Do you count cleaning as exercise?
LizRobot
Posts: 19
Having a bit of a debate with my spouse about whether or not cleaning counts as exercise. I spent four hours cleaning my child's room today, it was a huge project that took a lot of time and energy. I was actually sweating at some points. So, I put in two hours of light/moderate cleaning in my exercise log, just to be careful. My husband said it shouldn't count. What say you?
0
Replies
-
I don't generally count cleaning as an exercise, but I might in a situation such as yours. I remember late last month when I was getting the house ready for my older daughter's birthday party, which included taking down the Christmas tree and all kinds of stuff. I think it would be acceptable to put it down for a bigger project, one that takes a few hours, because it is not normally in your daily routine. If you cleaned like that constantly then I wouldn't count it because it would be part of your normal routine.0
-
Only if you're cleaning the gym equipment, after using it...0
-
I have put my lifestyle as sedentary and then would manually add everything. I would definitely count a big project like this.
Now I use a Fitbit and it takes care of my lifestyle calories on any given day.0 -
Tidying up around the house I do not count/log it... but I do a deep 4 hour clean every two weeks and you bet I count that!!! 4 hours is a long time to be dragging things up and down stairs, cleaning walls, wiping cabinets, vigorously cleaning the tub.. etc... I underestimate on the calories burned... but I do log it, and I do enjoy eating back the calories from doing it0
-
i think it depends on the individual and also how physical it is ie washing a car, gardening, painting a room etc.
https://www.weightlossresources.co.uk/exercise/tips/housework_workouts.htm0 -
My TDEE is about 2900 due to cleaning half the day. It's usually only 2500.0
-
I'd rather not log it and have it as extra floaty magical calories than count it and end up over-estimating. Unless I purposefully set out to do a workout, I don't add it.0
-
Never have.......never will.
I even tend to be an OCD type cleaner, every nook and cranny, and you will still never see "cleaning" grace my exercise log.0 -
It's up to you really. I usually count those as extra credit calories and it makes me feel good to know I went over and above. I usually don't long them, but then again I wouldn't rule it out. Remember logging is for YOU to make sure you keep yourself on track. If you want to log them, log them, but keep with your standard exercise you had planned for the day and get an extra burn! I did my girls rooms today too by the way.0
-
I wouldn't count light cleaning like vaccuming, but if you are moving and doing strainuous work, then yes. Put on your Heart Rate Monitor and see if your heart rate is up. If its not something you do daily, thats not part of your regular activity. Today I moved boxes, went up and down the stairs, etc. It was WORK!! I counted it! I don't usually do ALLLL THAT!!! LOL!! It counts!0
-
I wouldn't count it because I cleaned before this and it didn't help me lose weight then so I don't think it would help me now, have to do extra workouts0
-
No. Not unless I stop and do bicep curls with the bleach container or decide to squat my vacuum cleaner. I like to think of it as a happy extra burn for the day.0
-
I count pretty much everything. It is not negatively affecting my fitness goals.0
-
Deep cleaning, yes.0
-
Why wouldn't you! Your active and moving! Your heart rate is elevated and your burning a lot more calories then watching tv. You may not see "House Cleaning" as the new work out class at the gym but you were exerting force and energy. If you want you could try focusing on things like how you bend down when cleaing...use good squating form and get even more bang for your buck! Sounds like your husband should be greatfull you cleaned the room and happy you want to be healthy over all.0
-
I believe any form of movement can be classified as an exercise although the effectiveness is another thing. Movement burns calorie so if your think about it your up walking around the house moving your arm working on the arm and legs also some stretches may be out into the mix.
But overall is it an exercise .. It contain walking which is classified as a basic cardiovascular exercise, and it can include the use of your are which can be classified as some arm toning exercises do as much as you like, remember every little helps0 -
no really.... I have always been really active... so If I count things like cleaning or walking for certain hours... I would consider that like cheating because that is nothing for my body....0
-
I'd say it depends on if you include it in your determination of sedentary, lightly active, etc. If you don't, count it. If you do, don't. For me, when I don't work it wouldn't be right to count it. If I have a particularly active work day, such as subbing PE, I'll add a little activity for that.0
-
I wouldn't...I have a heart rate monitoring watch, and I don't usually record activities outside of "sedentary" unless my heart rate reaches 120+ for an extended period of time. Otherwise, I'm afraid of inputting too many calories lost. I would rather be on the safe side...0
-
I do light cleaning during the week to, but if I did 4 hours of continuous, sweat inducing, cleaning I think I would have approached it the same way you did, underestimated by cutting in half. You get to count some of the calories you earned and the rest are "floaty magical calories" as auroranflash said.0
-
No. But I bet if I did, it would get me to clean more. :laugh:0
-
No. I only count intentional exercise as exercise. If I were to find myself extra hungry as a result of my cleaning effort, I would just go over that day and note it in my diary. I think it's a slippery slope and a disservice to yourself to count everyday activities as exercise.0
-
No. I only count intentional exercise as exercise. If I were to find myself extra hungry as a result of my cleaning effort, I would just go over that day and note it in my diary. I think it's a slippery slope and a disservice to yourself to count everyday activities as exercise.
^^This0 -
it's exercise if you put some elbow grease into it...and don't eat or drink sugary drinks while you're exercising.0
-
I don't. I would feel ridiculous counting cleaning as exercise :-/0
-
Only if you're cleaning the gym equipment, after using it...
^^^ haha for real!!! I clean all day every day caring for my two children. But never log in because I know if I want to really change my body I need to be getting down in the gym for some seriou exercise. Just forget its even there to Log0 -
Deep clean, light clean, both are No. I take cleaning as a natural part of life. I think that as we get too lazy and try to take short cuts and call certain things excersing that is not.0
-
I count deep cleaning.0
-
I have sedentary in my profile so I count everything that is not just ordinary living. I want to contrast what I eat with what I do. Maybe later when I am closer to goal I will change that0
-
Doesn't "count" as what? If you burned the calories, you should get to log 'em!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions