Before or After a workout?

MichelleB1427

Hey All! So I am curious... I've heard it both ways before but I am really trying to get down to the bottom of this. Is it better to eat before or after a cardio workout? I suppose it would depend on what types of food I consume before or after the workout? Please let me know your thoughts!! I would appreciate it. :bigsmile:

Sidesteal

Hey All! So I am curious... I've heard it both ways before but I am really trying to get down to the bottom of this. Is it better to eat before or after a cardio workout? I suppose it would depend on what types of food I consume before or after the workout? Please let me know your thoughts!! I would appreciate it. :bigsmile:

Assuming your total daily nutrition is reasonable, you should really only be concerned about the following primarily:

1) Performance during your cardio bout
2) Personal preference/lifestyle

If you're performing multiple intra-day glycogen depleting events then post workout nutrition may become very important, but if you're just doing cardio once per day and eating something SOMETIME in between your workout and the following days workout (which you probably are) then it's a non issue.


Cliffs: Do whatever you prefer more.

1SlimShaylee

Hey All! So I am curious... I've heard it both ways before but I am really trying to get down to the bottom of this. Is it better to eat before or after a cardio workout? I suppose it would depend on what types of food I consume before or after the workout? Please let me know your thoughts!! I would appreciate it. :bigsmile:

Assuming your total daily nutrition is reasonable, you should really only be concerned about the following primarily:

1) Performance during your cardio bout
2) Personal preference/lifestyle

If you're performing multiple intra-day glycogen depleting events then post workout nutrition may become very important, but if you're just doing cardio once per day and eating something SOMETIME in between your workout and the following days workout (which you probably are) then it's a non issue.


Cliffs: Do whatever you prefer more.

this!

MichelleB1427

Awesome. Thanks!! That has helped

nancy4b2g

I am paying big bucks to learn this with a doctor. Here is what she says. A protein drink before the workout and if your are going to eat after you workout eat within a 45 minute timeframe from exercising. Your metabolism is up and the calories will burn faster but you need protein for your muscles when you work out. So I do both. Plus she has me eating 5 to 6 small meals a day. Hope this helps.

DonniesGirl69

I try to have something before if I'm running early in the AM....at least a banana or a GU pack, but that's just me. I usually run in the evening, though, so I've already spent the day eating before my cardio. After, I generally have low fat chocolate milk as a "recovery" drink. Again, that's what works for me but everyone is different.

virichi08

For ME it depends. If i starved the day before (usually not intentional...) then i might eat a piece of fruit. If all went well the night before then i work out without food. I prefer to workout on an empty stomach... (oddly enough i tend to feel full for agood 10 minutes after a workout)

StarvingDiva

I think everyone is different, eating prior to working out makes me pukey, so I workout fasted and usually eat within an hour after finishing my workout.

ellybeann

I work out every morning (cardio & strength training) I drink a whey shake (made with water) before and eat after.I think it depends on you, I cant eat before not even a bananna.

alvinder_kaur

from what i have learned from my trainer.. he say within one hour of your workout its advisable not to eat anything cause your body cells are active so the food you eat , will then be absorb and retain by the body cells... so it will lead to weight increase.

I have personally tried this for one week, and actually after doing 2 hours intense workout for 7 days... i didnt loose even a pound.
Then on the second week and till 2 months now i tried not to eat anything within the 1 hour after workout.. i can easily loose 4 pounds in a week...

but its true, u need to eat something 45 minutes before workout to give your body energy...

magj0y

My work outs tend to be an hour or so after dinner. When I get home, I typically eat a protein rich snack around 300 cals.
Usually a healthy lunch meat and cheese roll up.

MichelleB1427

Thanks for all of the advice! I dont like to eat before a workout but if it's going to help my body properly I will! lol. Someone told me if I am going to eat Carbs to eat before, if it's Protein to eat after. So I just wanted to clarify. What I have been doing is working well, I was just curious if it was a must or not. I want a healthy body, and if eating before or after will help thats all I care for. thanks again for all the responses!

kiddoc88

Both!
before a workout, not too soon before (don;t want an upset tummy-about an hour or so) you want something higher on the glycemic index or your carbs. I like to think of them as the "kindling" to get your fire started. Carbs are the quick burning fuel that will give you your energy for your workout.
Afterward, you want your meal / more protein. I've heard its important to eat withing 30 min of finishing a workout. The protein is your ' logs' what'll re-fuel and keep you going longer term.
Anyway thats what worked for me. hope my fire analogy makes sense

epmck11

I am paying big bucks to learn this with a doctor. Here is what she says. A protein drink before the workout and if your are going to eat after you workout eat within a 45 minute timeframe from exercising. Your metabolism is up and the calories will burn faster but you need protein for your muscles when you work out. So I do both. Plus she has me eating 5 to 6 small meals a day. Hope this helps.

Wow, you're paying big bucks for that advice? I'd ask for your money back, you're getting ripped off. That's all advice you could get from a 5-10 year old bodybuilding forum, which has all been proven wrong since then.

OP: read Sidesteal's post above and take his advice on this topic.