keeping up metabolism and losing 5 lbs a week?
tiatiamaria
Posts: 40 Member
hi everyone, i got a fitbit and have been researching and trying to understand it all quite a bit. I concluded that I can eat 1200 calories a day and burn 1200 calories a day and end up with a deficit of 2410 (my BMR) a day for an approx loss of 5lbs a week. Now I know many people say to not eat below your BMR but I am trying hard to lose 5 lbs a week before my beach vacation in October. (So only about 5 weeks of doing this) Could I do this plan for the next month and a half and then go back to trying to lose 2 lbs a week or will my metabolism be screwed up? Will staying at 1200 calories a day be the key to keeping my metabolism up or will I ruin it? Thanks for your help!
0
Replies
-
Don't lose more than 1-2 per week...it's not worth it.0 -
First, 1200 calories a day is the suggested net intake on MFP - not gross dietary calories eaten. You may already know that but many people new here are confused by the site's presentation of information and lack of clarity.
Honestly, there simply aren't many studies that have been done on massive caloric deficits (50% or below) and the effect on energy expenditure. Thus, there is really no way to accurately measure the degree of decline in energy expenditure or your Resting Metabolic Rate after two months at such a deficit. The famous Minnesota Experiment lasted six months and the men experienced a 40% decline in energy expenditure. Even given that example, you can't even estimate what that would mean for you because you are a woman and would be assuming a much larger deficit...
One thing you can likely count on, if you assume that large of a deficit, is: depressed Resting Metabolic Rate, reduced leptin levels, increased cortisol levels, and a likelihood of reduction in RMR due to loss of muscle mass.
Also, the vast majority of that 5 lb weight loss will come from water weight with some muscle loss, not true fat loss. This is especially true if you have been dieting or sustaining a caloric deficit for some time.0 -
I think you will crash and burn inside of a week or two.0
-
hi everyone, i got a fitbit and have been researching and trying to understand it all quite a bit. I concluded that I can eat 1200 calories a day and burn 1200 calories a day and end up with a deficit of 2410 (my BMR) a day for an approx loss of 5lbs a week. Now I know many people say to not eat below your BMR but I am trying hard to lose 5 lbs a week before my beach vacation in October. (So only about 5 weeks of doing this) Could I do this plan for the next month and a half and then go back to trying to lose 2 lbs a week or will my metabolism be screwed up? Will staying at 1200 calories a day be the key to keeping my metabolism up or will I ruin it? Thanks for your help!
You're joking right? 2410 deficit. Very bad idea. Hair loss, muscle loss, bone loss, fatigue, exhaustion, dehydration, maybe even a bonus trip to the hospital. It's unhealthy and dangerous...and quite honestly moronic.0 -
Don't lose more than 1-2 per week...it's not worth it.
rofl when a single facepalm is never enough0 -
So you are going to try and live on 0 calories for 5 weeks? :noway:
If you need to lose 5 lbs a week the only thing I can suggest is liposuction or amputation.
Forget metabolism worries, this kind of diet will put you in hospital. I seriously advise against it. Aim for 2 lbs a week max.0 -
Thanks so much for your answers (especially geekyjock.) That makes a lot of sense. I didn't realize I should be netting a minimum of 1200. You are right, there are a lot of things on here that are not clear but that does clear it up. Sounds like you have done your research! And it sounds like that extra few pounds won't be worth it to lose quickly.
Lizziebeth, no I wasn't "joking." The extreme weight loss show gives the extremely obese a caloric deficit of 3500 a day and they lose a pound a week, so in my mind it was possible to do slightly less for a slightly smaller person. I think there are a lot of people who don't understand the specifics of how to lose weight the "right way." I certainly am one of them. If there was a clear cut answer, I wouldn't have struggled with my weight my entire life.
The big question here.... what is the maximum deficit that would be healthy? I know they say 1000 a day for a 2 pound a week loss as an overall, but this applies to people of all weights. If people on the weightloss show who weight 350+ can deficit 3500 a day (from a licensed nutritionalist and fitness coach) and seem to be pretty healthy, what can someone who weighs 250ish deficit? It seems like a fair assumption that the bigger you are, the bigger you can expect to lose each week or the more you of a calorie deficit you can give yourself. People who don't have much to lose need to stick to 2 lbs a week... but what about me?0 -
but what about me ?
Good question, we don't know anything about you. If you were obese you could run a deficit of 1200+ calories per day but that needs 40 lbs of excess fat to fuel it. Is that you ?
A deficit of 10 - 15% is a gradual weight loss and easier to manage, but it does mean a long wait if you have a lot to lose. So starting with a larger deficit and tapering off is usually recommended.0 -
Ah, remember they are doing this for ratings and under the supervision of a doctor.
To lose weight safely and quickly I would:
Aim for a deficit giving you 2 lbs per week weight loss. You can up your exercise and for a short time only eat back half your calories (I do this for a week every now and then to bump a plateau. It is not healthy long term. Drink lots of water to help flush your system and eat as clean as possible. People who have more to lose tend to lose more easily anyway.
You won't work miracles in 5 weeks but it will be a start. For the rest I suggest Spanx.0 -
Thanks so much for your answers (especially geekyjock.) That makes a lot of sense. I didn't realize I should be netting a minimum of 1200. You are right, there are a lot of things on here that are not clear but that does clear it up. Sounds like you have done your research! And it sounds like that extra few pounds won't be worth it to lose quickly.
Lizziebeth, no I wasn't "joking." The extreme weight loss show gives the extremely obese a caloric deficit of 3500 a day and they lose a pound a week, so in my mind it was possible to do slightly less for a slightly smaller person. I think there are a lot of people who don't understand the specifics of how to lose weight the "right way." I certainly am one of them. If there was a clear cut answer, I wouldn't have struggled with my weight my entire life.
The big question here.... what is the maximum deficit that would be healthy? I know they say 1000 a day for a 2 pound a week loss as an overall, but this applies to people of all weights. If people on the weightloss show who weight 350+ can deficit 3500 a day (from a licensed nutritionalist and fitness coach) and seem to be pretty healthy, what can someone who weighs 250ish deficit? It seems like a fair assumption that the bigger you are, the bigger you can expect to lose each week or the more you of a calorie deficit you can give yourself. People who don't have much to lose need to stick to 2 lbs a week... but what about me?
The contestants on extreme weight loss shows are closely monitored by Doctors. 2 pounds of week is the maximum recommended for healthy weight loss and this number is not for people who don't have a lot to lose (in fact people who only have a few pounds to lose it's only recommended 1/2lb to 1lb).0 -
haha..Spanx, good idea! .. do they make them to fit under swimsuits hehe?
Thanks for the extra tips.
As a side note...I'm sure there are many benefits to exercising such as heart health and toning, but it just seems strange to me that I am supposed to eat back those calories (after this initial 5 lbs a week thing.) Almost seems like the exercise becomes pointless... but I know that it doesn't. But does anyone else see how that seems weird?
About me... female, 5'6'', 256lb, 27yr. So, can I lose more than 2 a week reasonably? At least for a little while?0 -
Still a bad idea. Not even close to healthy OR safe.
You are really willing to risk your health for some vanity outing in a swimsuit?
Burning that much could cause you to be sick, weak, faint, and such.
*facepalm*0 -
I understand where you're coming from. But please be realistic. Yes, you have some weight to lose. I do too. Even if you lose a few pounds by your trip, chances are you'll gain them back during your vacation. Better to decide that you are serious about losing and start today.
As for the exercise? Okay you eat 1200 cals a day. Maybe your BMR is that low (but I doubt it because I was your weight when I started and it was much higher) so the 1200 cals you just ate is keeping your body going (you know brain, lungs, etc). Now you ask your body to exercise and use 1200 cals to fuel your work out. Where does you body get this from? You've used all your food to stay alive. You can do this for a few days - but should you? Will the weight loss be worth falling over?
Find a bathing suit and cover up that you feel good in. Put on a smile and enjoy yourself. It's hard to do, but you don't want to put your life on hold until you are at goal.0 -
This is really a better question to ask a doctor, rather than a group on the Internet. A professional who knows your complete health history can go a lot further to help you plan a diet/exercise regime, and may be able to advise you on how much you can expect to lose per week. Keep in mind that not all weeks will be the same!
MFP is full of a lot of people with a lot of different health and fitness philosophies. I find it more confusing than helpful to try and sort out the truth in all the vastly different ideas here. It's definitely cool to see so many approaches, just not something I'd recommend to build one coherent plan.0 -
haha..Spanx, good idea! .. do they make them to fit under swimsuits hehe? Thanks for the extra tips.
As a side note...I'm sure there are many benefits to exercising such as heart health and toning, but it just seems strange to me that I am supposed to eat back those calories (after this initial 5 lbs a week thing.) Almost seems like the exercise becomes pointless... but I know that it doesn't. But does anyone else see how that seems weird?
About me... female, 5'6'', 256lb, 27yr. So, can I lose more than 2 a week reasonably? At least for a little while?
Eating your exercise calories back makes perfect sense to me. You're given a calorie goal number by MFP that already has a sufficient deficit built into it that you need for safe weight loss. Let's just go with 1200...this is the number you need to NET. If you eat 1200 calories and then exercises and burn 500, you have now ONLY netted 700 which is considered unhealthy and not enough calories to support all your bodily functions. Remember your body burns calories even in it's sleep so it's important to give it enough fuel. Eating too few calories can also cause your metabolism to slow down, become sluggish and hit a plateau. Your best bet is to -
Eat within the calorie goal MFP has given you
Eat lot's of fresh whole foods
Get enough protein (MFP is too low) you should strive for 100g
Exercise!!!!!!!!!! That's cardio and STRENGTH TRAINING
drink lot's of water
invest in a more expensive bathing suit that will flatter your figure...the cheapos tend to have zero support
kick *kitten* until October and then go enjoy your vacation0 -
You say you're looking to lose 5 lbs weekly. How about you not focus on the scale & just really focus on exercise. Inches are more noticeable than the # on the scale.0
-
I will give my opinion (getting ready for the lashings) I burn as many calories as i eat a day and have for the last 9 months every once in a while i take a day off. Most iv lost in a week was 8 lbs. When i was in the high to mid 300s i was working out 2 hrs a day and i was loosing on avg of 4.5 lbs a week "main thing is i was in the 300s" so i had a lot of fat to be able to burn for fuel.
I cycle 100-150 miles a week, I am benching 315 and just started doing mud runs. Saying all of this i still have about 40 lbs to loose and i have lost 35% of my body weight. I am perfectly healthy /skins great/ muscles are getting toned and i don't get sick anymore.
Main thing is don't listen to anyone except your body, it is the only thing that matters. You want to be healthy while loosing weight. I eat 1800 healthy calories a day. When im hungry i eat, before i work out i eat, when i wake up i eat.0 -
How heavy are you? Because my BMR is like 2500 (i eat between 1200-1500 a day) so if I ate 0 cals id barely lose 4 pounds. Cmon smarten up a bit.
edit: And eating back calories is the most counter productive thing if you are trying to lose weight (NOT bodybuilding). You might as well not exercise.0 -
haha..Spanx, good idea! .. do they make them to fit under swimsuits hehe? Thanks for the extra tips.
As a side note...I'm sure there are many benefits to exercising such as heart health and toning, but it just seems strange to me that I am supposed to eat back those calories (after this initial 5 lbs a week thing.) Almost seems like the exercise becomes pointless... but I know that it doesn't. But does anyone else see how that seems weird?
About me... female, 5'6'', 256lb, 27yr. So, can I lose more than 2 a week reasonably? At least for a little while?
I am about 271lbs and 5'11. I know I am taller than you but probably close to the same size around. 5lbs a week at 5 weeks would be 25 lbs and it is just not worth it to risk your health like that. It will not make that huge of a difference in your bathing suite! You should really think LONG TERM Goals here and shoot for 1.5-2 lbs per week. You will burn yourself out so bad that you may lose faith in yourself and stop the journey all together. Just know that if you take it slow and steady you will get there one day. The weight did not come on over night and you can't hope it to come off over night!0 -
MFP confused me with the net and deficit thing already built in too, so I read a suggestion somewhere that has helped me, at least visually. It probably wont be great for most because it requires a little math
I take out the deficit - i over write whatever MFP says with 500 more or whatever I calculate my normal base calorie expenditure actually is (I ended up with 1500 since I am pretty sedentary - but trying!). It will increase that as I exercise, but whatever is showing is approximately what I *really* am burning. Usually it ends up around 1900 by the end of the day, so I am eating between 1300-1400 most days, more if I exercise a lot, less if I dont (which really is about how it should be?)
Then I just aim to finish out the day at 500 less than that. I dont think of it as "eating my exercise calories", although that is what it is. I just know I want to eat 500 less per day than I burn, so I lose about a pound a week. If you want to lose 2 pounds a week, aim to finish out the day 1000 less than your allowance. It is just much more upfront this way for me than thinking about that hidden thing going on.
It also helps because I know that on my "bad" days, I can go ALL the way up to the total shown and not "blow it" since that is my maintenance calories - what I need to stay right where I am. A day here and there of ending up almost at my allowance wont hurt me one bit other than slow down weight loss. But no gaining if I dont go over. Makes me much less hard on myself.
Agree with the others - make it something you can sustain, not something you want to accomplish all at once. Try to lose 10 pounds over the next 5 weeks and then celebrate on your vacation knowing that you have the system figured out now and next year you will be way beyond that initial 25 you wanted. Honestly, at over 200 pounds even with losing 25 pounds quickly - you wont notice enough of a change in your body to be worth the risk! Get a good shaping suit and enjoy yourself healthily! (is that a word?!)0 -
How heavy are you? Because my BMR is like 2500 (i eat between 1200-1500 a day) so if I ate 0 cals id barely lose 4 pounds. Cmon smarten up a bit.
edit: And eating back calories is the most counter productive thing if you are trying to lose weight (NOT bodybuilding). You might as well not exercise.
says a guy eating 1200 cals. lololol0 -
Even if you could lose 25 pounds in 5 weeks, at 256 pounds now you will still be obese in October. You'll be 231...why are you willing to risk your health and still be very fat at the end? Isn't it better to lose weight in a reasonable healthy manner and end up slender and at a healthy weight?0
-
You won't work miracles in 5 weeks but it will be a start. For the rest I suggest Spanx.
truth.0 -
I have been using fitnesspal and it instructs me to eat 1200 calories/day plus the amount I accumulate with exercise. I try to stay in the 1200 range even if I DO exercise. I never really go above 1400. I'm not sure if that's the best way, but the fitnesspal app doesn't tell me I'm eating too little as long as I eat at LEAST 1200 calories total, not net.
The best advice I can give is to really go hard with exercise. You might not lose POUNDS, but your body will LOOK different. Don't eat less than 1200 calories no matter what. Your body needs it to do it's everyday functions. Also, don't eat crap. Eat healthy whole foods (beans, brown rice, salads, no dairy, poultry instead of beef/pork, fruit, veggies, nuts). These are basics, but honestly, I'm sure you want to look and feel good...not be a certain weight.
I have lost 2 pounds in 2 weeks...but people are asking me "how much weight have you lost" because the exercise changes your body. I do spinning...now THAT'S an intense workout...and jogging (make sure you have good shoes).
Good luck to you.0 -
I know it isn't mentioned a lot but there is a reason for the 2 lbs/week recommendation and someone in the mid 200s would certainly qualify.
Basically, your body is composed of various energy stores including glycogen, fat and muscle tissue. The body likes its glycogen stores as they are quick energy for the muscles and important in flight of fight situations. Fat is an important long term storage and muscle tissue is what helps you maintain your activity.
So if you cut your calories to a moderate level where your body isn't shocked, it is pretty willing to keep your metabolism as-is and shed a couple lbs of fat. You cut your calories to a drastic level and your body starts thinking that it needs to conserve. Now this may be that your body tries to slow down your metabolism but your body also tries to rid itself of what also burns calories 24 hours/day and that is muscle. So 2 lbs/week is generally an optimum fat loss number but more than that, you are more likely losing more muscle than you would otherwise. Since muscle burns fat, this is really not a good idea.0 -
edit: And eating back calories is the most counter productive thing if you are trying to lose weight (NOT bodybuilding). You might as well not exercise.
Please stop.0 -
edit: And eating back calories is the most counter productive thing if you are trying to lose weight (NOT bodybuilding). You might as well not exercise.
Please stop.
arghhhhhhh. once again......the deficit you need is already built into the calorie number MFP gives you. this website is designed with the intention that YOU EAT YOUR EXERCISE CALORIES BACK. if you don't you are not consuming enough calories and thus the reason why so many people flood the forums asking why have they plateaued. Eat your exercise calories, fuel your body, be kind to your body! :flowerforyou:0 -
http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/
Find your BMR and TDEE and eat slightly above your BMR, but below your TDEE. Do cardio and strength training. Measure your body by body fat percentage, inches lost on different parts of your body (bicep, calf, stomach, breasts, heips, neck, thigh, etc.) congratulate yourself for any non-scale victories and try not to weigh more than once a week....or at least only count your weigh in once per week.
Remember that TOM adds 2-10 pounds of water weight depending on your body and it takes about a week post TOM for it to go away on its own. It's natural, so don't beat yourself up over it.
Let's see...cut out processed foods, up your protein and veggie intake to way above what MFP suggests, cut your carbs (in this sense of the word "carbs" I mean, pasta, refined flour and not healthy complex carbs gained from vegetables and whole grains.)
Aim to lose 1-2 pounds a week and to be healthy, look healthy and avoid a hospital stay lol cus what you are suggesting could very well put you there.
Keep asking questions and don't let meanies deter you. Friend those that actually help you and ask them more questions.
**note...I eat my BMR which is 2300 a day and consistently am losing weight as do all of the people I look up to on this site who have met their goals. Yes, there are other ways of doing it...but this way, for me, has been sustainable and I feel amazing.0 -
NO.
Please do not destroy your metabolism!! Just eat like 2000 calories and begin strength training along with cardio! Strength training is key here.0 -
Large calorie deficit is for people who live sedentary lives and can't become active (have children, work 3 jobs, in school most the time, etc). I know people will reply "but you can STILL fit in time to exercise" but all I have to say STFU and adopt a child so you can see what it's like. And I do believe that there are people out there that SHOULD risk having their lean muscle mass eaten, because that is the ONLY way the fat is coming off until their circumstances change and they have the time/energy to exercise.
People who are telling you to eat 2000 calories a day are also leading active lives and have the confidence gained from "doing it wrong" at some point. If you can't be active, then a deficit is the best option you have. 5 lbs a week is a bit outrageous expectations though; you'd be better off shooting for 2 or 3 max.
My take on it is this: As long as what you're putting IN your body is 100% nutritious and has absolutely 0 empty calories, why would it matter if you are under your BMR or daily required. The point of dieting is to be at a deficit. These people just live in fear that they will never repair their metabolism. Don't listen to the fear mongers, do whatever you feel is safe.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions