Bananas are as good a choice as cookies!

TeachTheGirl
TeachTheGirl Posts: 2,091 Member
in Food and Nutrition
http://blog.massivehealth.com/infographics/bananas_vs_cookies

Linked on my Facebook wall via OXO today. Thoughts?
«1

Replies

  • Rae6503
    Rae6503 Posts: 6,294 Member
    In terms of staying fulling and having a blood sugar crash later, yes they are about the same as cookies. BUT they have more vitamins and nutrients. Potassium is very important to those who work out.

    So yes. Eat bananas AND cookies. Is that the question?
  • runfatmanrun
    runfatmanrun Posts: 1,090 Member
    Eat bananas AND cookies.[/quote]

    This. Or even banana flavored cookies, they just don't have the potassium
  • Elizabeth_C34
    Elizabeth_C34 Posts: 6,376 Member
    Put the bananas in the cookies. DOUBLE WIN.
  • becoming_a_new_me
    becoming_a_new_me Posts: 1,860 Member
    Dangit...now I want a banana creme pie with a cookie crust
  • Rae6503
    Rae6503 Posts: 6,294 Member
    Put the bananas in the cookies. DOUBLE WIN.

    And walnuts!
  • Sidesteal
    Sidesteal Posts: 5,510 Member
    My only issue with it is that satiety is not the only reason in making food choices and this article seems to have some implication that this is the case.

    Overall I probably eat more cookies than I eat bananas, but bananas will almost always provide my body with more benefit.
  • Toddrific
    Toddrific Posts: 1,114 Member
    MMmmm banana walnut brownies..close enough to a cookie.
  • UponThisRock
    UponThisRock Posts: 4,519 Member
    The next time I have a "sugar crash" will be the first
  • MIssFinny
    MIssFinny Posts: 194 Member
    This s**t is bananas. B-A-N-A-N-A-S! :happy:
  • ummommyme
    ummommyme Posts: 362 Member
    hmmm, i've had three bananas today;)
  • Sidesteal
    Sidesteal Posts: 5,510 Member
    hmmm, i've had three bananas today;)

    Want a fourth?




    (Sorry, I really had to go there).
  • taunto
    taunto Posts: 6,420 Member
    hmmm, i've had three bananas today;)

    Would you like another banana?

    IF-you-know-what-i-mean.png
  • Captain_Tightpants
    Captain_Tightpants Posts: 2,215 Member
    Nothing like a cookie in anything except the sugar profile. Even in that the insulinemic response is lower from fruit sugars because of the fiber that comes with them. They're packed with good nutrients. Not to mention they don't have any of the processed additives that your typical cookie would have.

    Banana Ingredients:
    Banana.

    Nestle Chocolate Chip Cookie Ingredients:
    Chocolate Semisweet [Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor, Flavor(s) Natural]), Sugar, Flour Bleached Enriched (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Iron Reduced, Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B1), Riboflavin (Vitamin B2), Folic Acid (Vitamin aB)), Margarine (Soybean(s) Oil Partially Hydrogenated and Cottonseed Oil Partially Hydrogenated, Water, Salt, Whey, Vegetable(s) Mono and Diglycerides, Soy Lecithin, Flavor(s) Artificial, Beta Carotene color(s), Vitamin A Palmitate added), Nestle Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunks (Chocolate Semisweet [Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor, Flavor(s) Natural]), Water, Nestle Toll House Morsels (Milk Chocolate [Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Non-Fat, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor, Flavor(s) Natural]), Egg(s), Oat(s) Rolled, Corn Syrup Solids, Molasses, Baking Soda, Salt, Corn Starch, Sodium Aluminum Phosphate, Vanilla Extract, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor
  • Sidesteal
    Sidesteal Posts: 5,510 Member
    hmmm, i've had three bananas today;)

    Would you like another banana?

    IF-you-know-what-i-mean.png

    I am totally stealing this.
  • WhittRak
    WhittRak Posts: 567 Member
    Bananas are great and healthy, I have one everyday, and it has not stopped me from losing weight.
  • taunto
    taunto Posts: 6,420 Member
    On topic. I know myself have gotten fat eating cookies, I don't know many who do get fat eating bananas. Actually, I don't know anyone who got fat eating too many fruits.

    Besides bananas give you monkey powa! All arguments fail against da monkey powa!
  • Trechechus
    Trechechus Posts: 2,819 Member
    I hate this vendetta against bananas and potatoes that has suddenly sprung up!!

    I guess, if you aren't going to count nutrients, then sure a banana is like a cookie.
    If you want nutrients and nutritional benefits from the food you eat, then no. Bananas are high in potassium, zinc, iron, protein, fiber, calcium, Manganese, Selenium and riboflavin. How many cookies can say that?

    There's some more about why bananas are awesome here.
    http://blog.massivehealth.com/infographics/bananas_vs_cookies
  • LuckyAng
    LuckyAng Posts: 1,173 Member
    Dangit...now I want a banana creme pie with a cookie crust

    Mmmm... get on that, I'm on my way ;)
  • AnninStPaul
    AnninStPaul Posts: 1,372 Member
    Would you eat as many calories worth of bananas as you would of cookies?
  • timmymon
    timmymon Posts: 304 Member
    I would take a banana covered in peanut butter over any cookie in the world :bigsmile:
  • lau444
    lau444 Posts: 120 Member
    I would take a banana covered in peanut butter over any cookie in the world :bigsmile:

    I literally JUST had that. SOOOOO good!
  • Masterdo
    Masterdo Posts: 331 Member
    Nothing like a cookie in anything except the sugar profile. Even in that the insulinemic response is lower from fruit sugars because of the fiber that comes with them. They're packed with good nutrients. Not to mention they don't have any of the processed additives that your typical cookie would have.

    Banana Ingredients:
    Banana.

    Nestle Chocolate Chip Cookie Ingredients:
    Chocolate Semisweet [Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor, Flavor(s) Natural]), Sugar, Flour Bleached Enriched (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Iron Reduced, Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B1), Riboflavin (Vitamin B2), Folic Acid (Vitamin aB)), Margarine (Soybean(s) Oil Partially Hydrogenated and Cottonseed Oil Partially Hydrogenated, Water, Salt, Whey, Vegetable(s) Mono and Diglycerides, Soy Lecithin, Flavor(s) Artificial, Beta Carotene color(s), Vitamin A Palmitate added), Nestle Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunks (Chocolate Semisweet [Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor, Flavor(s) Natural]), Water, Nestle Toll House Morsels (Milk Chocolate [Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Non-Fat, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor, Flavor(s) Natural]), Egg(s), Oat(s) Rolled, Corn Syrup Solids, Molasses, Baking Soda, Salt, Corn Starch, Sodium Aluminum Phosphate, Vanilla Extract, Vanillin An Artificial Flavor

    I really like that answer :p

    This blog post resumes very well my thoughts on that :
    http://evidencebasedfitness.blogspot.ca/2010/05/death-by-sand-when-do-fine-details.html

    In my mind, if you are worrying about bananas, you are either :
    a) an athlete trying to drop from 9% to 7% body fat for the upcoming competition.
    b) diabetic
    c) a tool.

    There are no other choices really...
  • Ingadinga
    Ingadinga Posts: 28 Member
    Cookies have saturated fat, bananas do not.

    I personally would prefer fructose found naturally in fruit over refined sugar.

    I am fine with eating one banana, cookies I can't just stop at one.

    Bananas win.

    That's what I think.
  • elysianashes
    elysianashes Posts: 100
    The infographic doesn't pretend to say that cookies are good for you - it points out several times that this is ONLY based on what will fill you up longer, and that bananas still have more nutrients.

    It also points out that there are much better choices than bananas OR cookies.

    Stop arguing a point that the infographic isn't making :)
  • milkyway03
    milkyway03 Posts: 1 Member
    Bananas are high in carbohydrates which means our bodies can process extra sugars from bananas into fat and store it in our bodies. Cookies are high in fat and carbohydrates therefore making it a lot easier to gain weight. Bananas are great for the nutrients they provide we just need to make sure not to eat too many or pair them to other high carb items. :)
  • Sidesteal
    Sidesteal Posts: 5,510 Member
    Bananas are high in carbohydrates which means our bodies can process extra sugars from bananas into fat and store it in our bodies. Cookies are high in fat and carbohydrates therefore making it a lot easier to gain weight. Bananas are great for the nutrients they provide we just need to make sure not to eat too many or pair them to other high carb items. :)

    But in a calorie deficit, lipolysis will still exceed lipogenesis in the long term, regardless of any short term effects of extra sugars.
  • Trechechus
    Trechechus Posts: 2,819 Member
    Bananas are high in carbohydrates which means our bodies can process extra sugars from bananas into fat and store it in our bodies. Cookies are high in fat and carbohydrates therefore making it a lot easier to gain weight. Bananas are great for the nutrients they provide we just need to make sure not to eat too many or pair them to other high carb items. :)

    But in a calorie deficit, lipolysis will still exceed lipogenesis in the long term, regardless of any short term effects of extra sugars.

    Also, carbs are ESSENTIAL to cellular respiration. Unless you don't like ATP, don't worry about carbs!!
  • ironanimal
    ironanimal Posts: 5,922 Member
    Oh **** I ate a banana today
  • MIssFinny
    MIssFinny Posts: 194 Member
    Devil.jpg
  • UrbanRunner81
    UrbanRunner81 Posts: 1,207 Member
    In terms of staying fulling and having a blood sugar crash later, yes they are about the same as cookies. BUT they have more vitamins and nutrients. Potassium is very important to those who work out.

    So yes. Eat bananas AND cookies. Is that the question?

    :flowerforyou:

Categories