DO you eat back your workout calories?
cmatos426
Posts: 14 Member
I was wondering who eats and doesn't eat there workout calories because I do not see the sense of eating back the calories you work off because isn't that counter productive. I can be wrong I am just wondering...
0
Replies
-
You work out to become stronger. If you don't eat back at least /some/ of those calories, basically all that hard work went to nothing.
I use to not eat back the calories, but once someone talked me into it... I feel stronger, am at a healthy weight, and can run longer distances then I could without eating those calories back.0 -
It depends on whether I'm hungry or not.
I usually eat at least some of my exercise calories back, but I eat them all if I'm still hungry. Sometimes, I'm hungry the next day after a long run or difficult workout, then I'll eat more calories THAT day.0 -
Thing is I haven't been hungry and I hate force feeding myself
0 -
If I am feeling hungry, I eat back my calories. Some days, I am just hungrier than others. Sometimes I almost can't seem to work out if I haven't had a little extra something. I'd say 75% of the time, I eat back my calories!0
-
I usually eat back 50 min if not all of them. I don't function well if I don't0
-
I eat back some of them depending on my appetite that day.0
-
no i dont....0
-
HELL YEAH I EARNED THOSE SUCKERS SO I AM GONNA EAT THEM DAMMIT0
-
HELL YEAH I EARNED THOSE SUCKERS SO I AM GONNA EAT THEM DAMMIT
lmao xD that made me smile0 -
-
I do a average of 45 minutes of cardio 6 days a week, and on occasion I eat over my calorie limit but my extra calories still keep me under my limit. It is defiantly ok to use some of your extra workout calories, that's why they are there!0
-
ok feel thesame way!!!!0
-
Think of it this way - you lose weight with a calorie deficit, which MFP already provides for you. 1200 calories alone will already be a calorie deficit. If you burn 600 calories, you'll be netting 600 calories.
Would you ever eat 600 calories a day to lose weight? No! It wouldn't be smart and you would lose weight at a slower pace.
At first I didn't believe in eating back calories either but I'm losing weight at a faster pace now that I have
0 -
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/206951-asked-my-trainer-re-eating-back-calories
Read.....best answer to this question. Ive had this discussion quite a bit lately, but this is a good answer.0 -
yep I eat just about every one of them back I have a great HRM and I`m sure of my burn plus MFP sets my defecit already so yep I earned them I eat them0
-
Yes, I do eat my exercise calories, and they are oh so tasty!0
-
I do eat a little less than 1/2 of my earned calories. You need to have to eat after each workout to fuel your muscles and help burn the fat. You dont want to waste your work out. You can try a protien shake or a good smoothie thats not packed with sugar Hope this helps! 0
-
I always try. My weight loss is more consistant when I eat them back.0
-
I try to eat back about half of my workout calories. Sometimes I don't want that much and I'm not going to eat just to eat though.0
-
MFP already creates a deficit for you when you choose your activity level.
MFP is set up so that it already creates a deficit, meaning you will lose weight even if you don't exercise. When you exercise, you further increase that deficit. Think of your exercise calories like fuel. When you workout , you need energy, you need fuel. Food is fuel.
P.S. Please please use the search function before posting a thread !!0 -
If I am trying to gain weight ...I eat back the calories...if I am trying to cut or lose weight...I don't eat back the calories....Defeats the purpose unless you short changed your calorie goal from the start...0
-
I just tr to stay around my normal caloie limit and still work out, I don't personally see them as extra calories to eat. I thought thats why we work out i to have a defecient.0
-
When I hit my goal weight last september, I never touched my exercise calories. I lost my weight ,no plateaus,no problem, was getting by on 1,300 calories a day, burning around 1,000 every day.
Now, i have gained 10 lbs and trying to lose them. This time, I eat back about half of my exercise calories..I again work out around 1,000calories a day. I lost 2lbs in February, and since then I have gained another 3 lbs....having said that, i feel better, more healthier.
Im not sure if eating back exercise calories will help me lose my weight, i know when i didn't eat them back, my weight loss was constant and very steady, but I certainly enjoy the feeling of not feeling extreme hunger now that I eat them back.0 -
No I don't since I am trying to lose weight I try to stick to or below my goal of 1500 cal.0
-
If I am trying to gain weight ...I eat back the calories...if I am trying to cut or lose weight...I don't eat back the calories....Defeats the purpose unless you short changed your calorie goal from the start...
That is not true. Please explain how eating back your exercise calories "defeats the purpose"? MFP already has you on a deficit!0 -
I've done both. It all depends on you! But you should not have to force yourself to eat!! But don't feel bad about what ever you decide its a journey to weight loss....0
-
I just tr to stay around my normal caloie limit and still work out, I don't personally see them as extra calories to eat. I thought thats why we work out i to have a defecient.
Yes, MFP already creates that deficit FOR you when it gives you your calorie goal. Even if you didn't work out, you would still lose weight eating at the amount set for you! But you should still work out!0 -
You need to be looking at your Net Cals total at the top of your home page and decide whether you need to be eating them or not - if you're under your daily goal, then eat away lol. MFP takes into account the fact you want to lose weight so has already made adjustments to your calorie goal to account for this.
However, there are lots of different opinons for and against. Personally I prefer to think of my exercise as EARNING me calories, not BURNING calories. If you are exercising and you DON'T eat those cals back, you'll be trying to make your body survive on much less than it needs (remember MFP has already given you a low calorie goal total to figure in a deficit over the week resulting in weightloss) . You'll also be slowing down your metabolism in the long term which will slow the rate at which your body will burn your calories.
I didn't eat my exercise cals for the first month or so, the weight fell off, I then lost really slowly for another month, then plateaued for a month. I then decided to do the dreaded thing of upping my cals (everything I read told me that's what to do but I still doubted it!), and that week I lost no weight but lost 3 inches, the following week I lost 3lbs, then I carried on at a better weight loss rate ever since. I find when I plateau again for a few weeks, if I up my cals I start losing again.0 -
I eat when I'm hungry. Solves that problem.0
-
Eat them back ppl. take a minute and read: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/206951-asked-my-trainer-re-eating-back-calories0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions