Picking the right running shoe........

Before all of you suggest me to go to a professional running shoe store and get fitted, thats not an possible right now! We live hours from the closest mall / shoe store so thats where I need your help. I'm looking for a good running shoe for a somewhat new runner. I run 4 miles every other day, I'm flat footed and strike with my heel but I don't roll or at least not much. I have looked on runners world and they have given me some suggestions but I want to hear from "real" people what shoe works for them. I mostly run on the road.

Replies