We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Running a deficit and 5x5 training

scottywor
scottywor Posts: 140 Member
edited December 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
So based on what I have read and suggestions from others, I think I will be starting a 5x5 routine next week.

Now I know that strength builds muscle, but if im still running with a 20%-25% deficit (500-650 for me), is the 5x5 the best option? Will I cut if Im on a deficit, obviously it will be near impossible to build muscle while running such a deficit. Thats not what Im looking for. I am looking for Fat Loss. But I understand that these lifts get heavy over time and if your not eating enough to build and repair muscle, how long can it be sustained. I hit my macros every day, pretty much, at present doing 40/30/30. Would it be adviseable to increase protein intake to say 35 or 40% knowing that increased protein will offset any muscle loss during cut, while doing 5x5 on a deficit? I also want to fit some cardio in during this time.

Would I be better off say training each body part 2x a week, with both tension (heavy,low rep), and metabolic training (light, high reps), in some kind of upper/lower split? And throw in some Mod cardio in there a few days?

Currently I do a total body 3x a week, 3 sets 10 reps, and cardio 3-4 x a week.

Thoughts?

Also have been reading a lot about IF, etc. Looking at Leangains, but I will post that one seperately...

Replies

  • JNick77
    JNick77 Posts: 3,783 Member
    So based on what I have read and suggestions from others, I think I will be starting a 5x5 routine next week.

    Now I know that strength builds muscle, but if im still running with a 20%-25% deficit (500-650 for me), is the 5x5 the best option? Will I cut if Im on a deficit, obviously it will be near impossible to build muscle while running such a deficit. Thats not what Im looking for. I am looking for Fat Loss. But I understand that these lifts get heavy over time and if your not eating enough to build and repair muscle, how long can it be sustained. I hit my macros every day, pretty much, at present doing 40/30/30. Would it be adviseable to increase protein intake to say 35 or 40% knowing that increased protein will offset any muscle loss during cut, while doing 5x5 on a deficit? I also want to fit some cardio in during this time.

    Would I be better off say training each body part 2x a week, with both tension (heavy,low rep), and metabolic training (light, high reps), in some kind of upper/lower split? And throw in some Mod cardio in there a few days?

    Currently I do a total body 3x a week, 3 sets 10 reps, and cardio 3-4 x a week.

    Thoughts?

    Also have been reading a lot about IF, etc. Looking at Leangains, but I will post that one seperately...

    Yes, lifting with maximal strength weight is fine on a deficit. You may experience minor hypertrophy but you will defnitely increase your strength and go through body re-composition.

    Diet wise you may want to look at 40/40/20 (pro/carb/fat) on lifting days and then 40/15/45 (pro/carb/fat) for non-lifting days. The non-lifting days may include cardio though.

    From a programming perspective the various 5x5 methods are fine if you're a beginner but I don't feel they're a good long-term training system. I'd prefer 5/3/1, Westside for Skinny *kitten*, or the Westside Conjugate method.
  • scottywor
    scottywor Posts: 140 Member
    Thanks Jnick,

    I just didnt want to lift heavy if I was going to be spinning my tires so to speak, but it does make sense. I will decide when i get to my chosen BF% if I will increase intake beyond maintenaince for hypertophy or not.

    I have been pretty close to 40/4/20 on training days actually, as Im always over my protein, usually by about 10% or so. Off days have been same, I have had good results from this too. I just wanted to opitmize my fat loss, as it seems to have slowed a bit..

    I have been thinking of combining training with IF approach.

    Thanks again
This discussion has been closed.