Scales with body fat % - UK

ania0307

Hi guys
I've been thinking about purchasing scales with body fat and muscle % analyser. Are they a waste of time or should I give them a go
also any brands you could recommend - available in the UK, I was looking at Salter stainless steel one (from Argos) but don't want to be spending 30 quid if it's unreliable - I have enough junk in the house without adding another piece haha
thanks

sam45890

i'm wondering about this too. bump!

leez1984

I got a set of weight watchers ones (on sale at £30 - original price was £80!). I get pretty consistent and believable readings from them so far, they do weight, body fat % and water %. You have to program in your details to get accurate readings though

Carrie3B

My trainers at the gym said that the body fat readings on the scales are completely inaccurate. I have a friend who is a marathon runner and in awesome shape. Our trainer just measured her at the gym (with calibers and another machine that is said to be very accurate) and it said 13% body fat. Her scale at home said 22%. I could be wrong but I just don't see how a scale can be that accurate--how can it tell what is fat and what is muscle, water etc...?

sniperzzzz

Complete waste of money! If you want to measure your body-fat, get a pair of these
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Accu-Measure-Fitness-Personal-Tester/dp/B000G7YW74
Then go here http://www.linear-software.com/online.html
And follow the guide

ania0307

thanks guys
last night i ordered body fat calipers on ebay can't wait to start measuring (and getting depressed looking at the results)

littlefreckle91

I got a set of weight watchers ones (on sale at £30 - original price was £80!). I get pretty consistent and believable readings from them so far, they do weight, body fat % and water %. You have to program in your details to get accurate readings though

I have these! They're great but I've lost the little feet on mine I got them in the sale and they've lasted a couple of years so far.

leez1984

@littlefreckle - the WW scales have a lifetime guarantee from the company, have you phoned them up? I've kept the booklet from mine just in case anything ever goes wrong

littlefreckle91

@littlefreckle - the WW scales have a lifetime guarantee from the company, have you phoned them up? I've kept the booklet from mine just in case anything ever goes wrong

No I haven't phoned them up,i wonder if they would give me some replacement feet for free? I think I have the booklet lying around somewhere haha.At the moment,I'm using a flat piece of wood underneath for an accurate reading.

creature275

DONT - scales and for that many any other kind of digital device that supposedly tells body fat % are innacurate as hell because they cant tell the difference between lean muscle and fat they just go off weight height and age, for example I am around 7% body fat, but because I am composed of mostly muscle, (and bone and organs and water obviously) those things tell ME that I have 20% body fat..so thats just an example of how innacurate they are

sam45890

thanks for the tips, i'll save my money!