Why am I starving?!!!!
BABetter1
Posts: 618 Member
Today was my rest day. I am just finishing week 1 of Insanity. I woke up with my tummy growling loudly, and I have just felt constantly hungry all day long. I started off having my protein shake and banana. Then, I went right ahead and ate my lunch too (5 egg white omelet with onions and kale greens and whole grain toast) because I was super hungry and I figured I would just eat less later. Later I had a yogurt, and when I got home from work a little while ago (after only working half a shift), I was still starving. My stomach was seriously growling. So, I dug around in the fridge and found some leftovers and ate like two plate fulls of the families unhealthy take out food. Now, I'm sitting here and my stomach is STILL growling. What the heck?!! Why am I so hungry?
This isn't one of those mental, "I want to eat something because I'm bored" or feeling deprived or whatever. This is a case of actual tummy rumbling and loud audible growling.
This isn't one of those mental, "I want to eat something because I'm bored" or feeling deprived or whatever. This is a case of actual tummy rumbling and loud audible growling.
0
Replies
-
how many calories a day are you eating?? it might be that you're not taking in enough calories to supplement all the calories you're burning off doing Insanity. open your diary so we can see
0 -
I'd eat if I was hungry.0
-
all that Insanity exercise?
ironically enough, i just posted this article i came across online from Time Magazine... might be somewhat relevant, might not.
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1914974-4,00.html
(just for the record, i am an avid exerciser and have been most of my life.)0 -
Diary is public now. I bumped up my calorie goals when I started doing Insanity. Today, I didn't plan on eating quite as much since I am resting, but . . . . . .
I'm also trying to sort out my macros, and I am trying to up my protein as well. I'm open to suggestions as to what I should be doing differently with my eating . . . .0 -
I have the same problem when I eat foods with a high glycemic index... like the banana first thing in the morning and the toast you had later. I try to stick to lower glycemic index choices first thing in the morning and mid-day so I don't get hungry faster during the day. Plus, I feel like protein shake and a banana will digest very quickly - I feel like having something more solid as my protein source first thing in the AM and a more fibrous fruit choice also helps. I like having eggs or an egg white omelette with a grapefruit or melon wedges. For lunch, I usually have something with chicken. I will need a small snack late in the day though if it's more than 5 hours between lunch and dinner.0
-
SO! Your stomach is "Growling", if THAT's YOUR indicator that YOU are hungry then You are in trouble. If you are hungry, say so but do not use your stomach as an indicator that it means someone/you are hungry. Also, if you ate that much and are STILL hungry, it can NOT be physical; "WE" need to STOP putting HUNGER and OVEREATING on PHYSICAL NEEDS. MOST hunger Starts Psychological and Emotionally! I say you are hungry because you just finished the first week of a very strenuous program, you've been eating right and you want to "reward" yourself on your day off. That's what your "Gut" is telling you...subconsciously! Next time on your day off and you have done well PLAN a Treat for Yourself and Save the grief...JUST PLAN Ahead!!!0
-
SO! Your stomach is "Growling", if THAT's YOUR indicator that YOU are hungry then You are in trouble. If you are hungry, say so but do not use your stomach as an indicator that it means someone/you are hungry. Also, if you ate that much and are STILL hungry, it can NOT be physical; "WE" need to STOP putting HUNGER and OVEREATING on PHYSICAL NEEDS. MOST hunger Starts Psychological and Emotionally! I say you are hungry because you just finished the first week of a very strenuous program, you've been eating right and you want to "reward" yourself on your day off. That's what your "Gut" is telling you...subconsciously! Next time on your day off and you have done well PLAN a Treat for Yourself and Save the grief...JUST PLAN Ahead!!!
I agree with some of this, but since i have been eating healthy, counting calories and exercising regularly, i find that on some days, i am just really hungry! So i disagree that you are necessarily eating emotionally to "reward" yourself. Sometimes your body just needs something and keeps telling you that till it gets it. It might be some very specific nutrients, or you might just be really short of calories. What is listed on MFP and what we enter in our diaries are estimates only - heart rate monitors - same thing - estimated calorie burns only. Our general problem is that we have learned to suppress the information our bodies give us about what we need in favor of what advertising tells us we need. But now that you are learning to listen to your actual body, it is not the time to stop listening!!
I would suggest making sure you've got something on hand for these times so you don't have to resort to the crappy leftover take out food. Make sure you've got fresh fruits and veggies, or nuts, some frozen veggies or lean meats around. I also keep some low sodium/low fat organic soups in the pantry for emergencies like this.
But if you are generally learning to receive good information from your body and respond appropriately, don't stop now!!0 -
SO! Your stomach is "Growling", if THAT's YOUR indicator that YOU are hungry then You are in trouble. If you are hungry, say so but do not use your stomach as an indicator that it means someone/you are hungry. Also, if you ate that much and are STILL hungry, it can NOT be physical; "WE" need to STOP putting HUNGER and OVEREATING on PHYSICAL NEEDS. MOST hunger Starts Psychological and Emotionally! I say you are hungry because you just finished the first week of a very strenuous program, you've been eating right and you want to "reward" yourself on your day off. That's what your "Gut" is telling you...subconsciously! Next time on your day off and you have done well PLAN a Treat for Yourself and Save the grief...JUST PLAN Ahead!!!
I'm not sure I understand what you are saying. Yes, my stomach growls when I am physically HUNGRY. No, it does not growl when I am psychologically "needy". In fact, over the years, my stomach has had very few occasions to growl because I usually have fed the fat thing long before it actually ever gets hungry. So, I know the difference. Also, I do not reward myself with food. It's not part of my mind set or even an appealing idea to me. No, I'm not saying I never indulge in sweets or fattening foods. I do. But, I log it and move on. I'm just wondering if I need to change up my macros or if anyone else has experienced this or what?! You don't like my post? Move on. If I'm taking you wrong, my apologies. But, YOU seem to be giving me a lot of "grief", and I don't know why.0 -
Find out how much water you should drink daily0
-
I have loads of low GI stuff in my cupboard for days just like this.
My favourite is Heinz (or similar) baked beans and something (normally pumpernickel toast). They fill me up and take away the hunger pangs big style.0 -
some on on here said you know your really hungry if you'll eat fruits and vegetables. If those don't sound good to you and only junk sounds good to you then you know youre eating for another reason.
I thought that was great advice, and I try to remember that when I'm filling hungry.
Of course like everyone else, first thing is to drink water then wait for 5-10-15 minutes and see if you are still craving. Maybe it's something else too tired, drained, upset.
Night times are not easy that is my weakest time.0 -
Try calculating your calorie goal as 20% less than you TDEE. this has helped me tremendously as eating less (1400) made me Hungry and led to binges. I sometimes eat less than my goal, but that's ok because I'm listening for my body to tell me I'm full. But if my body says "hungry" I can still eat and lose weight.0
-
Well, I usually drink about a gallon of water per day . . . . I didn't think about the glycemic index thing. But, I ate the huge egg white omelette basically at the same time or right after I finished the protein shake and banana. Still, that with the toast could have been enough to cause a spike I suppose.
Does other peoples' stomachs growl when they AREN'T hungry? I've never heard of that, and I've certainly never experienced it. :huh:0 -
Stomach does NOT "Growl." As I said and someone else, Next time, PLAN Ahead.0
-
This happens to me too for no apparent reason. I just have days where I'm freaking hungry all day and others when I really don't eat much at all. Just have to go with the flow and try hard to resist! Easier said than done when you're a mere human.:happy:0
-
Well, I usually drink about a gallon of water per day . . . . I didn't think about the glycemic index thing. But, I ate the huge egg white omelette basically at the same time or right after I finished the protein shake and banana. Still, that with the toast could have been enough to cause a spike I suppose.
Does other peoples' stomachs growl when they AREN'T hungry? I've never heard of that, and I've certainly never experienced it. :huh:
My stomach has made noises before when something didn't agree with it, from gas or bloating. The body is a strange place sometimes.0 -
how many calories a day are you eating?? it might be that you're not taking in enough calories to supplement all the calories you're burning off doing Insanity. open your diary so we can see
The Insanity workout would appear to be well-named.
Exercise makes you hungry, I think I'll skip the intense stuff ... mmm, time for some eggs and bacon ...0 -
I had this problem a lot at first and was extremely frustrated by always being so hungry (I'm not a very nice person when I'm hungry.... lol). I realized that I was consistently falling short on the amount of fat I was allowed to eat per day. I was eating everything low fat or non-fat - which makes sense that I was starving because fat is what helps you feel full! I now make a point to eat a bit of good fat at each meal (2 tbsp of peanut butter at breakfast, avacado slices with a salad, or full fat cottage cheese, etc....) After learning how to better balance and maintain my fat intake throughout the day I now easily avoid that constant hunger I was having. Not sure if this is your issue, but may be worth looking into!!0
-
Stomach does NOT "Growl." As I said and someone else, Next time, PLAN Ahead.
Okay, I don't know what country you're from. But where I am from, a "growling" tummy means you are hungry. It is a FIGURE OF SPEECH! You seem to think that I am attributing animal-like qualities to my stomach, and it clearly annoys you. It is a commonly used figure of speech here that refers to when you get so hungry that your stomach makes audible gurgly/growly noises. GET OVER IT. And, I have no idea why you keep telling me to "PLAN ahead". Plan for what??? All I'm talking about here is that I am unbelievably hungry today and don't know why! I'm wondering if anyone else has an idea WHY. That's all.0 -
Well, I usually drink about a gallon of water per day . . . . I didn't think about the glycemic index thing. But, I ate the huge egg white omelette basically at the same time or right after I finished the protein shake and banana. Still, that with the toast could have been enough to cause a spike I suppose.
Does other peoples' stomachs growl when they AREN'T hungry? I've never heard of that, and I've certainly never experienced it. :huh:
Yes, mine does it frequently. It is not a strange occurence and it most certainly does not mean I'm hungry, especially if it does it after I eat. If I just fed my stomach, why would I still be hungry? Your head can manifest physical symptoms, so, yes, it most certainly could be psychological.0 -
I'm currently doing INSANITY as well. My suggestion is to make sure you're eating enough...and the quality of the food you're consuming DOES MATTER. Yesterday was my super hungry day, so I ate a couple hundred calories more than I usually do. Good luck!
(this is my second go-round with INSANITY)0 -
Well, I usually drink about a gallon of water per day . . . . I didn't think about the glycemic index thing. But, I ate the huge egg white omelette basically at the same time or right after I finished the protein shake and banana. Still, that with the toast could have been enough to cause a spike I suppose.
Does other peoples' stomachs growl when they AREN'T hungry? I've never heard of that, and I've certainly never experienced it. :huh:
That noise ur hearing are waves of muscle contractions churning up food & liquid together & pushing them downward. Moving with those ingredients are gasses and air. As everything gets pushed around, these pockets of gas and air also get squeezed and create the 'growling' ur hearing. It's not always an indicator of hunger, tho it can be. After ab two hours of the stomach emptying itself, that process I just mentioned happens again. The contractions will come & go ab every hour until u eat again.
Everyone's stomach makes this noise & I'm sure not everyone is hungry when it does, I'm not always. I used to be though, that because people tend to relate that noise with hunger when growing up I think, so it just sticks.0 -
I had this problem a lot at first and was extremely frustrated by always being so hungry (I'm not a very nice person when I'm hungry.... lol). I realized that I was consistently falling short on the amount of fat I was allowed to eat per day. I was eating everything low fat or non-fat - which makes sense that I was starving because fat is what helps you feel full! I now make a point to eat a bit of good fat at each meal (2 tbsp of peanut butter at breakfast, avacado slices with a salad, or full fat cottage cheese, etc....) After learning how to better balance and maintain my fat intake throughout the day I now easily avoid that constant hunger I was having. Not sure if this is your issue, but may be worth looking into!!
Okay, this actually makes the most sense to me. I typically eat more fat, but thought I'd ramp up my visible results if I cut back my fat intake a little. Yesterday I had lots of nuts and avocado and felt fine all day. Today, I had only a miniscule amount of fat. That could be the culprit right there.
As to the rest of you who seem to think I don't know the difference between the gurgling of an upset tummy and the "growling" of a hungry tummy, I'm a grown @ss woman. I know the difference. I am actually, physically hungry. Now, I'm gonna' go eat a handful of walnuts.
Edit: That includes "digestion noises". I didn't just hear noises and ASSUME I was hungry. I am feeling the actual gnawing hunger pangs that go along with being HUNGRY.0 -
Well, I usually drink about a gallon of water per day . . . . I didn't think about the glycemic index thing. But, I ate the huge egg white omelette basically at the same time or right after I finished the protein shake and banana. Still, that with the toast could have been enough to cause a spike I suppose.
Does other peoples' stomachs growl when they AREN'T hungry? I've never heard of that, and I've certainly never experienced it. :huh:
That noise ur hearing are waves of muscle contractions churning up food & liquid together & pushing them downward. Moving with those ingredients are gasses and air. As everything gets pushed around, these pockets of gas and air also get squeezed and create the 'growling' ur hearing. It's not always an indicator of hunger, tho it can be. After ab two hours of the stomach emptying itself, that process I just mentioned happens again. The contractions will come & go ab every hour until u eat again.
Everyone's stomach makes this noise & I'm sure not everyone is hungry when it does, I'm not always. I used to be though, that because people tend to relate that noise with hunger when growing up I think, so it just sticks.
^^^ YES!0 -
So, just to clarify, one more time: The title of this post is "Why am I starving?!!!!" The title is not "Am I starving?" or "Please critique my use of the word "growling." By the way, when I referred to my tummy growling, I used the term in the same way that I have always heard it used, to refer to a hungry, loudly grumbling tummy WITH the accompanying hunger pangs. So, my bad for not realizing that others use it differently or otherwise don't have the same connotations to it. And, I even put a sentence in the original post that basically said this is not one of those psychological things, I am really hungry. I apologize for YOUR confusion, or alternately hope you have enjoyed your entertainment (for those of you who troll the forums as a passtime looking for someone to p*ss off.) Have a nice day.
For those of you who actually took my post at face value including the presumption that I knew what I was talking about when I said I was hungry, thank you. I appreciate the various suggestions/observations you have given me.0 -
Fat is not what makes you feel full.... protein and fiber are (mostly protein), which is why the peanut butter helps with hunger is because it has a lot of protein. Here is a nice little article on it.
http://www.fitwatch.com/weight-loss/foods-that-will-not-leave-you-hungry-577.html0 -
I agree with you OP. I know the difference between hunger growling and digestive gurgling!! and there is a pain/dull sensation associated with hunger. I agree that if you have an eating disorder or problems with overeating, this may be different. But it doesn't mean everybody is.......
Edit: I think it's just that you're doing more, so your body is demanding more. I think you're on the right track, as long as you don't made bad food choices (which it doesnt seem like you will), you can eat some more.0 -
Edit: That includes "digestion noises". I didn't just hear noises and ASSUME I was hungry. I am feeling the actual gnawing hunger pangs that go along with being HUNGRY.
There is also the possibility that it is stomach acid and/or acid re-flux causing the noise and hunger pains.0 -
Wow, again with the focus on the noise and some kind of suggestion that I'm not really hungry . . . really? *sigh* Whatever.
So, I just had a handful of walnuts and a big glass of water and waited 15 minutes. I do feel a little less hungry. SOME of the replies have made a lot of sense. Maybe I'm NOT eating enough calories to compensate for the increased intensity of my exercise. I did the calculations according to the Insanity nutrition guide, but of course it really isn't a one size fits all type of deal either. I looked at my macros again, too, and I THINK I'm doing okay in regards to protein, fiber, and even fat. So, I'm going to just bump up my calories for the duration of Insanity. And, I'm going to flip flop some of my go-to meals so I'm eating at a more appropriate glycemic index in the mornings. Thanks.0 -
What an insult to your intelligence by people thinking you can't tell if your hungry or not. You know your body better than anyone! Some of these comments are just plain rude. I agree with the posts about protein. Have some beans, egg whites, turkey or chicken or something high protein. Peanut butter doesn't stick with me. =/0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions