Protein Shakes & Powder - How to use?
Replies
-
Protein shakes can be used as a "meal replacement" if you wish to do so, the most important time to have a protein shake is right after a workout. I personally do both, I have one protein shake as a meal replacer and one shake immediately after a workout. If you have Casein protein that is what you would want to take before going to bed. For your cardio I'd suggest stop using the elliptical, that's cheating yourself and not much of a workout at all. Get on the treadmill, raise the incline to around 12 degrees to start, put the pace at a brisk walk level, and do this for 40-60 minutes. You will burn more calories than the elliptical and it isn't very strenuous for beginners at all.
I've lost 26 pounds since March doing a "cutting" phase with this kind of cardio and eating healthy, if anyone tells you that you have to run in order to lose weight then ignore anything they have to say and don't take their advice because they're clueless and feeding you crap.
Strange advice, no machine automatically burns more calories than another. It's all about level of effort. If you're just mailing it in on the elliptical then of course the dreadmill is going to burn more. And likewise. For me personally I find that the elliptical is much better because it engages upper and lower body and you can adjust the intensity too. So you can get a bigger burn in a smaller amount of time. Plus it's lower impact. Win/win situation.
At the end of the day it doesn't really matter what you use, do what you like and as long as you're putting in the effort.
Lol I didn't say that one machines burns more calories than the other. Doing the treadmill on an incline like I said also engages the upper and lower body, and you can also adjust the intensity. Sorry, but the elliptical is not even close to being better for losing weight, if that were the case than fitness models and bodybuilders would use them, but they don't.
With the elliptical you said you can get a "bigger burn in a smaller amount of time", after 20 minutes on the elliptical how many calories do you burn? Just curious
20 minutes, usually 400-ish calories at a fairly moderate pace (I don't push too hard, save the effort for lifting).
Hmmmmm, I have an extremely hard time believing 400 calories in 20 minutes on the elliptical.. I'd love to see an uploaded pic of your elliptical machine after you do your cardio on it to see those kinds of results.
I wasn't going to jump in on this conversation, but this argument popped up in another thread... like someone else said, its all about effort. If you put a treadmill at a 0.1 incline and walk at 15 minute miles, it will be hardly any effort, with no calorie burn.. the same is true for an elliptical.... no resistance equals no effort which equals no calorie burn... but, increase the incline, or the resistance, and the effort needed to walk, or move will increase, so the amount of calories burned will increase.... Simple.
If the effort is there, then it should not matter what equipment is used. Maybe you should try using an elliptical with a very high resistant level and see what it does
SilMarillion.
I don't disagree with that and never did... But you are wrong about burning no calories from a treadmill at .1 incline for 15 minute miles... Every single thing we do requires energy, calories are energy, more specifically macronutrients. You can pick your nose for an hour and burn calories doing so.
Also, the "burn" doesn't matter when it comes to losing weight, being in a caloric deficit at the end of the day is what matters. I do the treadmill at 3.0 speed (20 minute miles) at a 15 degree incline for an hour and burn around 850 calories every single time. That isn't strenuous at all and there's no drastic heart rate elevation, I've been doing this since March and have lost 27 pounds... There's a reason bodybuilders do that kind of cardio as well, because it works and it doesn't cause the body go into a catabolic state like fast paced cardio that elevates the heart rate...0 -
don't disagree with that and never did... But you are wrong about burning no calories from a treadmill at .1 incline for 15 minute miles... Every single thing we do requires energy, calories are energy, more specifically macronutrients. You can pick your nose for an hour and burn calories doing so.
Also, the "burn" doesn't matter when it comes to losing weight, being in a caloric deficit at the end of the day is what matters. I do the treadmill at 3.0 speed (20 minute miles) at a 15 degree incline for an hour and burned around 850 calories every single time. That isn't strenuous at all and there's no "burn", I've been doing this since March and have lost 27 pounds... There's a reason bodybuilders do that kind of cardio as well, because it works and it doesn't cause the body go into a catabolic state like fast paced cardio that elevates the heart rate...
Agreed... what I should have really said is: A calorie burned\used\spent, is a calorie burned\used\spent... doesn't matter how it was used..
Just out of curiosity, how many calories would you use on an elliptical for 20 or so minutes, but keep your heart rate to around where you are when using the treadmill? I think they would be the same, or within a very small %..0 -
don't disagree with that and never did... But you are wrong about burning no calories from a treadmill at .1 incline for 15 minute miles... Every single thing we do requires energy, calories are energy, more specifically macronutrients. You can pick your nose for an hour and burn calories doing so.
Also, the "burn" doesn't matter when it comes to losing weight, being in a caloric deficit at the end of the day is what matters. I do the treadmill at 3.0 speed (20 minute miles) at a 15 degree incline for an hour and burned around 850 calories every single time. That isn't strenuous at all and there's no "burn", I've been doing this since March and have lost 27 pounds... There's a reason bodybuilders do that kind of cardio as well, because it works and it doesn't cause the body go into a catabolic state like fast paced cardio that elevates the heart rate...
Agreed... what I should have really said is: A calorie burned\used\spent, is a calorie burned\used\spent... doesn't matter how it was used..
Just out of curiosity, how many calories would you use on an elliptical for 20 or so minutes, but keep your heart rate to around where you are when using the treadmill? I think they would be the same, or within a very small %..
Yeah I agree, a calorie burned is a calorie burned regardless of how it's burned. I'm not sure how many calories it would be honestly, I don't think you can accurately put the difficulties at the same level; treadmill has incline and ellipticals have resistance so I'm not sure equivalencies for the two. Plus at that low level of speed for the elliptical the momentum from the pedals would do a lot of the work for you, so accurately calculating the amount of calories burned wouldn't be as easy.0 -
Thank you to all for your thoughts & suggestions. It really helps me out trying to learn all this stuff. The debate between the treadmill or elliptical is interesting, however all I own is an elliptical due to bad knees so I have no choice but to use it.
One other question that I thought of after reading the reply"s. I work out right after I wake up before eating breakfast. Should I drink a protein shake or some form of protein before I work out or can I wait till after?0 -
Possibly not.... To give a test from a metabolic chamber, 70% VO2max, 155bmp heartrate = 100cal/10min give or take. 30cal more /min would mean you're prob close to pushing anaerobic threshhold.
Hmmmmm, I have an extremely hard time believing 400 calories in 20 minutes on the elliptical.. I'd love to see an uploaded pic of your elliptical machine after you do your cardio on it to see those kinds of results.
It all depends on how fast and how high you have the resistance set. Personally I average 130calories per 10 minutes on the elliptical at a steady 5mph. I'm not sure how to gauge the resistance I use - but I keep the resistance to the point where I feel a decent burn in my legs. The same I get from walking on an incline on the treadmill. I usually do 30 minutes, which puts me around 350-400 calories.
I can't get those numbers on a treadmill. I can't go as fast, as long, with as much resistance. Forget it. My knees give out at 10 minutes, no incline.
Cardio is cardio is cardio. It's not what you're doing, it's how you're doing it. And puh-lease. My trainer never had me on the treadmill. It was the elliptical, strairmaster or stationary bike for cardio.0 -
To answer your question and earlier question, a protein shake does nothing more for your body than eating a piece of chicken does. post workout, or any other time of the day. It's ONLY used because it's an easy to eat protein. Outside of that, if offers ZERO other benefit to eating real food. So to answer your question, eat it in the morning if you want, or after a workout if you want. it doesn't matter. Just eat the protein you need and the calories you need every day., What form of food you use to get them in your body by and large is meaningless.Thank you to all for your thoughts & suggestions. It really helps me out trying to learn all this stuff. The debate between the treadmill or elliptical is interesting, however all I own is an elliptical due to bad knees so I have no choice but to use it.
One other question that I thought of after reading the reply"s. I work out right after I wake up before eating breakfast. Should I drink a protein shake or some form of protein before I work out or can I wait till after?
And before or after is really up to you. It won't impact your weight loss either way, but you may feel more energetic having some food in you. It's really preference.0 -
I originally got some protien powder so I can drink my shakes after I work out. But it was a little bit of a hassle since I don't work out close to home. So I just started drinking my protien shakes in the mornings when I eat my cereal.0
-
Thank you to all for your thoughts & suggestions. It really helps me out trying to learn all this stuff. The debate between the treadmill or elliptical is interesting, however all I own is an elliptical due to bad knees so I have no choice but to use it.
One other question that I thought of after reading the reply"s. I work out right after I wake up before eating breakfast. Should I drink a protein shake or some form of protein before I work out or can I wait till after?
I do my workouts and cardio in the morning while I'm still fasted from sleeping. Works for me and I still have plenty of energy to be able to my workouts, but I am only 22 so of course having energy isn't an issue. As far as working out while fasted I've always been told when you workout on an empty stomach your body burns fat easier, I don't have any research to back that up but regardless I work out while fasted still.0 -
Bump....0
-
I originally got some protien powder so I can drink my shakes after I work out. But it was a little bit of a hassle since I don't work out close to home. So I just started drinking my protien shakes in the mornings when I eat my cereal.
Just buy a shaker bottler and problem solved. I'm not sure what grocery stores you have in your area obviously but one of mine (H.E.B) actually sells shaker bottles there. If you can't find one at your grocery store just go to a local Vitamin Shoppe or GNC and there will be plenty to choose from!0 -
Lots of input here, my, what to do, Lol.
I will throw in my 2 cents, and my change is in no way a larger sum than others, it's just to ration the information a bit.
Okay lets see, First off..
Alot of people say, "Take your Protein Shake RIGHT AFTER you workout," as usually Whey Protein digests quickly (quicker than say solid food, such as Chicken, Tuna, Salmon, cetera) But the fact of the matter is, (okay not FACT, but what I have come to understand) your body doesn't know you're "replenishing" your muscles AT THAT MOMENT, and if you take it a few hours before, or after, the outcome seems to average the same. The reason I would say to have one after, is because sometimes having that set in your stomach and sift through your body can upset your stomach, and make you feel a tad heavier than you like - from MY experience, shakes before don't work, I get an upset stomach when working out if I do.
As another suggested, Casein Protein is a SLOW digesting protein, enough to satisfy you at night and replenish those muscles with Protein.
(Also, Google on YouTube LeanBodyLifeStyle - he uses MANY healthy recipes, with Protein Powders from snacks, to dinner, to lunch, to breakfast to desserts! all healthy! and delicious).
As for when to work out? Work out when YOU can, your body doesn't necessarily know, "OH IT'S MORNING, I BURN MORE NOW", it's calories in, calories out, no matter what time of the day. Myself, I can't wake up until a few hours after my bed-headed pillow rises, so for me to workout on an empty stomach would be disastrous, I am incompetent in the mornings and thus.. I could see myself burning less calories as my energy would be low and my motivation, "Grr, argg" with the sleep need.
As for the cardio bit, Who is to say Ellipticals DON"T work? They do, almost every bit of cardiovascular equipment on the market (save a few "As Seen on TV!" ones) it's basic math:
Your Work + Effort + Machines Mechanics = Caloric Burn, Success and a divy of euphoria on a good job.
I think it's kind of biased to state one machine is better than another, if we were to navigate into THAT direction, I could say, "My SPIN BIKE tops ALL CARDIO MACHINES" and does it? Probably not, but I have done the Treadmill for over 8 years, and it doesn't top my Spin Bike, why? Because my Spin Bike is better? No. It is because my joints are pummelled and I can't give my all running OR INCLINE Walking, but spinning I can sweat a bucket and fill the neighbours pool.
To state that one isn't "Weight Loss" worthy, because you find it unsatisfactory isn't justified, because we are all built differently, we all think differently, we walk, talk and work out in a way that WORKS FOR US.
..Sooo.. My 2 cents...and then some.
***Ah..and as for a meal replacement, on their own? Probably not.. as Whey (not casein) is faster digesting, But throw in some Oatmeal, Spinach, Berries, Bananas, Peanut Butter.. Sky is the limit, yeah, could be a great filler.0 -
1. I have a blender bottle and it is awesome. (comes with a little wire ball to help stir/mix)
2. I use plain unsweetened almond milk with my shakes its tastes great. I pay the extra few bucks for the optimum gold standard everyone I've tried tastes great. I take them right after a workout and any day where my protein and calories might be a little low.0 -
Unless you absolutely hate the shake I'd advise against trying to cook with it. I have a few times and it results in total failure, and I end up with something that resembles and has the texture of soggy cardboard. So put it in water or milk and chug it down.0
-
1. I have a blender bottle and it is awesome. (comes with a little wire ball to help stir/mix)
2. I use plain unsweetened almond milk with my shakes its tastes great. I pay the extra few bucks for the optimum gold standard everyone I've tried tastes great. I take them right after a workout and any day where my protein and calories might be a little low.
I have three of the blender bottles, love them!
Which ON Whey flavors have you tried? I haven't found one that I find to be that great for my tastes. So any recommendations would be great.0 -
AAAnnnnnd, to be a little more annoying and in your face, (SORRY, Lol.. I'm usually mous-y on boards) with Protein Powders they help you reach your Protein Intake for the day, and for some they drink it, some eat food, some do a mixture of both, here's an example of mine today:
Breakfast
Egg Whites
Cheese
= Protein Sources
Post-Workout Shake
Protein Powder, Optimum Whey Gold Standard, Coffee Flavour
Dinner
Spaghetti + Sausages
But tomorrow I work and I want a break from Eggs, so I will have "Sweet Potato Pancakes" a recipe I acquired online from YouTube's "LeanBodyLifeStyle"
1 Sweet Potato, Sml/Medium, cooked, mashed and discarding Skin
1 Scoop of Protein Powder (your choice, Vanilla, Chocolate, W/e)
1/2 Cup Egg Whites/Substitute
1 sp Baking Powder
1 Tsp/TB or Sweetener (Honey, Sugar, Splenda, Stevia)
1 Tsp Vanilla Extract
Spices - Cinnamon, All Spice... Whatever
I made it the other day and it was delicious, but that's because I love Sweet Potatoes, Lol, if you don't, check other recipes, like regular Pancakes with Protein, there's Muffin.s.. seriously, great sources out there. I top mine with a mixture of No-Sugar Added Butter Flavour Syrup and a small dollop of Greek Yogurt, Mmm sprinkled with cinnamon.
Gives you a good Carb source, protein and flavour, and you get guilt-free (for the most part, 'pends on the toppin' Pancakes 0 -
I like the Natural Chocolate ON Whey Protein. I put it in cold water, give a good shake and drink it down. Does not taste bad. If you want to add addditional flavor than Almond Milk is a good choice. One of the best tasting shakes out on the market is Bill Phillip's Right Light Shakes. They are more of a meal replacement and can be a little pricey. I normally have at night put it in a blender with water and ice and it comes out smooth, filling, and taste is awesome.0
-
Some good stuff in this thread. One thing that has not been mentioned is that MFP sets protein goals lower than what most people in the fitness community consider adequate. A commonly sought after goal is 1g of protein per pound of lean bodyweight. That's roughly 200gs/day for me. I basically had to change my eating habits to make sure my protein is adequate. Meals are much more centered around a big hunk of lean meat, usually chicken breast.
I too like Optimum nutrition whey mix, specifically the Chocolate deluxe. Mixed with skim milk, it is very good, but it is not bad with water either. When I'm on caloric restriction I'll use protein mix as a milk in cereal- much more nutrition bang for the buck than milk. The muscletech sold at Sams club tastes bad in my opinion. . I finally finished the bag after nine months. The cytosport at Sams is only marginally better. Pay a little extra for one you will look forward to drinking.
I too prefer real food and have drastically reduced my whey intake. If you are careful what you pay for them, chicken and egg whites (egg beaters)are more satisfying to me and have roughly the same and calorie efficiency and cost per gram as whey protein mixes. Costco is a good place to pick that stuff up, with chicken breast at roughly 2.25 lb here locally.
You can get decent tasting protein bars at walmart that are lower in sugars, the detour brand is not bad. The supreme protein brand tastes really good IMO. They are not as calorie efficient as drinks but I still eat them on occasion when I want a relatively healthy treat.
Casein is a slower acting protein that many people eat before bed. You can buy casein mix, but a lower fat greek yogurt has roughly the same calorie efficiency and is much more satisfying to my appetite. I buy plain and mix with crystal lite or other sugar free drink mixes. You can also mix in a sugar free jelly.
One final suggestion- along with plenty of protein, some basic weightlifting will help you retain muscle mass during weight loss. You will probably lose some muscle anyway, but it will be minimized with some effort on your part. So consider adding at least one resistance training workout a week, two is better, and three would be great if you have the energy for it and feel like it while on caloric restriction.0 -
BTW, Amazon has pretty competitive pricing on Optimum's products..0
-
Agreed... what I should have really said is: A calorie burned\used\spent, is a calorie burned\used\spent... doesn't matter how it was used..don't disagree with that and never did... But you are wrong about burning no calories from a treadmill at .1 incline for 15 minute miles... Every single thing we do requires energy, calories are energy, more specifically macronutrients. You can pick your nose for an hour and burn calories doing so.
Also, the "burn" doesn't matter when it comes to losing weight, being in a caloric deficit at the end of the day is what matters. I do the treadmill at 3.0 speed (20 minute miles) at a 15 degree incline for an hour and burned around 850 calories every single time. That isn't strenuous at all and there's no "burn", I've been doing this since March and have lost 27 pounds... There's a reason bodybuilders do that kind of cardio as well, because it works and it doesn't cause the body go into a catabolic state like fast paced cardio that elevates the heart rate...
Just out of curiosity, how many calories would you use on an elliptical for 20 or so minutes, but keep your heart rate to around where you are when using the treadmill? I think they would be the same, or within a very small %..
I actually tested this last week as I was curious. I use a Garmin Forerunner 210 with HRM (strapped to chest). I did 20min on the elliptical (using arms) and 20min on the treadmill (not counting warm-up and cool down). The goal was to have my HR steady at 150bpm for the entire 20min on both machines.
Results: Effort was the same, so calorie burn was within 8cal (I call that a margin of error).
Elliptical: Level 8, 2.15miles, 63RPM (this is what was required to keep me at 150bpm)
Treadmill: 5.6mph, 2.02miles (this is what was required to keep me at 150bpm)
The kicker was what the "machines" said I burned. Elliptical (which has quite an accurate HR reading) overestimated calorie burn by 45%, while treadmill (which only takes into consideration weight) overestimated by 20%. (obviously, this is based on my stats, so someone that is less active would probably have a higher effort at these levels and thus %variance would be different/lower.
Conclusion: What pretty much was said already: it's not the machine, but the effort you put in. BUT, don't trust everything the machine tells you...cause it might be setting you up to think you've burned more than you actually did...0 -
Atkins shakes are my favorite, especially when I'm having a busy day.0
-
Oh, and about the actual topic from the OP:
I use Promasil Whey Powder (vanilla is by far the best) and have 2 scoops with only water about 20min after my workout. If I find I'm low on protein during my day, I might have an extra scoop in a shake with half a banana, a cup of milk (half almond and half 1%) and a tbs of all natural peanut butter...yum.0 -
WOW! A lot of great information & support. MFP is awesome! Thank you for the recipes & the ideas on how to use the shakes as well as the different kinds available. All of you have helped me a great deal in starting g to become a healthier version of myself:)
If anyone wants another friend, feel free to add me. The support & motivation that is given & received thru MFP is second to none.0 -
Which ON Whey flavors have you tried? I haven't found one that I find to be that great for my tastes. So any recommendations would be great.
Cake Batter is outta control and Extreme Milk Chocolate, is really good too.0 -
I like to use almond milk with my protein powder. Sometimes I add in a tbsp of sugar free butterscotch pudding mix for added flavor. Or I put it in a smoothie to get fruits/protein together.
If I have it in the morning I have to have it in smoothie form or I feel sick. If I have it at night after a workout I can have it with the milk and feel fine.
Wow, I never thought of the pudding idea...I have some sugar/fat free stuff hanging out in my pantry.
Personally, I love using my MRM Dutch Chocolate Whey with Silk Light Original. The soy milk boosts the protein and it's a nice smooth chocolate concoction. Yeah, there's sugar in the soy milk, but less than 1g in the protein powder so it evens out pretty well.0 -
When looking for a protein powder, look for one that has 20-26 grams of protein and no less than 3 g of sugar. I loooooove the protein shake by six star triple chocloate.
I have a recipe you could use:
1 scoop protein powder
1 Cup Almond Milk (Preferrably unsweetened)
1 tbsp of instant coffee
5 ice cubes
Mix in a blender, serve in a chilled glass. Enjoy!!!
or the Peanutbutter cup:
1 Scoop Protein powder
1 Cup Almond Milk (less calories than real milk and better tasting in my opinion)
1 Tbsp Peanut butter (or I like Wow!Butter (which is a soy substitute and tastes just like peanutbutter)
1 stp no sugar chocolate syrup
5 ice cubes
blend in blender and Enjoy.0 -
I have used both vanilla and chocolate and usually replace the protein shake as my breakfast. I lost 20 lbs in 2 weeks doing this! I also do different recipes and change it up alot. I have made a greek yogurt strawberry mix with vanilla protein. Used no sugar orange jello mix mixed with vanilla protein shake to make like a orange creamsicle shake. It's sooo delicious.
Here a few websites you could check out which offer great tasting and different protein shake recipes for every day variety use!!!
http://fatlossschool.com/76-protein-shake-recipes/
http://locarbolicious.com/protein-shake-recipes/
http://mollygalbraith.com/blog/my-favorite-protein-shake-recipes/0 -
1 tbsp of instant coffee
Can't believe I never thought of this!!!!
I tried to mix some into hot coffee and it cooked it into a soggy lump.0 -
I also mix cold coffee into my chocolate protein shake before working out when I need an energy boost. Tastes great!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions