Anyone else do alternate day Intermittent Fasting?
CatholicUK
Posts: 88 Member
Just curious if there's many of us on here! Plenty of 18:6 and those who do 5/2, but not many like me who fast on alternate days - if you're out there please add me up!
0
Replies
-
bump!0
-
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.0
-
Hi I've started the 5:2 this week, found my second day really hard but thinking of my Hairy Dieters Korma sand eating today kept me going. What made you choose ADF, did you see the horizon programme?0
-
Perhaps you should ask this in the Intermittent fasting group. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/49-intermittent-fasting0
-
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx0 -
Hi I've started the 5:2 this week, found my second day really hard but thinking of my Hairy Dieters Korma sand eating today kept me going. What made you choose ADF, did you see the horizon programme?
Yes, the Horizon programme very much intrigued me. Mostly by the neurological benefits it offers too - fascinating! xx0 -
Perhaps you should ask this in the Intermittent fasting group. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/49-intermittent-fasting
Already have done hun, so now I'm asking on here xx0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic?
edited to add...
problematic for those who are at risk of developing an eating disorder..as said in my initial post.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
read my post--nowhere did i call it an eating disorder. i know very well what it is..but intermittent fasting (as a shortened eating window) is one thing...fasting completely every other day is another. and no, it is not ideal for someone who is at risk of developing an eating disorder. maybe you should try googling that.0 -
Perhaps you should ask this in the Intermittent fasting group. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/49-intermittent-fasting
Already have done hun, so now I'm asking on here xx
Asking in a open forum is like throwing raw meat to wolves. You see to handle those sort of responses well so far, so have at it.
I have don't ADF before, I prefer the one of two 24 hour fasts of ESE.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.
I fast one or two 24 fasts a week. I am rarely hungry during the fast. Frankly, being constantly full of food is more unnatural if you look back previous to the last hundred to two hundred years.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.
That's not how it works. You're misinformed. You're suppose to be counting your calories and protein intake for 2 days instead of one. For instance, if i fast tomorrow then I will normally eat 4 to 5k calories for two days.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
I'm just going to go ahead and call you a fear monger. You try and scare people without any hard research to back you up. What eating disorder are you talking about and what research paper can you find to back up your claim?0 -
There is an alternate day diet/fast group and a Judd group (Dr Johnson up down day diet) on MFP. I combine Judd, ese, and leangains depending on my schedule etc. Research studies such as alternate day show that people who fast (500-800 calories) on alternate days do not make up all those calories on up (non-fast) days.
Fasting also has enormous health benefits)0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.
I fast one or two 24 fasts a week. I am rarely hungry during the fast. Frankly, being constantly full of food is more unnatural if you look back previous to the last hundred to two hundred years.
So you mean to tell me that during the past hundred years, farmers, construction workers, and blue collar factory workers that lived by the sweat of their brows performing grueling manual labor jobs would feel better during a fast? I'm sure they preferred to eat a hearty big breakfast before heading out on their exhausting work days. Purposely fasting for the sake of weight loss doesn't make sense to me. It's completely unnecessary for weight loss and the weight loss rate juxtaposed to eating on a daily basis is negligible for those with a significant amount of weight to lose and probably non-existent for those with lower body fat %.0 -
I fast daily from 10pm-2pm but every once in a while ill go from 8pm-8pm.0
-
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
I'm just going to go ahead and call you a fear monger. You try and scare people without any hard research to back you up. What eating disorder are you talking about and what research paper can you find to back up your claim?
I see you lack in reading comprehension skills.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.
That's not how it works. You're misinformed. You're suppose to be counting your calories and protein intake for 2 days instead of one. For instance, if i fast tomorrow then I will normally eat 4 to 5k calories for two days.
I know exactly how IF and alternate day fasting works. Not only do I work part time at a gym as a trainer, I've got my Master's Degree in Food and Nutritional Sciences and work in the Food Industry. So please, spare me the lesson.0 -
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.
That's not how it works. You're misinformed. You're suppose to be counting your calories and protein intake for 2 days instead of one. For instance, if i fast tomorrow then I will normally eat 4 to 5k calories for two days.
I know exactly how IF and alternate day fasting works. Not only do I work part time at a gym as a trainer, I've got my Master's Degree in Food and Nutritional Sciences and work in the Food Industry. So please, spare me the lesson.
So how am i starving myself if I'm eating all my calorie and protein requirement in one setting? Fear monger?0 -
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/fasting-weight-loss/#axzz24iM2oyo1
http://www.naturalnews.com/034704_intermittent_fasting_fitness_HGH.html
http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html
At the end of the day it really boils down to convenience!
If you are cutting calories and want to have larger meals and not feel like you are eating birdfood, fast!
I'd rather have 2-3 large meals and get **** done first thing in the morning than have to worry about eating every 2-3 hours.
The thermic effect of food is the same.
If you do ADF make sure you up the calories on regular eating days to about TDEE or 10% below.
This helps with the hormonal effects and will help you lose fat while maintaining LBM.
Also, lifting makes the world of a difference!0 -
I love food too much!lol But I have done the 3-day diet...mostly to prove to myself that I could do it. Tried it again 4 days later...Epic Fail!Haha I fast from about 12am-10am...while I'm sleeping
I don't know much about the health benefits/hazards of fasting, so I'm not even going there....Hope you find a group! 0 -
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/fasting-weight-loss/#axzz24iM2oyo1
http://www.naturalnews.com/034704_intermittent_fasting_fitness_HGH.html
http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html
At the end of the day it really boils down to convenience!
If you are cutting calories and want to have larger meals and not feel like you are eating birdfood, fast!
I'd rather have 2-3 large meals and get **** done first thing in the morning than have to worry about eating every 2-3 hours.
The thermic effect of food is the same.
If you do ADF make sure you up the calories on regular eating days to about TDEE or 10% below.
This helps with the hormonal effects and will help you lose fat while maintaining LBM.
Also, lifting makes the world of a difference!
I'm rather sure the intermittent fasting touted on lean gains is an 18:4 or 16:8 regimen NOT every other day fasting. quite a difference. I'd much rather not compromise my training by being incredibly weak on fasting days--and instead do a 16:8 or something similar so that my energy levels don't plummet and I can actually maintain strength and LBM. I highly doubt that an individual fasting every other day would be able to maintain a comparable intensity during their workouts if they are FASTING every other day.0 -
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/fasting-weight-loss/#axzz24iM2oyo1
http://www.naturalnews.com/034704_intermittent_fasting_fitness_HGH.html
http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html
At the end of the day it really boils down to convenience!
If you are cutting calories and want to have larger meals and not feel like you are eating birdfood, fast!
I'd rather have 2-3 large meals and get **** done first thing in the morning than have to worry about eating every 2-3 hours.
The thermic effect of food is the same.
If you do ADF make sure you up the calories on regular eating days to about TDEE or 10% below.
This helps with the hormonal effects and will help you lose fat while maintaining LBM.
Also, lifting makes the world of a difference!
I'm rather sure the intermittent fasting touted on lean gains is an 18:4 or 16:8 regimen NOT every other day fasting. quite a difference. I'd much rather not compromise my training by being incredibly weak on fasting days--and instead do a 16:8 or something similar so that my energy levels don't plummet and I can actually maintain strength and LBM. I highly doubt that an individual fasting every other day would be able to maintain a comparable intensity during their workouts if they are FASTING every other day.
True that LG is about 16:8 but he does endorse and speak highly of Brad Pilon on ADF and ESE.
Besides, usinf ADF would be optimal on rest days and not on lift days where you would want the nutrients.
I'm sure OP isnt lifting in the proper regimen to see any difference.
She would probably spin her wheels trying any fasting program.
OP my advice is to find a good deficit of 15-20% below TDEE if you plan to lose fat.
wouldnt worry about fasting unless its convenient.0 -
i regularly go 15 or 16 hours between my last meal of the day and breakfast the next day and I'm rarely hungry during that time. sometimes i even go 24 hours ( not always on purpose) but i still try and get all my needed nutrients.0
-
hmmm..i sincerely hope you rethink this plan. especially if you have any propensity to develop an eating disorder.
Sweetheart, that is the craziest thing I've ever read xx
crazy because you wouldn't be likely to develop an eating disorder or crazy because you think that the plan, in general, isn't likely to be problematic.
You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Intermittent fasting, though not for everyone, is a very healthy thing to practice. If you don't believe me, then try Googling it. It is not an eating disorder.
You don't see a problem with purposely forcing yourself to go without food? I can't imagine why people chose to endure hunger for the sake of weight loss, when it's completely unnecessary.
That's not how it works. You're misinformed. You're suppose to be counting your calories and protein intake for 2 days instead of one. For instance, if i fast tomorrow then I will normally eat 4 to 5k calories for two days.
I know exactly how IF and alternate day fasting works. Not only do I work part time at a gym as a trainer, I've got my Master's Degree in Food and Nutritional Sciences and work in the Food Industry. So please, spare me the lesson.
So how am i starving myself if I'm eating all my calorie and protein requirement in one setting? Fear monger?
Again, you've demonstrated your lack of reading comprehension skills. Please point out where I said starving is the same thing as IF or ADF. It's not the same. Starvation is the result of severe malnutrition, the result of extended caloric, vitamin and mineral deficiency. Very different than IF and ADF which are self induced short term intervals of abstaining from food with the goal of fat loss and minimizing muscle loss. Both are achieveable without fasting so why bother?0 -
Again, you've demonstrated your lack of reading comprehension skills. Please point out where I said starving is the same thing as IF or ADF. It's not the same. Starvation is the result of severe malnutrition, the result of extended caloric, vitamin and mineral deficiency. Very different than IF and ADF which are self induced short term intervals of abstaining from food with the goal of fat loss and minimizing muscle loss. Both are achieveable without fasting so why bother?
Isnt starvation a lack of food up to and exceeding 72 hours?
WTF is this other guy talking about?
O.o0 -
Again, you've demonstrated your lack of reading comprehension skills. Please point out where I said starving is the same thing as IF or ADF. It's not the same. Starvation is the result of severe malnutrition, the result of extended caloric, vitamin and mineral deficiency. Very different than IF and ADF which are self induced short term intervals of abstaining from food with the goal of fat loss and minimizing muscle loss. Both are achieveable without fasting so why bother?
Isnt starvation a lack of food up to and exceeding 72 hours?
WTF is this other guy talking about?
O.o
In bro science maybe but nutritional journals defines starvation as eating less then 50% your maintenance. Eating all your calories and protein in one setting is not a starvation diet until you dip below that 50%.0 -
I haven't heard of this. what is it and how is it beneficial to your health??? Interesting.
:glasses:0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions