and hang onto a man: looking after their looks and maintaining a figure that's more hourglass than beer keg. While there are some wives whose medical issues prevent them from losing weight, too many interpret "Till death do us part" as "You're stuck with me forever — more of me than you'd ever imagined." In worst cases, a woman will eat herself so big that Greenpeace tries to save her — until they realize that's a scrunchie on her head, not a decorative blowhole.
Beyond all the love hooha, marriage, especially as a child-farming enterprise, is a business partnership. Each partner has their end of the bargain to hold up, including not becoming substantially different from the person the other person married. Yes, I know it can be exhausting taking care of kids, and tedious lifting big old weights instead of Little Debbies. Well, it's exhausting and tedious earning a living, too, but imagine countering your wife's "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it!" with "I'm happy with the money I've earned, and plan to take the rest of my life off to drink beer and wax my car." Just guessing, but her response probably wouldn't be turning the other chin.
The sad thing is, many women who are fat aren't that way thanks to a diet that's high in cupcakes, or because their fitness goal is avoiding ever going to the gym. In fact, their attempts to lose weight might be making them fat. Award-winning investigative science journalist Gary Taubes has discovered that we've been sold a bill of goods by the medical establishment, which based its advice to follow high-carb, low-fat diets on "science" instead of science. In Taubes' exhaustively researched book, "Good Calories, Bad Calories," he lays out substantive evidence that obesity is caused by carbs — from flour, sugars, and easily digested starches like potatoes — that cause insulin levels to rise. When insulin levels rise, we stockpile calories as fat. Eating foods with very low (or no) carbs — meat, fish, poultry, cheese, eggs, butter, and non-starchy veggies — decreases appetite and increases fat loss and weight loss.
Women have been brainwashed by feminism's whacked contention that men "shouldn't" care about women's looks, that what's inside is all that matters. And because women don't care nearly as much about men's looks, they can't understand why men are so fixated on theirs. The truth is, male sexuality is different from female sexuality. It's highly visual, which explains the vast porn industry for men, and the itsy bitsy — almost novelty — industry for women. And, while men go for nonstop body shots in their porn, Susan Dominus reports in The New York Times that not only do women want more plot, more emotion, and more conversation, they want to know "Is the bedspread pretty?" and "Why is she wearing those shoes?"
You need to help your wife understand that you're making this plea because you love her and want to keep the spark in your marriage (and sadly, you aren't able to make do with the kind generated by her thighs rubbing together). Chapter three of evolutionary psychologist David Buss' book "The Evolution of Desire" should help you explain that men are hard-wired to be looks-driven. After you get that out of the way, explain what you wrote above: You sacrifice a lot for her and your kids, without reservation. You ask only one thing from her — not that she meet some bizarro new need, just that she start acting like she said "I do" to being in a partnership with you, not "I dough."
Inspires me to step it up a bit. :smokin:
When I married my wife seven years ago, she was 20 pounds lighter. She's unwilling to sacrifice a constant flow of sugary stuff, and lazy about working out. During our last conversation about her weight, she said I should be attracted to her no matter what, then said, "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it." This sent me into a panic. I'm somewhat and sometimes attracted to her at her current weight, but I would be (SET ITAL) greatly (END ITAL) and (SET ITAL) frequently (END ITAL) attracted if she lost the extra pounds. I want her to understand that being attracted to her is a basic need, and almost all of my crankiness stems from it not being met. I've been willing to sacrifice a lot — like working long hours to support our kids while she pursues a career she loves that generates almost no income. I have a strong preference for a certain body type — the one she used to have — and I'm willing to do virtually anything, and pay any amount of money, to see it again. The only thing I'm not willing to do is make her miserable.
In the dating phase, women do what it takes to attract and hang onto a man: looking after their looks and maintaining a figure that's more hourglass than beer keg. While there are some wives whose medical issues prevent them from losing weight, too many interpret "Till death do us part" as "You're stuck with me forever — more of me than you'd ever imagined." In worst cases, a woman will eat herself so big that Greenpeace tries to save her — until they realize that's a scrunchie on her head, not a decorative blowhole.
Beyond all the love hooha, marriage, especially as a child-farming enterprise, is a business partnership. Each partner has their end of the bargain to hold up, including not becoming substantially different from the person the other person married. Yes, I know it can be exhausting taking care of kids, and tedious lifting big old weights instead of Little Debbies. Well, it's exhausting and tedious earning a living, too, but imagine countering your wife's "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it!" with "I'm happy with the money I've earned, and plan to take the rest of my life off to drink beer and wax my car." Just guessing, but her response probably wouldn't be turning the other chin.
The sad thing is, many women who are fat aren't that way thanks to a diet that's high in cupcakes, or because their fitness goal is avoiding ever going to the gym. In fact, their attempts to lose weight might be making them fat. Award-winning investigative science journalist Gary Taubes has discovered that we've been sold a bill of goods by the medical establishment, which based its advice to follow high-carb, low-fat diets on "science" instead of science. In Taubes' exhaustively researched book, "Good Calories, Bad Calories," he lays out substantive evidence that obesity is caused by carbs — from flour, sugars, and easily digested starches like potatoes — that cause insulin levels to rise. When insulin levels rise, we stockpile calories as fat. Eating foods with very low (or no) carbs — meat, fish, poultry, cheese, eggs, butter, and non-starchy veggies — decreases appetite and increases fat loss and weight loss.
Women have been brainwashed by feminism's whacked contention that men "shouldn't" care about women's looks, that what's inside is all that matters. And because women don't care nearly as much about men's looks, they can't understand why men are so fixated on theirs. The truth is, male sexuality is different from female sexuality. It's highly visual, which explains the vast porn industry for men, and the itsy bitsy — almost novelty — industry for women. And, while men go for nonstop body shots in their porn, Susan Dominus reports in The New York Times that not only do women want more plot, more emotion, and more conversation, they want to know "Is the bedspread pretty?" and "Why is she wearing those shoes?"
You need to help your wife understand that you're making this plea because you love her and want to keep the spark in your marriage (and sadly, you aren't able to make do with the kind generated by her thighs rubbing together). Chapter three of evolutionary psychologist David Buss' book "The Evolution of Desire" should help you explain that men are hard-wired to be looks-driven. After you get that out of the way, explain what you wrote above: You sacrifice a lot for her and your kids, without reservation. You ask only one thing from her — not that she meet some bizarro new need, just that she start acting like she said "I do" to being in a partnership with you, not "I dough."
Inspires me to step it up a bit. :smokin:
0
Replies
-
Amy Alkon is my favorite no-nonsense advice columnist. (Taken from Westword magazine)
When I married my wife seven years ago, she was 20 pounds lighter. She's unwilling to sacrifice a constant flow of sugary stuff, and lazy about working out. During our last conversation about her weight, she said I should be attracted to her no matter what, then said, "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it." This sent me into a panic. I'm somewhat and sometimes attracted to her at her current weight, but I would be (SET ITAL) greatly (END ITAL) and (SET ITAL) frequently (END ITAL) attracted if she lost the extra pounds. I want her to understand that being attracted to her is a basic need, and almost all of my crankiness stems from it not being met. I've been willing to sacrifice a lot — like working long hours to support our kids while she pursues a career she loves that generates almost no income. I have a strong preference for a certain body type — the one she used to have — and I'm willing to do virtually anything, and pay any amount of money, to see it again. The only thing I'm not willing to do is make her miserable.
In the dating phase, women do what it takes to attract and hang onto a man: looking after their looks and maintaining a figure that's more hourglass than beer keg. While there are some wives whose medical issues prevent them from losing weight, too many interpret "Till death do us part" as "You're stuck with me forever — more of me than you'd ever imagined." In worst cases, a woman will eat herself so big that Greenpeace tries to save her — until they realize that's a scrunchie on her head, not a decorative blowhole.
Beyond all the love hooha, marriage, especially as a child-farming enterprise, is a business partnership. Each partner has their end of the bargain to hold up, including not becoming substantially different from the person the other person married. Yes, I know it can be exhausting taking care of kids, and tedious lifting big old weights instead of Little Debbies. Well, it's exhausting and tedious earning a living, too, but imagine countering your wife's "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it!" with "I'm happy with the money I've earned, and plan to take the rest of my life off to drink beer and wax my car." Just guessing, but her response probably wouldn't be turning the other chin.
The sad thing is, many women who are fat aren't that way thanks to a diet that's high in cupcakes, or because their fitness goal is avoiding ever going to the gym. In fact, their attempts to lose weight might be making them fat. Award-winning investigative science journalist Gary Taubes has discovered that we've been sold a bill of goods by the medical establishment, which based its advice to follow high-carb, low-fat diets on "science" instead of science. In Taubes' exhaustively researched book, "Good Calories, Bad Calories," he lays out substantive evidence that obesity is caused by carbs — from flour, sugars, and easily digested starches like potatoes — that cause insulin levels to rise. When insulin levels rise, we stockpile calories as fat. Eating foods with very low (or no) carbs — meat, fish, poultry, cheese, eggs, butter, and non-starchy veggies — decreases appetite and increases fat loss and weight loss.
Women have been brainwashed by feminism's whacked contention that men "shouldn't" care about women's looks, that what's inside is all that matters. And because women don't care nearly as much about men's looks, they can't understand why men are so fixated on theirs. The truth is, male sexuality is different from female sexuality. It's highly visual, which explains the vast porn industry for men, and the itsy bitsy — almost novelty — industry for women. And, while men go for nonstop body shots in their porn, Susan Dominus reports in The New York Times that not only do women want more plot, more emotion, and more conversation, they want to know "Is the bedspread pretty?" and "Why is she wearing those shoes?"
You need to help your wife understand that you're making this plea because you love her and want to keep the spark in your marriage (and sadly, you aren't able to make do with the kind generated by her thighs rubbing together). Chapter three of evolutionary psychologist David Buss' book "The Evolution of Desire" should help you explain that men are hard-wired to be looks-driven. After you get that out of the way, explain what you wrote above: You sacrifice a lot for her and your kids, without reservation. You ask only one thing from her — not that she meet some bizarro new need, just that she start acting like she said "I do" to being in a partnership with you, not "I dough."
Inspires me to step it up a bit. :smokin:0 -
thank goodness for a fresh perspective:flowerforyou:0
-
Great article, Shannon!!!!!:flowerforyou:0
-
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
I could do that. :bigsmile:0 -
:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
Hey, I'm trying to lose the weight like everyone else around here, but that was just funny.0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
I could do that. :bigsmile:
I just thought of a fantastic way to get people to the gym. A class called Cardio & Cocktails...but not necessarily in that order. Oh, the money I'll make!
0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
I could do that. :bigsmile:
I just thought of a fantastic way to get people to the gym. A class called Cardio & Cocktails...but not necessarily in that order. Oh, the money I'll make!
Make sure there's a lot of padding around the equipment. :laugh:0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
I could do that. :bigsmile:
I just thought of a fantastic way to get people to the gym. A class called Cardio & Cocktails...but not necessarily in that order. Oh, the money I'll make!
Make sure there's a lot of padding around the equipment. :laugh:
Probably not a good idea for a step class. I bet Zumba would be a good one to drink in. :drinker:0 -
Honesty! Refreshing!!:laugh:
I saw myself getting into the "He's stuck with me no matter what" attitude but decided I was only doing myself a disservice that way and my son as well. So, I stepped it up baby!!:glasses: :drinker:
And I have never felt better!! WOOO!!!:bigsmile:0 -
I agree that both should try to keep similar to (or better than) the way they were when they got married. (My DH and I are now both thinner than when we got married almost 2 years ago.) But I hate the "Guys are visual, girls aren't" thing. Wives get more turned on when their husbands look good and take care of themselves too!0
-
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
Beer (aka: wine) up front, mister! :bigsmile:0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
Beer (aka: wine) up front, mister! :bigsmile:
denied...show me ..."wax on...wax off"0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
I did read the article, Dave. It just made me want beer & to wax a car. Is that so wrong? :huh: Plus, car waxing could be cardio.
0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
Beer (aka: wine) up front, mister! :bigsmile:
denied...show me ..."wax on...wax off"
hrmpf! You're waxing solo then.
0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
I did read the article, Dave. It just made me want beer & to wax a car. Is that so wrong? :huh: Plus, car waxing could be cardio.
good attitude....I like that,,,,good spirit,,,but uh,,,car is waiting while we discuss,,,,,try to slap the wax and the gums at the same time....go on now...chop chop0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
Beer (aka: wine) up front, mister! :bigsmile:
denied...show me ..."wax on...wax off"
hrmpf! You're waxing solo then.
hmpf??? LOL
come on now...our friend thinks its a cardio session...join her....go on now...andele!!! Arriba!!!!0 -
Perhaps the wife could drink the beer & wax the car....just sayin'. :bigsmile:
Good bit of advice, Shannon!
well? whats the hold up?
my car could use a waxin....beer when you are through if there is any left ..shake a leg!!
seriously now......read the article..
I did read the article, Dave. It just made me want beer & to wax a car. Is that so wrong? :huh: Plus, car waxing could be cardio.
good attitude....I like that,,,,good spirit,,,but uh,,,car is waiting while we discuss,,,,,try to slap the wax and the gums at the same time....go on now...chop chop
Well, we all know I'm an excellent multi-tasker. :smokin:0 -
So if he starts losing his hair can I go too?0
-
When I married my wife seven years ago, she was 20 pounds lighter. She's unwilling to sacrifice a constant flow of sugary stuff, and lazy about working out. During our last conversation about her weight, she said I should be attracted to her no matter what, then said, "I'm happy with my weight, and don't intend to change it." This sent me into a panic. I'm somewhat and sometimes attracted to her at her current weight, but I would be (SET ITAL) greatly (END ITAL) and (SET ITAL) frequently (END ITAL) attracted if she lost the extra pounds. I want her to understand that being attracted to her is a basic need, and almost all of my crankiness stems from it not being met. I've been willing to sacrifice a lot — like working long hours to support our kids while she pursues a career she loves that generates almost no income. I have a strong preference for a certain body type — the one she used to have — and I'm willing to do virtually anything, and pay any amount of money, to see it again. The only thing I'm not willing to do is make her miserable.
20 bucks says that guy isn't the same size he was when they were married seven years ago...and he wasn't the one squirting out kids. :grumble:0 -
So if he starts losing his hair can I go too?
LOL exactly...the man can turn into a balding ape, but we have to stay with him because 'women aren't visual' ...puhlease!0 -
focus
breathe deep
accept0 -
This was a good article.
We as women can say we are visual but we are not as visually stimulated as men. Maybe a few of us but for the most part we are wired differently. I'm glad we are otherwise we'd never get them away from the beer & waxing the car.0 -
This was a good article.
We as women can say we are visual but we are not as visually stimulated as men. Maybe a few of us but for the most part we are wired differently. I'm glad we are otherwise we'd never get them away from the beer & waxing the car.
Thanks.
To parrot Tami, I had the same thought process when I was heavier. The "oh well, tell death do us part" wasn't fair to either one of us.0 -
This was a good article.
We as women can say we are visual but we are not as visually stimulated as men. Maybe a few of us but for the most part we are wired differently. I'm glad we are otherwise we'd never get them away from the beer & waxing the car.
Thanks.
To parrot Tami, I had the same thought process when I was heavier. The "oh well, tell death do us part" wasn't fair to either one of us.
plus you are hot
its all good0 -
This was a good article.
We as women can say we are visual but we are not as visually stimulated as men. Maybe a few of us but for the most part we are wired differently. I'm glad we are otherwise we'd never get them away from the beer & waxing the car.
Thanks.
To parrot Tami, I had the same thought process when I was heavier. The "oh well, tell death do us part" wasn't fair to either one of us.
plus you are hot
its all good
:smooched:
All right, I'll wax the car now. :blushing:0 -
This was a good article.
We as women can say we are visual but we are not as visually stimulated as men. Maybe a few of us but for the most part we are wired differently. I'm glad we are otherwise we'd never get them away from the beer & waxing the car.
Thanks.
To parrot Tami, I had the same thought process when I was heavier. The "oh well, tell death do us part" wasn't fair to either one of us.
plus you are hot
its all good
:smooched:
All right, I'll wax the car now. :blushing:
It's already done, Shannon. Let's just drink. :smokin:0 -
This was a good article.
We as women can say we are visual but we are not as visually stimulated as men. Maybe a few of us but for the most part we are wired differently. I'm glad we are otherwise we'd never get them away from the beer & waxing the car.
Thanks.
To parrot Tami, I had the same thought process when I was heavier. The "oh well, tell death do us part" wasn't fair to either one of us.
plus you are hot
its all good
:smooched:
All right, I'll wax the car now. :blushing:
It's already done, Shannon. Let's just drink. :smokin:
You're the bestest!!!!!!!!
0 -
Dave! Get me a bottle! Chop chop!
*snicker* did it work?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.4K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.4K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 442 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 921 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions