Should I REALLY eat my exercise calories back?
samwichbox
Posts: 5
MFP tells me that my net calorie intake is 1620 and that as this is my net, I can eat my calories from exercise back.
Can anyone with experience reassure me that it's ok to do this?
I don't always eat every single one back, but I'm often still hungry/hungrier from working out so I often eat some back.
Thanks :-)
Can anyone with experience reassure me that it's ok to do this?
I don't always eat every single one back, but I'm often still hungry/hungrier from working out so I often eat some back.
Thanks :-)
0
Replies
-
I do for the most part, and 26lbs are gone and the fat is still coming off. :bigsmile:
Easier than figuring or worrying about whether or not to eat a certain amount of exercise calories, learn your BMR and your TDEE, and eat in between those two numbers. Some days I'm hungrier, some days I'm not, but I always make sure to NET at least my BMR - gotta at least give the body the amount it needs to function in a coma.
This thread is very helpful with that info: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/654536-in-place-of-a-road-map-2-0-revised-7-2-120 -
I don't eat them all back either. In fact I find it difficult to eat them all back.0
-
Hmmm. I've never thought of that. No one has asked that before. I'll have to give that some thought.0
-
You're using MFP to allocate and track your calories that are burned and consumed in order to maintain a healthy deficit.
Or you're not, you're just randomly burning and eating a figure you're making up on a daily basis, and going through the rigour of logging everything just out of curiosity.0 -
You don't have to eat your exercise calories back and sometimes eating back your calories can be counter productive. The more exercise you do, the larger your deficit. No paper, diet, or journal has ever said you must eat your exercise calories back. That's a MyFitnessPal myth. If there is a journal paper that says you must eat your exercise calories back, I'd be open minded to read it.
Edit, You should be still losing even if you eat your calories back but you don't have too.0 -
I guess what you mean IronSmasher is that you are advising the original poster to use MFP to track their calories consumed in a day, including activities and consuming up to them in order to maintain a healthy deficit; which has already been factored into the MFP calculation which was calculated for you when you first created your profile.
Is that what you mean?0 -
I only eat them back now because I am maintaining.
While I was losing weight, I ate 0% to 50% of my burned calories. Mostly zero though.0 -
I guess what you mean IronSmasher is that you are advising the original poster to use MFP to track their calories consumed in a day, including activities and consuming up to them in order to maintain a healthy deficit; which has already been factored into the MFP calculation which was calculated for you when you first created your profile.
Is that what you mean?
I think so. Unfortunately, what will follow, is hordes of people applying methods from other diets and calculators that do not use the same methods as MFP, and instead add calories to account for the exercise in the original calories allowance. What's best (and this is really special), some KNOW they are using a different method, but forget to mention that they're not using MFP as intended, and have actually manually changed their calorie settings.0 -
Do whatever works for you. MFP is designed so that you eat back your exercise calories...if you do not...you are creating a bigger defecit. Big defecit is not always good however because your body needs fuel....especially when burning it off exercising...otherwise why not create a massive defecit and just lose weight like crazy? just doesnt work that way....low and slow is the proper way to go. That being said...if you have a TON of weight to lose and eating alot of calories per day anyway due to that fact....not eating back exercise calories is fine.
Others who may only have 5-10 pounds to lose...need to eat back theirexercise calories so they dont have too big of a defecit.0 -
You don't have to eat your exercise calories back and sometimes eating back your calories can be counter productive. The more exercise you do, the larger your deficit. No paper, diet, or journal has ever said you must eat your exercise calories back. That's a MyFitnessPal myth. If there is a journal paper that says you must eat your exercise calories back, I'd be open minded to read it.
Edit, You should be still losing even if you eat your calories back but you don't have too.0 -
MFP tells me that my net calorie intake is 1620 and that as this is my net, I can eat my calories from exercise back.
Can anyone with experience reassure me that it's ok to do this?
I don't always eat every single one back, but I'm often still hungry/hungrier from working out so I often eat some back.
Thanks :-)
MFP as designed expects you to eat your calories back because the calorie deficit is built in BEFORE exercise. When you exercise you increase the deficit MFP gave you. When the deficit is too large you will burn fat AND muscle. One of the reasons people workout is to KEEP muscle.
Now, the problem(s) with this ..... calorie burns can be inflated .... machine & MFP are often too high. Some people have their activity level set too high ... this means that they are alread accounting for some of their exercise calories.
So, a suggestion would be to eat back a percentage of exercise calories ... if you stop losing weight ... you are eating too much. If you feel fatigued and run down ... you are eating too little.0 -
depends on if your goals are set up with exercise included or not.
and how your body feels. if you don't feel you need to eat them, don't. if you do - do...0 -
MFP tells me that my net calorie intake is 1620 and that as this is my net, I can eat my calories from exercise back.
Can anyone with experience reassure me that it's ok to do this?
I don't always eat every single one back, but I'm often still hungry/hungrier from working out so I often eat some back.
Thanks :-)
MFP as designed expects you to eat your calories back because the calorie deficit is built in BEFORE exercise. When you exercise you increase the deficit MFP gave you. When the deficit is too large you will burn fat AND muscle. One of the reasons people workout is to KEEP muscle.
Now, the problem(s) with this ..... calorie burns can be inflated .... machine & MFP are often too high. Some people have their activity level set too high ... this means that they are alread accounting for some of their exercise calories.
So, a suggestion would be to eat back a percentage of exercise calories ... if you stop losing weight ... you are eating too much. If you feel fatigued and run down ... you are eating too little.
And while we're at it
DOUBLE CHECK THE NUTRITION LABEL of everything you add. Most are added by users that know little about nutrition, and very often mistakes have been made. Always give it a quick glance to make sure the portion nutrition you've chosen makes sense according to the label.
You're not going to make it through this without learning quite a bit about nutrition and labels I'm afraid.0 -
MFP tells me that my net calorie intake is 1620 and that as this is my net, I can eat my calories from exercise back.
Can anyone with experience reassure me that it's ok to do this?
I don't always eat every single one back, but I'm often still hungry/hungrier from working out so I often eat some back.
Thanks :-)
MFP as designed expects you to eat your calories back because the calorie deficit is built in BEFORE exercise. When you exercise you increase the deficit MFP gave you. When the deficit is too large you will burn fat AND muscle. One of the reasons people workout is to KEEP muscle.
Now, the problem(s) with this ..... calorie burns can be inflated .... machine & MFP are often too high. Some people have their activity level set too high ... this means that they are alread accounting for some of their exercise calories.
So, a suggestion would be to eat back a percentage of exercise calories ... if you stop losing weight ... you are eating too much. If you feel fatigued and run down ... you are eating too little.
Excellent answer!! I've been getting my calorie burns from a Polar F6 then Polar FT4 heart rate monitor (HRM) since I started back in January 2010 and most of the time I eat all of them back. As you can see, I've lost almost 90 pounds to date. Don't pay too much attention to how long it's taken me - about 60 pounds came off the first year and I've fallen off the wagon a few times and not been in much of a rush since then.
If you use the calorie burns from cardio machines or MFP calculations aim to eat back half to 2/3rds of the calories back. Don't force yourself or fill the calories with junk just to get to a certain number, instead try to pre-plan by keeping snacks on hand and/or by eating a slightly larger breakfast (lunch or dinner) on the days you work out.0 -
I work out with a personal trainer approximately 3 times a week doing a mixture of crossfit, circuit and strengh training, and another 2 days a week purely cardio. I have a 1300 calorie allowance plus exercise. Most of the time I eat between 1200 and 1400 calories a day depending on whether I have been to the gym and what type of exercise / training I have been doing.
The one thing I have been told by my PT that has helped me is that providing I eat a minimum of 1200 clean nutritional calories each day I should maintain a healthy diet and weight loss. I have to admit that on this basis I have lost 1lb a week since the beginning of this year!! 44lb in total.
Hope this helps:)0 -
I don't think you "have" to eat your calories back; unless your Net is under 1200. 1200 calories a day intake is not just MFP's recommendation, it is widely accepted as the minimum caloric intake that your body needs to function correctly.
"According to the Mayo Clinic, you do not want to lose more than one to two pounds per week, which means a safe calorie deficit would be to burn 500 to 1,000 calories per day through a reduced calorie diet AND exercise."
Source: http://www.fitsugar.com/Why-1200-Calories-Day-Important-When-Dieting-130808640 -
Weight loss is about calories in vs. calories out. So if you eat back all of those calories you will not lose as much weight or at least not lose it as quickly as you would have if you hadn't eaten those calories.0
-
I don't. No matter how much exercise I do and how many calories I burn I try to eat the allotted calories that I have set for myself -- not the NET calories - period. If I go over on exercise days it's no big deal. On a night that I'm going out and I know I'm going to indulge I consider the exercise calories a "buffer" so that if I go over it's not as big a deal as it would be if I didn't exercise.0
-
I started eating back my exercise calories about a month ago after hitting a month long plateau.... It DID help me get over the plateau. I don't eat all of em back. usually just half but I can see a difference... seems to have sped the process up a bit in my case..... Just eat healthy though... veggies are great calorie fillers lol.. even though they are SUPER low in calories I can eat a TON of em lol...0
-
Weight loss is about calories in vs. calories out. So if you eat back all of those calories you will not lose as much weight or at least not lose it as quickly as you would have if you hadn't eaten those calories.
Please dont simplfy the answer that much....if people were to listen to this logic they would create huge defecits that would end up slowing down their metabolism and hurt them in the end. If I were eating 2500 calories a day, then exercising so much per day that I burned 2000-2500 a day (crazy I know but proving a point) then I would be at 0 Net and my body after a week would collapse. It is not simply calorie in vs calorie out in terms of weight loss.
The fact is you want to maintain a healthy defecit. This is the reason you eat back your exercise calories...because the defecit is ALREADY built in to your daily calories here on MFP.
If you were to go by TDEE...that is a different story, but MFP calculates your 1 pound loss a week defecit for you. Make all numbers hit 0 or as close as you can....its that simple.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.7K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.8K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 415 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.6K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions