Favorite Peanut Butter

ToughTulip

Also i just hate skippy. Worst pb ever IMO xD

MindyBlack

^^ Yes, this but i am not to be trusted with it. I once had an incident.

CarleyLovesPets

Crunchy Kraft.

lacreek7

We like the generic Great Value peanut butter from Walmart. It is not as sweet as the JIF which used to be my favorite. I really like the Almond Butter but it's not generic.

Sarah_Wins

Smucker's Natural, one of the few truly natural pb's. Salt and peanuts. SImple as.

harlanJEN

Ohhhhh .... Yumm. My fave subject. Wellll ...almost : ). My friends know I'm pretty passionate about my nut butter. My fridge and pantry have several jars

Used to be a diehard Jif girl. Still LOVE it, but have moved on to natural .

Smuckers Natural Crunchy

branching out from peanut :
Maranatha no-stir crunchy almond
Justin's original almond
Archer Farms (Target). Peanut, almond cashew combo

Honorable mentions / special use : Peanut Butter & Company dark choc dreams and White Choc Wonderful

I think they are too sweet ..but good mixed or smeared on dark chocolate Powercakes www.powercakes.net

And!! Going to start processing up my own nut butters. think of the possible combos : )

taylor5877

Jif for me. I know how negligible any difference is in the "health" value of PB, that I just go with what tastes the best.

You don't miss the salt in the "natural" vs regular versions, so I'll probably be buying it when the time arises.

Disclaimer: if being real freaks you out, don't read any thing further on my post.

A rotation student in our lab had a project to measure the aflatoxin (potent liver toxin and carcinogen produced by aspergillus flavis mold) levels in a variety of peanut butters (spanning "normal", natural, and organic). All had measurable levels of AFB1(the specific type of aflatoxin) and there were more natural PB's than normal that had levels above 10 parts per billion (ppb). The legal limit in PB and corn is 20 ppb. The highest we tested was 13 ppb, and it was a normal shelf stable one (not saying what brand). All were therefore within legal limits.

I ended up eating the remainder of all the PB's we tested.

My personal opinion goes: Jif, natural PBs made from valencia peanuts, Reeses, and natural PB's made from undisclosed peanuts.

Nickiii_123

Adams- Hands down. Its what I grew up eating and it doesn't have sugar in it. I hate eating peanut butter with sugar in it, it just doesn't taste the same to me

I'm curious about the Peanut butter and co., we don't have that in Alaska. Where do they sell it/ can you get it online?

Athena98501

Just looked it up...the PB machines are Whole Foods look awesome! Wish I had one closer!

Fred Meyer stores (owned by Kroger, so may apply to their other stores too) have machines that grind fresh peanut butter, with nothing added but roasted unsalted peanuts. It tastes amazing! It's not as smooth as creamy peanut butter, but not chunky either.

metalvegan

Justin's - one ingredient and no stir!!

V3ggieL0vinGinger

Nuts to You - Organic Natural, Unsalted, Creamy Peanut Butter
I love it so much, and I can get it bulk at my local health food store!

Dee_84

Laura Scudder's.

Peanut butter should have one thing on the ingredients list:peanuts.

^This.

Laura Scudder's is produced by Smuckers, so it might be the same like Smuckers natural, only peanuts and salt.

rumor23

Jiff Mocha Cappuccino hazelnut spread. 230 cal. per 2 tbsp serving. This goes great with reduced sugar Smuckers strawberry spread. Yum! They also have a chocolate hazelnut spread, I haven't tried it yet, I have to finish this jar 1st. You really only need a small amount and it seems to stay with me longer. After lunch, I am good until about 2:30 before I really need a snack.

McBully4

the one that's on sale

lmeola18

Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter!

WickedBean

the one that's on sale

QFT

KimL78

JIF Natural creamy

deo_volente

"Naturally More" with Flax Seed and Flax Oil.

McBully4

JIF Natural creamy

It was BOGO last week my cupboard looks like I won some kind of peanut butter contest.

Meganalva

Peanut Butter & Co- White Chocolate Wonderful


I also love their Cinnamon Raisin Swirl...yummmm

cupcakes_

I like natural peanut butter, but most any kind will do. I live in Canada and buy the President's Choice brand. The only ingredient is peanuts.

jessicalynn75

I like Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter and the Peanut Butter & Co versions. I don't have a Whole Foods or Trader Joe's in my town so it can be difficult to find some of these other brands that have been mentioned on this tread.

alylynn10

Pb2 chocolate! Haven't tried the regular yet but I'm hooked & won't change!

_SpeshK_

Jif Natural Creamy. Yummmm.

laineyluma

the one that's on sale

:drinker:

spicypepper

Skippy or Jiff in my house.

flobeedoodle

Jif Reduced Fat Extra Crunchy. It was off the market for a while, but I just found it again at Target. ("Reduced Fat" should in no way be interpreted to mean that it is healthier than not reduced fat peanut butter. It is probably less healthy. I just like it better. )

kvalmera

I have a new favorite.... Planters Nutrition with banana and granola.. omg its the best!! I am low carbing so I can't eat much but I allow for a tbsp or two sometimes

DianaJaneD

I haven't seen this mentioned, but I adore Smart Balance All Natural Rich Roast Chunky Peant Butter. It tastes and spreads wonderfully and has 320 mg. of omega-3 fats per 2 Tbsp. because they use some flax oil in making it.

Jennacita

Barney Butter