Intermittent Fasting Works...
Treadmillmom1st
Posts: 579 Member
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
0
Replies
-
Works for me too!
There is an IF group here, which I hadn't found until someone pointed it out to me
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/forums/show/66-intermittent-fasting
You might want to look in!0 -
what are u eating on the other days are you sticking to your calorie goals0
-
Me?
I am eating the same foods as I have always eaten, I just bulk out small portions with lots of veg. So veg curries, veg and egg strir fry, tuna mayo and ryvita, chicken salads and casseroles, fruit salads .... anything other than bread, pasta rice etc. Apart form being high in calories I just don't fancy them anymore. Given that I could eat a mountain of mashed potato without feeling full, my husband is finding that very amusing!
I only really count the Down Day calories and make 500kcals a day no problem, occasionally I make the lower end of my 20% allowance, 350kcals, with no hunger or any feeling of deprivation. I have modified a few of these recipes to suit my down day, pudding for lunch, main for tea, that sort of thing!
http://www.goodtoknow.co.uk/recipes/173283/Thinner-dinner-recipes
This really seems to work for me, starting week 6 and not feeling anything other than lighter!0 -
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
i meant this lady
on the days u don,t fast at 600 cals do u follow your normal cals on mfp say 1500 or do u eat at maintanance .
im sorry im not interested in people who eat at 500 cals daily on a regular basis0 -
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
i meant this lady
on the days u don,t fast at 600 cals do u follow your normal cals on mfp say 1500 or do u eat at maintanance .
im sorry im not interested in people who eat at 500 cals daily on a regular basis
If you're not interested, you could've simply "walked away" from this post without being so rude.0 -
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
i meant this lady
on the days u don,t fast at 600 cals do u follow your normal cals on mfp say 1500 or do u eat at maintanance .
im sorry im not interested in people who eat at 500 cals daily on a regular basis
If you're not interested, you could've simply "walked away" from this post without being so rude.
He wasn't rude. He said he isn't interested in people who eat 500 calories daily on a regular basis, and asked what they ate on other days.0 -
And it didn't bother me. Just because I like it doesn't mean everyone will. If ADF/IF/JUDDD etc worked for everyone then, like any other diet, we'd all be doing it.
That given it was a bit abrupt! Then again I'm not interested in people who type in textspeak!
I am fully aware IF sounds like hoodoo and that the science behind it is new in human studies but, as I have access to a wide range of science journals and have read a lot of the bariatric and diabetes studies, amongst others, I am happy that it has benefits other than weight loss, is effective and, even better, it works for me.
Others are free to disagree, that's why there are so many different plans. You just have to hope you find the one that suits you best!0 -
I'm a fan of fasting. I was told to do that by my doctor when I was 17. Unfortunately I didn't stick with it. It isn't for everyone but I did like it. I would do a 'liquid day' every 3 days.0
-
Bump0
-
Bump for later0
-
Bump for later, interesting!0
-
Bump. Looks interesting0
-
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
IF does work....BUT you are still supposed to hit your macros. At least 1200 cals a day +exercise cals.
You just eat them in a specific time window and therefore are "fasting" the other hours of the day.0 -
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
IF does work....BUT you are still supposed to hit your macros. At least 1200 cals a day +exercise cals.
You just eat them in a specific time window and therefore are "fasting" the other hours of the day.
There are different forms of IF. The one the OP is referring to is the 5:2 where you only eat 600 cals (500 for women) on 2 days of the week and eat 'normally' the other 5. You're referring to more leangains I guess? Or there's Warrior and probably loads of others.... just find what suits you personally
0 -
...for me.
I watched this program on BBC Iplayer a couple of weeks ago http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01lxyzc it discusses fasting as a necessary means to good health and maintaining a sharp brain in old health. Anyway the presenter explorers a number of differing fasting techniques and lost a stone in 5 weeks by REDUCING his calorie intake for two days out of seven, so I thought I'd give it a go.
Monday net calorie intake 600, same again Thursday. Now remember net calories is your daily calorie figure after exercise.
Weighed in this morning and 2ibs lost, whoa.
i meant this lady
on the days u don,t fast at 600 cals do u follow your normal cals on mfp say 1500 or do u eat at maintanance .
im sorry im not interested in people who eat at 500 cals daily on a regular basis
If you're not interested, you could've simply "walked away" from this post without being so rude.
He wasn't rude. He said he isn't interested in people who eat 500 calories daily on a regular basis, and asked what they ate on other days.
no i wasn,t being rude and i am a lady too my pic fools everyone , ahah i was asking the op and i should,ve stated that as i saw the horizon programme too , but i will apologies if it came out rude .0 -
Don't apologise, and could you please imagine a smiley at the end of my sentence about textspeak? I thought I had added one but it seems I got that wrong! 0
-
In an ADFer and it works well for my body. Then again it's not surprising really at my weight very little could be more damaging to myself asides from fully starving myself.
I can understand why people are skeptical about it. I've always had the 1200 calories or you won't lose drilled into me. I've had my thyroid tested been on pills (which made me feel terrible) and a whole heap of other stuff.
I've never really had a diet that I've thought I could adopt as a lifestyle until IF.
On my fast days I don't eat at all. Just drink lots of water. This divides opinions even among other IFers. On days I do eat I eat plenty of vegetables (not a fruit fan) protein, carbs and (shock) fat as even on a diet your body still needs those. I also take multi vitamins but I always have so nothing new to that.
The health benefits I'm experiencing can't be argued with but this diet won't work for everyone.
In the last month I've lost a stone, 7lbs of which has been in the last 8 days.
I lost weight quicker on the lighter life diet (meal replacement at 500 calories a day everyday) but I felt crap so stopped, no point losing weight if you feel worse for it.
IF is all about being sensible and adapting to your needs, you need to listen your body (which I've learnt to do now happily)0 -
I saw it too and thought I'd give it a go. I fasted on Tuesday & Friday when I ate 520 calories (was shooting for 500, but oh well....) and ate between 1450ish and 1650ish on the other days = my normal amount, eating back about 50% of exercise calories as I think MFP overestimates in some cases.
Result? I have lost 3.4lbs, breaking the plateau I've been sitting on for over 3 weeks.
I'm planning on continuing - you can vary the fast day to suit your schedule & I like to spread the calories out over lunch & dinner. I have found that in the day or two after fasting I get hungry quicker than normal - looking for lunch by late morning & for dinner a bit earlier than we normally eat. Otherwise nothing to report except weight loss. 0 -
I watched the programme too and found it extremely interesting. I have decided to give it a go but so far have refrained as I don't want to just jump into it without working out a good plan of action. It was more than the weight loss - well actually the weight loss was a beneficial side effect - it was to do with mental and physical health and well being. The only thing I think I would reccommend to anyone who wants to try this, is to make sure that the 500/600 calories that they eat on the fast day are made up of good nutritional food - I am not a fan of shakes or artificial supplements - after all the aim is to be not only slimmer but healthier too.0
-
I saw it too and thought I'd give it a go. I fasted on Tuesday & Friday when I ate 520 calories (was shooting for 500, but oh well....) and ate between 1450ish and 1650ish on the other days = my normal amount, eating back about 50% of exercise calories as I think MFP overestimates in some cases.
Result? I have lost 3.4lbs, breaking the plateau I've been sitting on for over 3 weeks.
I'm planning on continuing - you can vary the fast day to suit your schedule & I like to spread the calories out over lunch & dinner. I have found that in the day or two after fasting I get hungry quicker than normal - looking for lunch by late morning & for dinner a bit earlier than we normally eat. Otherwise nothing to report except weight loss.
ah this is the answer i was looking for ta very much i think i will try it ta very mucho lol
0 -
IF is the biz
Absolutely love it, makes everything so easy and my appetite for junk is subsided and I'm never hungry!0 -
Another success here:
First week 5:2 ADF
Weight Loss: 4.4 Lbs
Average Daily Input Calories: 1,642
Total Exercise Calories: 3,060
Weekly Net Calories: 8,434
Est. TDEE with 1.2 Mult: 19,303
19,303
-8,434
10,869
= 3.1 Estimated Weight Loss for week
3,500
It is worth noting that this week I had two days which were over my typical calories goals without exercise and one day I was over my goal, but had exercise to cover it. It is worth noting that because of the two 'fast' days that my average daily Calorie intake was right on my goal. I am a little concerned about the difference between the calculation and the actual result so I must conclude that there might be an anomaly in the measured weight, but I would expect if there is a problem with the number that it should flush itself out with next week's data. So far it is a pretty cool experiment and I look forward to week two.0 -
MFP allowance is 1320 but I usually eat 1800 - 2000 exercise approx 300 calories.0
-
I read about this a while ago but I never stuck with it long enough to see if it worked. I think I did it for a week and forgot about it. Here's the resource I was given on IF.
Download me ---> http://uranus.ckt.net/~gochiefs/Eat Stop Eat.pdf0 -
Sweet0
-
Just to add a quick note regarding the health benefits of fasting as highlighted in the programe, my grandmother died just short of her 100th birthday.
She had one hearing aid and wore specticles.
She was on no medication.
She was an active member of her church and read allot.
She'd walk to the grocery store, cook, clean and do laundry.
For most of her adult life she'd fast for 24 hours every week, for religious reasons, not health.
As they say 'the proof is in the pudding'.0 -
It doesn't work for me, but I'm glad if it works for others. We all have to find what is best for us.
A lot of times I eat only one meal a day because I just don't feel like having more. But when I tried going to one meal a day as a form of intermittent fasting, I found that on days when I was forcing myself not to have a snack of cheese or a second, small meal I got pretty sick and very mean.
Oh well, it was worth trying to see if it would speed up weight loss a bit.0 -
Bump0
-
I saw it too and thought I'd give it a go. I fasted on Tuesday & Friday when I ate 520 calories (was shooting for 500, but oh well....) and ate between 1450ish and 1650ish on the other days = my normal amount, eating back about 50% of exercise calories as I think MFP overestimates in some cases.
Result? I have lost 3.4lbs, breaking the plateau I've been sitting on for over 3 weeks.
I'm planning on continuing - you can vary the fast day to suit your schedule & I like to spread the calories out over lunch & dinner. I have found that in the day or two after fasting I get hungry quicker than normal - looking for lunch by late morning & for dinner a bit earlier than we normally eat. Otherwise nothing to report except weight loss.0 -
bump0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions