Sacred Heart Diet

0dreamer0

Has anyone tried this diet? I'm considering it.
If you haven't heard, I can send you the link...

Feedback?

DrBroPHD

I'd rather be fat than eat this diet

FredDoyle

Are you headed in for surgery and need to lose weight fast?

Cr01502

I'd rather be fat than eat this diet

For the win.

BurtHuttz

I looked the diet up on the internet, and there's a bit of a math problem with it.

So, there are 3500 calories in a pound of fat.
This means that in order to lose one pound of body fat, you need to burn 3500 more calories than you eat.

According to the internet, you should expect to lose 10 - 17 pounds in one week on this diet.[1]

That means that you will have burnt 35,000 to 60,000 more calories than you consumed (10 x 3,500 to 17 x 3,500).

Since this diet includes no exercise, and the average person burns about 2,000 calories a day, you will only burn an average of 14,000 calories in a week, which equates to a maximum potential weight loss on a total starvation diet of

four pounds.

(14,000 / 3,500 = 4).


So, in summary, NO NO NO NO.





[1] http://www.idiet4u.com/diets/sacredheart.html

aelunyu

Seems legit. Does the heart come on the side? Why is there no heart in the soup? What if I want extra heart, hold the sacred?

Lalasharni

This diet is nutritional haulocaust. You'd have to be crazy to try it, and you will do yourself no good.
Hoever, thats only my opinion, and if anyone is one it - good luck. MFP would never support this kind of dieting, its not a lifestyle change and thats the only way to succeed.

pastryari

These threads are running rampant today.

Look, most people on here have had success with maintaining a calorie deficit and putting in some old fashioned plain hard work (exercise). It works. It does. Calorie deficit = weight loss. You don't have to adhere to any other rules but that. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed.

TylerJ76

These threads are running rampant today.

Look, most people on here have had success with maintaining a calorie deficit and putting in some old fashioned plain hard work (exercise). It works. It does. Calorie deficit = weight loss. You don't have to adhere to any other rules but that. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed.

Does it get old repeating the same thing, day after day?

Chief_Rocka

Day 4

Bananas and skim milk: Eat at least 3 bananas and drink as much milk as you can today, along with the soup.

Apologize to your toilet beforehand

aelunyu

These threads are running rampant today.

Look, most people on here have had success with maintaining a calorie deficit and putting in some old fashioned plain hard work (exercise). It works. It does. Calorie deficit = weight loss. You don't have to adhere to any other rules but that. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed.

every time a severely overweight person claims they are in starvation mode, god kills a kitten.

quirkytizzy

After googling, this is one of those "If you don't have an eating disorder before going into this, you sure as hell will AFTER." Also, any diet that says "This soup does not have calories" is dead-wrong from the get-go.

I'd steer clear. Most people are screwed up enough without adding this kind of dysfunction onto their plate.

Trechechus

Day 4

Bananas and skim milk: Eat at least 3 bananas and drink as much milk as you can today, along with the soup.

Apologize to your toilet beforehand

:laugh:

MB_Positif

Just read about it. What. The. Eff?

ILiftHeavyAcrylics

I looked the diet up on the internet, and there's a bit of a math problem with it.

So, there are 3500 calories in a pound of fat.
This means that in order to lose one pound of body fat, you need to burn 3500 more calories than you eat.

According to the internet, you should expect to lose 10 - 17 pounds in one week on this diet.[1]

That means that you will have burnt 35,000 to 60,000 more calories than you consumed (10 x 3,500 to 17 x 35,000).

Since this diet includes no exercise, and the average person burns about 2,000 calories a day, you will only burn an average of 14,000 calories in a week, which equates to a maximum potential weight loss on a total starvation diet of

four pounds.

(14,000 / 3,500 = 4).


So, in summary, NO NO NO NO.





[1] http://www.idiet4u.com/diets/sacredheart.html

^^ Full of awesome.

0dreamer0

These threads are running rampant today.

Look, most people on here have had success with maintaining a calorie deficit and putting in some old fashioned plain hard work (exercise). It works. It does. Calorie deficit = weight loss. You don't have to adhere to any other rules but that. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed.

That's the whole point of requesting feedback. Calorie counting is wise to train yourself on portion control...however, I was seeking opinions because I need to cleanse somehow due to the amount of bull**** I've put my body through. My friend who doesn't calorie count but simply works out 6 days/wk tried the "diet" but everyone is different so I was looking for feed back. Not a quick fix. I am smart enough to know that exercise and proper eating is key.

Firefox7275

That's the whole point of requesting feedback. Calorie counting is wise to train yourself on portion control...however, I was seeking opinions because I need to cleanse somehow due to the amount of bull**** I've put my body through. My friend who doesn't calorie count but simply works out 6 days/wk tried the "diet" but everyone is different so I was looking for feed back. Not a quick fix. I am smart enough to know that exercise and proper eating is key.

That website is just a serious of unsustainable/ unhealthy/ cranky/ faddy/ crash diets and adverts, doesn't that tell you something? Also note it claims
"This diet comes from the Sacred Heart Memorial Hospital that is used for overweight heart patients in order to lose weight rapidly, usually prior to surgery."
And
"Continue on the diet as long as you wish and feel the difference both mentally and physically."
No doubt you would feel the difference mentally and physically once malnutrition kicks in in earnest.
http://www.idiet4u.com/diets/sacredheart.html

"The American Heart Association (AHA) and the hospitals whose names have been associated with the cabbage soup diet have issued formal disclaimers warning the public that they do not endorse this diet. The Hopital du Sacré-Coeur de Montréal states in its 2004 press release that the diet is contrary to healthy feeding patterns and even presents potential dangers to good health. The Sacred Heart Medical Center (SHMC) in Spokane requests that people do not affiliate the diet with their hospital as they do not consider it a safe or healthy method of weight loss. A SHMC disclaimer states, “This diet did not originate at SHMC and it is not endorsed by the dietitians or the staff of our cardiac rehabilitation program. One of our major concerns about this diet plan is it emphasizes the consumption of fruits and vegetables while excluding the consumption of meat or fish, cereal grains and milk products on most days.

Any diet that focuses on only certain food groups will be low or deficient in essential nutrients and, therefore, lead to poor nutritional status long-term. Our experience with any low calorie diets like this one is that they do not lead to permanent weight loss. Once individuals start eating in a more normal pattern, the weight is regained. A very important factor in obtaining a healthy weight is to evaluate your physical activity and other lifestyle concerns. This is most appropriately done by consulting with a registered dietitian.”
http://www.diet.com/g/cabbage-soup-diet

BurtHuttz

These threads are running rampant today.

Look, most people on here have had success with maintaining a calorie deficit and putting in some old fashioned plain hard work (exercise). It works. It does. Calorie deficit = weight loss. You don't have to adhere to any other rules but that. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed.

That's the whole point of requesting feedback. Calorie counting is wise to train yourself on portion control...however, I was seeking opinions because I need to cleanse somehow due to the amount of bull**** I've put my body through. My friend who doesn't calorie count but simply works out 6 days/wk tried the "diet" but everyone is different so I was looking for feed back. Not a quick fix. I am smart enough to know that exercise and proper eating is key.

Adini wasn't critiquing, Adini loves you and wants you to be successful.

Also @firefox that was just some website I found, I don't know what relationship it has to the diet the OP is talking about necessarily.

We are all in violent agreement that moderate exercise and consumption leads to sexy results.

:happy: :happy: :happy:

carriem73

I did the cabbage soup diet years ago (very similar) BEFORE I realize how to lose wieght in a healthy manner-

I disagree with the person above who said you can't burn nearly enough calories to lose 16 lbs in a week- the amount of times you have to get up and RUN AS FAST AS YOU CAN TO THE BATHROOM must be the way you burn calories!

Don't do it, unless you want to spend 13 out of your 15 waking hours on the toilet!!!!

:blushing:

jamacattack

This is the same "diet" that was supposedly originally put out by one of the tire companies for their employees. Yep, I trust those tire companies to tell me how to eat.

I've also read reviews of people who did this diet and by the banana day.... they felt like they were going to die. Google reviews from people who were stupid enough to try it.

BurtHuttz

Ah - and also, you don't need to cleanse yourself, OP. Clean will be a byproduct of your new lifestyle. If you're looking for some sort of spiritual / psychological break from the past, more for a milestone, then that's going to be something that's personal and meaningful for you. Your body just wants some veggies and a walk around the block :-)

EstiloPanama

Try to focus less on "diet" and more on "lifestyle change"....

Dieting may only take you so far, lifestyle change is your new FOREVER...as in, something you can keep up with that fits your life and personality, yet is healthy and helps you stay in shape.

seena511

, I was seeking opinions because I need to cleanse somehow due to the amount of bull**** I've put my body through.

careful with that word (cleanse)...that'll get people on a whole nother rant. just do it the old fashioned way.

SageGoddess320

0dreamer0

Ah - and also, you don't need to cleanse yourself, OP. Clean will be a byproduct of your new lifestyle. If you're looking for some sort of spiritual / psychological break from the past, more for a milestone, then that's going to be something that's personal and meaningful for you. Your body just wants some veggies and a walk around the block :-)

Thanks.
I was thinking more so toxic crap from drinking and smoking and bad eating...but I'm sweating it out I suppose when I do cardio.
Too cold here for a walk around the block, eh... but I'll run in the spot instead. lol

0dreamer0

LMAO!

So I think my final answer is... take it away Steve!

chocciechip

personally - I actually quite like the taste of the soup - so I make it up and put it in freezerbags so when I come home from work and need something quick whilst cooking dinner instead of snacking I shove one of those in the microwave.

Juliejustsaying

WIN!!!!

stephdeeable

Sacred Heart? Does this have anything to do with Scrubs? If so, I am so in.

Alford96

I tried something very similar about 17 years ago. I actually liked the taste of the soup but got tired of it after awhile. Midway through banana day, I got the WORST MIGRAINE EVER!!! And I have had some bad ones. To this day, I can hardly eat bananas.

vim_n_vigor

These threads are running rampant today.

Look, most people on here have had success with maintaining a calorie deficit and putting in some old fashioned plain hard work (exercise). It works. It does. Calorie deficit = weight loss. You don't have to adhere to any other rules but that. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed.

That's the whole point of requesting feedback. Calorie counting is wise to train yourself on portion control...however, I was seeking opinions because I need to cleanse somehow due to the amount of bull**** I've put my body through. My friend who doesn't calorie count but simply works out 6 days/wk tried the "diet" but everyone is different so I was looking for feed back. Not a quick fix. I am smart enough to know that exercise and proper eating is key.

You don't need to cleanse, although this diet would certainly 'cleanse' something. If you count your calories and increase the amount of fresh fruits and veggies and lean proteins, you will be doing plenty for your body there.