Anyone successfully lose weight eating 1200 cal or less?
Replies
-
yes...as of last monday i have lost 103 .. eating 1200 cals... occationally i do go above and some times less but mostly 1200. and it is healthy.0
-
I think the title should read: Anyone successfully lose muscle eating 1200 cal or less?
I know what the answer will be. Have fun starving yourselves.
You can maintain muscle mass at 800 calories....
Evidence: http://www.jacn.org/content/18/2/115.full0 -
1200 IS NOT A MAGIC NUMBER!!!0
-
Do you mean net 1200 or 1200 total. By the end of the week (I eat lots more during the weekends than the weekdays usually), I usually net around around 1100-1500, and have been losing.0
-
I eat 1200 cals or less per day and have lose 57lbs in 10 months so far and l don't eat back my exercise cals ever. Occasionally I will go above on some days but mostly 1200 cals.0
-
The first time I lost weight, I got all the way down to 118 lbs, my lowest weight ever. I was eating about 1000-1200 calories a day give or take. I now eat 800-1600 calories a day. I try to keep it in the 1000-1300 calorie range but some days I am doing well with only 800 calories and other days I am super hungry and eat 1600 calories. I am steadily losing about 0.5-2 lbs a week. I am down 8 lbs from my heaviest.0
-
That's pretty much it!
It really depends on your RMR. This is too low for taller/bigger people with a higher RMR.
It also depends on your ability to handle a deeper calorie deficit. Some people can handle a deeper calorie deficit than others and this is not right or wrong. Some people have emotional eating disorders and it comes into play. Even a small deficit puts your body in a state of flux with hormones and such and everyone is different. The more stress you have the more your hunger hormones are turned on so this factors into your ability to stay in control. Binges are a clue that you are not in control and the deficit you are on is not working well for you. You can always notch up then notch back down when you are have less stress.
I was able to handle a pretty deep calorie deficit because I'm very disciplined and eat healthy (good fuel for the body so I can perform well at the gym) and I do not have emotional eating issues. I have a very low RMR so my doctor said I could go lower than 1200.
To tell everyone eat more is wrong.
To tell everyone to eat less is wrong.
To find the exact amount of calories for you to be in a sustainable calorie deficit is correct. Calorie estimate tools are just a starting point. You can always notch up or down according to your own needs.0 -
Please eat more. Sustain your body don't starve it. Be healthy. 1200 calories a day is not acceptable for organisms as large as humans.
Actually it is. You can get all the necessary macro and micronutrients with 1100 calories per day. There even may be some evidence that if you got your maintenance level down to 1100-1200, you could live for a while longer than other human beings who eat at the average 2000-2500.
What research do you know of? I have heard of the group called the skinnies that live longer lives on high nutrient low calorie diets.0 -
Please eat more. Sustain your body don't starve it. Be healthy. 1200 calories a day is not acceptable for organisms as large as humans.
Actually it is. You can get all the necessary macro and micronutrients with 1100 calories per day. There even may be some evidence that if you got your maintenance level down to 1100-1200, you could live for a while longer than other human beings who eat at the average 2000-2500.
What research do you know of? I have heard of the group called the skinnies that live longer lives on high nutrient low calorie diets.
It was from a BBC documentary called "Eat, fast and live longer", people who followed the CRON(calorie restriction optimum nutrition) their diets they showed improvements in life span and other fitness tests. It probably was the same thing as this 'skinnies' group..it was an American pioneered study.0 -
Yes, I lost 30 lbs in 6 months on a 1200 cal diet, plus exercise.0
-
yep0
-
It has been working for me. I've only been doing it 2 months now.
GREAT JOB!!!! Gives me hope 0 -
I have, but I'm 5'3" and a desk jockey. I honestly haven't been exercising that much so it has worked for me.0
-
Certainly worked for me, I cant complain!0
-
Simple answer is yes, people have lost weight eating 1200 calories.
Much better answer is no, you won't healthfully lose weight loose weight eating that few calories.
This. Plus, you're more likely to gain back all the weight once you start eating your BMR/maintenance level if you lose on a low-calorie diet.
Says who? Most Doctors recommend that for women. I guess you both know more than they do. Congratulations on being so smart.
1200 is perfectly fine for women. Ask a doctor but then they are apparently not the right choice for medical opinions like MFP anonymous posters are.0 -
It depends on how fast you want to lose weight .. Anything around 1400 usually works for me, but it comes off much faster at 1200 and under.0
-
of course people will lose weight doing that! - & of course you will get the "Lectures" dont eat 1200 or less, thats too low, blah blah blah..... i eat less than a 1,000 & am doing just fine!
Yet your profile says "healthy living", go figure? :flowerforyou:0 -
Simple answer is yes, people have lost weight eating 1200 calories.
Much better answer is no, you won't healthfully lose weight loose weight eating that few calories.
This. Plus, you're more likely to gain back all the weight once you start eating your BMR/maintenance level if you lose on a low-calorie diet.
Says who? Most Doctors recommend that for women. I guess you both know more than they do. Congratulations on being so smart.
1200 is perfectly fine for women. Ask a doctor but then they are apparently not the right choice for medical opinions like MFP anonymous posters are.
Slightly rude, thou dost protest too much. Most doctors would be the first to admit they have the minimum training in nutrition, my nurse suggested 800 calories, I'd rather be healthy0 -
Simple answer is yes, people have lost weight eating 1200 calories.
Much better answer is no, you won't healthfully lose weight loose weight eating that few calories.
This. Plus, you're more likely to gain back all the weight once you start eating your BMR/maintenance level if you lose on a low-calorie diet.
Says who? Most Doctors recommend that for women. I guess you both know more than they do. Congratulations on being so smart.
1200 is perfectly fine for women. Ask a doctor but then they are apparently not the right choice for medical opinions like MFP anonymous posters are.
Slightly rude, thou dost protest too much. Most doctors would be the first to admit they have the minimum training in nutrition, my nurse suggested 800 calories, I'd rather be healthy
No your not likely to gain it back if you do it correctly. By changing your dietary habits which causes the issue in the first place.
Also even though doctors have little training, they do have far more training than most here and try see the medical implications of changing, whereas a fully qualified dietician does not nor will not have access to the same information and tools a doctor will have. When last has a dietician used a bilology testing facility to watch blood markers and other signs of health? They don't.. They get taught by what is learnt in those labs and sometimes the training will not change even if a breakthrough occurs.
CRON is a perfect example. 800c ? Yes you can be healthy and live longer eating that low. It is how you eat.
Calories are not the be all end all of dieting. Nutrition should be primary focus however to manage everything hadly anyone has the need nor the time and skill to do so hence 1200 will in general provide all the nutrition we need without the managing needed when going to low levels of calorie dense foods but rather nutrient dense and low calories. It requires lots of planning but can work.0 -
I have been eating 1200 calories for a month and working out 6 days a week...3 days of Zumba and 3 days of fitness boxing. I had previously lost 65 pounds on weight watchers than gained 20 back and I'm working hard to lose the 20...but I haven't lost a single ounce!! I know I am gaining muscle but I should be losing something!
0 -
yep, I'm almost 40 lbs down since May. Exercise and 1200ish calories. Do what your body likes, not what other people do. Everyone's different.0
-
I have lost 85 lbs since April 2011, eating 1200 calories a day. I didnt follow the program for a while but never gained any back. I have 30 lbs to go......
0 -
I eat a -NET WORTH- of 1.2k calories. Meanng I eat my workout calories. But yeah it works.0
-
Depends on your size and activity level, just like anything else. Make the calories count!0
-
I aim for that but often go over by a hundred or so. Lost 7lbs so far. It's easier for me to hit it on the weekends as I often sleep through breakfast. XD0
-
I have lost about 20lbs so far since starting my diet 2 months ago, so not very much yet and quite a bit less than I had hoped. My MFP target is 1,330 a day, but I am very often below that and get the "starvation" warning when I submit my calories for the day.
I have been considering increasing my calorie intake to about 1500 to see if I lose weight faster. However, my philosophy with eating is not to eat anything wih sugar in it, and I am finding it actually quite hard to eat 1500 a day!
Today for example, I had Special K for breakfast, a Greek salad for lunch and together that only comes to 400 calories or so. For dinner I have plans to go out to a steak restaurant, but even a (8oz fillet) steak with fries is only about 700 calories which would bring me up to 1100.
I am finding myself eating things before going to bed, not because I am hungry, but because I am worried that my body is going into starvation mode!0 -
Simple answer is yes, people have lost weight eating 1200 calories.
Much better answer is no, you won't healthfully lose weight loose weight eating that few calories.
This. Plus, you're more likely to gain back all the weight once you start eating your BMR/maintenance level if you lose on a low-calorie diet.
Says who? Most Doctors recommend that for women. I guess you both know more than they do. Congratulations on being so smart.
1200 is perfectly fine for women. Ask a doctor but then they are apparently not the right choice for medical opinions like MFP anonymous posters are.
Actually 1200 calories is not fine for a lot of women. Even coming from my doctor a lot of people get stuck on the 1200 cal magic number and they are really clueless to what they should actually be comsuming. All a 1200 calorie diet got me was a destroyed metabolism and a skinny fat body. This time I actually quit listening to random "experts" and got the facts. I was surprised to find out that my BMR was over 1400. No wonder my body was so messed up. That's all in the past now. I guess I just finally woke up.0 -
I net between 800 - 1200 a day.
Though on weekends I usually have around 15000 -
I lost a ton of weight eating 800 cal/day two years ago. I also lost my coloring, my hair, and my period among other things. 1200 is the recommended minimum for a reason. Tread carefully. If you do go that low, you really have to think about meeting your nutritional needs.0
-
I am a very little girl with a very low BMR and quite sedentary. My TDEE (what I'd need to eat per day to maintain my weight) is only 1600 or so. I've lost 30lbs so far from eating around 1,200 - 1,300 calories per day and doing a bit of exercise. For the average person (and I am far littler than average) 1,200 wouldn't be enough.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions