Why am I still hungry?!
Serendipityunt
Posts: 120 Member
So, as I've noticed over the last few weeks, I'm getting hungry about two hours after I have my lunch. Today I even had a good lunch: a pork chop, broccoli, a plum and 90-cal brownie for dessert. And I had a good breakfast of a bagel thin and banana. I've also had a good amount of water all day. But I'm hungry, just as I have been over the last few weeks, whether I'm swamped at work or not. I"m also craving real food, not a bag of chips or a candy bar... I want a sandwich or slice of pizza.
I'm trying my best to ignore the feeling and not indulge in a second lunch, but I'm starting to wonder why it's been this way. It's also over the last 8 weeks that I've been gaining weight too... likely from indulging in the second lunch too many times.
Is this normal to anyone?
I'm trying my best to ignore the feeling and not indulge in a second lunch, but I'm starting to wonder why it's been this way. It's also over the last 8 weeks that I've been gaining weight too... likely from indulging in the second lunch too many times.
Is this normal to anyone?
0
Replies
-
When I first started I was hungry 24/7. It passed after a while though I just had to stick it out. I'm sure others will suggest alternative food choices, slow release energy or whatever. I would suggest perhaps trying moving your lunch later, try a larger breakfast and a smaller lunch, try a smaller breakfast and a larger lunch. If second lunch is your thing try splitting your lunch in two! Half now and half when you're hungry. Think of it like an experiment, we're all different and what doesn't work for others may be just right for you. If I get that mad craving for more food then I go with a banana or a low fat yoghurt they seem to do the trick for me. Raspberries and blueberries are great too
0 -
if you open up your diary we can have better advice, but try increasing your protein to about 1g per lb of lean body weight.
also LOTS of veggies and fruits to fill you up. healthy fats also help.
and i may suggest upping your calories, but since i dont know how many you currently eat, then i cant suggest that
whats a typical day of food for you? and your height/weight and activity level0 -
I have this same exact problem, So I'm interested in what others have to say....
I have tried to drink some tea after lunch or more water, sometimes it helps othertimes it does not.0 -
Eat slowly.
Snack on some almonds (they have healthy fats that we crave, and protein that is good) and drink even more water to fill your stomach. When i say drink alot of water i mean a gallon a day.
Your stomach will shrink and so will your appetite.
Stay strong!0 -
This was happening to me too. I had to suck it up and give up my "real-sized" dinners...instead I usually eat a lunch-sized dinner so I can eat more throughout the day. Usually... 0
-
It can take time to adjust to different diets and food. Hunger cravings aren't unusual. Here are some things that work to solve them:
1. Try eating more protein for breakfast. I would definitely not call a bagel thin a good breakfast. That's actually your stereotypical high carb & high GI index breakfast that's bad. In general, try and eat protein and veggies/fruit at every single meal!
2. You can try eating more often too. For example, measure out an ounce of almonds and have a few anytime the hunger pangs start.
3. Coffee and Tea are AWESOME for blunting hunger cravings.
4. NEVER snack on simple processed carbs. Seriously, if you must snack, make it real food: whole fat dairy product, fruit, veggies, nuts, lean meat, etc. Avoid snacking on things like chips, bread, etc.0 -
You should eat a bigger breakfast, try consuming most of your calories during the day. You should include whole grains in your diet. Try replacing that pork chop with a turkey chop. You should eat more protien to help you feel full like eggs, nuts, beans, etc. Today , I ate a whole grain fajata omlet with tomato, spinach, cheese, and green peppers. I wasn't that hungry at lunch. So, I just grabbed some white tuna, and mutigrain crackers.0
-
I'll share from my experience. Take it or leave it. I don't mean this to be a push to any one kind of diet... just sharing what has worked for me.
I used to eat whole wheat bagel thins every morning. I told myself they were healthy, because they where whole wheat, only 100 cals, and I put low-fat cream cheese, margarine, or PB on them. I was hungry within an hour after eating. Even if I ate the same with a fattening whole bagel, I'd be hungry pretty quickly. Fruit smoothie in the morning? Hungry after. Oatmeal? Hungry.
No matter what I ate for lunch, whether it was "healthy" or not, I still wanted something sweet after. Same with dinner. And even if I was full, I would still want 2nds of whatever carb was available... bread, rice, pasta.
On July 3, I started eating according to the primal blueprint. www.marksdailyapple.com. I eliminated all grains, legumes, processed foods, and anything with added sugar. Since those are all foods I tended to overeat, and crave, and have the least willpower to moderate, I decided that I would try eliminating them for a while to see if I could, and how it would go.
Within about 3 days of starting eating this way, I realized that my sugar cravings were disappearing. My blood sugar levels were more stable. I no longer obsessed over when my next meal would be, and could easily go from early morning breakfast to mid-afternoon lunch without feeling hungry or shaky. When I do get really hungry, I know it's because I didn't have enough good fat in my last meal.
Anyway, that's what's worked for me to slay the hunger/sugar beast so far. Good luck on your journey!0 -
I find that the more protein I get in, the less hungry I am and the less snacking I do.0
-
without seeing your food diary its hard to give better advice0
-
this is what worked for me too. the nice thing about it is if you try it you should know within a short time if its for you. trying different things won't hurt.I'll share from my experience. Take it or leave it. I don't mean this to be a push to any one kind of diet... just sharing what has worked for me.
I used to eat whole wheat bagel thins every morning. I told myself they were healthy, because they where whole wheat, only 100 cals, and I put low-fat cream cheese, margarine, or PB on them. I was hungry within an hour after eating. Even if I ate the same with a fattening whole bagel, I'd be hungry pretty quickly. Fruit smoothie in the morning? Hungry after. Oatmeal? Hungry.
No matter what I ate for lunch, whether it was "healthy" or not, I still wanted something sweet after. Same with dinner. And even if I was full, I would still want 2nds of whatever carb was available... bread, rice, pasta.
On July 3, I started eating according to the primal blueprint. www.marksdailyapple.com. I eliminated all grains, legumes, processed foods, and anything with added sugar. Since those are all foods I tended to overeat, and crave, and have the least willpower to moderate, I decided that I would try eliminating them for a while to see if I could, and how it would go.
Within about 3 days of starting eating this way, I realized that my sugar cravings were disappearing. My blood sugar levels were more stable. I no longer obsessed over when my next meal would be, and could easily go from early morning breakfast to mid-afternoon lunch without feeling hungry or shaky. When I do get really hungry, I know it's because I didn't have enough good fat in my last meal.
Anyway, that's what's worked for me to slay the hunger/sugar beast so far. Good luck on your journey!0 -
I've had this same issue, and used to eat similar breakfasts to yourself.
Having changed to eating more protein heavy breakfasts has helped reduce my hunger issues throughout the day.
Tempeh and quinoa are pretty regular breakfast ingredients for me now (I follow a vegan diet, but your options may be much wider spread - quiche, etc.). I can still have a bit of granola / cereal / bagel, I just don't have a full serving.
While my breakfast still has about the same number of calories as before my switch, between 300 and 400, the higher versus non-existent protein content does seem to be my fix.
Good luck on finding your own.0 -
I have two lunches, the gap between lunch and dinner in my house is too long, so I have 2 lower calorie 'meals' it works wonders, and stops that evil snacking0
-
Like others have said, protein as a significant part of breakfast, and lunch, helps me.
I've also learned I really need to eat something about every two to three hours. Otherwise I overeat at meals.
It's easier to eat less over all if I eat more frequently.
I try to think about what I'm going to be eating all day and them spread it out over the course of the day.0 -
Almost every time someone posts this topic (about once a day) the answer is that they aren't eating enough. I can't see your diary so I don't know if this applies to you.
If you have an unrealistically high weight loss goal then MFP will default to 1200 cals a day and that really isn't much at all for most people.
If you are eating all the calories that MFP suggests (and extra when you exercise) but you are still hungry, then start experimenting with the kinds of foods that you are eating. Meat and veggies doesn't keep me full for long, but if I add in some potato or rice or pasta (ie carbs) then I stay full for longer. Lots of other people say that more protein keeps them full. There isn't any right or wrong here, just experiment to see what works for you.0 -
well if possible i say excercise more i eat when i am hungry (almost every hour i am awake) and never worry about my calories, most days i end up somewhere between 3300 to 3500 calories and i have been maintaining this way for months now, i am the same weight i was back in may, more excercise = no worrys about eating all the time,which really works for me cause i'm always hungry hahaha 0
-
This ALWAYS happens to me when I'm not getting enough sleep, or wake up too early.0
-
How many calories are you eating a day? How much do you exercise? Do you eat any of those calories back. You might be hungry because your body needs fuel.0
-
Also, I agree with all of the suggestions on eating protein for breakfast. I've actually taken to eating chicken tikka masala or lamb saag frozen dinners for breakfast... 290 / 300 calories for the meal, and plenty of protein!0
-
It can take time to adjust to different diets and food. Hunger cravings aren't unusual. Here are some things that work to solve them:
1. Try eating more protein for breakfast. I would definitely not call a bagel thin a good breakfast. That's actually your stereotypical high carb & high GI index breakfast that's bad. In general, try and eat protein and veggies/fruit at every single meal!
2. You can try eating more often too. For example, measure out an ounce of almonds and have a few anytime the hunger pangs start.
3. Coffee and Tea are AWESOME for blunting hunger cravings.
4. NEVER snack on simple processed carbs. Seriously, if you must snack, make it real food: whole fat dairy product, fruit, veggies, nuts, lean meat, etc. Avoid snacking on things like chips, bread, etc.
I agree with this post 100%!! I've lost over 100lbs and this has been a long road and a bumpy one but the above suggestions is what I've used to not be hungry all the time. #4 is huge...Lean proteins and plant based foods (nuts, hard boiled egg, quinoa, veggies, fruits, greek yogurt) to keep you full longer. I do allow myself the things I love (like pizza) once in a while, just not everyday. Lots of water too!
Best of luck!0 -
If I dont get my fill of vegetables and water I'm hungry0
-
As others have said before, you have to eat to not be hungry. Personally I eat about 1500 calories per day spread over 5 times. A typical day looks something like this:
- Breakfast: Fiber Enriched oatmeal (50g dry) with a banana or just a fruit salad
- Snack 1: a banana or wallnuts
- Lunch: 250g Fillet of beef or other lean meat, for this I have broccoli or other cooked vegetables (lightly cooked)
- Snack 2: a banana or other fruit
- Dinner: same as lunch
If I get tired of meat, I usually replace it with fish and then mainly salmon0 -
When I'm on my game with eating mostly fruits and veggies, yes I am hungry within an or two after every meal. My suggestion is instead of having 3 meals a day have 5 with small snacks. I used to never eat breakfast then when I started to eat breakfast I felt hungry all the time. I think this is because it wakes up my metabolism to eat breakfast in the morning.0
-
I am not sure what will work for you, however this is what works for me.... (I notice others replies are saying similar things).
I'm less hungry when I don't skimp (or skip) on breakfast.
I'm hungry if I don't have at least 4 glasses of water a day,
I notice that my hunger increases if I have high sugar foods on some days.
Increasing my intake of high protein foods at lunch time helps reduce hunger through the afternoon.
If I feel hungry before a meal, I'll have an apple (or two) which seems to supress the hunger long enough to make it to the next meal - especially if I eat it slowly.
Finally, I notice some people recommend we get enough sleep. I'm experimenting with this at the moment and early signs seem to support this idea. Hope this helps....0 -
i think i have a fast metabolism, as i get hungry every two hours without fail. and painfully hungry, almost throwing an adult tantrum hungry. haha
i have snacks, piece of fruit and nutty muesli bar (i know not healthy - but good for energy kick i find) for morning tea, 1 meat + salad sandwich for lunch, almonds or rice wafers+peanut butter, and another piece of fruit for afternoon tea.0 -
i think i have a fast metabolism, as i get hungry every two hours without fail. and painfully hungry, almost throwing an adult tantrum hungry. haha
i have snacks, piece of fruit and nutty muesli bar (i know not healthy - but good for energy kick i find) for morning tea, 1 meat + salad sandwich for lunch, almonds or rice wafers+peanut butter, and another piece of fruit for afternoon tea.
It's a sign of a fast metabolism? That's good, because I get hungry every 2 and a half hours like clockwork. For this reason, I plan to smaller meals to make room for several snacks throughout the day. And coffee works as an appetite suppressant.
I'm also finding that vegetables other than leafy-greens fill me up much better. I started out with a lot of spinach and salad as my daily veggies, and I think they passed through the stomach way too fast.
It's encouraging to hear that the stomach will shrink and adjust to the new food amounts... I'm starting to see this myself, actually as a side effect of having smaller meals. I went out to eat today and the plate they gave me was double what I would put on my plate at home. First thing I did was get a to-go box and put half of it inside for a meal later.0 -
you need more protein. take a can of tuna or small amount of chicken etc, keeps you full for longer. should be eating protein at ever meal, even brekky.0
-
I’ve been hungry for as long as I can remember (35+ years) and can/could count on my fingers the number of times I’ve felt full. That was up until three weeks ago. I started to eat bulky low calorie food, peppers carrots cucumber cottage cheese coleslaw cabbage, green vegetables tomatoes in large quantities and a small amount of protein and fat.
Where as a small high calorie meal would take four or five minutes to eat, my meals were taking 15 to 20 minutes, purely because of the time it takes to eat.
On the days it takes more than fifteen minutes or to eat my 500 calories of food, I’m not hunger for 4 hours.
So what work for me, is mounds of low calorie food that take time to eat. You are tricking your mind into feeling full only because of the time spent eating.0 -
I eat my bigger meal at lunch time most days, I find that works better for me than a small lunch and large dinner.0
-
Thanks to everyone for all of their suggestions. I took a couple of days to see what I could do differently. I always knew I felt better after having protein in my breakfast, so I've been starting out with a hard-boiled egg, a banana and some tea. I've kept a second egg around with me if I got hungry before lunch. I have kept something as a snack around, like string cheese or crackers. It's really helped hold me off till lunch better.
After lunch, I've tried munching on fruit. Eating an apple has always somehow made me hungrier, so I've stuck with plums.
I'll keep working on it, but I'm starting to find my way. But having a better breakfast with protein in it has really helped a lot.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions