Do roller coasters burn calories?

leavinglasvegas

I know this is kind of silly and I'm not asking because I'm trying to count it in my log.:laugh:

Just curious if anyone has ever use an HRM on a roller coaster. I spent the day at Cedar Point yeasterday and those rides wiped me out! Of course there was ALOT of walking involved as well, but I really think it was the rides that did me in!
Don't know if you've ever been there, but there is a ride called the Mantis, it is a standing roller coaster. I really hurt my leg on that one. I must have shifted my weight just before the first drop and the force really hit me. Then I tried a new ride, The Wicked Twister, and felt like I had run a marathon on the moon when I got off Here is a video of it if you are not familiar:
http://www.cedarpoint.com/_includes/flash/media_player_popup.cfm?videoID=13415&videoWidth=320

Anyway, I'm really curious if you burn calories on crazy rides like that? The heart is racing and the body is all out of whack, what are the physical effects of it besides an adreneline rush? While I did not indulge in the sweets or junkie foods, can they serve a purpose for replacing calories and energy quickly?

♥seoid♥

hummm...i don't think so. you're just sitting down and not doing any working out. sorry. but glad you had fun!

angiered

That depends, how hard did you have to work to pry your hands off of the safety bar?? :laugh:

Seriously, though....Nope. No joy.

iRun4wine

Not sure about that one... but I was wondering the same thing about thinking really, really hard or having a day at work where your brain gets used every minute of the day. I find on days where I really am doing difficult (mentally) work, I come home exhausted and hungry. Maybe it's just a coincidence? :huh:

VballLeash

Kelynn you do burn more calories if you are thinking and doing work like writing and such than if you were just sitting and doing nothing, we did a calorie burn assignment and one of the options was school work sitting in a desk so same kind of thing! Obviously you don't count it but good to know...

The roller coaster thing I don't think your burning cals but hey if your heart rates up and your sweating from being scared than your burning more than sitting around!!

~Leash

Peschuntz

That's similar to asking if watching horror movies burn calories because your heart rate increases. The only way a roller coaster ride or scary movie can assist with your dieting is if you pass away from fear. Corpses don't tend to eat much. Nice try, Wannabea Cullen!

arewethereyet

I read an article once describing the different chemicals released when your adrenaline is pumped up with fear vs. exercise. It is an entirely different process one for fight or flight the other for endurance.

You prob burned 1000 extra calories in the day just from walking and standing in line though!!


:flowerforyou: Jeannie

leavinglasvegas

I did log the walking and that burned over 1400 calories! I did not eat those calories either. I didn't even think of it actually. Of course I don't walk that much on a regular basis so I did count a little less that half of the time as exercize.

BTW: I wasn't asking because I thought it would help with dieting, I was just curious because of the physical impact on the body. I know you are just sitting there; but speed, the changes in the plane of your body, and the physical force have to attribute something to your body. I'd like to know the science behind it. I'm going to google it.

lessertess

Sorry no. An increased heart rate does not equal calorie burn. Otherwise we could all lose weight going to a horror movie film festival. Sounds like a really fun day and all the walking is great!

Tgrey75

You know what? I think that was a great question. My family has season passes to Worlds of Fun and this is the first time i've gone in years. I was wondering the same thing. My heart pumps a little extra harder than others because i have a little "condition". When i ride the rides, my heart races alot, then my legs are really shaky and i'm out of breath for a few minutes. I would think that if you can burn calories while sitting on the floor doing calm, slow, yoga, then why wouldn't you burn a few extra calories with your heart rate up? When you are doing cardio that's what you do, you raise your heart rate to burn the calories. I did however add in all the walking and like you, it was like over 1300 calories. Either way, it's a lot of fun and a good way to exercise.

melindasuefritz

no but walking around the place does

phjorg1

oh jesus ****. you can't be serious..

Ok, just so this sinks in. Your heartrate has ZERO BEARING on calories burned, UNLESS you are ONLY doing steady state cardio in a somewhat climate controlled environment. (very hot temps makes your heart beat faster in an attempt to cool you down, so faster heartrate yet no extra calorie burn. Same thing for being scared. Heartrate goes up, but no calorie burn)

dandandee

I love Cedar Point! great rides
I've never thought of that but it's a good question. judging by what others have said it's not enough to really count for anything, but still more than you would have had you been sitting on the couch.

glad you had fun at the park! and good for you for not indulging in sweets there!

DavPul

I love Cedar Point. And Kings Island. When I lived in Chicago, my cousin and I would take road trips to our aunt's place in Pittsburgh and then hit every amusement park and water park on the way back to Chicago. Good times.










Oh, and the answer to your question is NO

iulia_maddie

They burn so many calories you must be in starvation mode right now.

iWaffle

Roller coasters burn so many calories. You would have to wear an accelerometer and something that measured G-forces to determine the actual calorie burn. You would also need to know the weight of the coaster, the acceleration rate and descent angle of each hill as well as the time taken to descend from the hilltop.

EmilyEmpowered

Ah, best part about living in Ohio is being close to Cedar Point, can not WAIT unti my first trip of the year

Sarauk2sf

I do not think the OP cares as they posted this in 2009 and sometime in the intervening 4 years has deactivated.

ILiftHeavyAcrylics

I do not think the OP cares as they posted this in 2009 and sometime in the intervening 4 years has deactivated.

It's probably because no one was supportive of roller coaster calorie burns. :flowerforyou:

billsica

Tiznonay

Haha, yeah thats quite a thread revival, but im down - its an intriguing question. I feel like you'd have to burn calories on a rollercoaster. Your body is constantly fighting g-forces, plus, if nothing else, you're likely screaming and/or laughing during the ride anyhow. Both those burn calories.

Is it negligible? Yes . . . but still

ahfronk

People don't need to be so rude. Enjoy this article on research done on calories burned riding roller coasters:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/theme-park-rides-lose-you-1691017

nanosuitninja

If you're really bricking it, i'm sure that half the time spent waiting to get on the rides, and also whilst on the ride, your heart rate and respiration is elevated, not to mention adrenaline, so it's possible. but a very unorthodox weight loss plan.

michellechawner

Account deactivated - I assume trolling...

TinaMontella22

You can actually burn up to 500-1000 calories riding roller coasters.

L1zardQueen

TinaMontella22 wrote: »

You can actually burn up to 500-1000 calories riding roller coasters.

Riding? Or being rundown?

Need more info. I love rollercoasters because I could ride them all day long, crowds permitting.

NorthCascades

leavinglasvegas wrote: »

I know this is kind of silly and I'm not asking because I'm trying to count it in my log.:laugh:

Just curious if anyone has ever use an HRM on a roller coaster. I spent the day at Cedar Point yeasterday and those rides wiped me out! Of course there was ALOT of walking involved as well, but I really think it was the rides that did me in!

This is a great example of a situation where an HRM will get it wildly wrong.

Your heart rate really doesn't give any insight into how many calories you're burning. The most accurate ways we have of measuring calorie use all ignore heart rate completely.

You were burning calories while you were walking. And in a BMR sense you were burning them sitting in the coaster too but that's no different than if you were burning them on the couch at home.

Some things are exhausting for reasons that don't have much to do with calories. Like listening to my former boss!

LeanButNotMean44

This thread was started nearly 10 years ago.
Better late than never, I guess? 😂

BrianSharpe

Zombie thread back from the dead!

quiksylver296

BrianSharpe wrote: »

Zombie thread back from the dead!

L1zardQueen