American Idol week of 5/5/09

mello

Wow, so Paula was that bad I guess. I did see a small replay on the news just a few mins ago and it looks like she was trying to be a Britany Spears wanna-be.:noway:

I was thinking she was trying to be Madonna.
But she pulled an Ashlee Simpson, just didn't get caught

And that's so sad.....she was the greatest thing going in her day. She needed to leave that portion of her career alone!!

icandoallthings

Hee hee! I love the critique comments about Paula.
You guys crack me up! :laugh:

I actually thought she did pretty well (especially with
her years with chronic back pain). I hope I look that
good when I'm 46! Dang!

Yeah, my husband despises lip-syncing! I don't like
it either but I sing, so I totally "get it" that to dance and
sing at the same time would really make the song
into a trainwreck with your lungs doing double-duty
right into the mic. That would be embarrassing - haha!

shutterbug4674

Hee hee! I love the critique comments about Paula.
You guys crack me up! :laugh:

I actually thought she did pretty well (especially with
her years with chronic back pain). I hope I look that
good when I'm 46! Dang!

Yeah, my husband despises lip-syncing! I don't like
it either but I sing, so I totally "get it" that to dance and
sing at the same time would really make the song
into a trainwreck with your lungs doing double-duty
right into the mic. That would be embarrassing - haha!

I liked the song she did. I wouldn't expect her or Britney to ever sing live.
I want to see a good performance, and as long as your dancing and I'm
entertained, then lipsync away! :drinker: